No fines or recalls for food with illegal levels of potentially harmful agrichemicals in last five years
Photo:
RNZ / Richard Tindiller
Not a single fine or recall has been issued for food with illegal levels of potentially harmful agrichemicals in at least five years, despite dozens of breaches.
The Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI), had sent "educational letters" to seven businesses since 2020, but had not recalled food nor prosecuted any business during that time.
An academic told RNZ the lack of action risked undermining trust in New Zealand's exports.
The ministry's annual testing regime - the Food Residues Survey Programme or FRSP - tested hundreds of samples for hundreds of chemicals to ensure they were under the maximum residue level set by law.
It was an offence to sell food with residues above the levels.
Last month, RNZ revealed testing in 2015 found a third of wheat samples had glyphosate - the active ingredient in RoundUp and other herbicides - levels exceeding the legal limit,
some by 50 times
.
Glyphosate is the active ingredient in the weedkiller RoundUp.
Photo:
AFP
The ministry has not tested for glyphosate in its annual monitoring since 2015.
It was those breaches that prompted the review of maximum glyphosate levels underway, which
could see some levels increased exponentially
.
Analysis of testing for other agrichemicals showed despite multiple breaches of maximum levels across dozens of chemicals the ministry had not recalled food and had not issued fines, penalties or warnings in at least the past five years.
The only enforcement taken as a result of the 75 breaches consisted of educational measures.
The ministry defended its approach, calling it "international best practice".
University of Canterbury biology professor Jack Heinemann said residue limits were about more than human health, and breaches posed a serious risk to New Zealand's exports and international reputation.
He pointed to the upheavals after the Japanese government identified
repeated breaches of glyphosate
residue limits in New Zealand honey in 2021.
"MRLs are used internationally to monitor the safety of food being traded. New Zealand has exceeded MRLs in some food products being exported to other countries and those food products have been rejected. A regulator who ignores those MRLs, or is too tolerant of excess residues, places our safe food export reputation at risk."
There were legitimate, permitted practices for off-label use of some chemicals, Heinemann said.
"But you'll also notice in those [NZFS] reports there's a number of compounds being detected for which no off-label use is permitted, and it seems to me that's something the regulator should take very seriously."
Acute and chronic health risks and other factors, such as differences in body weight, were taken into account when regulators set maximum residue limits, he said.
"When it comes to some of the compounds that have been detected in our food, these compounds have exceeded the maximum residue limits, and in some cases they may have also exceeded by a good margin the potential [acceptable daily intake] depending on body weight and the kind of food."
The limits were also a key mechanism to provide confidence in the food supply, he said.
"You can let that equation down by ignoring them or not being transparent about the reasons why in some cases you are exempting or not prosecuting or not following up," he said.
"There's lots of ways in which people can lose confidence in their food supply, so we wouldn't want such an obvious measure to go unexplained or to be treated with too much ability to walk away from enforcing."
Greenpeace campaigner Gen Toop said the lack of action showed "a very lackadaisical approach to food safety from the very body that is charged with ensuring food is safe in New Zealand".
The ministry routinely recalled food when there were cases of acute food poisoning, Toop said.
"But toxic pesticides don't necessarily cause acute symptoms when they're at residual levels on our food - they're more associated with chronic long-term health impacts, so New Zealand Food Safety is managing to quietly get away with just leaving them on the shelves, but that doesn't mean that it's safe," she said.
"A food product that has thirty times the legal limit of a pesticide so toxic it's now banned in New Zealand - that should have gone to prosecution.
"That food should never have made it to the shelves, or it should have been pulled off them and there should have been some very strong messages sent to the food producers of New Zealand that it's unacceptable to use chemicals in a way that is illegal, that's not allowed on the product use label, and in a way that breaches the maximum residue limits.
"Instead, NZFS has been sending a clear message that you can do what you like... we're not really bothered if you breach the maximum residue limit. In fact, in some cases, when it comes to glyphosate, we'll just stop looking at it. It's not even about not prosecuting, its we found some breaches, so we'll stop monitoring it so we don't find anymore."
She believed New Zealand Food Safety falling under the auspices of the Ministry for Primary Industries was part of the problem.
"[NZFS] should not be within the same organisation that is charged with promoting New Zealand's primary producing export market. It doesn't make any sense to be nested in there."
The 2022 - 2023 FRSP report found 33 instances of breaches of the maximum residue limits from 27 samples.
The majority of the breaches were a result of growers applying agricultural chemicals off-label.
Three samples had illegally high residues of a highly-toxic, now-banned insecticide called methamidophos, which the World Health Organisation classified as highly hazardous.
At the time of the breaches, methamidophos was authorised in New Zealand for restricted use, but was being phased out and banned from the crops it was detected on.
Methamidophos breaches were also detected in previous surveys.
Chlorpyrifos, another organosphosphate which was banned in the European Union, United States, Canada and the United Kingdom, was found at illegal levels on broccoli and kale with both growers previously breaching the limits.
Neonicotinoid insecticides
imidacloprid and thiamethoxam - which have been banned in the European Union and United Kingdom
due to the risk they pose to bees and other pollinators - were also detected at illegal levels, as was acetamiprid, which was under review in the EU.
Four of the six previous reports found breaches of another banned pesticide called diazinon.
The Environmental Protection Authority announced a ban on the pesticide in 2013
with a 15-year phase out period
.
The United States banned its residential use in 2004 and restricted it to specific crops, the European Union banned its use in 2007, and Australia's ban would come into force later this year.
Other breaches in the past five years include sulfoxaflor, which has been banned for outdoor use in the EU and parts of the US, linuron (banned in the EU in 2017); propiconazole (banned on food crops in the EU in 2018); methomyl (banned in the EU in 2008) and epoxiconazole (banned in the EU and UK).
New Zealand Food Safety acting deputy director-general Jenny Bishop confirmed there had been no prosecutions in the past five years.
MPI could not say when, or even if, it had last prosecuted a producer for exceeding maximum levels.
New Zealand Food Safety deputy director-general Vincent Arbuckle said none of the breaches posed food safety risks, and the vast majority of test results - 99.99 percent - were under the legally allowed limit.
"For each of these detections we conducted a rigorous scientific food safety assessment to ensure there was no risk to consumers, which is standard practice," Arbuckle said.
Each non-compliance was carefully followed up, and the product was traced back to the grower or supplier with the ministry requesting they identify the cause of the breach, he said.
Food recalls would be undertaken if a food safety concern was identified, and in more serious cases, MPI would consider prosecution, he said.
"Our monitoring system is working well and is picking up the relatively low level of non-compliance where it is occurring and helps us to take action where required," Arbuckle said.
Where non-compliant test results were identified, the businesses changed their practices where directed, Arbuckle said.
Asked about growers who had been found to breach the limits more than once, Bishop said there were approximately seven companies which exceeded the limits more than once since 2020.
"All were assessed for food safety issues and none was found," she said.
MPI determined the appropriate corrective action had been taken and further escalation was not necessary, she said.
Last year, the Ministry for Regulation led a review - alongside MPI, NZFS, the Ministry for the Environment and the Environmental Protection Authority - on agriculture and horticultural products, triggered by "concern from farmers, growers, and businesses that the regulatory burden on these products was impacting New Zealand's international competitiveness," according to the ministry's website.
In May, Cabinet agreed to all sixteen of the review recommendations, including a new fast-track approval process for pesticides deemed a priority, allowing industry to "self-assess" some hazardous chemicals, and accelerating the approval of hazardous substances.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero
,
a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
29 minutes ago
- RNZ News
Accountants call for capital gains tax
Photo: RNZ A group representing more than 3000 accountants in New Zealand has called for a rethink of the tax system, including the introduction of a capital gains tax. CPA Australia has made a submission in response to Inland Revenue's long-term insights briefing, which warned that tax would need to increase in the coming years. The organisation agreed with Inland Revenue on many of the pressures on the New Zealand system, including an ageing population that would mean fewer working taxpayers, and higher pension and healthcare costs. Productivity was also a problem, along with the cost of living and AI potentially changing how people worked. It said the country's tax base was narrow with a heavy reliance on income tax and GST, which make up the bulk of the tax take. It said the absence of a capital gains tax put pressure on the other taxes. It suggested adding a CGT, land tax and even GST changes to help recalibrate the tax mix, as well as indexing tax brackets to inflation so that people's tax bills did not increase over time when their income was only keeping pace with inflation. CPA said it was also worth considering making KiwiSaver compulsory, means-testing super and providing more tax incentives for retirement savings, such as a model in which contributions and returns were not taxed. The chair of CPA's New Zealand Tax Committee, Angus Ogilvie said unless there were significant changes to the way superannuation was set up, there were clear issues around a long-term structural deficit. "We are not bringing in sufficient revenue to cover the cost of the existing welfare system and running the government, which is problematic. One option is to increase economic growth, which will bring in more revenue as a result but one wonders whether that alone will close that gap." He said New Zealand had long been described as a "broad-based low rate tax system". "For many years it was just that. The base was fairly comprehensive and the rates were relatively low. But now the top personal tax rate has gone to 39 percent, I don't think anyone could argue that is low. The company tax rate is one of the highest in the OECD. We argue that we aren't that low rate, nor are we broad-based. "With a couple of exceptions, we don't tax capital gains in New Zealand, that's quite unusual in the OECD context. Pretty much every OECD country has some for of CGT, Australia certainly does but New Zealand does not. If we want to broaden that base, we need to consider a CGT." He said CPA was suggesting it should apply to assets purchased from a certain date, so that it was not retrospective. "The downside is it would take some time before it realised a reasonable amount of revenue but we acknowledge that you have to start somewhere. The alternative is to put all assets into that net but that would verge on impossible. "You have to value all those assets, some of them are easy to value, like property, but you can imagine a small business, valuing the assets in terms of what it would sell for in an active market, if it's a specialist business it's difficult to ascertain without a property valuation process. That's always been a very valid criticism of a CGT. "If it's based on assets that are purchased after a particular date then it becomes very easy." He said the superannuation settings needed to be revisited, but it was a political question that was difficult for politicians to deal with. "Universal provision of super for everyone over the age of 65 is very expensive. It's not means tested in any way - in Australia it is." He said something would need to be done. "I don't think there's anyone who seriously believes going to get on top of structural deficit issue unless the economy grows and that doesn't seem to be happening spontaneously so what other options have we got?" He said putting GST up was another option, but it would hit lower-income earners hard because they spent a greater proportion of what they warned. That could require an adjustment to welfare settings. CPA was not in favour of a wealth tax because it could prompt people to shift wealth to other countries without such a tax. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Will Auckland's Sky World ever be returned to its former glory?
If you ask an Aucklander about Sky World Indoor Entertainment, once known as the Metro Centre, chances are they'll have a story to tell about getting lost inside the labyrinth-like interior, loitering outside Burger King or celebrating a birthday at the long-gone Planet Hollywood. But over the last decade the Queen St building has slowly decayed with numerous businesses shutting up shop and foot-traffic dropping dramatically. In 2017, RNZ reported the building remained open without a warrant of fitness for more than a year despite a "high risk" to public safety. Auckland Council confirmed the building does now have a valid warrant of fitness through to 24 August. The building spent two years on the market and as of October 2024, the owner of the building James Kwak from JNJ Holdings, said there were plans for redevelopment. Inside the maze-like structure of Sky World. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ Kwak has owned the building since 2011 when he paid $37 million for it. In 2026 the City Rail Link (CRL) is set to open with a stop called Te Waihorotiu Station just 50 metres from the building - it is expected to be the busiest station , catering for up to 54,000 passengers per hour. While it could be an opportunity for Sky World to attract more customers, remaining tenants inside the building said they had been "left in the dark" about any refurbishment plans. Most of the stores inside Sky World are empty, and the international food court has been demolished, leaving Event Cinemas, Metro Lanes, Game On arcade and Odyssey Sensory Maze. A Jack's Fried Chicken has opened within the past year. A false wall covers up what was once the entrance to the international food court. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ A worker at GameOn said they had "no idea" what was going on in terms of the building being renovated or sold. "I don't know… I would love it to be developed or sold. When I first heard about it I was looking forward to that." The food court now being empty and closed off by false walls, stopped people being able to walk through a large section of the building, the worker said, making it uninviting for customers. The worker said the building, and most of Auckland's mid-town , had taken a big hit during the Covid-19 pandemic and this was when many remaining tenants made the decision to leave. An interior entrance to GameOn arcade. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ "I had a big walk-through mid-town the other day, it's a bit sad. Our building is one of the worst ones." The arcade had been a tenant at Sky World in some form, since 1999, the year the building, then Force Entertainment Centre, first opened. The worker said they had been on level two, until 2018 when they moved to the upper basement. "It's not been a great experience [recently] the building was badly hurt by Covid, and it hasn't refilled." The food court has been removed. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ The arcade was lucky to have survived, and the worker said he believed this was only due to them having an entrance to the store from Queen St. He said he believed if the building could only be accessed from inside the complex, it would not still be in business. "I would like to see it in its former glory - the council, everyone, wants to see this part of town fixed." The manager of Odyssey Sensory Maze, which is hidden down in the basement of Sky World, said they had also been kept in the dark about renovations. The state of the building and their positioning in the basement did impact business, she said. "Customers often get lost trying to find us or leave bad reviews online because of the state of the building, which is something we can't control, it's not ideal. "Things look messy and dirty - for me, it would be nice to have some more life in it." Rubbish and debris tossed into the corners of Auckland's Sky World building. Photo: MELANIE EARLEY / RNZ Former tenant of Sky World, Brad Jacobs, the director of Coffee Club, said the final straw for many tenants was the cost of rent during the pandemic. "We used to trade well there, it was a good store prior to 2020, but when things got tough during the lockdowns we could not reach any fair rental agreement - we tried very hard, we begged even." But Jacobs said there was no support offered by the landlord. Coffee Club exited the building in March 2021, and Jacobs said by that stage most of the other food places had already closed. "The whole thing was ridiculous, bizarre, I still don't know what the landlord was trying to achieve. "By then we could see the writing on the wall - the city was falling apart, and it was not the place to be." The entrance to Sky World is down a series of steps next to Aotea Square. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ For Sky World to thrive again, Jacobs believed it would need a clear vision. "Everyone has a story about that building, I remember I used to hang around the Borders bookstore and go to the movies, but the design is past its used by date now. "It will be sad if it just sits like that for another ten years." Speaking to people passing through Sky World on a week day, one woman said she still visited to watch a movie or go bowling. She remembered the food court was thriving when she was a child and hoped the complex could be rebuilt in some way. "It's quite sad seeing it so empty." Bumping into another person is now a rarity at Sky World. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ Another passer-by said he had been involved with the opening of Planet Hollywood, an international movie-themed restaurant chain, when the complex was built. He remembered actor Robin Williams came down for the opening and the premier of his movie Bicentennial Man at the IMAX cinema which caused a serious buzz. "It just deteriorated over the years … it's an awkward building to get around. It's confusing with the sky ways going in every which way, it's hard to find which level you're exactly on. "I just use it to cross through to the other side now." Another woman passing by described it as a "ghost town", while another queried whether it was closed altogether. One of the three architects behind the design of the building agreed it was past its used by date. What the exterior of Sky World looked like in the early 2000s. Photo: ASHLEY ALLEN / SUPPLIED Ashley Allen said he had been inspired by the film Blade Runner when he designed the building 25 years ago with Jamie Simpkin and Peter Diprose. "The brief was to create a space that becomes a dynamic escape from city living and working life. The intention was this building would be without doubt memorable and the hub for entertainment for all in Auckland City. "I have a sadness that the generation of children who enjoyed this space now as adults see its demise due to minimal maintenance, minimal refurbishments or any new innovations". He said the building was designed to be maze-like, to give people a sense of escapism and make it feel as though they had entered another world. "I wanted people to get lost and discover things within the building. I liked the playfulness of it, the rocket lift, the bridges almost to nowhere." Bookstore Borders was inside Sky World until 2012. Photo: ASHLEY ALLEN / SUPPLIED The building had gone down hill dramatically, Allen said, and every building needed to be refurbished and re-energised throughout its life. "You need to put money into it. Successful buildings need to be constantly refreshed and it's so unfortunate the owner seems to not want to spend any money on it - it's very sad." An entertainment centre needed to be refreshed every four to five years, Allen said, as technology moved on. "Entertainment is not a static approach - what's needed to entertain a 12-year-old today is not the same as what was needed 15 years ago." He did not believe it would take much to make the building successful again, but it would need someone to agree to spend the money. The exterior of Sky World as it stands today. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ "It needs a new owner; it needs to be refurbished to get good tenants back in there or it needs to be demolished and rebuild with higher density." Allen said he did not want to see the building demolished, but he found it hard to see it in its current state. "It feels like someone is abusing your child - I'd do anything I possibly could to help the current owner out or help a new one fix it. "I just want someone to refurbish it. I'm keen for Auckland to have an entertainment hub again. All it takes is one person to start refurbishing and then people will join in." Heart of the City's Viv Beck would not comment directly on the state of Sky World, but said in general, next year's opening of the CRL would be great for the mid-town area. There are numerous empty buildings in Auckland's CBD. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ "It's certainly an opportunity… it has been challenging for businesses operating there with the ongoing construction." Beck said they were thinking about how to bring people back to the area, and she was optimistic about the long-term. "I see next year as a milestone. I think the concept of an entertainment centre is still relevant, but it needs to be an immersive experience with new technology. The concept is something that people still want." Attempts by RNZ to reach the owner of the building James Kwak or his company JNJ Holidings have been unsuccessful. You can still catch a movie inside Sky World. Photo: MARIKA KHABAZI / RNZ The number listed on a 2022 renovation plan belonged to a man who said he had "no idea" why his number was listed. Voice messages left for numbers which were listed for lease enquiries on signs inside the building went unanswered, as did emails to Kwak and his company. A number listed as accounts on the company's office led to a man who said he had not worked at the company for two years and he requested RNZ "stop calling". The building's manager Tristan Kim, confirmed to RNZ the email had been received and said he would get back in touch with RNZ about whether there were any renovations underway. "I'm at a restaurant with my son - I'll call you back." By time of publication, he had not responded. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
'Really, really well off people' needing help with problem debt
A new report by FinCap says the ongoing cost-of-living crisis has led to an increased debt burden for many people. Photo: RNZ Financial mentors say problem debt isn't only a problem for the lowest-paid New Zealanders, and action is needed to stop debt collectors "deliberately distressing" struggling people . FinCap, which represents the country's financial mentors, has released its latest Voices report, outlining data for 2024. It was to be presented at Parliament on Thursday morning. The report shows mentors are dealing with a growing number of clients, despite the number of people working in the field dropping. From 19,543 closed cases in 2021, there were 25,140 dealt with last year. The top reason that people were experiencing hardship was the cost of living, responsible for 29 percent of cases. FinCap said mentors had reported much more engagement with people who might previously have not needed assistance, including those in work and not receiving a benefit, and people with home loans . Ten percent of the mentors' clients were people who owned their own homes. That is up from 7.5 percent in 2021. The mentors reported an 88 percent increase in the number of people seeking help who earn more than $1000 a week in the past three years. One mentor who was not identified, but worked in a regional centre, said they had seen some "really, really well off people". "In their previous lives, [they] have been extremely well-off, had really, really good jobs. And then just one thing has unravelled and then slightly another thing and then ... Trying to negotiate our systems seems to have caught them out." People earning more than $1000 a week were spending a median 19.7 percent of their money on groceries, compared to 25 percent for people earning $250 to $499. One in eight closed cases resulted in a client taking money out of KiwiSaver. Car loans were 21 percent of all unique debts reported, at a median $10,230. People with a car loan reported expenses exceeding income by 10 percent, and those without a car loan by 6 percent. But the percentage by which expenses exceeded income had decreased for those with a loan, and risen for those without. "The ongoing cost-of-living crisis has led to an increased debt burden for many people. Many of the whānau financial mentors work alongside are resorting to KiwiSaver hardship withdrawals just to make ends meet or avoid further debt," FinCap's report said. FinCap says many consumers feel vulnerable, especially if they are not familiar with the laws governing the debt collection process. Photo: 123RF Chief executive Fleur Howard said "unreasonable" debt collection practices were making the experience worse. She said debt collectors did not have incentives to consider the impact of their actions on the people they were chasing for money. "The consumer protections financial mentors might use to challenge unreasonable debt collection conduct can be unclear or unactionable depending on which industry the debt originated from. "Debt collection issues can be overwhelming for many whānau who have multiple debts being chased. Interactions with debt collectors can be confrontational, intimidating, and stressful." Many consumers felt vulnerable, especially if they were not familiar with the laws governing the process. "They can feel there is no option but to pay unrealistic demands relative to their financial circumstances, despite this meaning they might not be able to afford food to eat." Howard said debt collectors were sometimes contacting people unreasonably frequently, calling at unreasonable hours, calling other family members or employers and applying unreasonable fees and interest. Sometimes people were being coerced into paying debt that had previously been written off. Howard said the rules on debt collector conduct should be tightened. She said it was still not even possible to tell who the country's debt collectors were. The line between legitimate behaviour and harassment needed to be more clearly defined. "Financial mentors tell us they are working with people who are being harassed and coerced by debt collectors at work, at home, and on social media. This can endanger people's employment and embarrass them in front of their communities," Howard said. She said it seemed deliberately distressing. "These tactics force people to agree to repay debts they may not be legally responsible for, and repayment plans they can't afford. This can send people into a spiral of missed repayments, and see small initial debts balloon in size. "There are debt collection agencies who act responsibly, but the lax legal framework creates a wild west situation, where some unscrupulous debt collectors act unethically. "The Financial Services Reforms Bills currently before Parliament and the government's planned review of the Fair Trading Act are important opportunities to fix the law around debt collection." The Green Party supported the call for action. "We support the calls to regulate debt collectors, including greedy behaviour by Buy Now Pay Later companies. We also agree that the government needs to address the core issue by lifting income levels so families can survive without falling into debt or poverty," said Green Party spokesperson for commerce and consumer affairs, Ricardo Menéndez March. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
