UK judges sound alarm over AI-fabricated cases
Victoria Sharp, president of the King's Bench Division of the High Court, along with fellow judge Jeremy Johnson, reprimanded lawyers involved in two separate cases for apparently relying on AI tools to draft written arguments that were submitted to the court without verification.
'There are serious implications for the administration of justice and public confidence in the justice system if artificial intelligence is misused,' she said in the ruling on Friday.
The cases arose after lower courts flagged suspected use of AI-generated arguments and witness statements containing false information.
In the ruling by Judge Sharp, the court revealed that one attorney, in a £90 million ($120 million) lawsuit concerning an alleged breach of a financing agreement with Qatar National Bank, cited 18 non-existent cases.
Hamad Al-Haroun, the client in the case, apologized for unintentionally misleading the court with false information generated by publicly available AI tools, accepting personal responsibility and absolving his solicitor, Abid Hussain.
Sharp said it was 'extraordinary that the lawyer was relying on the client for the accuracy of their legal research, rather than the other way around.'
In another case, barrister Sarah Forey cited five fabricated cases in a tenant's housing claim against the London Borough of Haringey. The lawyer denied intentionally using AI but acknowledged she may have done so inadvertently while conducting online research for the case.
The judge scolded her saying that 'Ms Forey could have checked the cases she cited by searching the National Archives' caselaw website or by going to the law library of her Inn of Court.'
Sharp warned that presenting false material as genuine could constitute contempt of court or, in the most serious cases, perverting the course of justice – a criminal offense punishable by up to life imprisonment.
The judges referred the lawyers in both cases to their respective professional regulators but declined to pursue more severe penalties.
High-profile figures and scientists have raised concerns in recent years over the potential dangers posed by AI.
Researchers warn that artificial intelligence is advancing rapidly, with some models reportedly becoming self-aware and rewriting their own code. Palisade Research reported last month that in recent tests, a powerful AI model 'sabotaged a shutdown mechanism to prevent itself from being turned off,' raising concerns of a potential real-world AI rebellion.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Russia Today
6 hours ago
- Russia Today
Recently vandalized UK warplanes are foreign assets – ex-envoy to RT (VIDEO)
The Royal Air Force warplanes defaced by pro-Palestinian activists last month are owned not by the British government but a US hedge fund, prominent human-rights activist Craig Murray has alleged. He added that at least some of the planes appear to be routinely leased out to the Israeli military. In June, several activists from the group Palestine Action broke into Brize Norton, the UK's largest airbase, and sprayed red paint into the turbines of two Voyager aircraft before fleeing the scene undetected. The group said the stunt was a protest against the supposed involvement of the Royal Air Force in Israel's military operation in Gaza. The British authorities vowed to prosecute those responsible. Speaking to RT on Sunday, Murray, who served as British ambassador to Uzbekistan from 2002 till 2004 and is an associate of WikiLeaks' co-founder Julian Assange, said that he had discovered that the planes in question were owned by Airtanker Ltd, which, in turn, is supposedly 'owned by a string of seven fake companies.' According to Murray, behind the cutout entities stands a US hedge fund named Polygon Global Partners LLP, which is the real owner of the planes. He claimed that the entity 'has joint interests with the Trump organization and BlackRock,' which has stakes in several military industrial giants. The former British diplomat told RT that of the 14 planes in question 'nine are permanently with the RAF, and five of them are sometimes with the RAF, and sometimes can be leased out to other foreign militaries, including the Israeli military.' 'It seems to be fairly definite that the Israelis are using these planes. These planes have been frequently flying to [the RAF Akrotiri airbase in Cyprus] which has been the main military support base for Israeli activities into Gaza,' Murray claimed. He added that officials in London refuse to either confirm or deny that such military missions are carried out in support of Israel. On top of that, according to Murray, the British 'taxpayer is being ripped off' as under the contract with Polygon Global, the UK government is 'paying five times the value of these planes.' He said the agreement expires in 2049. In the wake of the vandalism, UK Home Secretary Yvette Cooper announced plans to designate the activist group as a terrorist organization and ban it.
Russia Today
7 hours ago
- Russia Today
Putin speaks at BRICS summit
Russian President Vladimir Putin is delivering a speech at the plenary session of the 17th BRICS summit. The annual two-day gathering of the group kicked off on Sunday in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, which currently holds the group's rotating presidency. This year, Russia's delegation at the summit is led by Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov. The Russian president has joined the plenary session, called 'Strengthening Multilateralism, Economic-Financial Affairs, and Artificial Intelligence' via a videolink. Brazil had named six priorities for this year's agenda, namely global health cooperation; trade, investment, and finance; climate change; AI governance; reform of the multilateral peace and security system; and institutional development within BRICS. This year's summit brings together some 4,000 participants from 37 nations, including senior dignitaries from member states, partner countries and international bodies.
Russia Today
a day ago
- Russia Today
French police entering the sea with knives to tackle illegal migration
French police have begun using knives to slash inflatable dinghies used by illegal migrants attempting to cross the English Channel to reach the British coast, according to video footage aired by the BBC. Employed for the first time, the tactic is expected to give officers greater powers to prevent illegal crossings, The Times reported on Friday. BBC footage released the same day showed a group of police officers approaching a rubber boat packed with migrants as it attempted to push away from the shore, puncturing the vessel before it could depart for the UK. The deflated dinghy was later seen being dragged back to land. The practice of puncturing rubber boats already in the water comes as a 'precursor' to an anticipated change in French maritime law, according to a source familiar with the matter cited by the BBC. The impending update will reportedly allow officers from the specialized Compagnie de Marche policing unit to reach migrant dinghies not only on beaches but also in shallow coastal waters before they can launch into the Channel. Current rules allow police to only intervene at sea in rescue operations. France and Britain are expected to formally unveil the new enforcement measures next week at a bilateral summit, where the two nations will discuss cooperation on reducing small-boat crossings in the Channel. The step forms part of a renewed partnership to tackle illegal migration and strengthen border security. The measures are reportedly set to be implemented later this month. The decades-long migrant crisis largely stems from conflict, poverty, and political instability across regions such as the Middle East, Africa, and South Asia. Western interventions, including wars in Iraq, Libya, and Afghanistan, as well as support for uprisings in Syria, have exacerbated these conditions, destabilizing governments and fueling violence. As a result, many people have been forced to flee, making today's migration challenges, in part, a consequence of past foreign policies. Earlier this week, the UK Home Office reported that the number of asylum seekers arriving in the UK via small boats during the first half of 2025 totaled 19,982, marking a 50% increase over the same period last year. The figure is also 75% higher than the 11,433 recorded in 2023.
