‘Why is nursing looked down on?' Student in Singapore pushes back against tired stereotypes
In her post titled ' Why are nurses so poorly regarded in society despite how hard they work?' , the student shared that whenever she tells someone she is studying nursing in a polytechnic, she often receives a 'judgy look.' Some even go so far as to ask whether nursing was her 'first choice.'
'Yes! It was my first choice,' she wrote in her post. 'With my O-Level score, I could have gone to JC, but I chose not to. I decided to go into nursing.'
She went on to discuss the stigma surrounding the nursing profession — particularly how some people assume nursing is a backup option for students with poor grades. This perception, she said, is far from the truth. She pointed out that the cut-off point for nursing in polytechnics is actually among the highest across all courses, yet the field still suffers from a lack of respect.
'Despite all the bio, the diseases, and the hands-on clinical skills we're learning now, people have this idea like, 'Oh, nursing is for people who didn't do well and have nowhere else to go.' Like, what do you mean? All this stuff I'm learning right now is so hard,' she said.
She also raised concerns about the pay gap between nurses and doctors, noting that it contributes to the belief that nurses are merely 'helpers' rather than professionals in their own right.
'People think that nurses are just the helpers for doctors because doctors get paid an insane amount of money, while nurses are paid so poorly. I do agree that nurses help doctors, but we aren't just helpers — we do so much more. Even if I could go into medicine, I wouldn't, because I love how much patient interaction nurses have,' she explained.
Despite the stigma, the student expressed pride in her choice, describing her nursing journey so far as 'amazing' and deeply fulfilling.
'Nursing is so versatile. There are so many different pathways to pursue after you start working, and every day is something different. The last couple of weeks have been nothing but amazing, and as of now, I don't regret my decision,' she shared.
She ended her post by inviting Singaporeans to share their thoughts on the profession.
'I know that there are also some people who are really grateful for nurses. But anyway, this was just a thought, and I would love to hear what other Singaporeans think about nurses!' 'Singaporean society values prestige and money.'
Contrary to the judgments she received, many users in the comments shared that they do not look down on the profession and are, in fact, grateful for nurses.
'I don't regard nurses poorly at all,' one user said. 'Just surprised that people are willing to take up such a demanding and unappreciated profession, especially if they are local. Takes a certain strength of character, nothing but respect.'
'I respect nurses and caregivers 100%, especially during COVID,' another chimed in. 'I can't imagine seeing a patient coughing his lungs out, asking for help while professing to be anti-vax.'
Others, however, shared their views on why some people might look down on the profession. A user, who claimed to be a doctor, suggested that it often comes down to pay:
'Doctor here. I would say for SG, it's mainly because of the pay, and as you know, in SG society, getting money = having dignity. If a nurse were paid similarly to a doctor, you wouldn't receive such comments. It also didn't help that the population white paper accidentally called nursing a low-skilled job (which they amended after).'
Another echoed this sentiment, stating, 'Singaporean society values prestige and money. If a career doesn't lead to tangible money, it's immediately regarded as inferior. Such is, unfortunately, the sad state of things.' See also Rambo:Last Blood politics explained What's behind the stigma against nurses?
Back in 2022, Dr Pamela Cipriano, the president of the International Council of Nurses (ICN), spoke out about why nursing tends to be looked down on in many parts of the world. One big reason, she said, is because of gender.
Since around 90 per cent of nurses worldwide are women, nursing has historically been seen as less important or skilled. For a long time, jobs that involve caregiving, such as nursing, have been labelled as 'women's work' and therefore not taken seriously. This outdated view has led to the profession being undervalued, both in terms of public perception and in how much nurses are paid.
Dr Cipriano added, 'ICN calls for health systems around the world to invest in nursing and evaluate the gendered pay models toward the nursing profession as a historically female profession. Women and other gender minorities need equal pay for equal work within nursing and the health sector.'
Read also: 'Why should I pay for a car I won't use?' — Singaporean upset after parents ask him to pay for family car's COE
Featured image by Depositphotos (for illustration purposes only)
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Business Times
3 minutes ago
- Business Times
China's Juneyao Air takes over JetStar Asia's Singapore-Wuxi route in August
[SINGAPORE] Shanghai-based airline Juneyao Air is restarting its service between Singapore and Wuxi on Aug 29, having last flown the route in July 2021. This service was one of four exclusive routes flown from Singapore by low-cost carrier JetStar Asia, which is part of Quantas-owned JetStar. JetStar Asia will cease operating on Jul 31. Juneyao, using Airbus A320neo aircraft, will fly four times weekly between the two cities: flight HO1561 from Wuxi to Singapore and flight HO1562 from Singapore to Wuxi. Wuxi is a city in the Jiangsu province of China. Singapore-based low-cost carrier Scoot is taking two other JetStar Asia exclusive routes, namely Singapore-Labuan Bajo and Singapore-Okinawa, with plans to begin in October. So far no airline has announced plans to step in for the last JetStar Asia exclusive route of Singapore-Broome.
CNA
3 minutes ago
- CNA
Young Hong Kong residents apply modern touches to preserve traditional crafts, attract new crowds
HONG KONG: A new generation of Hong Kong residents is giving traditional crafts a modern revival, using technology and creative applications to ensure age-old practices continue to thrive beyond the legacy of old master artisans. Among them is 32-year-old architect Nick Tsao, who is reviving the folk art of paper cutting by fusing it with his design know-how. 'Paper cutting is a folk art … it is something that you're supposed to learn at home, through your mother or through a grandmother. Unfortunately, they didn't pass down this skill to me,' he added. Instead, he turned to the skills he honed while studying architecture. 'I was building models … and cutting a lot of paper and card … then building things in 3D and mostly hand cutting with a penknife,' he added. Tsao began his paper-cutting venture after he wanted more unique Chinese New Year zodiac animal decorations, leading him to expand the use of his paper cutting techniques. He started producing and selling the zodiac paper cutting crafts publicly four years back. A year ago, he left his corporate job to pursue it full time. Tsao is currently working with international brands such as Dior and apparel retailer Lululemon, moving beyond paper products but also conducting workshops for their clients. 'Outside of Chinese New Year, I would collaborate with luxury brands, clothing stores, to help them design workshops that their VIP guests can come and experience rather than just giving out gifts.' Even though he was not trained through traditional lineage, Tsao believes his work keeps the spirit of the craft alive. 'I try to embody parts of the traditional crafts by bringing it into new media, by adding contemporary philosophies, design concepts into a fading industry,' he said. Through his work, Tsao said he also hopes people will recognise that 'paper cutting as a traditional craft is very strong in Chinese culture, but also in many other cultures". He noted that it is like taking something that is very cheap and very easy to access, like paper, and creating art that is not specific to a certain location. Tsao added that anyone can incorporate these ideas and create something new. As a young creative entrepreneur, Tsao said he does not shy away from using technology. 'I like incorporating the use of machines … design software because of my architecture background. I think people feel like AI is a type of threat to art making, but you could choose to do things," he added. "You can either stick to very traditional means and make everything like it was years ago or you can start to learn more about these technologies and see how they can help you.' DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION AND REVIVAL Experts said that for traditional crafts to survive, they must be relevant in today's world. Professor Henry Duh, associate dean of global and industry engagement at The Hong Kong Polytechnic University's (PolyU) School of Design, stressed the importance of adapting to societal changes. 'We can still use the traditional way to preserve cultural heritage … but it's slow and a bit harder to trigger (the) young generation's interest ... That's why I think digital technology will be able to promote (and) trigger their interest,' he added. PolyU has received funding this year to revitalise the city's traditional arts and promote digital transformation of its culture industry. It is the first tertiary institution in the city to receive funding from the China National Arts Fund. The fund, which opened to applicants in Hong Kong and Macau in 2021, promotes development of arts and culture by supporting local artistic talents. PhD students at PolyU have managed to capture a porcelain paint master's techniques using generative AI. Duh said: 'One of the masters (thought of) new technology to quickly trigger the kids' attention and interest … and reduce the process into simple, interesting steps.' He noted that using a 3D space to replicate the process allowed apprentices or younger people to observe the workflow from different angles, compared to video. With fewer master artisans, technology has become more important in the preservation process. "Some masters … may not be able to describe the process precisely or using terminology (that the) younger generation can understand. Using digital technology or virtual reality to visualise the process … will be easier,' he said. VIRTUAL REALITY Virtual reality (VR) also allows learners of a traditional craft to gain skills without being constrained by old craftsmen's physical availability. PolyU students have also used AI to create a 'digital human' from the fast-disappearing indigenous Tanka group, known as boat dwellers, to share their history and experiences. The interactive nature of the project could generate interest in such cultures by young people, said PhD student Yue Xu. 'A lot of culture and art pieces are disappearing … for me I think that technology can help to digitalise these things,' he added. VR tools are also used by museums like the Intangible Cultural Heritage Centre. It is also working with PolyU on a VR project to allow people who are interested in learning about Hong Kong's traditions to experience its exhibits virtually. It features more than 40 different traditions, cultures and crafts synonymous with Hong Kong. The Intangible Cultural Heritage Centre is using technology to reach out to younger members of the population, strengthening its goal of preserving Hong Kong's history and techniques of the city's traditional crafts, according to its curator Celia Shum. 'We can make use of interactive programmes … (like) some QR codes for audio guides to (inform) … the public,' she said. Shum added that many young people are keen to know more about the city's cultural heritage. 'They mentioned to us (that they joined the) programmes and have the opportunity to know more about the techniques,' she said. The project is slated for launch in libraries and schools by the end of next year, bringing the city's traditional crafts and culture closer to the people.
Independent Singapore
21 minutes ago
- Independent Singapore
'Hate your job? So why are you still there every Monday?'
SINGAPORE: It began with a simple admission on Reddit: 'I work in internal audit, but lately it's becoming obvious to me that I don't love it. At all.' The user went on to explain that he had selected accounting for security and stability, values that once offered ease and well-being, but now, it feels more like he's in chains. 'Should I at least like what I am doing, so I would have the motivation to excel and climb the corporate ladder? Or should I find something else exciting to do?' the Redditor asked. It was a vulnerable yet authentic moment that hit a nerve. Several netizens, strangers to each other, weighed in, not with answers or explanations, but with solidity and cohesion. The price of staying One netizen shared his nine-year stint in a job he detested, holding on for the salary. Ultimately, the effects on his body and mind became unbearable. 'Recently just resigned for the sake of physical and mental health.' Another echoed that feeling of resignation with a more exhaustive account — six years in a turf for which he never really felt well-matched, suffering lack of sleep, body pains, digestive problems — all while trying to gather the courage and the energy to plan an exit. 'It's almost by design,' he said, 'that the system makes sure you don't have leeway or time to look for something else.' It's an inaudible, everyday burnout many Singaporeans know too well — trapped in roles that pay the bills but weaken the spirit. Different jobs, same dilemma Others from totally diverse industries — from graphic design to PR, tech to marketing — have the same gloomy feeling: Is this it? One marketing expert, worn out and disenchanted, put it without the sugar-coating: 'There is no meaning in the work I do.' This netizen labelled his industry as one gradually being outdone by AI and low-priced labour, with social media drives that require huge creative effort yet die out into the void because of user lethargy. 'The input vastly outweighs the outcome. Engagement numbers are faked anyway.' An ex-graphic designer shared her story of signing up for a small company, only to find out that the whole team had resigned before her. They weren't just designing — they were doing admin tasks, stocktaking, and printing. They ultimately stopped working to go freelance. 'If freelance wasn't an option,' she admitted, 'I would've stayed just for the security.' The rationalisation game However, not everybody craves exhilaration or meaning from their work. 'I'd rather my job be repetitive than constantly ambiguous and changing,' said one Redditor working in strategy and tech. Fatigued from endless office politics and changing expectations, he yearned for predictability. 'I don't define myself by my work. I just wish I had a stable, repetitive job so I can enjoy life outside of work.' Another netizen shared a realistic stance: 'I don't like my job anymore. I used to be passionate about tech… Now I'm passionate about my family and the money that helps them live comfortably.' For this Redditor, the job had become transactional. No love, just common needs. Should you like your job? The original poster's query — whether he should relish his job enough to want to shine — doesn't come with a common answer. For some, contentment and self-actualisation come from work itself. For others, it's the life that work permits them to create and then build outside of office hours. However, what's evident from the reactions is this — staying in a job that leaves you feeling exhausted, depleted, apathetic, or 'unseen' is a skirmish many are silently fighting. Whether it's the apprehension of uncertainty, no time to plan an exit, or merely the math of enduring an excessively expensive world, the choice to stay or leave isn't just about passion. It's about survival. Nonetheless, the most compelling takeaway from the thread came not from a sophisticated piece of advice, but from the tone of the post itself – if you're feeling stuck, you are not alone!
