Karen Read juror leaned guilty through trial. Here's what changed her mind
At least one juror told interviewers afterwards that she was leaning toward guilty as she met with her fellow jurors to deliberate.
Janet Jimenez, in an interview with WCVB, told the news outlet that she had filled up a notebook and a half with notes on evidence and witness testimony.
'I was hoping that my fellow jurors could help me to go through all of this,' Jimenez said during the interview. 'So I went in with a very open mind but definitely leaning toward that she was guilty.'
Read, 45, was charged with second-degree murder, manslaughter while operating under the influence and leaving the scene of an accident causing injury or death in the 2022 death of her police officer boyfriend, John O'Keefe, who was found in the snow outside the Canton home of a fellow Boston police officer.
The jury acquitted Read of the three most serious charges — second-degree murder, manslaughter, and leaving the scene of an accident — but was convicted of operating under the influence.
That verdict ended a near three-year saga as well as two trials, the first ending in a mistrial.
Jimenez, who WCVB identified as a personal trainer, said she felt it was highly likely she would be selected to be a juror because she knew almost nothing about the case — unlike many who had followed along with the first trial.
Jimenez told WCVB that she found the defense's argument about a Google search for 'hos long to die in cold' hours before O'Keefe's body was found unconvincing, and that she found lead investigator Michael Proctor's text messages about Read 'crude' but not proof of a coverup.
What eventually swayed Jimenez was when she went looking for something among the 200 pieces of evidence, but didn't find it.
Jimenez wouldn't tell WCVB what it was she was looking for, but when it didn't turn up, that was meaningful to her.
'It was one big part that led me closer to 'there's a lot of doubt,'' she said.
Jimenez and the other jurors had a long period of deliberations. Overall it took about 22 hours for the seven women and five men to come to their decision.
The jurors sent four notes to presiding judge Beverly Cannone and had a false start on Wednesday before delivering their verdict.
Jimenez said she stands by her decision.
'I'm very comfortable with how I came to the decision,' she said. 'So I guess it will be part of my story.'
That echoes another juror who has come forward, Paula Prado, who told the Today show she was convinced Read was not guilty and that 'We did the right thing.'
MassLive reporter Charlie McKenna contributed to this article.
Poll finds widespread support for Karen Read among eligible jurors
Albert, McCabe families address Karen Read trial verdict in TV interview
'We did the right thing': Juror in Karen Read retrial confident in acquittal
Karen Read's defense changed its strategy for retrial — and won
Michael Proctor to speak in 2-hour Dateline special following Karen Read trial
Read the original article on MassLive.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Why Bryan Kohberger's guilty plea means he may get the last laugh — and torment his victims further
When Bryan Kohberger pleads guilty to murdering four college students today, he wins control of the narrative and has the last laugh, a murder case expert tells The Post. With a trial averted and the death penalty taken off the table through a plea deal, Kohberger, 30, will go to prison the only person with firsthand knowledge of what he did in the bedrooms of 1122 King Road in Moscow, Idaho, on November 13, 2022, and why. 'With no trial, he gets to keep certain secrets. The air of mystery and in some ways that gives him the upper hand,' Jeff Guinn, author of crime books including 'The Life and Times of Charles Manson,' and 'Waco,' among others told The Post Tuesday. Advertisement Indeed, Guinn notes that the lack of a trial means the victims' families and the general public may never hear evidence of what motivated Kohberger to murder four University of Idaho students, which of them – if any – were the intended target or if he had ever met them. 5 Criminal trial experts tell The Post Kohberger will get the power to spin the story of the despicable crime to suit him from prison when he answers a guilty plea. 5 The University of Idaho victims (clockwise from bottom left): Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Madison Mogen, 21, Ethan Chapin, 20, and Xana Kernodle, 20. Advertisement 'If he decides he wants to make a public statement he's taking control through this deal because he's still living, breathing and talking. As long he can talk, he's got some control,' Guinn said. However, the trauma of the despicable slaughter will continue to burden the grieving families of his victims: Madison Mogen, 21; Kaylee Goncalves, 21; Xana Kernoodle, 20; and Ethan Chapin, 20. Furious family members of the murdered students have already said they will fight the plea deal offered by prosecutors, which puts Kohberger behind bars for life without the possibility of appeal or parole. 'Idaho has failed. They failed me. They failed my whole family,' Steve Goncalves, father of Kaylee, told NBC's 'Today' show. Advertisement Kohberger, who was a Criminology student at Washington State University, just a few miles from Moscow but over state lines, was arrested in December 2022. He was slated to go to trial in August after a protracted legal back and forth delayed proceedings. 5 'By not having a trial, he [Kohberger] gets to keep certain secrets, the air of mystery and in some ways that gives him the upper hand,' Jeff Guinn, author of crime books including 'Manson: The Life and Times of Charles Manson,' and 'Waco,' among others told The Post Tuesday. AP 5 Steve Goncalves, father of University of Idaho student Kaylee Goncalves, speaking during a vigil in 2022 James Keivom Now, Guinn says, it's most likely the majority of evidence amassed by prosecutors about Kohberger's crimes will remain sealed. Advertisement Guinn noted Kohberger's life behind bars could play out much like notorious career criminal Charles Manson, who died behind bars in 2017. Manson was handed the death penalty for murders carried out by his cult in 1971 in California, but the sentence was commuted to life in prison in 1972 when the state briefly abolished the death penalty. 5 Victim Xana Kernodle (middle) with her father Jeff and sister Jazzmin in Dec. 2021. AP '[Charles] Manson set the paradigm for how much notoriety you can get, for how much you can live off your bloody exploits by getting that life imprisonment. Periodically he would say or do something crazy and get his name back in the news,' Guinn told The Post. 'In [Kohberger's] case, if you commit this kind of crime you tend to think of yourself as sort of a God-like figure anyway. The plea gives him a further chance to exist in a way that will get more attention, and make him seem [to himself] more superhuman … I doubt he's taking this plea to quietly disappear into the penal system. 'The secondary thing is I'm surprised the prosecution would do this if they felt they had a slam dunk case.' Although Idaho has the death penalty, its last successful execution was in 2012. An attempt to execute prisoner Thomas Creech in February 2024 was aborted after an hour after the team could not establish a reliable IV line into his body.
New York Post
3 hours ago
- New York Post
Why Brian Kohberger's guilty plea means he may get the last laugh — and torment his victims further
When Bryan Kohberger pleads guilty to murdering four college students today, he wins control of the narrative and has the last laugh, a murder case expert tells The Post. With a trial averted and the death penalty taken off the table through a plea deal, Kohberger, 30, will go to prison the only person with firsthand knowledge of what he did in the bedrooms of 1122 King Road in Moscow, Idaho, on November 13, 2022, and why. 'With no trial, he gets to keep certain secrets. The air of mystery and in some ways that gives him the upper hand,' Jeff Guinn, author of crime books including 'The Life and Times of Charles Manson,' and 'Waco,' among others told The Post Tuesday. Indeed, Guinn notes that the lack of a trial means the victims' families and the general public may never hear evidence of what motivated Kohberger to murder four University of Idaho students, which of them – if any – were the intended target or if he had ever met them. 5 Criminal trial experts tell The Post Kohberger will get the power to spin the story of the despicable crime to suit him from prison when he answers a guilty plea. 5 The University of Idaho victims (clockwise from bottom left): Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Madison Mogen, 21, Ethan Chapin, 20, and Xana Kernodle, 20. 'If he decides he wants to make a public statement he's taking control through this deal because he's still living, breathing and talking. As long he can talk, he's got some control,' Guinn said. However, the trauma of the despicable slaughter will continue to burden the grieving families of his victims: Madison Mogen, 21; Kaylee Goncalves, 21; Xana Kernoodle, 20; and Ethan Chapin, 20. Furious family members of the murdered students have already said they will fight the plea deal offered by prosecutors, which puts Kohberger behind bars for life without the possibility of appeal or parole. 'Idaho has failed. They failed me. They failed my whole family,' Steve Goncalves, father of Kaylee, told NBC's 'Today' show. Kohberger, who was a Criminology student at Washington State University, just a few miles from Moscow but over state lines, was arrested in December 2022. He was slated to go to trial in August after a protracted legal back and forth delayed proceedings. 5 'By not having a trial, he [Kohberger] gets to keep certain secrets, the air of mystery and in some ways that gives him the upper hand,' Jeff Guinn, author of crime books including 'Manson: The Life and Times of Charles Manson,' and 'Waco,' among others told The Post Tuesday. AP 5 Steve Goncalves, father of University of Idaho student Kaylee Goncalves, speaking during a vigil in 2022 James Keivom Now, Guinn says, it's most likely the majority of evidence amassed by prosecutors about Kohberger's crimes will remain sealed. Guinn noted Kohberger's life behind bars could play out much like notorious career criminal Charles Manson, who died behind bars in 2017. Manson was handed the death penalty for murders carried out by his cult in 1971 in California, but the sentence was commuted to life in prison in 1972 when the state briefly abolished the death penalty. 5 Victim Xana Kernodle (middle) with her fahter Jeff and sister Jazzmin in Dec. 2021. AP '[Charles] Manson set the paradigm for how much notoriety you can get, for how much you can live off your bloody exploits by getting that life imprisonment. Periodically he would say or do something crazy and get his name back in the news,' Guinn told The Post. 'In [Kohberger's] case, if you commit this kind of crime you tend to think of yourself as sort of a God-like figure anyway. The plea gives him a further chance to exist in a way that will get more attention, and make him seem [to himself] more superhuman … I doubt he's taking this plea to quietly disappear into the penal system. 'The secondary thing is I'm surprised the prosecution would do this if they felt they had a slam dunk case.' Although Idaho has the death penalty, its last successful execution was in 2012. An attempt to execute prisoner Thomas Creech in February 2024 was aborted after an hour after the team could not establish a reliable IV line into his body.
7 hours ago
A day outside an LA detention center shows profound impact of ICE raids on families
LOS ANGELES -- At a federal immigration building in downtown Los Angeles guarded by U.S. Marines, daughters, sons, aunts, nieces and others make their way to an underground garage and line up at a door with a buzzer at the end of a dirty, dark stairwell. It's here where families, some with lawyers, come to find their loved ones after they've been arrested by federal immigration agents. For immigrants without legal status who are detained in this part of Southern California, their first stop is the Immigration and Customs Enforcement processing center in the basement of the federal building. Officers verify their identity and obtain their biometrics before transferring them to detention facilities. Upstairs, immigrants line up around the block for other services, including for green cards and asylum applications. On a recent day, dozens of people arrived with medication, clothing and hope of seeing their loved one, if only briefly. After hours of waiting, many were turned away with no news, not even confirmation that their relative was inside. Some relayed reports of horrific conditions inside, including inmates who are so thirsty that they have been drinking from the toilets. ICE did not respond to emailed requests for comment. Just two weeks ago, protesters marched around the federal complex following aggressive raids in Los Angeles that began June 6 and have not stopped. Scrawled expletives about President Donald Trump still mark the complex's walls. Those arrested are from a variety of countries, including Mexico, Guatemala, India, Iran, China and Laos. About a third of the county's 10 million residents are foreign-born. Many families learned about the arrests from videos circulating on social media showing masked officers in parking lots at Home Depots, at car washes and in front of taco stands. Around 8 a.m., when attorney visits begin, a few lawyers buzz the basement door called 'B-18" as families wait anxiously outside to hear any inkling of information. Christina Jimenez and her cousin arrive to check if her 61-year-old stepfather is inside. Her family had prepared for the possibility of this happening to the day laborer who would wait to be hired outside a Home Depot in the LA suburb of Hawthorne. They began sharing locations when the raids intensified. They told him that if he were detained, he should stay silent and follow instructions. Jimenez had urged him to stop working, or at least avoid certain areas as raids increased. But he was stubborn and 'always hustled.' 'He could be sick and he's still trying to make it out to work,' Jimenez said. After learning of his arrest, she looked him up online on the ICE Detainee Locator but couldn't find him. She tried calling ICE to no avail. Two days later, her phone pinged with his location downtown. 'My mom's in shock,' Jimenez said. 'She goes from being very angry to crying, same with my sister.' Jimenez says his name into the intercom – Mario Alberto Del Cid Solares. After a brief wait, she is told yes, he's there. She and her cousin breathe a sigh of relief — but their questions remain. Her biggest fear is that instead of being sent to his homeland of Guatemala, he will be deported to another country, something the Supreme Court recently ruled was allowed. By mid-morning, Estrella Rosas and her mother have come looking for her sister, Andrea Velez, a U.S. citizen. A day earlier, they saw Velez being detained after they dropped her off at her marketing job at a shoe company downtown. 'My mom told me to call 911 because someone was kidnapping her,' Rosas said. Stuck on a one-way street, they had to circle the block. By the time they got back, she says they saw Velez in handcuffs being put into a car without license plates. Velez's family believes she was targeted for looking Hispanic and standing near a tamale stand. Rosas has her sister's passport and U.S. birth certificate, but learns she is not there. They find her next door in a federal detention center. She was accused of obstructing immigration officers, which the family denies, but is released the next day. About 20 people are now outside. Some have found cardboard to sit on after waiting hours. One family comforts a woman who is crying softly in the stairwell. Then the door opens, and a group of lawyers emerge. Families rush to ask if the attorneys could help them. Kim Carver, a lawyer with the Trans Latino Coalition, says she planned to see her client, a transgender Honduran woman, but she was transferred to a facility in Texas at 6:30 that morning. Carver accompanied her less than a week ago for an immigration interview and the asylum officer told her she had a credible case. Then ICE officers walked in and detained her. 'Since then, it's been just a chase trying to find her,' she says. As more people arrive, the group begins sharing information. One person explains the all-important 'A-number,' the registration number given to every detainee, which is needed before an attorney can help. They exchange tips like how to add money to an account for phone calls. One woman says $20 lasted three or four calls for her. Mayra Segura is looking for her uncle after his frozen popsicle cart was abandoned in the middle of the sidewalk in Culver City. 'They couldn't find him in the system,' she says. Another lawyer, visibly frustrated, comes out the door. She's carrying bags of clothes, snacks, Tylenol, and water that she says she wasn't allowed to give to her client, even though he says he had been given only one water bottle over the past two days. The line stretches outside the stairwell into the sun. A man leaves and returns with water for everyone. Nearly an hour after family visitations are supposed to begin, people are finally allowed in. Still wearing hospital scrubs from work, Jasmin Camacho Picazo comes to see her husband again. She brought a sweater because he had told her he was cold, and his back injury was aggravated from sleeping on the ground. 'He mentioned this morning (that) people were drinking from the restroom toilet water,' Picazo says. On her phone, she shows footage of his car left on the side of the road after his arrest. The window was smashed and the keys were still in the ignition. 'I can't stop crying," Picazo says. Her son keeps asking: "Is Papa going to pick me up from school?' More than five hours after Jimenez and her cousin arrive, they see her stepfather. 'He was sad and he's scared," says Jimenez afterwards. 'We tried to reassure him as much as possible.' She wrote down her phone number, which he had not memorized, so he could call her. More people arrive as others are let in. Yadira Almadaz comes out crying after seeing her niece's boyfriend for only five minutes. She says he was in the same clothes he was wearing when he was detained a week ago at an asylum appointment in the city of Tustin. He told her he'd only been given cookies and chips to eat each day. 'It breaks my heart seeing a young man cry because he's hungry and thirsty,' she says. Four minutes before visitation time is supposed to end, an ICE officer opens the door and announces it's over. One woman snaps at him in frustration. The officer tells her he would get in trouble if he helped her past 4 p.m. More than 20 people are still waiting in line. Some trickle out. Others linger, staring at the door in disbelief.
