
Long before Op Sindoor, Marathas first carried out ‘surgical strike'. NCERT Class 8 book is proof
The book describes Shivaji, the founder of Maratha Empire, as a 'strategist and true visionary' while introducing Babur, the founder of the Mughal Empire, as a 'brutal and ruthless conqueror, slaughtering entire populations of cities'.
New Delhi: The NCERT's new Class 8 Social Science textbook, in a chapter called 'The Rise of the Marathas', compares a raid carried out by Shivaji on the Mughal enemy camp in the dead of the night to a 'modern-day surgical strike'.
'The Rise of the Marathas' adds that Shivaji raided his enemy's camp at night 'with only a few' soldiers. 'This daring raid resembles the modern-day surgical strike,' it says, with 'surgical strike' highlighted in purple.
Another chapter, 'Reshaping India's Political Map', says Babur 'enslaved women' and erected 'towers of skulls made from the slaughtered people of plundered cities' when he entered the Subcontinent after being 'thrown out of Samarkand (modern-day Uzbekistan)'.
Initially, the Mughals and the Delhi Sultanate were part of the Class 7 social science curriculum. However, the NCERT has now replaced those chapters with new ones on the Magadha kingdom, the Mauryas, the Shungas, and the Sātavāhanas.
Now, it is the Class 8 social science textbook that introduces students to the Delhi Sultanate, the Mughals, and the Marathas. In the textbook, named 'Exploring Society: India and Beyond', the NCERT has added what it has called a 'Note on some darker periods in history', along with a disclaimer.
The note says, 'Understanding the historical origin of cruel violence, abusive misrule, or misplaced ambitions of power is the best way to heal the past and build a future where, hopefully, they will have no place.'
'No one should be held responsible today for events of the past,' reads the disclaimer.
ThePrint reached NCERT Director Dinesh Prasad Saklani for comment through calls and texts. This report will be updated if and when a response is received.
Speaking to ThePrint, Irfan Habib, a historian of ancient and medieval India said history depended entirely on facts, not religion, and that the past could not be changed, just by removing parts of it from the syllabus.
Habib added that no Constitution existed at the time, so all rulers ruled by the sword. Calling the revisions a part of political strategies, Habib said, 'Rajputs, for instance, were equally cruel. There is no need to see it through the prism of religion.'
Dynasties would not have survived if the rulers were not good strategists or swordsmen, he added.
'This is a faulty and farcical way of going about making changes,' Habib said, adding that the distortion of history is a way of turning history into mythology.
Also Read: Aurangzeb keeps haunting Maharashtra politics. This time, he can hurt Fadnavis' governance
Shivaji was 'careful' not to attack religious places
The book claims Shivaji was always 'careful' not to attack religious places and mentions a 'retaliatory action' that involved Shivaji attacking Surat, which, it says, was a 'great insult' to the might and prestige of the Mughal Empire.
In contrast, it describes the Sultanate period as one marked by political instability and the destruction of temples and seats of learning. During Alauddin Khilji's conquests, 'Hindu centres such as Srirangam, Madurai, Chidambaram, and possibly Rameshwaram' came under attack, the textbook says.
Discussing the Mughal Empire, the text says Akbar tried to intimidate the Rajputs during the Chittorgarh attack by proclaiming he had already occupied several 'forts and towns belonging to the infidels' and 'established Islam there'.
Akbar, once called 'The Great Akbar' in history textbooks, ruled with a 'blend of brutality and tolerance', the text says, adding: 'Despite Akbar's growing tolerance for different faiths, non-Muslims were kept in a minority in the higher echelons of the administration…'
'Can't selectively glorify or vilify historical figures'
Arvind Sinha, a retired history professor from Jawaharlal Nehru University, told ThePrint that history, as a discipline, should be rooted in objectivity, warning that 'prejudice' not only distorts facts but also has a harmful influence on young minds.
'You cannot selectively glorify or vilify historical figures. For instance, Shivaji cannot be viewed as a hero in isolation, without acknowledging the historical context, including Aurangzeb,' he said, adding that rulers operated under different circumstances, something that needed to be understood, not judged.
He also drew parallels with Pakistani textbooks and their 'ideological portrayals' that made thinking among students narrow.
'If you omit facts or twist them to suit a narrative, you are not teaching history, you are promoting propaganda,' he said, adding that the problem was not limited to any one political party. 'Ideological influence, whether Marxist or Right-wing, has no place in History textbooks.'
(Edited by Madhurita Goswami)
Also Read: Aurangzeb is politics, not history. Indian Muslims must bury his ghost
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Print
4 hours ago
- The Print
Czech Republic president meets Dalai Lama in Ladakh
'President Petr Pavel of the Czech Republic met with His Holiness the Dalai Lama this morning in Leh, Ladakh, India. During the meeting, the President extended his warm congratulations to His Holiness on the occasion of his 90th birthday,' the office of the spiritual leader posted on X. This is for the first time that a sitting head of a state has visited India to meet his holiness Dalai Lama, who had reached Leh on July 12 on a month-long tour of the Union Territory. Leh, Jul 27 (PTI) Czech Republic president Petr Pavel on Sunday met Tibetan spiritual leader Dalai Lama in Ladakh, an official said. The official handle run by the name of Dalai Lama also shared the picture of the meeting late tonight. PTI TAS NB NB This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.


Hindustan Times
5 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Delhi: Restored 103-year-old Roshanara Club inaugurated
The historic Roshanara Club in north Delhi, a 103-year-old institution considered the cradle of Indian cricket, was officially reopened on Sunday after extensive restoration by the Delhi Development Authority (DDA). Lieutenant governor (LG) VK Saxena inaugurated the restored club, which had remained sealed for over a year and a half before undergoing a meticulous revival aimed at preserving its architectural and cultural legacy. Roshanara Club on Sunday. (Vipin Kumar/HT Photo) Established in 1922 by British officials and Indian elites, Roshanara Club is widely regarded as the birthplace of the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI). Spread over 22 acres of green space, the club once hosted viceroys, governor generals, and leaders like Jawaharlal Nehru, Dr Rajendra Prasad, and Zakir Hussain. 'It is a big moment for us as this heritage club has been restored and relaunched. I congratulate the citizens of Delhi on this occasion. Delhi is a city of heritage and in the last three years, a number of heritage sites have been restored and we are committed towards more in the future,' Saxena said. Roshanara Club was originally built over 22 acres on the western side of the historic Roshanara Bagh, which was built by the daughter of Mughal Emperor Shah Jahan, and designed in colonial architectural style with European influences. Over the decades, it became known for gatherings of Delhi's political, administrative, social, and business elite. After Independence, the club remained exclusive to its members but when DDA took over the premises on September 29, 2023, it was opened to the public. By that time, the club was in a dilapidated state with poor maintenance and a crumbling facade, and the site was also marred by encroachments. The club's infrastructure and sports facilities had also sustained significant damage. DDA then embarked on a comprehensive restoration project to revive the club's structural integrity and historic charm. 'A careful and meticulously drawn up revival plan was undertaken by DDA, while ensuring that the historic character of the structures remains intact,' a DDA spokesperson said. DDA did extensive civil, electrical and aesthetic restoration. The restored Roshanara Club now houses indoor amenities including a reception area, main lounge, card and billiards rooms, children's play area, a fully functional bar and dining hall, banquet, library, swimming pool with changing rooms, gym/fitness centre, squash board and badminton hall, yoga and sauna and steam area. Outdoor facilities have also been upgraded and include grass, clay, and synthetic lawn tennis courts, cricket grounds and practice pitches, mini football and basketball zones and a dedicated jogger's park. 'Particular attention was given to the preservation of the Club's architectural legacy. The century-old façade, including the European-style doors and windows, Mangalore-tiled roof and intricate wooden trusses, has all been carefully restored. Antique chandeliers and original furnishings were refurbished and reupholstered to revive their classic charm,' the spokesperson said. Various sports facilities in the club were gradually started over the last few months but the club building had remained shut until Sunday.
&w=3840&q=100)

Business Standard
13 hours ago
- Business Standard
PM Modi's praise for Bhopal's sanitation efforts boosted morale: CM Yadav
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mohan Yadav on Sunday thanked Prime Minister Narendra Modi for appreciating Bhopal's sanitation measures during his monthly Mann Ki Baat' radio broadcast and said the praise has upped the state's morale. In the recently released Swachh Survekshan 2024', Bhopal was ranked the second-cleanest city in India, with MP's financial capital Indore bagging the top position for the eighth consecutive time. The PM's words have boosted the state's morale, said Yadav, who listened to Mann Ki Baat at an event in the city's Gulmohar Colony in Ward No. 50. He also planted a banyan sapling on the occasion. Prime Minister Modi ji inspires the power of every citizen for nation-building, Yadav said. Addressing the gathering, the CM said Modi's radio programme has become an effective platform for direct communication with the people of the country. It brings inspiring stories from across India that play a key role in nation-building, he added. Earlier, PM Modi lauded Sakaratmak Soch', a Bhopal-based organisation comprising 200 women, which works in the field of sanitation. They don't just clean, they also change mindsets. Cleaning 17 parks in the city together, distributing cloth bags, every step of theirs is a message. Owing to such efforts, Bhopal has now come a long way in the Swachh Survey, Modi said in Mann Ki Baat. Yadav said Bhopal residents deserve congratulations for the city's stellar performance in the cleanliness rankings. During his address, PM Modi also spoke about 12 Maratha forts listed as UNESCO World Heritage Sites and said there are such amazing forts in other parts of the country too, which have faced attacks, faced the vagaries of weather, but never let their self-respect bow down. He said that MP's Bundelkhand region also is home to several forts that were cultural symbols. ... Gwalior, Jhansi, Datia, Ajaygarh, Garhkundar and Chanderi. These forts are not just bricks and stones; they are symbols of our heritage. Sanskar and self-respect still peep from the high walls of these forts, said Modi. The PM also urged citizens to visit these forts, know their history, feel proud.