ITAT rejects Congress appeal against tax demand of Rs 199 cr
Income Tax Appellate Tribunal
(ITAT) Monday dismissed an appeal filed by Congress challenging a tax demand of ₹199.15 crore for assessment year 2018-19.
The tribunal rejected the party's claim for tax exemption under Section 13A due to late return filing and violations of cash donation limits, establishing strict compliance requirements for political parties seeking tax benefits.
"All these assessee's (Congress) vehement submissions fail to evoke our concurrence," ruled the quorum of judicial member Satbeer Singh Godara and accountant member M Balaganesh.
Referring to a leading
Supreme Court
judgment and a March 2016 high court ruling, the tribunal in its July 21 ruling held that an exemption mentioned in a tax statute must be "strictly complied with".
The 50 page ITAT order referring to the two rulings (SC and HC) said "this is for the precise reason that so far as an interpretation of such an exemption provision in a fiscal statute is concerned", not only the high court has made it clear "that Section 13A has to be strictly complied with" but also the Supreme Court in a 2018 ruling "has settled the issue that it is not liberal but stricter interpretation only in a taxing statute which has to be employed in an exemption claim".
Live Events
Dismissing Congress's appeal, the tribunal held "that being the case and in light of the fact that even Section 139(4B) has stipulated filing of return within the 'due' date i.e. required to be furnished u/s 139(1), we are of the considered view that the above former clause in fact restricts any further liberalism herein as clearly incorporating the expression of 'due' date". "Therefore, the moment there is violation of such a 'due' date, Section 13A third proviso gets attracted, so as to result in denial of exemption to the party concerned," the order said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
26 minutes ago
- Time of India
Old rivals Katti, Patil join hands to counter Jarkiholi influence in Belagavi
1 2 Belagavi: In a dramatic political twist in Belagavi district, former BJP MP Ramesh Katti and senior Congress functionary AB Patil — rivals for over three decades — have set aside differences and joined hands in Hukkeri taluk. The surprise alliance is being seen as a strategic counter to the growing influence of the Jarkiholi family, especially over the key Hiranyakeshi cooperative sugar factory. Their coming together has re-energised Lingayat representatives in the region, with recent meetings at Kaneri Mutt pointing to broader plans to curb the Jarkiholi family's rising clout. Though long-standing adversaries, both Patil and Katti insisted their collaboration is "solely aimed at safeguarding cooperative institutions", especially the Hiranyakeshi factory, once a bastion of the Katti family. You Can Also Check: Bengaluru AQI | Weather in Bengaluru | Bank Holidays in Bengaluru | Public Holidays in Bengaluru The factory, founded in 1956 by Appanagouda Patil, had been under the Kattis' control since 1995 until Jan 2025, when a faction led by BJP's Annasaheb Jolle and MLA Balachandra Jarkiholi seized control. The defection of seven board directors led to the resignation of Nikhil Katti as chairman, ending the Kattis' 30-year dominance. However, discontent with Jolle's leadership reportedly drove board members to approach Patil and Katti for help. "Hiranyakeshi isn't just a factory; it's a symbol of the cooperative movement," said AB Patil. "Initially, Rs 150 crore is required to kick-start the factory. We will arrange funds from various sources and restore it. Our goal is to crush one lakh tonnes of sugarcane in the coming season." At a joint press meet, Katti said, "I am a loyal BJP worker, while AB Patil is a loyal worker of Congress. When it comes to politics, we will follow our party directions, holding our respective party flags." The rising political clout of the Jarkiholi brothers in Belagavi, a region traditionally dominated by representatives of the Lingayat community, had triggered anxiety among senior Lingayats, prompting a closed-door strategy meeting at the influential Kaneri Mutt near the Maharashtra border. The meeting sparked intense political chatter across the district as it came ahead of the high-stakes Belagavi District Central Cooperative (BDCC) Bank elections in Oct, where Balachandra Jarkiholi is leading efforts to secure all 16 seats unopposed. However, minister Satish Jarkiholi had played down the Kaneri Mutt meeting saying "such meetings against the Jarkiholi family are not new".
Time of India
27 minutes ago
- Time of India
After 1999 flashback, Kharge emerges as possibleCM face amid Siddaramaiah-DKS fact-off
Bengaluru: Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge 's recent remarks recalling how he was denied the CM's post in 1999 despite support of the majority in the party has raised a key question: Is the veteran Dalit functionary positioning himself as a fallback Karnataka CM candidate if the current deadlock between chief minister Siddaramaiah and his deputy, DK Shivakumar , continues? The comment, seen by many as a reminder of both his past contribution and present relevance, has added a new layer to the ongoing political churn in the state. With talk of a possible mid-term CM change gaining traction and no clarity yet on a succession plan, Congress sources say Kharge could emerge as a compromise candidate acceptable to multiple factions. "Kharge has been aspiring for long to become CM," said a senior Congress functionary. "Even though he was elevated to the highest position (AICC chief) in the party, he still regrets missing out on opportunities not just in 1999 but at other times as well when Congress governed the state. Though he was eligible for the post, the entry of Ahinda leader Siddaramaiah kept him at bay." You Can Also Check: Bengaluru AQI | Weather in Bengaluru | Bank Holidays in Bengaluru | Public Holidays in Bengaluru Kharge's becoming CM could tick several boxes. It could fulfil a long-standing demand for a Dalit CM in Karnataka, where the Scheduled Caste population stands at 18% as per the 2011 Census. Some party strategists believe the move could also help unite factions in the state unit and send a strong political message ahead of the 2028 assembly and 2029 Lok Sabha elections. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Moose Approaches Girl At Bus Stop And Nudges Her To Follow - Watch What Happens Happy in Shape Undo by Taboola by Taboola Political observers suggest Kharge's public expression of regret is more than just an emotional outpouring. For many, it suggests a subtle signal to the party's central leadership, especially in the context of the leadership tussle between Siddaramaiah and Shivakumar that appears no closer to a resolution. However, not everyone is buying the idea. "C Rajagopalachari became CM of Madras after serving as governor general, but chief ministership after being AICC president may not be desirable. However, in politics, nothing can be ruled out," said Brijesh Kalappa, senior Congress functionary. "While Kengal Hanumanthaiah became railway minister after his CM stint, Kharge has already served as railway minister. Though chief ministership has eluded Kharge so far, as AICC president, he controls the fortunes of several CMs. " Sandeep Shastri, psephologist, suggested it would be a demotion of sorts. "Kharge has gone far beyond the role [of CM] after becoming party president and leader of opposition in both Lok and Rajya Sabha," said Shastri. "What he expressed over the weekend is deep anguish at not having been able to make it to the CM post a quarter century ago. Much political water has flown under the bridge since then." Political analyst Harish Ramaswamy from North Karnataka believes such a move would be a step backward. "Given Kharge's current status, it would be unwise to look towards becoming CM," said Ramaswamy. "He should let go of the past and look to win the forthcoming Parliament elections. No doubt, Kharge is a tall leader among Scheduled Castes. However, his leadership as Congress president is much more valuable, besides being pan-India. Aiming to become Prime Minister would be more suitable than positioning himself to be CM. This will be a misguided preference, given his current disposition, both in the party and in Parliament." While Kharge has not openly staked claim to the CM post, the timing of his remarks — and the silence it has drawn from the party's top brass — has only fuelled further chatter. Whether it's a reminder of a missed opportunity or a signal of future intent, only time will tell.
Time of India
31 minutes ago
- Time of India
Jubilation in BJP as Operation Mahadev dampens opposition ammunition
NEW DELHI: "All these days we were being asked what happened to the Pahalgam attackers. And now that they have been eliminated by our security forces, they are laughing and asking why now? As if we chose a Monday during the month of Sawan to accomplish the task," PM Narendra Modi said. The remark came amid jubilation in BJP over the success of Operation Mahadev which blunted the offensive the opposition had planned to corner the govt over the April massacre of tourists by jihadi terrorists who marked the victims out on basis of their faith. The build-up to the debate had seen the opposition targeting the govt for failing to nab the Pakistani terrorists, and looked set to sharpen the line on Parliament's floor. On Tuesday, a sense of satisfaction was writ large on the face of Amit Shah as he detailed the steps taken by the agencies to verify that the three Pakistanis killed in Dachigam sanctuary outside Srinagar were indeed the killers of Pahalgam. He also disclosed that his instruction to security forces in the immediate wake of the mass killings was to ensure that the terror troika did not cross over into PoK. Opposition on Tuesday did question the govt over "intelligence failure" and absence of security arrangements for the tourists, but the taunts paled before the full-scale offensive that had seemed on the cards and would have been unleashed if Lashkar jihadis had escaped or remained elusive. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like She Was The Dream Girl In The 80s, This Is Her Recently Click Here "The opposition would have been far more aggressive," an NDA source said. As the treasury benches greeted Shah's announcement with chants of "Har Har Mahadev", they were also helped by P Chidambaram's remark in an interview that the Pahalgam attackers could very well be homegrown terrorists. "Why are you giving a clean chit to Pakistan?" asked Shah who also said the Congress neta's interview was tantamount to questioning the very rationale of Operation Sindoor. Chidambaram was not the only opposition neta to have figured prominently in the Lok Sabha debate while not being present in the House. His colleague in the UPA cabinet Salman Khurshid also featured in a big way, with Shah recalling his statement that Sonia Gandhi had broken down after seeing the photograph of Indian Mujahideen terrorists who were killed in an encounter with Delhi Police at Batla House. "It would have made sense if she had shed tears for Mohan Chand Sharma," the home minister said in a reference to the celebrated police officer who was killed in the encounter with IM bombers. "I have Salman Khurshid's interview saved on my mobile," Shah said to rebut those from Congress who questioned the veracity of his statement. Speaking later, Priyanka Gandhi responded to Shah by saying the home minister should also have spoken about Sonia Gandhi's tears after the assassination of her father. But the Prime Minister brought the issue to the fore once again by referring to the statement of Khurshid and by linking the spate of terror attacks under UPA to Congress's politics of "appeasement".
