logo
SMME Focus: How SA banks are rethinking SMME finance in a cash-first economy

SMME Focus: How SA banks are rethinking SMME finance in a cash-first economy

Daily Maverick01-05-2025
Cash is still king in South Africa's informal economy, and banks are not pretending otherwise. Lenders are starting to rewrite the rules of engagement when it comes to the country's spaza shops and township traders.
South Africa's small, medium and micro enterprises (SMMEs) are punching well above their weight. They contribute to around 34% of GDP and employ roughly 60% of the labour force, according to the Banking Association of South Africa.
Regardless of their economic muscle, SMMEs – especially those in townships and the informal sector – remain financial outsiders. The formal banking system often misses the mark in a country where cash is still the currency of trust.
'In the battle between cards and mobile money, who is winning? Cash. I think cash is still winning,' said Wiza Jalakasi, director of African expansion at payments partner, EBANX.
The R5-trillion sector running on rands and cents
The MSME (micro, small, medium enterprises) sector has an estimated turnover of R5,29-trillion, with 72% of SMMEs operating informally and remaining largely cash driven, according to FinScope's MSME 2024 survey.
Townships and rural SMMEs often exist outside the formal banking system, leaving them vulnerable to theft, limited growth and a lack of credit history.
'Physical cash being handed to a merchant and being translated into a digital currency or an instant deposit into a transaction account – that makes businesses work,' said Chris Wood, Absa's executive of product. '[Banks] have got to be sitting there at the crossroads.'
South Africa's banks are showing up to that intersection. But rather than forcing SMMEs to go digital, they're starting by meeting SMMEs where they are.
Lending on a swipe
At Capitec's annual financial results presentation this week, the company's CEO, Gerrie Fourie, said the bank sees huge potential in the informal market. 'There's about 3 million spaza shops out there, 70% of them in the informal market. How do we capture that market and actually unlock the potential in South Africa?'
Capitec's solution analyses a business's daily takings and tailors credit accordingly. 'We say you need to look at the cash flows. They haven't got assets,' Fourie said. 'So you need to lend against the cash flow. And that's the model we've built.'
Capitec's dynamic loan model deducts payments as a fixed percentage of a merchant's inflows – whether from cash, card, or EFT. '[The customer] repays his loan as their business is performing,' he said.
In a year, the bank's small business base has more than doubled from 28,000 to 63,000. It has also issued more than R1.2-billion in scored loans to small businesses.
The card machine cartel
A major barrier to digital inclusion is the hardware itself.
Traditional card machine rental models, costing around R500 a month, are out of reach for micro enterprises. Fourie noted that Capitec has shifted towards a model where businesses can buy a device from R1,499.
'I think the rental model is ridiculous,' Fourie told Daily Maverick. 'The average rent is just below R500. If you buy your machine it's R2,000. So in four months, you've repaid (the cost of) your machine.'
Competitors such as Yoco offer similar hardware from as little as R750. Although, it isn't just upfront costs that need to be considered. Transaction commission fees typically range between 2% and 3.5% per sale, depending on the provider, which adds up quickly for high turnover, low margin businesses.
Tap, type, swipe
For banks such as Absa, getting merchants online means giving them options. 'We've got to make sure that where our merchants are, they are able to accept more,' Wood said.
'It could be QR codes, it could be pay by link. And that includes cash,' Wood said. 'That convergence of physical cash and what would always typically have been a merchant card machine, is getting closer and closer.'
The real banking role is systemic: getting cash safely back into the banking system. 'We want to make cash safe and make sure our customers are getting that cash into their transactional accounts sooner,' Wood said.
The SMME arms race
Across the sector, banks are rushing to build trust and relevance with SMMEs.
Standard Bank has launched a township entrepreneur initiative, focused on financial literacy and tailored products. Nedbank, named South Africa's Best SME Bank in 2024, now supports more than half a million businesses through digital tools and a free business development platform.
Meanwhile, FirstRand Bank secured a $150-million (about R2.8-billion) loan from the International Finance Corporation (IFC), earmarked for SMME lending, particularly for women-owned businesses.
FNB announced on 24 April that it is strengthening its lending muscle with more than R4-billion in SMME-lending capacity through two funding streams: a R1.8-billion risk-sharing facility, backed by the International Finance Corporation (IFC) and the EU; and a R2.5-billion social bond issued by FirstRand Bank. The funds will target women-owned businesses and rural sectors such as agriculture and healthcare.
What this means for you as a small business owner
Banks are starting to speak the language of small businesses.
By offering services such as cheaper card machines, loans based on a business's daily takings, and converting cash into credit history, the tide is turning towards financial tools that work in practice and not just on paper.
Teaming up to bridge the gap
To close the IFC's estimated $30-billion (R550-billion) SMME financing gap, banks are teaming up with fintech players.
A notable alliance is Mastercard's partnership with Johannesburg-based Sava, which provides small businesses with digital bank accounts and expense-tracking tools. This hybrid model could help informal businesses become creditworthy.
'Consumers are getting more and more comfortable with the way we're doing digital payments,' said Meagan Rabe, Visa's senior director for sub-Saharan Africa fintech. 'In South Africa specifically, 70% of consumers are wanting to be digital.'
That shift is already playing out in numbers – at Capitec, at least. 'When we started 20 years ago, 80% of our transactions were cash and 20% was electronic. Now we're 13% cash and 87% card,' Fourie said.
The Reserve Bank, he added, is also laying the groundwork for a more digital economy, taking cues from countries such as India and Brazil. DM
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Tshwane slaps 713 properties with penalty rates over illegal land use
Tshwane slaps 713 properties with penalty rates over illegal land use

The Citizen

timean hour ago

  • The Citizen

Tshwane slaps 713 properties with penalty rates over illegal land use

In a bid to ensure the legal use of land, the metro has referred over 700 properties for penalty rates and taxes. Sarah Mabotsa, MMC for Economic Development and Spatial Planning, said the suburbs where the illegal land use activities have been identified range from Arcadia to Zwavelpoort. 'The non-permitted land use activities range from unauthorised commercial activities in residential zones, through to illegal construction and land encroachments. The implications of these violations on the city and its residents are significant, as they can lead to loss of revenue, inability to access critical servitudes, offer unfair land-use activity and commercial advantages to transgressors.' They can also increase the costs of policing for the city, and have potential safety and legal liabilities.' The areas or farms she listed include: – Alphenpark – Annlin – Arcadia – Ashlea Gardens – Atteridgeville – Bon Accord – Booysens – Brooklyn – Capital Park – De Onderstepoort – Derdepoort – Die Wilgers – Eersterust – Elandsfontein – Eldoraigne – Ga-Rankuwa – Garsfontein – Haakdoornboom – Hartebeesfontein – Hazelwood – Kameeldrift – Kleinfontein – Kudube – Laudium – Magalieskruin – Montana – Moreletapark – Olievenhoutsbos – Onderstepoort – Pretoria Central – Pretoria North – Silverton – Sinoville – Soshanguve – Sunnyside – The Reeds – The Willows – Waterkloof – Witfontein – Zwavelpoort She highlighted the financial magnitude of the properties under scrutiny, saying: 'The 713 properties have a combined municipal value of almost R1.4-billion, with the average property value being R1.9-million.' She explained that township establishment laws are designed to prevent chaotic urban sprawl and ensure that the city infrastructure keeps pace with development. 'For example, when an estate is established legally, the developers contribute to the cost of expanding roads, water, sewage and electricity services. Those costs are then passed on to property purchasers. When a development happens illegally, developer contributions could unfairly be expected to be paid for by all other ratepayers. Illegal developments can also place too much strain on available electricity or other services in an area,' she explained. This comes after the recent report tabled and approved by the metro, listing the properties that have been referred by the Department of Economic Development and Spatial Planning to the finance department for implementation of penalty rates and taxes. 713 properties worth R1.357 billion have been referred for penalty rates & taxes for illegal land use activity. — City of Tshwane (@CityTshwane) July 3, 2025 She emphasised that several properties or farms relate to illegal township developments where landowners have not adhered to development planning laws and regulations. 'The city's Department of Economic Development and Spatial Planning Department's Built Environment and Enforcement Division receives numerous complaints related to contraventions of zoning, national building regulations and the city's outdoor advertising by-law. The recommendation to implement nonpermitted land-use rates is one mechanism we use to encourage landowners engaged in non-compliant land-use activities to correct their actions,' she said. She added that the equitable enforcement of laws is a priority to help curb the illegal use of land. 'We want our city to be safe, clean and work for everyone. I thank our law-abiding developers and property owners who work with the city and within the national building codes to ensure that land use activities are compliant and that buildings are safe for people to use and occupy.' She encouraged the legal development processes as they protect homeowners and residents. 'The processes ensure that homes are built on stable land and not in environmentally vulnerable areas. In some illegal estates, there has also been no formal subdivision of the land. This means that purchasers in illegal estates may not actually own the land that they live on,' she said. LISTEN: Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!

G20 audiovisual advert launch marks the beginning of a significant journey
G20 audiovisual advert launch marks the beginning of a significant journey

The Citizen

time3 hours ago

  • The Citizen

G20 audiovisual advert launch marks the beginning of a significant journey

With the G20 five months away, Brand South Africa, on July 3 at Circa Gallery, launched an audiovisual advert to mark the beginning of a significant journey; one that offers a historic platform to influence global dialogue. The G20 is an international forum of both developing and developed countries which seeks to find solutions to global economic and financial issues. Brand South Africa's CEO Neville Matjie explained: 'The launch of the [advert] marks a significant leadership journey. One that offers a historic platform to influence global dialogue and inclusive development, sustainable partnerships, and shared prosperity. Our president has been clear that the G20 is not only about South Africa; it's about the importance of showcasing the opportunities, benefits, and the importance of the African continent.' Also read: 26 foreign nationals rescued from alleged human trafficking ring in Rembrandt Park Deputy Minister in the Presidency Kenny Morolong added that South Africa cheering the G20 will not only mark a historic milestone; it'll mark a pivotal opportunity to emphasise the voice of the global south, and reshape global co-operation in a way that is more inclusive, equitable, and sustainable. 'As the first African country to cheer the G20, we are conscious of the trust placed on us, not only by our G20 members, but by the broader international community, looking at this forum for leadership in times of uncertainty,' noted Morolong. Follow us on our Whatsapp channel, Facebook, X, Instagram, and TikTok for the latest updates and inspiration! Have a story idea? We'd love to hear from you – join our WhatsApp group and share your thoughts! At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!

Mamelodi hits back at relief scheme: ‘Scrap debt for all, or none!'
Mamelodi hits back at relief scheme: ‘Scrap debt for all, or none!'

The Citizen

time7 hours ago

  • The Citizen

Mamelodi hits back at relief scheme: ‘Scrap debt for all, or none!'

Mamelodi hits back at relief scheme: 'Scrap debt for all, or none!' Tshwane metro recently announced that they have written off more than R4.4-billion of debt to 20 000 amnesty applications from residents who tampered with their electricity meters. This initiative, championed by Deputy Mayor and MMC for Finance, Eugene Modise, was designed to ease the financial burden of municipal debt. However, Mamelodi residents are still complaining that despite applying for amnesty, they have not had any feedback from the council, and some residents are still receiving final letters of demand. President of Mamelodi Concerned Residents for Service Delivery, Oupa Mtshweni, said more and more people are still coming to his office complaining about receiving final letters of demand, despite applying for amnesty. 'Debt must be scrapped for all people of Mamelodi because the problem stems from the incorrect, estimated billing system, which affected most and not only those the metro regards as indigents,' he insisted. He said he had pleaded with the deputy mayor during his visit to Mamelodi to deal with illegal connections at informal settlements before helping the residents of Mamelodi. 'We cannot pay for municipal services while illegal squatter camps around Mamelodi get the services for free,' said Mtshweni. He added that when Tshwane is done with the informal settlements, it should come back and discuss the scrapping of debt for all residents of Mamelodi. 'When these estimations started, it affected everyone in Mamelodi – therefore scrap all municipal bills for all residents and we all start afresh from zero,' said Mtshweni. He said that they are still waiting for the metro to remove all illegal connections in informal settlements around Mamelodi. Metro spokesperson Lindela Mashigo said the city's Finance Department has submitted applications for amnesty to its Electricity Department, but they have not received the exact figures for Mamelodi or per region. Mashigo said these will be available once job cards are assigned and the meters are attended to. He added that a total of 20 056 applications from across the city have been received. 'The number might rise slightly as counting wraps up. For the incentive and debt relief scheme, we received 1 033 applications, with a total debt of more than R147-million.' He added that the metro reported a late rush in submissions. 'More than 50% of the applications were received in the last week before closing.' All applications received under the debt relief scheme have been approved, with some receiving a partial write-off after agreeing to a payment agreement. With regard to the electricity amnesty process, which targeted illegal meter tampering, the metro said it had already captured 17 140 of the 20 056 forms. A total of 10 741 were issued to the electricity department, but only 300 had been normalised so far. 'The process is ongoing until all legible [applications] have been normalised.' Mashigo said that while the debt relief approvals are nearly finished, the amnesty programme is still in progress. 'The total value of municipal debt written off through the combination of indigent relief, inactive accounts, and incentive schemes stands at a staggering R4.4-billion.' He said the incentive and debt relief scheme helped write off R66.4-million in debt owed by 918 residential accounts and 66 businesses, who together owed R147.4-million. Of this, R81-million was either collected or payment arrangements were made. 'The scheme is not a simple debt write-off arrangement. The metro incentivised customers to settle a portion of their municipal accounts or enter into a settlement arrangement to benefit from a write-off of a portion of the debt.' Although the amnesty campaign focused mainly on electricity, the incentive scheme covered all services, including water, refuse, and sanitation. Mashigo said on the indigent relief side, about R2.4-million was written off from 85 361 indigent accounts, an intervention aimed at aiding the poorest residents. The metro plans to review the effectiveness of the campaign, and the outcome of that review will inform the next course of action. Mashigo said Tshwane's credit control and debt collection policy remains the central guide to future financial strategy, and that this policy includes ongoing measures, such as disconnections and prepaid blocking. He closed by saying, 'The metro's revenue recovery has been enhanced by the R81-million recovered or committed to through arrangements.' Do you have more information about the story? Please send us an email to [email protected] or phone us on 083 625 4114. For free breaking and community news, visit Rekord's websites: Rekord East For more news and interesting articles, like Rekord on Facebook, follow us on Twitter or Instagram or TikTok. At Caxton, we employ humans to generate daily fresh news, not AI intervention. Happy reading!

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store