Edinburgh locals 'deeply concerned' as fire station threatened with closure
An Edinburgh fire station threatened by closure has sparked a frenzy of concern from locals and firefighters who say they are concerned for the safety of their neighbourhood.
The Marionville Fire Station in Restalrig may close and relocate three miles away to Newcraighall.
Edinburgh Live spoke to David Strachan, Marionville's branch representative for the Fire Brigade Union (FBU). The firefighter has worked at the station for 17 years and was "deeply upset" by the news of potential closure.
He claimed the move to Newcraighall would come with a downsize, costing the station 10 firefighter posts which he called a safety concern for the area.
David said: "This is my community. I live in Abbeyhill. My family lives here and my kids go to school in this area. Marionville would be the first [station] attendance at my home and my kids school and for friends in the area if there was a fire.
"I'm worried that my family and friends, the people of of our community, would have to wait longer for fire engines to respond to an emergency. I have serious concerns that it would make people in this part of Edinburgh less safe."
David claimed the next nearest fire station at McDonald Road, one of the busiest bases in Scotland, would pick up the bulk of Marionville's calls - making the station "significantly busier".
He added: "If McDonald Road [station] is busy - they can only respond to one call at a time - if there were two calls concurrently, people would be waiting even longer for a response."
Join Edinburgh Live's Whatsapp Community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
Asked about the morale at the station, David added: "Everyone is very unsettled because we don't know what future holds for us. Our primary concern is for the people of this community that are ultimately going to be less safe as a result of this decision."
The Scottish Fire and Rescue Service said the decision to close Marionville was not final and that "any permanent changes to our station footprint or how we deliver our services will only come after we have sought views from the public".
Chris Murray, MP for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh, has voiced his support for the fire station.
He told Edinburgh Live: "I am perplexed that the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service are taking forward proposals to close Marionville Fire Station. This station is a vital resource in addressing callouts across my constituency, and the whole city.
"Given the pressures we have seen on the fire service over the likes of Bonfire Night, I am clear that closing this station is not in the interests of my constituents' safety."
A post on his Instagram adds: "The Marionville firefighters put their lives on the line every day to protect people in central and east Edinburgh. I have met with them several times and heard how bravely they act to save lives – and how they are increasingly overstretched.
"Cutting this station to move resources elsewhere would increase response times – which could be the difference between a bad incident, and a disastrous one. As the local MP, I am crystal clear: Marionville fire station should not be considered for closure."
David launched a petition to help save the station, which garnered over 1,500 signatures in 24 hours.
It explains that Marionville was built using Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete (RAAC) panels, meaning the station is unsafe and needs to be rebuilt.
The petition continues: "The closure of Marionville presents a huge increase in risk, with increased response times to a densely populated area of Edinburgh, a city where the population is increasing at an unprecedented rate . . . Resources are already spread far too thin in the capital.
"It is a matter of minutes for a fire to go from manageable to fully developed, dramatically increasing the risk to people, property and firefighters."
You can find David's petition here.
Deputy Assistant Chief Officer Andrew Girrity from the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service said: "We are currently in the midst of a service delivery review, which aims to ensure that our resources – our staff, stations and appliances – are matched to operational risk and demand across Scotland.
'We also must address urgent property issues including stations affected by Reinforced Autoclaved Aerated Concrete (RAAC), which includes Marionville Community Fire Station.
"We have now concluded an options appraisal and development process, and a number of change options have been recommended to progress to public consultation in the summer. This remains subject to final approval by the SFRS Board.
"Any permanent changes to our station footprint or how we deliver our services will only come after we have sought views from the public and a final decision has been made by the SFRS Board."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Record
3 days ago
- Daily Record
Heartbroken mum pays emotional tribute to baby son who was born sleeping
Nadine Cooper is helping families in the same gut-wrenching position she found herself in. A heartbroken Scots mum has used the pain of losing a child as a force for good - fundraising in the tragic tot's memory to help. other families living the same nightmare. Nadine Cooper is still grieving the death of her stillborn baby, Carson Cooper, who died in February but was born at 37-weeks-old. Nadine has been working to raise money to purchase CuddleCot's to donate in memory of her son. The 33-year-old hailed the CuddleCot device, which allows parents to spend extended time with their baby who has died. And she said she wouldn't have been able to spend the precious days with her son in hospital if it wasn't for the cooling device, Edinburgh Live reports. Nadine added: "I hope my son is proud because they have been donated in his name. It's such a hard feeling to describe what it's like going through something like that. Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community! Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today. You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland. No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team. All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in! If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice. "I set up the GoFundMe after I lost Carson because it was a distraction from everything going on. I lost Carson in February and I was 37 weeks at the time. "You know situations like this happen but you don't think it will ever happen to you. At 37 weeks, you are planning for the arrival - not to give birth and know he's not alive. "We were based at St John's and when I left the hospital, three families lost their child that week and they needed a CuddleCot to see their child. "I saw people had donated CuddleCot's to other hospitals and I wanted to try do the same. I have managed to raise enough for two and we are just waiting for them to be delivered. We are just so grateful to everyone who has donated and helped us with this." The fundraiser has collected over £5,000 and Nadine is glad to be able to help the hospital that were "fantastic" to them throughout the devastating process. The mum-of-two is expecting a third child and is currently at 14 weeks. A description on the GoFundMe reads: "If it wasn't for the CuddleCot, I wouldn't have been able to spend the precious days with my son in hospital. "These CuddleCots are so important to many families and the NHS need more of them. The CuddleCot provides grieving families the opportunity to spend time with their loved ones without needing to cool the entire room. "This time allows families to create precious memories, enables mothers to recover from medication side effects, make arrangements without feeling rushed, and gives family members the chance to visit—all while keeping their loved ones close by. "The CuddleCot can gently cool a pre-term or full-term baby from day one thereby preserving their appearance, condition, and dignity. The CuddleCot is compatible with any cot or bassinet. "If the target for two CuddleCots is not met, one will be purchased and the surplus money will be given to the hospital to help towards their special dedicated family room where we spent a few days."
Daily Record
4 days ago
- Daily Record
Perth fire service cuts could put lives at risk, union warns
If approved, the FBU said, it would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance at Perth and 15 firefighter posts. Lives could be at risk if the number of Perth frontline firefighting appliances are cut according to the Fire Brigades Union (FBU). Their warning comes as Scottish Fire and Rescue Service (SFRS) chiefs announced a public consultation into changes at Perth Community Fire Station in the city. In 2023 the Scottish Fire and Rescue Service cut Perth appliances from three to two, with a reduction of 15 firefighters – a move which they want to make permanent. But the Fire Brigade Union (FBU) point out that firefighters who attended recent Perth blazes - the tragic fire in Scott Street in which a man lost his life and at Balhousie School now facing demolition – reported being under pressure while waiting for help from other fire stations. If the 2023 changes are approved, the FBU said, it would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance at Perth and 15 firefighter posts. SFRS chiefs said Perth operational demand for the city's three wholetime appliances is lower than most fire stations with two wholetime appliances. But Perth-based FBU official Colin Brown said: 'As we have seen in recent weeks the speed and weight of response to fires and other emergencies is crucial to save life and property. 'Crews who attended the fires at Scott Street and Balhousie School have reported being stretched too thin in the early stages of these incidents whilst they awaited additional crews coming from county stations – Dundee's and Fife. 'Perth crews were also deployed to support and provided fire cover into Aviemore during the recent spate of wildfires. 'Cutting firefighter numbers and fire appliances removes resilience from the service when incidents do occur, this has the potential to put lives at risk and the FBU would encourage members of the public to fully engage in the ongoing SFRS consultation and let both SFRS and the Scottish Government know they don't want to see their fire and rescue service cut even deeper. 'The changes in Perth, if approved, would mean the permanent removal of the third pumping appliance and 15 firefighter posts.' Perth MSP Murdo Fraser criticised the move, particularly given the two devastating blazes in the city last month. He said: 'These proposed cuts to Perth Fire Station have been feared for a while and I understand the concerns that these will leave the brave firefighters who work there extremely short of much needed resources. 'The spate of recent fires we have seen in Perth underlines the need for a properly resourced fire and rescue service in our community.' SFRS head of service delivery for the east and the north of Scotland deputy assistant chief officer Andrew Girrity, said: 'Our modelling has shown that two appliances would align better with risk and demand. 'Currently, the third vehicle at Perth is a combined aerial rescue pump, and we want to change this to a dedicated high reach appliance. 'Since 2023, the dedicated high reach appliance has been temporarily crewed, and we need to find a permanent solution.' Speaking about the service delivery review Mr Girrity added: 'We have an opportunity for the first time since the national SFRS was formed in 2013 to review how we provide our emergency service across Scotland. 'I would encourage as many people as possible to take part in the public consultation process and attend the public meetings.' A drop-in public meeting will take place tomorrow, Wednesday July 23, from 3pm to 7pm at AK Bell Library in Perth.
Scotsman
19-07-2025
- Scotsman
Why I'm proud to call 'Scotland's worst seaside resort' my home
Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... 'Are you doing Edinburgh this year?' It's a question asked of many performers, meaning 'are you doing the Fringe this August?' When I lived in the city, involved in the performing arts for most of my adult life until 2020, it tickled me to be asked this annually. I 'did' Edinburgh every day. I planned to for the rest of my life. Sure, her drinks were extortionate, her rents became alarming, and the old architecture looked down on the shiny glass of yet another student accommodation block with understandable disdain. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad But I loved her. She was a privilege to know – yes, a little difficult to – but worth the effort. Our relationship felt permanent, despite others finding her a mere 'base' or a transient city, to be studied in, 'done', or visited, before leaving. I'd served her tourists, extremely incompetently, as a waitress in my late teens. I'd dropped out of one of her universities in a hail of failure in the year 2000. I'd pulled pints in her clubs, performed on her stages from the noughties onwards. It is a wonderful thing to live in Edinburgh, a city that so many people want to visit (Picture: Jane Barlow) | PA Privilege of life in Edinburgh I'd cleaned her apartments and ferried distraught, often angry, newly homeless individuals and families into temporary accommodation, all over the city, as a homelessness warden in 2008/09. I eventually taught in three of her secondary schools, from coastal, diverse-intake comprehensives, to a posher state school in the leafy suburb of Barnton. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad I knew her – as many writers have noted – to be a city of enormous contrasts. 'All roads lead to Princes Street,' the saying goes, but I was well aware that the city centre, with the arts hubs I was working towards making a full-time living in, didn't reflect her full story. Nevertheless, until my final year in Edinburgh, by which point I'd been a full-time, freelance poet/performer and literary events programmer for a few years, I felt an enormous privilege living somewhere that people loved to visit. Edinburgh was proud of herself, of her culture, her history. Breaking up with her was traumatic. But, frankly, by the time I left she really hadn't been behaving herself. Amongst other antics, her most eminent university caved to shouty activist pressure in 2020, renaming David Hume Tower the bland '40 George Square'. On the basis of complaints over one footnote in one essay, which, as poet Don Paterson pointed out in a recent polemic for the Irish Pages is entirely at odds with everything else Hume ever wrote, contemporary Edinburgh decided to put the boot in, declaring 'problematic' one of her most famous philosophers and influential sons. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad People stroll along Ayr beach (Picture: John Devlin) | National World No regrets about leaving Edinburgh had started to feel hostile. The increase in 'cancel culture' activism across the arts, and a subsequent change in finances, meant divorce was necessary. I packed up my scuffed memories, moving to the seaside town of Ayr, near where I grew up spending my teenage-hood dreaming of leaving for a life in Edinburgh. Ten days later, the Covid lockdown, 2020 was discombobulating... Five years in, however, I've no regrets. Apart from anything else, my writer's income wouldn't get me a mortgage on a letterbox in Edinburgh. I'm now in the nicest, most affordable apartment I've ever lived in. Yes, the seagulls are boisterous: one of them in particular should be on the stalking register for the way it eyes my cats through the window. But the salt cure of being next to the sea is priceless. My neighbours are friendly. The skies seem huge after the cramped, no-sunlight tenements of Tollcross. And, if I can thank those pesky Edinburgh arts activists for something, I experienced the otherwise bleak isolation of Covid in a place of serious beauty. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The River Ayr, where I used to go when skiving school 25 years prior, was a particular source of solace in those early days. Coming to terms with successfully escaping Ayrshire, only to be chewed up and spat out by the city, returning as someone then pushing 40, wasn't exactly the life-plan. 'That's my girl' But, in confirmation that my wee town truly is home now, I enjoyed my reaction to a recent headline. ''Scotland's worst seaside resort' revealed as locals blast 'ghost town' full of empty shops that's 'only getting worse'' led the story in The Sun. According to a survey of 3,800 Which? magazine readers, Ayr failed to impress many tourists, with residents also eager to point out the obvious decline of the town over the last three decades. My response? A chuckle and a 'that's my girl!' Like the early philosophers urged, Ayr knows itself. As with Edinburgh, it has a rich history worth exploring. But nobody denies the grim state of this once-thriving holiday town; nobody tries to put a shine on the stark situation. While there are pockets of affluence, like many Ayrshire towns there is serious rural poverty, a lack of affordable housing, and schools that struggle to improve educational attainment. While some have responded to the Which? survey by extolling the virtues of good transport links to Glasgow, the plentiful family-oriented activities and beautiful countryside (all true), as a resident it's unavoidable: Ayr is tired, needing more than sticking-plaster solutions to solve its problems. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Nevertheless, I'm certain residents wouldn't indulge activists trying to rename Burns Statue Square, denigrating the celebrated Ayrshire-born poet's entire work, despite his arguably 'problematic' utterances. While the town struggles, it's characterised by real potential; people trying to improve things – alongside those who rightly chuff about the seeming lack of vision from local authorities. Much as with Edinburgh, Ayr's taken some getting used to, particularly after so long away from her. Despite the divorce, Edina and I are also back on – albeit cautious – speaking terms. But Ayr is, proudly, home, for the foreseeable.
