Pixar faces backlash after cutting LGBTQ, Latinx content from ‘Elio'
'Suddenly, you remove this big, key piece, which is all about identity, and Elio just becomes about totally nothing,' a former Pixar artist told the Hollywood Reporter in a story posted Monday, June 30.
The changes reportedly led to the departure of the animated feature's original director Adrian Molina and star America Ferrera.
'The 'Elio' that is in theaters right now is far worse than Adrian's best version of the original,' added the artist, who spoke to THR under anonymity.
Pixar suffered the worst opening weekend in its history with 'Elio,' which was released in theaters on June 20 and pulled in just $21 million in North America and $14 million overseas in its first three days. It earned an additional $10.7 million last weekend, but that's still a 49% drop for a film estimated to have cost between $150 million and $200 million.
'I'd love to ask Pete and the other Disney executives whether or not they thought the rewrite was worth it,' says the artist, referring to Pixar's Chief Creative Officer Pete Docter. 'Would they have lost this much money if they simply let Adrian tell his story?'
The studio, reacting to rejection by audiences, has taken to social media to call out fans and critics for not supporting original content.
Molina, who co-wrote and co-directed Pixar's 2017 hit ' Coco,' is an openly gay filmmaker whose original cut of 'Elio' reportedly included a sequence in which Elio, an 11-year-old boy who dreams of being abducted by aliens to escape his lonely life, collects trash on the beach and turns it into a pink tank top and shows it off to a hermit crab as his 'trash-ion show.'
Also eliminated was a scene in Elio's bedroom with pictures suggesting a male crush.
'Elio was just so cute and so much fun and had so much personality, and now he feels much more generic to me,' added another former Pixar staffer who worked on the film.
The film was delayed for about a year after a disastrous test screening in Arizona in 2023. The audience said they generally enjoyed the movie, but when asked how many of them would see it in a theater, not a single hand was raised, according to THR's report.
Molina also screened the film for Pixar leaders, including Docter, and the filmmaker was reportedly 'hurt' by the conversation that followed. Molina exited the project soon afterward and was eventually replaced by ' Turning Red ' director Domee Shi and East Bay native Madeline Sharafian.
Molina is still credited as co-director on the finished film.
Ferrera, who had already recorded dialogue as Elio's mother Olga, also left because 'America was upset that there was no longer Latinx representation in the leadership,' the former Pixar artist said.
In the reworked film, Olga, voiced by Zoe Saldaña, is now Elio's aunt who is raising him after his parents' death.
'I was deeply saddened and aggrieved by the changes that were made,' former Pixar assistant editor Sarah Ligatich, who provided feedback during the production as a member of the company's internal LGBTQ group PixPRIDE, told THR. 'The exodus of talent after that (original) cut was really indicative of how unhappy a lot of people were that they had changed and destroyed this beautiful work.'
It is unclear if executives at Disney, the parent company of Pixar, were involved in the changes, although the former Pixar artist said, 'A lot of people like to blame Disney, but the call is coming from inside the house.'
This is not the first time Pixar has faced controversy regarding queer content.
A same-sex storyline was reportedly removed from its 2021 film 'Luca.' When ' Lightyear,' an offshoot of the ' Toy Story ' franchise, hit theaters in 2022, conservative commentators slammed it for including a same-sex relationship and kiss, prompting bans in potentially lucrative Middle Eastern territories.
'Lightyear,' which featured Marvel's 'Captain America' star Chris Evans as the voice of Buzz Lightyear, severely underperformed at the box office, which may have led to the decisions made a year later during the production of 'Elio.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
21 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Pixar fires back at fans, critics on social media after ‘Elio' flops
Pixar is clearly frustrated by the dismal box office performance of its latest feature ' Elio,' and is starting to hit back at its critics on social media. The Emeryville-based animation studio, owned by Disney, recently posted a video to Instagram that follows a new internet trend where people share hard truths off-screen and then pretend they don't know where the source of the statement is. In this case, an unidentified woman sitting in a car is looking off screen when she says, 'Stop complaining that Disney doesn't make original stories if you don't show up to movie theaters and support them in the first place.' After a sound effect 'alerts' the woman that she is being filmed, she looks at the camera and says, 'Oh, my gosh, I thought I was the only one in my car!' She then holds up a poster for ' Elio ' and says, 'Anyways, there's a new original story from Disney Pixar ... called 'Elio,' you should go and support it.' 'Elio' opened in theaters on June 20, and so far is the worst performing Pixar movie in its history despite strong reviews, including by the Chronicle. As of Monday, June 30, the film holds an 83% approval rating by critics and 91% from audiences on review aggregate website Rotten Tomatoes. But that hasn't translated to ticket sales. After two weekends in theaters, the $150 million film about a lonely boy who becomes a galactic ambassador for Earth has grossed about $42 million domestically and $72 million globally. At issue is criticism leveled at the animation giant that it makes too many sequels and not enough movies based on new stories. Last year's ' Inside Out 2 ' took in $1.7 billion at the global box office and briefly became the highest-grossing animated film of all time. Next year's slate includes ' Toy Story 5,' with ' Incredibles 3 ' also in the works. But original films have struggled since ' Onward ' was released in theaters in 2020 on the cusp of the pandemic. ' Soul ' (late 2020), ' Luca ' (2021) and ' Turning Red ' (2022) all went straight to streaming on Disney+, while ' Lightyear ' (2022), an offshoot of the 'Toy Story' series, underperformed in theaters. ' Elemental ' (2023), an original film, also had a weak box office opening but hung around in theaters and eventually became a sleeper hit. With this new social media post, Pixar is hoping that 'Elio' can do the same.
San Francisco Chronicle
21 hours ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Pixar faces backlash after cutting LGBTQ, Latinx content from ‘Elio'
Pixar insiders, stung by the box-office failure of ' Elio,' are slamming the Emeryville animation studio's decision to remove its gay-coded content and Latino representation, claiming it stripped the film of its heart and identity. 'Suddenly, you remove this big, key piece, which is all about identity, and Elio just becomes about totally nothing,' a former Pixar artist told the Hollywood Reporter in a story posted Monday, June 30. The changes reportedly led to the departure of the animated feature's original director Adrian Molina and star America Ferrera. 'The 'Elio' that is in theaters right now is far worse than Adrian's best version of the original,' added the artist, who spoke to THR under anonymity. Pixar suffered the worst opening weekend in its history with 'Elio,' which was released in theaters on June 20 and pulled in just $21 million in North America and $14 million overseas in its first three days. It earned an additional $10.7 million last weekend, but that's still a 49% drop for a film estimated to have cost between $150 million and $200 million. 'I'd love to ask Pete and the other Disney executives whether or not they thought the rewrite was worth it,' says the artist, referring to Pixar's Chief Creative Officer Pete Docter. 'Would they have lost this much money if they simply let Adrian tell his story?' The studio, reacting to rejection by audiences, has taken to social media to call out fans and critics for not supporting original content. Molina, who co-wrote and co-directed Pixar's 2017 hit ' Coco,' is an openly gay filmmaker whose original cut of 'Elio' reportedly included a sequence in which Elio, an 11-year-old boy who dreams of being abducted by aliens to escape his lonely life, collects trash on the beach and turns it into a pink tank top and shows it off to a hermit crab as his 'trash-ion show.' Also eliminated was a scene in Elio's bedroom with pictures suggesting a male crush. 'Elio was just so cute and so much fun and had so much personality, and now he feels much more generic to me,' added another former Pixar staffer who worked on the film. The film was delayed for about a year after a disastrous test screening in Arizona in 2023. The audience said they generally enjoyed the movie, but when asked how many of them would see it in a theater, not a single hand was raised, according to THR's report. Molina also screened the film for Pixar leaders, including Docter, and the filmmaker was reportedly 'hurt' by the conversation that followed. Molina exited the project soon afterward and was eventually replaced by ' Turning Red ' director Domee Shi and East Bay native Madeline Sharafian. Molina is still credited as co-director on the finished film. Ferrera, who had already recorded dialogue as Elio's mother Olga, also left because 'America was upset that there was no longer Latinx representation in the leadership,' the former Pixar artist said. In the reworked film, Olga, voiced by Zoe Saldaña, is now Elio's aunt who is raising him after his parents' death. 'I was deeply saddened and aggrieved by the changes that were made,' former Pixar assistant editor Sarah Ligatich, who provided feedback during the production as a member of the company's internal LGBTQ group PixPRIDE, told THR. 'The exodus of talent after that (original) cut was really indicative of how unhappy a lot of people were that they had changed and destroyed this beautiful work.' It is unclear if executives at Disney, the parent company of Pixar, were involved in the changes, although the former Pixar artist said, 'A lot of people like to blame Disney, but the call is coming from inside the house.' This is not the first time Pixar has faced controversy regarding queer content. A same-sex storyline was reportedly removed from its 2021 film 'Luca.' When ' Lightyear,' an offshoot of the ' Toy Story ' franchise, hit theaters in 2022, conservative commentators slammed it for including a same-sex relationship and kiss, prompting bans in potentially lucrative Middle Eastern territories. 'Lightyear,' which featured Marvel's 'Captain America' star Chris Evans as the voice of Buzz Lightyear, severely underperformed at the box office, which may have led to the decisions made a year later during the production of 'Elio.'
Yahoo
a day ago
- Yahoo
Kun on Latest Single 'Deadman' and His Next Chapter: 'It's Really Just the Beginning'
It only takes a moment with Kun – the 26-year-old singer-songwriter who rose to fame on China's Idol Producer – to feel like long-lost friends. The boy group member turned singer-songwriter is quick to jump into conversation about his seemingly favorite topic – making music. There's plenty to talk about. His latest single, 'Deadman,' was released a month ago. The soulful track's release was accompanied by a cinematic music video, which the 26-year-old was deeply involved in creating. More from The Hollywood Reporter 'Cinema Jazireh': An Afghan Woman Looking for a Loved One Must Transform Herself (KVIFF Trailer) 'Broken Voices' Is Inspired by a Girls' Choir Sexual Abuse Scandal Long Before #MeToo Kelly Clarkson Postpones Opening Night of Las Vegas Residency Shortly Before Showtime Fresh off a somewhat-surprise performance of the song song at 88Rising's Head in the Clouds festival last month, Kun sat down with The Hollywood Reporter to talk about making deadman, his love for music and what's next in his 'new journey.' Can you tell me more about your latest single 'Deadman?' Well, I'm very, very happy because this track was made last year, so it was a year [until the time] when people could actually hear it. I heard it a thousand times already, so now people actually are hearing it and a lot of them are surprised. I think they'd [say], 'Oh, I didn't know Kun's voice was like this now.' But I was just doing my thing over the past year. I would just keep cooking music in the studio. That's what I love. I like to focus on it, and I made a lot of demos. But 'Deadman' is definitely the one I loved, so I'm very happy. Finally, I put out this track. Something about this track has the vintage sound that I've never made before, and [there's] the contrast between the vintage and the modern thing. I think it's very interesting, so I really wanted people to hear it. It does have an nostalgic feeling to it. It feels like you've heard it before, in a good way, not a reptetitve way. Tell me about the process making songs? There's no reference, to be honest. We have the guitar player [and the] piano players. I just tell them, 'Hey, let's do this groove.' I would just start giving a groove, a tempo, we set up a vibe. I start [to] freestyle, just easy. No reference. I'll tell them, 'Hey, I want to do something like old school, but not too old.' Does that make sense? I like soulful stuff. I listen to a lot of classic jazz, soul and R&B. They know what I like. I like Prince. I like Elvis. They all know that. My friends, we make music together, so when I start free-styling, they just know. They'll tell me, 'This is the line.' We're just chilling. We're just playing. Do you have a favorite part of releasing this single? Definitely the music video. There's a lot of crazy stories behind the music video. Look at his face, look his face. It is like, we shot it in Montenegro. It's a very beautiful place. I was there for a week, a whole week. I learned the choreography there, and I learned fighting. I learned dance. We set up the rig. It was kind of crazy, and the schedule was very tight. We had to move to different locations, and I couldn't even sleep at night, so I was posting [to my Instagram] story that I was just sitting on the sofa like, 'I hope this will be good, I hope everything will be fine.' My friends were always asking me, 'What's going on? Why are you not sleeping? It's supposed to be very late right now, right?' It wasn't an easy one. Definitely. But I'm very thankful for all the people that worked on this project. It's not an easy one. It's kind of like a movie shoot. That is impressive, especially given the scale. I wanted to make this character. He's dying over and over again because of the things he loves, so he's bleeding all the time, very painful. Always rocking with the guitar like today is the last day, today's the end. This is going to be the last song I sing to the world. That's the direction we went for, and that's the first line I said to everybody. 'Hey, I want to write a song. It sounds stupid, but what if I die tomorrow? Today is the last track I'm going to play.' That's how we got 'Deadman.' It sounds like you're very, very creatively involved in everything you do. What is that so important to you as an artist? I'm just a creative guy. I like to learn new things. I like to create new stuff, like cool shit, but in my own way, I don't want to be anybody [else]. I just want to be myself, right? I just want to sound like myself. I just want to do my own thing. I'm the guy that's always [improving] myself. I always hate the old me. It is like, 'Why did I [do] this shit?' [There's] nothing bad about it. I just want to be better all the time. You get what I mean? That's just my personality, so I just like to beat myself. Essentially, for you, your only competition is yourself? Exactly. Can you tell me a bit about Head in the Clouds and what it was like performing there? This time I really just came here to support. [I wasn't] playing a set. I only have one new track out. I want to play the new songs. I don't want to play the old songs. We can probably play [them] next time, like a new set, maybe in New York. But this time I was mostly just here to show people the new music, what it sounds like. I wanted to show the audience in America, let them hear the new track. And also connect with my fans. I love the crowds. What is it like performing in the U.S. for you? Do you enjoy it? Do you find it a little different? I think it's different. It's very cool. It's my first time [doing a festival]. In China, we have a lot of festivals too, but [I] never really go to [them]. I was only doing [my own] concerts, so this is the first time. I just really did something I haven't done before. I'm just very happy. I'm really enjoyed it. We didn't even have a lot of time to prepare [with] rehearsals. I just went on the stage and tried it. I didn't even know what mic I was going to use. I didn't even know who was going to give me my in-ears and everything. It's a funny story. I was actually fixing the mic stand when I was singing the high notes. Somebody didn't tighten it, so it was just going up and down. I'm trying to fix it, but I'm also singing the high notes. It's kind of crazy, but there's a lot of stories people don't know. Do you want to perform more in the U.S.? We will. We will. I feel like we're just starting. Starting from 'Deadman,' everything is just new. [I'm] starting a new journey, so It's really just the beginning. Head in the Clouds, it's fun. It's a good start. It's helping a lot of Asian artists. That's something I respect. There's not a lot of labels [or] festivals that's helping Asian artists. That's amazing. That's something very cool. What is like to be able to perform at a festival like that? It's a very good experience for me. When I'm singing, everything just kind of tunes out. I just focus on the track. I just want to put out the message I want. I just want to show people, 'Hey, this is the new sound.' In the past, we just spent too much time in the studio. I spent too much time in studio. And I know that my fans [have been] waiting for too long. I feel a little sorry. I always say that. I feel sorry sometimes they don't see me that much. I don't even post a lot… That's just me. I'm not an internet guy. I'm not a social [media] guy. That's just not me. I just like to focus on my thing. Sometimes I feel sorry to my fans, so this time when they asked me to play [the] festival, they said, 'Can you play a set?' I said maybe next time, but I can show up. I can come to support. I'd like to because I love Head in the Clouds. I love the vibe. Best of The Hollywood Reporter From 'Party in the U.S.A.' to 'Born in the U.S.A.': 20 of America's Most Patriotic (and Un-Patriotic) Musical Offerings Most Anticipated Concert Tours of 2025: Beyoncé, Billie Eilish, Kendrick Lamar & SZA, Sabrina Carpenter and More Hollywood's Most Notable Deaths of 2025
