The mushroom murders resemble an Agatha Christie plot – and film studios, publishers and streaming platforms know it
Now, real life has delivered its own gothic culinary thriller – and the literary and entertainment worlds are eating it up.
The conviction of Erin Patterson, the Victorian woman found guilty of murdering three members of her estranged husband's family – and attempting to murder a fourth – with a homemade beef wellington laced with death cap mushrooms, has created an international media maelstrom. Publishing houses, streaming platforms, film studios and podcast producers are circling the story like salivating wolves closing in to make a killing.
Even before the jury delivered its guilty verdict on Monday, Australia's national public broadcaster, the ABC, confirmed it was turning the Patterson poisoning into a TV drama. Its co-creator Tony Ayres (The Survivors, Clickbait) told Deadline that Toxic would 'go beyond the surface – to reveal, not just sensationalise', and he was working closely with the ABC journalist Rachael Brown, co-podcaster of Mushroom Case Daily, the ABC's most successful podcast in a decade.
It is one of some half a dozen podcasts that covered the murder trial daily, with reporters from around the world flocking to the Latrobe Valley law courts.
These podcast series are now expected to delve deeper into the forensic science behind mushroom toxicity, the ethics of food preparation, and the cultural fascination with domestic crime.
This Sunday, Seven is promising a Spotlight Special, with a criminal barrister, a forensic psychologist, a former detective, and journalists dissecting the trial and the convicted poisoner's motives.
And Nine has confirmed a deal with its streaming platform Stan for Death Cap, a documentary that Screen Australia promises will showcase 'exclusive access into the investigation and trial' and examine 'how one lethal lunch can shatter the myth of small-town security in Australia'.
Comparisons to the 2004 Netflix hit The Staircase, based on the true case of Michael Peterson, an American novelist accused of murdering his wife who was found dead at the bottom of the stairs in their North Carolina home in 2001, abound.
Toni Collette who played the victim in The Staircase, is being touted on social media as an ideal actor to play Patterson.
New Idea threw local names Magda Szubanski, Mandy McElhinney and Jacki Weaver into the mix, along with Hollywood heavyweights Melissa McCarthy and Kathy Bates, and Baby Reindeer's Jessica Gunning.
With one of Australia's most lauded novelists Helen Garner spotted in the Morwell court public gallery, there has been speculation that another gripping work of nonfiction, along the lines of This House of Grief, her 2014 work about the trial of Robert Farquharson, convicted of crashing his car into a dam and killing his three sons, is in the works.
And Allen & Unwin has already announced it will publish The Mushroom Murders, a nonfiction work by the Underbelly creator Greg Haddrick – 'with details not previously published' – in November.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
With global media outlets including CNN, the BBC and Al Jazeera covering the verdict, the story's reach has been unprecedented for an Australian criminal case.
'It resonated with an audience all over the world,' the UK Daily Mail journalist Caroline Cheetham, who gained a cult following with her The Trial Of Erin Patterson podcast, told the ABC.
'It just feels so totally off the wall, bizarre, crazy, bonkers.'
With so many spin-off projects already confirmed, the Erin Patterson saga may now become one of the most dramatised true crime stories in recent memory.
Whether ethical questions, about how the tragic deaths of Gail and Don Patterson and Heather Wilkinson have become entertainment fodder, will be examined remains to be seen.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
4 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Dragons forward Jack de Belin to face ex‑cop who lied in sexual assault case that was ultimately dropped
Jack de Belin will next week face a former police officer in court who admitted lying during his sexual assault proceedings. The officer, known only as Officer A, will be sentenced for giving false evidence under oath in 2020. The false testimony related to his handling of legally privileged text messages found on de Belin's seized phone. The officer, under a court suppression order, pleaded guilty to perjury. The charge relates to false evidence given in February 2020 in the NSW District Court. He told the court he believed text messages between de Belin and his lawyer were 'Dragons business'. The messages were in fact with solicitor Craig Osborne, a Dragons director and part of de Belin's legal team. Police seized de Belin's phone in December 2019 and examined it using Cellebrite software. They accessed 203 messages between de Belin and 'Craig Lawyer', many covered by legal privilege. Lawyers for de Belin and co‑accused Callan Sinclair argued this breached their right to a fair trial. The issue emerged during a pre‑trial stay application, which was rejected. De Belin and Sinclair were accused of sexually assaulting a 19‑year‑old woman in December 2018. They denied all allegations and pleaded not guilty. The first trial in 2020 ended without a verdict. A retrial in 2021 also failed to reach a verdict. The Director of Public Prosecutions later dropped all charges. Both men maintained the encounter was consensual. The NSW Police Professional Standards Command investigated Officer A's conduct for three years. He was later medically retired from the force. He will be sentenced in Wollongong District Court on Tuesday. De Belin, Sinclair and their families are expected to attend. They have called for an inquiry into police handling of the case. De Belin was sidelined from the NRL for three years under the 'no fault' stand‑down rule. He challenged the policy in the Federal Court but lost. Justice Melissa Perry ruled the rule lawful. De Belin returned to the field after the case ended. He has since played regularly for the Dragons. The 34‑year‑old has made 245 NRL appearances since 2011. He has represented New South Wales in State of Origin and Papua New Guinea at Test level. Earlier this year, Parramatta Eels announced they had signed him for 2025. De Belin said leaving the Dragons 'broke his heart' after his long career at the club.
Daily Record
2 hours ago
- Daily Record
Queen's 'great, great, granddaughter' seeks DNA test and approval from Charles
Much has been made of Queen Victoria's relationship with her ghillie John Brown - now a woman who believes she is their descendant wants to prove the affair was real. A woman who reckons she might be the illegitimate great, great granddaughter of Queen Victoria says her ultimate aim is to get acknowledgement from King Charles. Angela Webb-Milinkovich, from Minnesota, believes she and her sister have ancestry that traces back to Victoria's lengthy, passionate affair with her devoted servant John Brown. Fresh research by historian Dr Fern Riddell indicates that whilst officially Angela's great grandmother Mary Ann was the sole child of John's brother Hugh and his wife Jessie, there's proof suggesting the infant might actually have been born from his secret romance with the monarch, during which they were clandestinely wed. Angela, 47, is now preparing to undergo a DNA test as the definitive evidence of her Royal bloodline. She insists she has no desire to profit from the tale, solely wanting to ensure her family's position in history receives the acknowledgement it merits, reports the Mirror. "My main goal is to have the story acknowledged - I want their relationship to be recognised and for the royal family to stop saying it didn't happen," she explains. "If I'm going to reach for the top, it would have to be from King Charles," she adds, when asked who she'd most like to hear from. "I mean, it's a great story and it has his family involved, too. So he would be interested in it." Or Prince William perhaps? "That'd be great. That's acceptable," she laughs. Angela was raised believing her family descended from royalty through baby Mary Ann. She can't recall exactly when she learned this, only that there was a tale about "a big boat trip... and a baby given to the family." Dr Riddell reached out to Angela during her four-year investigation for her new book Victoria's Secret, revealing she'd found that childless couple Jessie and Hugh had sailed to New Zealand in 1865, recording Mary Ann's birth there shortly afterwards - which could account for the maritime journey. Speaking on Channel 4's accompanying documentary, Dr Riddell suggested that the widowed Victoria could have easily hidden a pregnancy during the 1860s, then had the infant - her tenth child - secretly transported to the opposite side of the globe to prevent scandal. Records show that in 1874, Victoria funded the family's return voyage to Scotland, even providing them with a substantial residence on the Balmoral estate. Following John's death, she also relocated Hugh's family to Windsor to be closer to her. Angela managed to grant Dr Riddell access to a wealth of new evidence from the Brown family archive, which contained items and documents that have been in their possession for decades. Some of this came from a safety deposit box that Angela and her sister, who wishes to remain anonymous, opened about five years ago following their father's death. "We didn't know what we had, just that they were items from John Brown and Queen Victoria," she now admits. "It was always something in the back of our minds - we should probably get these looked at." Despite longstanding family suspicions that they were related to Queen Victoria, Angela was still taken aback when Dr Fern reached out. "I believed my family was being truthful with it, but we could never prove it. Once she sent that message, I thought 'What the heck? Is there actually validity to this?'" Angela, who is employed as a mental health care worker, expressed her desire for the love affair, which was concealed both during and after Victoria's lifetime, to be recognised as the truth. "It's something that I'm very proud of," she declared. "I want the vindication essentially for John Brown and just for my lineage, because they were not able to talk about it. It was something that just became that secret that we couldn't really share, but we knew." If Dr Riddell's account is accurate, and there's substantial evidence backing it up, Victoria and John shared a passionate romance spanning nearly two decades, right up until his passing in 1883. Beyond exchanging mutual declarations of love on his deathbed - "I told him no one loved him more than I did and he answered 'nor you - than me'" - she had also created a cast of his hand, precisely as she'd done for Albert. When her own end came in 1901, she requested to be interred with a lock of hair and photograph of the man who'd stood beside her for twenty years following Albert's demise in 1861. Letters that survived show her addressing him as "my beloved" and "darling one". Yet, at the behest of her eldest son Bertie - poised to become Edward VII - the Palace began systematically wiping John from history. Victoria's diaries were transcribed and altered, with the originals being destroyed. Bertie, who had frequently feuded with Brown, also commanded that the statues and private monuments Victoria had erected in his honour be demolished. Angela's grandfather passed away when she was in primary school, but she recalls him being distressed about the Browns' erasure from history. "My understanding from my Mum was that he was just really upset and bitter about it," she shared. "He didn't like to talk about it. Now, having both my parents and my aunt gone, we don't have those resources any more. So the bulk of the story I have been learning from Fern, which is amazing, and I'm so grateful." Angela remains hopeful that the Royals will eventually have to acknowledge the legitimacy of the claims made about her ancestors, as highlighted in a Channel 4 documentary aired on Thursday. "My gut says it's going to have to get acknowledged at some point," she suggests. "Scandals are always very exciting so I'm sure there'll be a lot of questions for them to answer. If they don't say anything, that's their choice. But I'd like them to acknowledge the truth of this love, to recognise that it wasn't cool to cover up and destroy evidence of the relationship they shared. Let's be real, Bertie was a bit of a d**k to the Browns. "That story deserves to be known, to have its own breath out there in the world. You don't get that kind of romance every day. It's what you'd hope for anybody, that you would find another chance at love. So I don't see why we should look down on that. It's like an opportunity presented itself and they embraced it, and I think that is beautiful." Angela is hopeful of undergoing a DNA test to confirm her lineage, but has been cautioned that it might take a while due to the necessity for impeccable source material for testing across four generations. "I'll let the scientists do the science," she says with a smile. "I'm a supporting character in this journey, and so I will follow wherever the story leads me. I'm totally open to it. So far it's been so exciting, so cool. I'm just really stoked." The tattooed American, sporting a nose-ring, firmly denies that she's merely attempting to profit from the Royal family's wealth. "Money is the furthest thing from my goal in telling this family story. It has always been to get Queen Victoria and John Brown's story the truth it deserves." She can't fathom any other reason why her family would possess valuable keepsakes from Victoria and John, including a brooch and a lock of hair. "Their relationship was authentic and genuine. They obviously had feelings for each other. It went well beyond a queen and man servant situation." There was a fair amount of speculation at the time about the duo, portrayed by Dame Judi Dench and Billy Connolly in the 1997 film Mrs Brown. In 1865, after Victoria requested John's transfer to the Royal Household at Windsor, two of her daughters, Helena and Louise, openly referred to him as 'Mamma's lover'. And the following year a Swiss newspaper published a story claiming Victoria, then aged 46, had privately married John and become pregnant. Angela would be delighted regardless of whether Mary Ann proves to be John or Hugh's daughter. "Either John Brown is my great, great uncle or he is my great, great grandpa. My family still played a key role in history with their friendship and closeness to Queen Victoria. I'm proud of their steadfastness in keeping the legacy of John Brown alive and their word to holding the secret close. It's still a beautiful romance that deserves its moment of recognition in history." With her Scottish heritage through her mother's lineage, Angela adores visiting the UK at every opportunity and confesses she occasionally feels more British than American. "I've always felt a little disconnected in the sense that I feel more at home over there. Scotland is my happy place. I would move there if I could, for sure."
Times
2 hours ago
- Times
Man, 76, charged over poisoning of children at summer camp
A trustee who runs a Christian charity has been charged over the poisoning of children at a summer camp. Jonathon Ruben, 76, was arrested on Monday after eight children under his care fell ill during a trip to Stathern Lodge in Leicestershire. The pensioner, of Ruddington in Nottingham, is the secretary of the charity running the three-day holiday camp, which was attended by about 45 children last weekend. Police received reports that several children were unwell on Sunday, but officers and paramedics did not attend until Monday. The group of campers are understood to have been dining at a nearby pub in the village of Plungar when emergency services arrived at about 3.30pm. Chaotic and 'stressful' scenes followed as the children and charity workers were taken to the village hall, which was used as a makeshift triage centre, for examination. Eight children, all boys aged between 8 and 11, and one adult were taken to hospital, but have all been discharged. Ruben was arrested in the pub car park on Monday on suspicion of administering poison or a noxious substance with intent to injure, aggrieve or annoy. He was charged on Friday evening with three counts of wilful ill treatment of a child, relating to three of the children. The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) has authorised prosecution of Ruben for child cruelty offences. Janine McKinney, the chief crown prosecutor for CPS East Midlands, said: 'This has been an extremely upsetting and shocking moment for the community, and especially for the children and parents most directly affected.' Ruben will appear at Leicester magistrates' court on Saturday. Ruben and his wife run the Stathern Children's Holiday Fund, which organises subsidised holidays at the lodge for children from disadvantaged areas of Nottingham. The charity calls its summer camps 'safe havens for fostering friendships, building skills and sparking potential'. It welcomes children of all faiths. Campers enjoy outdoor activities at the lodge, which has games rooms, as well as the park, zip wire and bouncy castles. Children who have attended have said their favourite features are the tuck shop and 'delicious food'. In its annual reports, the charity suggested volunteers have struggled to cope with the demands of caring for a large number of children, a significant proportion of whom have 'moderate to severe behavioural, learning or medical conditions'. The report in 2023 said: 'Even though we have a large number of volunteers, we do need a higher ratio of adults to children than legally required to care effectively for these youngsters.' The trustees previously agreed to limit the length of the stays to three days and reduce the number of children in each group 'because four days appeared too exhausting for the volunteers'. Ruben qualified as a primary school teacher before working as a locum and a youth worker at his church. Plungar residents described upsetting scenes as children were taken for medical assessments before their parents started to arrive. Leicestershire police referred itself to the Independent Office for Police Conduct over its initial handling of the incident. The watchdog will investigate its delayed response.
