We are a diverse nation. Enough stale, pale males
For a project like the SRL, the last thing we need is a business case. Major projects that will continue to be impacting in 100 years' time require a vision. Business cases largely apply to the now and next few years based on business as usual. Major transport developments like the SRL are based on a vision of Melbourne where our dependence on road transport is diminished. Where we can think differently about travel across suburbs. This will allow town planners with vision, create a better living environment. Political leaders should keep quiet if this is all they can say about major projects.
Howard Tankey, Box Hill North
A decade late
The Metro Tunnel, due to open in 2026, is actually seven to 10 years late from its originally recommended timeframe. Sir Rod Eddington's report, Investing in Transport, (2008) had it planned in two sections; the western part (Footscray to Domain) was to open in 2016, and the eastern part (Domain to Caulfield) in 2019. This version was included in the Brumby government's 2008 Victorian Transport Plan, but that was shelved by the Baillieu government in 2011.
In 2013, the Napthine government proposed the Melbourne Rail Link, which inexplicably bypassed Melbourne's CBD.
Finally, the Metro Tunnel was re-introduced, albeit in a shortened, single-stage form (South Yarra to West Kensington) by the Andrews government in 2014, and construction started in 2017. This was a year after it would have opened, if the original plan had been followed.
Political interference in the planning process is the main cause of the delay, which has also added considerably to the cost and reduced the original scope.
William McDougall, Woodend
A big launch lost
The Metro Tunnel opening should be a celebration of a generational step-up in rail services. It should deliver long-overdue service enhancements across much of the rail network. Despite best intentions, projects will inevitably run late however this should not detract from the primary goal of delivering better public transport.
The public quickly forgets the extra time and cost of such projects once they start to experience genuinely improved services.
A partial opening will undermine the community's confidence in the project. It's understandable those responsible for delivering the project are motivated to see the first trains run as soon as possible. Yet a partial service at off-peak times only will confuse passengers and compromise service reliability.
The original business plan foresaw the project opening in 2026. By this measure, the project remains on schedule. The optimism of those delivering the project has created an earlier expectation. The impression of delay shouldn't become the dominant narrative. More importantly, this can't be fixed by starting services with a compromised service plan.
John Hearsch, president, Rail Futures Institute Inc, Heathcote Junction
Many don't get it
If you ask anyone over 60 what they think of the SRL, the majority will say, why would I want to travel from Cheltenham to Box Hill on a train? They don't get it. The major benefit, in our ever expanding city, is a rail loop to connect the outer suburbs, without always having to head to Flinders Street station. Promoting travel times this early means nothing. To cancel the project would be madness, it will never be any cheaper to build.
Paul Custance, Highett
Education business
Graeme Turner's Broken: Universities, Politics & the Public Good offers a timely and sobering reflection on the systemic neglect of Australia's universities (' Netflix has romanticised academia. This is what it's really like ', 29/6). Yet one vital consequence of this neglect is barely mentioned: the proliferation of low-quality, market-driven degrees from bottom-tier or for-profit institutions – degrees that offer little academic substance or job readiness.
As public funding dwindled and universities were told to operate 'like businesses,' many did exactly that – competing for market share by offering dubious degrees with vague titles, weak curricula, and little alignment with real-world skills or scholarly merit – often from institutions few Australians could name. These programs, typically heavy on marketing spin and light on rigour, reflect a system incentivised to enrol, not to educate.
In this race for enrolments, academic standards have been quietly sacrificed. Meanwhile, genuine research and teaching – especially in the humanities and sciences – are underfunded and undervalued. Students are left paying for thin content; employers are left disillusioned by meaningless qualifications.
If we're serious about Australia's 'knowledge infrastructure,' we need to reclaim the integrity of a university education – not just through funding, but through regulation and an unapologetic commitment to quality. A healthy tertiary sector isn't just a line item. It's a national imperative.
Professor David Fox, Beaumaris
Savings start at the top
Graeme Turner's article strikes a loud chord. As an academic myself, I have personally experienced the frustrations outlined and have watched over the last couple of decades as course after course has been cancelled and academics' workloads have increased due to cost-savings. However, there is one aspect to the matter that Turner did not mention. This is the inflated pay packets of the CEOs – sorry, vice chancellors – of our top universities; according to the Australia Institute many are now earning over seven times as much as their teaching staff. While many of those august institutions are firing administrative staff and increasing teaching and administrative workloads on their academics, they somehow can find the money to pay the heads of the university million dollar-plus salaries.
Dr Peter Christopher White, Hawthorn
The hobbies are free
Shona Hendley may not be able to afford to buy herself a bathing suit (' All year, I've tried to find a new hobby. One major problem is crushing my efforts ', 29/6), luckily she can do a lot of things for free. She could join her local Landcare group and help with pulling out weeds in native bushland, and in the evening she might join a group listening for frog song. She can volunteer at her local hospital and spend time holding pre-term babies and giving them some human warmth. She can volunteer at a primary school and help children learn how to read aloud. She can go to her local library and borrow a book for free and if feeling inspired, maybe even write a poem. She can then read it for free at her local pub poetry gig and perhaps lash out, and shout herself a glass of lemonade.
Di Cousens, Upwey
A change of pace
Shona Hendley is looking for a hobby for benefits in mental health, finding purpose and reducing stress. It must fit the budget. One answer is a weekly Scottish country dance class for $6-$10 per class. You enjoy dancing to bright and lively Scottish dance music, make new friends and grow your mental and physical health. There are groups all around Victoria that will welcome new dancers.
Ross Gawler, Malvern
Certain players
Richmond's Tom Lynch is facing a lengthy suspension after throwing a dangerous haymaker (' 'His frustration spills over': Two-touch Tom on report after dirty day at MCG ', 29/6). As a neutral observer of the game, I could not imagine a player being mauled, held and denied access to the contest more than the number of occasions this occurred to Lynch. He remonstrated at length with the umpires. Nothing changed.
The game I love and will continue to love is being compromised by players who continually push players in the back, scrag others and play outside the rules at the behest of coaches. I'm hoping to see defenders in particular given the opportunity to play in front and not get shoved under the ball. And for players like Lynch to be protected from those who scrag and block players' access to the ball.
Andrew Dowling, Torquay
Trusted old lippy
While working overseas at weekends I always read The Age from cover to cover. The article (' Hailey Bieber's latest makeup trend is 'fairy magic'. Here's how to nail it ', 29/06) caught my eye with a breathtaking photograph and how-to video tutorial. How I would love to emulate this look and wondered what it would cost to purchase the recommended products. To my surprise they came to $598. So instead of dreaming of having a fairy magic look when I next go out, I slink away with my trusted old lippy and sunscreen. I could never justify spending close to $600 on a look, especially when the fashion could turn to something different next month.
Judith G. Hudson, Elwood
Public benefit
Your correspondent seems to be suggesting there is an inverse relationship between the money spent on education and the prevalence of youth crime (Letters, 30/6). If he is correct, perhaps the better question might be how do we increase the amount spent on the public system to decrease the number of youths offending?
John Alley, Thurgoona, NSW
AND ANOTHER THING
Venice wedding
Bezos, Zuckerberg and co could be tamed quite quickly if the global online community decided to boycott Amazon purchases, Instagram use etc. And while we're at it, stop watching AFL on Thursday/ Friday night. Could we do it?
Andrew Barnes, Ringwood
So many complaints in The Age letters page about the ugly display of wealth at the Bezos wedding. I don't think they could care less. Memo to the rest of us: Money can't buy class.
Robyn Williams, Sale
I can't believe The Age gave a double-page spread on a multimillion-dollar wedding when there are people in war-torn streets struggling for survival. The bridegroom and the Musks of this world don't deserve one line of print.
Ian Anderson, Surrey Hills
Trump and Israel
Is it true Trump has instructed the Israeli judiciary not to sneeze without his permission, otherwise tariffs will be imposed? (' 'We are not going to stand for this': Trump ties Israeli legal action against Netanyahu to US aid ', 30/6).
Barrie Bales, Woorinen North
Loading
Maureen Dowd recounts Trump's view that a reporter's question disrespected the US military's action. Yet a greater 'disrespect' of the US military came from Trump himself a few years ago when he privately denigrated soldiers who gave their lives, calling them 'losers'.
Joyce Butcher, Williamstown
Maureen Dowd, keeping us sane and entertained.
Denise Deerson, Bulleen
Furthermore
Now, now, George Brandis (Opinion, 30/6) calling your former colleagues 'political onanists' is a little unchristian of you.
Sandra Torpey, Hawthorn
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
6 days ago
- The Age
We are a diverse nation. Enough stale, pale males
Long-term benefits For a project like the SRL, the last thing we need is a business case. Major projects that will continue to be impacting in 100 years' time require a vision. Business cases largely apply to the now and next few years based on business as usual. Major transport developments like the SRL are based on a vision of Melbourne where our dependence on road transport is diminished. Where we can think differently about travel across suburbs. This will allow town planners with vision, create a better living environment. Political leaders should keep quiet if this is all they can say about major projects. Howard Tankey, Box Hill North A decade late The Metro Tunnel, due to open in 2026, is actually seven to 10 years late from its originally recommended timeframe. Sir Rod Eddington's report, Investing in Transport, (2008) had it planned in two sections; the western part (Footscray to Domain) was to open in 2016, and the eastern part (Domain to Caulfield) in 2019. This version was included in the Brumby government's 2008 Victorian Transport Plan, but that was shelved by the Baillieu government in 2011. In 2013, the Napthine government proposed the Melbourne Rail Link, which inexplicably bypassed Melbourne's CBD. Finally, the Metro Tunnel was re-introduced, albeit in a shortened, single-stage form (South Yarra to West Kensington) by the Andrews government in 2014, and construction started in 2017. This was a year after it would have opened, if the original plan had been followed. Political interference in the planning process is the main cause of the delay, which has also added considerably to the cost and reduced the original scope. William McDougall, Woodend A big launch lost The Metro Tunnel opening should be a celebration of a generational step-up in rail services. It should deliver long-overdue service enhancements across much of the rail network. Despite best intentions, projects will inevitably run late however this should not detract from the primary goal of delivering better public transport. The public quickly forgets the extra time and cost of such projects once they start to experience genuinely improved services. A partial opening will undermine the community's confidence in the project. It's understandable those responsible for delivering the project are motivated to see the first trains run as soon as possible. Yet a partial service at off-peak times only will confuse passengers and compromise service reliability. The original business plan foresaw the project opening in 2026. By this measure, the project remains on schedule. The optimism of those delivering the project has created an earlier expectation. The impression of delay shouldn't become the dominant narrative. More importantly, this can't be fixed by starting services with a compromised service plan. John Hearsch, president, Rail Futures Institute Inc, Heathcote Junction Many don't get it If you ask anyone over 60 what they think of the SRL, the majority will say, why would I want to travel from Cheltenham to Box Hill on a train? They don't get it. The major benefit, in our ever expanding city, is a rail loop to connect the outer suburbs, without always having to head to Flinders Street station. Promoting travel times this early means nothing. To cancel the project would be madness, it will never be any cheaper to build. Paul Custance, Highett Education business Graeme Turner's Broken: Universities, Politics & the Public Good offers a timely and sobering reflection on the systemic neglect of Australia's universities (' Netflix has romanticised academia. This is what it's really like ', 29/6). Yet one vital consequence of this neglect is barely mentioned: the proliferation of low-quality, market-driven degrees from bottom-tier or for-profit institutions – degrees that offer little academic substance or job readiness. As public funding dwindled and universities were told to operate 'like businesses,' many did exactly that – competing for market share by offering dubious degrees with vague titles, weak curricula, and little alignment with real-world skills or scholarly merit – often from institutions few Australians could name. These programs, typically heavy on marketing spin and light on rigour, reflect a system incentivised to enrol, not to educate. In this race for enrolments, academic standards have been quietly sacrificed. Meanwhile, genuine research and teaching – especially in the humanities and sciences – are underfunded and undervalued. Students are left paying for thin content; employers are left disillusioned by meaningless qualifications. If we're serious about Australia's 'knowledge infrastructure,' we need to reclaim the integrity of a university education – not just through funding, but through regulation and an unapologetic commitment to quality. A healthy tertiary sector isn't just a line item. It's a national imperative. Professor David Fox, Beaumaris Savings start at the top Graeme Turner's article strikes a loud chord. As an academic myself, I have personally experienced the frustrations outlined and have watched over the last couple of decades as course after course has been cancelled and academics' workloads have increased due to cost-savings. However, there is one aspect to the matter that Turner did not mention. This is the inflated pay packets of the CEOs – sorry, vice chancellors – of our top universities; according to the Australia Institute many are now earning over seven times as much as their teaching staff. While many of those august institutions are firing administrative staff and increasing teaching and administrative workloads on their academics, they somehow can find the money to pay the heads of the university million dollar-plus salaries. Dr Peter Christopher White, Hawthorn The hobbies are free Shona Hendley may not be able to afford to buy herself a bathing suit (' All year, I've tried to find a new hobby. One major problem is crushing my efforts ', 29/6), luckily she can do a lot of things for free. She could join her local Landcare group and help with pulling out weeds in native bushland, and in the evening she might join a group listening for frog song. She can volunteer at her local hospital and spend time holding pre-term babies and giving them some human warmth. She can volunteer at a primary school and help children learn how to read aloud. She can go to her local library and borrow a book for free and if feeling inspired, maybe even write a poem. She can then read it for free at her local pub poetry gig and perhaps lash out, and shout herself a glass of lemonade. Di Cousens, Upwey A change of pace Shona Hendley is looking for a hobby for benefits in mental health, finding purpose and reducing stress. It must fit the budget. One answer is a weekly Scottish country dance class for $6-$10 per class. You enjoy dancing to bright and lively Scottish dance music, make new friends and grow your mental and physical health. There are groups all around Victoria that will welcome new dancers. Ross Gawler, Malvern Certain players Richmond's Tom Lynch is facing a lengthy suspension after throwing a dangerous haymaker (' 'His frustration spills over': Two-touch Tom on report after dirty day at MCG ', 29/6). As a neutral observer of the game, I could not imagine a player being mauled, held and denied access to the contest more than the number of occasions this occurred to Lynch. He remonstrated at length with the umpires. Nothing changed. The game I love and will continue to love is being compromised by players who continually push players in the back, scrag others and play outside the rules at the behest of coaches. I'm hoping to see defenders in particular given the opportunity to play in front and not get shoved under the ball. And for players like Lynch to be protected from those who scrag and block players' access to the ball. Andrew Dowling, Torquay Trusted old lippy While working overseas at weekends I always read The Age from cover to cover. The article (' Hailey Bieber's latest makeup trend is 'fairy magic'. Here's how to nail it ', 29/06) caught my eye with a breathtaking photograph and how-to video tutorial. How I would love to emulate this look and wondered what it would cost to purchase the recommended products. To my surprise they came to $598. So instead of dreaming of having a fairy magic look when I next go out, I slink away with my trusted old lippy and sunscreen. I could never justify spending close to $600 on a look, especially when the fashion could turn to something different next month. Judith G. Hudson, Elwood Public benefit Your correspondent seems to be suggesting there is an inverse relationship between the money spent on education and the prevalence of youth crime (Letters, 30/6). If he is correct, perhaps the better question might be how do we increase the amount spent on the public system to decrease the number of youths offending? John Alley, Thurgoona, NSW AND ANOTHER THING Venice wedding Bezos, Zuckerberg and co could be tamed quite quickly if the global online community decided to boycott Amazon purchases, Instagram use etc. And while we're at it, stop watching AFL on Thursday/ Friday night. Could we do it? Andrew Barnes, Ringwood So many complaints in The Age letters page about the ugly display of wealth at the Bezos wedding. I don't think they could care less. Memo to the rest of us: Money can't buy class. Robyn Williams, Sale I can't believe The Age gave a double-page spread on a multimillion-dollar wedding when there are people in war-torn streets struggling for survival. The bridegroom and the Musks of this world don't deserve one line of print. Ian Anderson, Surrey Hills Trump and Israel Is it true Trump has instructed the Israeli judiciary not to sneeze without his permission, otherwise tariffs will be imposed? (' 'We are not going to stand for this': Trump ties Israeli legal action against Netanyahu to US aid ', 30/6). Barrie Bales, Woorinen North Loading Maureen Dowd recounts Trump's view that a reporter's question disrespected the US military's action. Yet a greater 'disrespect' of the US military came from Trump himself a few years ago when he privately denigrated soldiers who gave their lives, calling them 'losers'. Joyce Butcher, Williamstown Maureen Dowd, keeping us sane and entertained. Denise Deerson, Bulleen Furthermore Now, now, George Brandis (Opinion, 30/6) calling your former colleagues 'political onanists' is a little unchristian of you. Sandra Torpey, Hawthorn
The Age
28-06-2025
- The Age
Living in the fifties is not progress
No case for SRL There is no credible case that we need the SRL. It's envisaged for a Melbourne that doesn't exist, and may never exist. The catchcry that 'Melbourne will be the size of London by 20XX' is a red herring. If you superimpose a map of London public transport over Melbourne, you see nothing resembling the SRL (the Croydon Tramlink is a tram – it lacks the speed and capacity of heavy rail). What you do see is many extra links in the inner suburbs that the government has no plans to implement. To create the demand to justify it (which would be a complete transformation from what is there now) would entail also creating demand for local transport options, eg, local trams or buses with tramlike frequency servicing the surrounds of each of the new stations (and preferably joining up the networks in between), none of which is part of the SRL plan (and if it were it would multiply the cost many times over). It's such an immense distraction from the lack of adequate services in so many areas where the demand exists now but is not being catered to. Samuel McMahon, Parkville Remember Gaza? Israel attacks Iran, America attacks Iran, Iran attacks Israel. Donald Trump calls a ceasefire. The World relaxes. Meanwhile, in forgotten Gaza, thousands starve and hundreds die. Daniel Cole, California Gully Nature equals wellbeing I strongly agree with Ken Henry: our natural environment is very important to our wellbeing, from trees in suburban streets to what's left of the original bush (″ Nature is critical to productivity ″, 25/6). It is good to see a clear, logical explanation of why environmental law reforms are a critical component of the productivity agenda. We should extend the definition of GDP to include not just the monetary value of goods and services created, but the non-monetary value of our natural capital of forests, national parks, oceans and other less developed assets. We could allow for the enjoyment of nature in an overall measure of quality of life. This revised definition of GDP would use many assumptions about the relative value of material goods v the use and experience of nature. Any fall in GDP per head would immediately identify problems with our ″natural capital″. Treasurer Jim Chalmers is convening a productivity summit in August, followed by a tax forum. Now would be the time for Henry to prepare submissions for these conferences. He prepared a detailed report on tax reform back in 2009, with 138 recommendations. Few were implemented. I wish him well this time around, especially for his ″high-integrity environmental laws″. John Hughes, Mentone Overblown view Your correspondent's take (Letters, 27/6) that Julian Assange helped to make Donald Trump 'who has not the slightest interest in accountability' vis-a-vis his selective leaks during the 2016 election campaign, is overblown. On the contrary, the American people made the ″monster″ by re-electing him twice over thereby cementing his unfettered powers that has effectively facilitated his unchecked dismantling of democracy pillars. Not to mention that the Wikileaks material has been sourced by journalists the world over for its veracity. Jelena Rosic, Mornington St Kilda memories I love St Kilda (″ Facing up to boho blues: How St Kilda living lost its lustre ″, 28/6) the Palais, the waterfront, the Acland Street cake shops, Luna Park, Catani Gardens and more. As a child my family were regulars at Leo's Spaghetti Bar on Fitzroy Street and the Fairy Stork Chinese restaurant on Ackland Street. Then as a teenager I graduated to the Prince of Wales, the Venue and the Palace, seeing bands such as Hunters and Collectors and Hoodoo Gurus and on occasion even visiting Bojangles. I'm sad to see empty shop fronts and the turn some parts of the area have taken. We need to be regular visitors to the area as we don't have any other place like this in Melbourne and we will only realise what we have lost when it is gone. Samantha Keir, East Brighton Farewell to Kyiv Foreign correspondent Rob Harris reminds Ukrainians how Kyiv has survived through the ages and continues to defy Putin (″ The city that continues to defy Putin ″, 27/6) . How life goes on as normal. Bars are packed, streets hum with life. The war is not lost as Russia says it is ready for peace talks. Harris in his final visit alongside World Vision Australia says he will not forget Kyiv. I am sure Kyiv will not forget him. George Jaworsky, Wollert Not wedded to this Why do we need to see days of the wedding excesses of Jeff Bezos and Lauren Sanchez? Are there really people out there who watch it and don't realise these people are just revelling in their advantage over the rest of us? I don't understand why so much coverage was given to this in Australia. Maureen Gunn, Strathmore
Sydney Morning Herald
25-06-2025
- Sydney Morning Herald
The secret rail plan to tackle ‘crush' hour in Melbourne's north and west
A secret government report warns passengers will face 'crush' conditions at train stations across Melbourne's fast-growing northern and western suburbs without an urgent overhaul of the rail system. The ambitious blueprint, which supports electrification of the Melton and Wyndham lines and extending the Upfield line, forecasts that without any action within the next five to 10 years, dozens of commuters will be left stranded on platforms every time a train comes. But the plan – which was the catalyst for the state and federal governments' $4 billion revamp of Sunshine Station – poses financial and political challenges for the cash-strapped Allan government. The price tag for the works is estimated to be comparable to the $34.5 billion first stage of the Suburban Rail Loop (SRL). The report also refers to a proposal that would require people travelling from Ballarat to switch trains to go to the city. It raises sensitive political choices for a government committed to the SRL and wary of upsetting regional Victoria, but also under pressure to deliver on plans for the west first proposed in 2018. The urgency of the plan, which seeks to make public transport in Melbourne's west and north comparable to services long-enjoyed by commuters in more established parts of the city, is revealed in a letter written by Victoria's most senior transport bureaucrat and obtained by this masthead under freedom of information laws. 'The report's key finding is that due to significant population growth in the north and west of Melbourne – more than twice the population of Canberra is forecast to move into this region in the next 15 years – there is an urgent need to begin detailed development of rail capacity-boosting projects in the north and west,' then Department of Transport secretary Paul Younis wrote in a letter to his Commonwealth counterpart a year ago. While the Albanese and Allan governments refused to release the plan to this masthead under freedom of information laws, a dozen industry and government sources, including some of the document's contributing authors, confirmed its existence.
