Hipkins Undermines Finance Spokesperson As Labour Struggles With Economic Policy
'He also unbelievably claimed she was talking about Labour's policy at the 2023 election, despite Barbara Edmonds specifically saying the 50 per cent cap will continue to be Labour's policy and her rejection of the OBEGALx fiscal measure adopted in 2024.
'At the same time, she also committed to an operating surplus in the year ending June 2029, a year not mentioned in Labour's 2023 fiscal plan, making it difficult to see how she could have been talking about their 2023 policy.
'Earlier this year, her position on public-private partnerships was promptly undermined by Chris Hipkins before she excruciatingly had to walk it back in the media.
'If New Zealanders are being told not to read into what Barbara Edmonds says is Labour's position on debt or PPPs, how can they take seriously anything Labour says on the economy and the Budget?
'Chris Hipkins needs to start being upfront on Labour's fiscal plan. They have opposed every savings measure and committed to spending more on virtually everything, including locally made school lunches, and half-price public transport, while also reversing changes to pay equity laws, and continuing all of this Government's infrastructure projects.
'They will need to find the money through higher taxes, higher debt or both. A recipe that has already proven to be a disaster for Kiwis.
'If Chris Hipkins can be clear enough to undermine Barbara Edmonds' positions on almost everything, he can be upfront on what Labour's actual position on debt is.'
Notes:
Transcript of Chris Hipkins' comments:
Martyn Bradbury: So why has Labour locked itself into the exact same neoliberal economic debt straitjacket that National have us chained to? Economist Bernard Hickey was heavily critical of your decision to strangle us with the exact same neoliberal limitations of net debt capped at 50 per cent of GDP.
Chris Hipkins: Well, I mean, I don't think we should read too much into the fact that Barbara was – Barbara, our Finance spokesperson – Barbara Edmonds, was talking about the policy we went into the last election with. We haven't determined the policy that we're going to go into the next election with.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
3 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Government report shows homelessness ‘appears' to be outstripping population growth
The report comes around halfway through this Government's term, which has included tightening emergency housing rules, and social and transitional housing initiatives. Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka said although accurate numbers on homelessness were difficult to find, it was 'clear we have a real problem'. 'The Government takes this seriously. All New Zealanders deserve a warm, dry place to stay, and the Government is determined to make progress on this long-running challenge for New Zealand.' Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka says it is clear New Zealand has a real problem with homelessness. Photo / Mark Mitchell Potaka said the Government was seeking advice from officials on further interventions to help rough sleepers, saying 'we are also open to new ideas that will make an enduring difference'. Officials defined homelessness as living situations where people have no way of accessing safe and secure housing. This could include having no shelter at all, living in temporary or uninhabitable accommodation, or staying in a house with others, such as couch surfing. The report estimates people living without shelter are more likely to be older, with more than a quarter aged over 65. Twelve per cent were under 15 years old. Concerns from groups, collated in the report, included people and families sleeping rough, in cars, garages or uninhabitable conditions, or couch surfing during winter. They told researchers there were increasing levels of hopelessness and complex needs because of methamphetamine use, anti-social behaviour and severe mental health concerns. Emergency housing The portion of applications for emergency housing that were declined increased from 4% in March 2024 to 32% in March 2025, the report found. This statistic comes after Potaka's emergency housing policy changes in August 2024, which included limiting discretion and tightening rules to ensure it was only accessed 'where absolutely necessary'. Reasons people were declined included that they could meet their needs another way (34.3%), their circumstances could have been 'reasonably foreseen' (22.5%), they were not eligible for a grant (16.7%) or their situation was not considered an emergency (14.7%). Labour leader Chris Hipkins says the Government has no plan for where people go when they are removed from emergency accommodation. Photo / Mark Mitchell Potaka said more than $550 million was being spent annually across a range of programmes run by multiple agencies, including Transitional Housing, Housing First, Rapid Rehousing and many other support services. The minister argued there was a 37% increase in people living in shelters between 2018 and 2023 when the previous Labour Government was in power and that the Government was also dealing with the large-scale emergency housing 'social disaster' it had inherited from Labour. In January, the Government celebrated reaching its target for reducing the number of people in emergency motels by 75% five years early. But it raised questions over where people went when they left emergency housing. Associate Housing Minister Tama Potaka (left) and Prime Minister Christopher Luxon say the Government has spent half a billion dollars helping people in homeless situations. Photo / Mark Mitchell Labour leader Chris Hipkins accused the Government of kicking 'everybody out of emergency accommodation' without having a plan for where they were to go. 'I think every New Zealander living in a main city can walk down the street and see there are more people living on the street, in cars, and that the Government's actions have contributed to that,' he said. 'When you boot everybody out of emergency accommodation ... this is what happens.' The report said for around 14% of people who left emergency housing, officials were not sure where they went. Others went into a mix of social and transitional housing, or received housing support supplements. 'We do know where 85% [of people] have gone and we're really happy that a lot of kids have come out of emergency housing. Those 14% we don't know where they've gone, but they don't have to tell us where they are going,' Potaka said. Prime Minister Christopher Luxon told reporters his Government had spent half a billion dollars helping people in these situations. 'Homelessness is a really complex issue. People often come with a complex set of needs, whether its mental health or addiction. No Kiwi wants to see homelessness.' Luxon said he was proud of 'the fact that we have taken 6000 people off the social state housing list'. 'I'm also really proud that we've got 2100 kids out of motels and into really good homes by prioritising those families.' Julia Gabel is a Wellington-based political reporter. She joined the Herald in 2020 and has most recently focused on data journalism.
NZ Herald
4 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Helius and Elysian to continue merger after Cannabis Clinic withdrawal
'I think these things happen when you're looking at mergers and going through that process, you get to learn more about how the entire structure would work, about each other's cultures and how we approach things, we understand more about each other's businesses as well,' Alzaher said. 'That's why we mutually agreed and reached the conclusion that it would be better for us to work independently.' Dr Waseem Alzaher, CEO and co-founder of the Cannabis Clinic, says it will be better for the businesses to work independently towards their shared goal. Alzaher said the proposal had been spoken about between the parties for about two months before the announcement to the public. After a further three weeks deep-diving on the proposal and deciding on how it would work, the decision was made for it not to proceed. Alzaher said the decision to communicate proactively about the proposal was because of Helius Therapeutics' shareholders and its responsibility to keep them involved, and he said he would do the process the same if given another opportunity. 'We're still open to partnerships, to collaboration, to investment, to coming together, so that one plus one equals 10. 'The bigger picture for us is revolutionising healthcare, how healthcare is delivered, the systems, the expectations, how it's centred around people. 'That's a big mission. Our big area audacious goal is to have a million long-term clients with us, and that's not going to happen overnight.' As for what didn't work between Cannabis Clinic and Helius Therapeutics, Alzaher said that their business cultures and visions were not necessarily aligned. He viewed Cannabis Clinic as a 'rebel' and a 'misfit' trying to disrupt the system, and said the business' time could be better spent helping more Kiwis instead. Alzaher said he could see the businesses working together in the future, although not in the 'foreseeable future'. 'With Helius they've got products that are New Zealand made and we're still distributing them. We see them as a strategic partner for us moving forward. 'They believe in what we're doing, we believe in what they're doing, and we're still talking to each other and on good terms.' Helius Health chairman Guy Haddleton previously said the industry long needed a reset. Photo / File Merger moves on Despite the mutual decision for Cannabis Clinic to pull out of the proposed merger, Helius Therapeutics and Elsyian Group/CannaPlus have confirmed a two-way merger will now take its place. Helius Therapeutics financial officer Bruce McEwen said the businesses expect to settle in August. 'What happens now – it's full steam ahead with the execution of the new strategy and the merger with CannaPlus," McEwen said. 'Whilst it's now a two not three-way merger and reduces overall scale, it doesn't change the direction or effectiveness of the strategy. It does however make it simpler, enabling us to move faster.' McEwen said Helius Therapeutics shareholders were firmly behind the strategy pivot to vertically integrate and the proposed two-party merger. He said Helius Therapeutics and Cannabis Clinic had a strong mutual respect for each other and continued to be key business partners. 'After careful consideration we mutually agreed not to proceed with the proposed merger between Helius Therapeutics and Cannabis Clinic. 'Whilst there is strong alignment around increasing access to medicinal cannabis and reducing the stigma, we agreed that was better achieved independently.' Helius Health chairman Guy Haddleton was unavailable for comment. Elysian executive chairwoman Eva Piëch said the fundamentals of the transaction remained intact. 'The transition to a two-party merger between Elysian and Helius is a deliberate and strategically focused decision. It enhances clarity, accelerates execution, and strengthens alignment – not only operationally, but philosophically,' Piëch said. 'This structure allows for faster execution, clearer governance and greater strategic clarity. Our infrastructure, patient network and digital platform remain core to the combined strategy.' Piëch said that as discussions matured with Cannabis Clinic, it became clear a three-party integration would introduce operational complexity and dilute strategic focus – without materially strengthening the core proposition. She said the two-party plan would preserve strategic coherence and allow the pair to integrate with speed, purpose and precision. 'This two-way merger creates a clean, tightly aligned platform – one that enables rapid integration, strategic coherence and a stronger foundation for long-term innovation and growth.' Tom Raynel is a multimedia business journalist for the Herald, covering small business, retail and tourism.
RNZ News
4 hours ago
- RNZ News
Fonterra boss meets with politicians over high butter prices
Fonterra's boss has given media the silent treatment over the sky high price of butter. Both National and Labour's finance spokespeople met with Fonterra's chief executive Miles Hurrell last night, trying to find out why the cost of a block is so steep. But whether the debate leads to a price correction or just more froth and churn from lawmakers is yet to be seen. Russell Palmer reports.
