Judge strikes out assault charge against law professor and barrister Diarmuid Phelan
A judge has dismissed an assault charge against law professor and barrister Diarmuid Phelan, saying the man would not get a fair trial.
Mr Phelan (57), also known as Diarmuid Rossa Phelan, who lectures at Trinity College Dublin, came before Judge William Aylmer at Wexford District Court on Monday in a special application to have the charge dismissed given the delays in bringing the case to hearing.
Mr Phelan, who was in court, appeared on a charge of allegedly assaulting neighbour Kevin McHale at Reedstown in Tacumshane, Co Wexford, on August 26th, 2021, causing him harm.
The case had been adjourned a number of times, with Monday set aside as a special day for hearing.
READ MORE
Mr Phelan had been acquitted of murdering 35-year-old Keith Conlon at Hazelgrove Farm, Kiltalown Lane, Tallaght, Co Dublin, earlier this year.
Justin McQuaid, defending, told Wexford District Court that while the assault took place on August 26th, 2021, Mr Phelan was not notified of a complaint until December 15th when Garda John Coughlan texted him.
Potentially critical video evidence was not available to exonerate Mr Phelan because he had not been notified of the complaint in time, Mr McQuaid said.
The court also heard that a previous allegation made against Mr Phelan had proven to be false when gardaí looked at dashcam footage from his car on the same day.
He said Mr Phelan had denied assaulting his neighbour, saying he was acting in self defence.
Under cross-examination by Mr McQuaid, Gda Coughlan told the court that on the date in question the wife of Mr McHale made contact with gardaí.
Gda Coughlan said the injuries suffered were 'minor'.
He told the court how on October 29th, 2021, he received a medical report stating that Mr McHale had received abrasions to the face and had complained of tenderness to the left side.
According to the garda, on November 23rd, 2021, the accused showed him a shirt which he wore on the day of the alleged assault that was torn and had buttons removed.
Garda Coughlan said the accused was never arrested, but by agreement had on February 2nd, 2022, attended Wexford Garda Station. He made a statement denying he had assaulted Mr McHale and that Mr McHale was the aggressor.
Gda Coughlan said there had been a history between Mr Phelan, who owned a farm, and Mr McHale, with Mr Phelan alleging his land had been trespassed upon going back to 2000.
The court heard there had been complaints about trespassing and interfering on the land dating back years.
Gda Coughlan blamed his workload for the delay in notifying Mr Phelan sooner of the allegation.
Mr Phelan told the court he owned a farm, both in Dublin and Wexford, but primarily lived in Dublin.
He said the assault proceedings had been very stressful, adding to the stress of the murder trial which he said was 'very traumatic' and 'horrific'.
The two were interwoven, he said.
The day after Mr Phelan was charged with the murder of Keith Conlon, Gda Coughlan made a statement about the assault allegation and sent a file to the DPP the following day.
Mr Phelan said he first heard he was being charged with assaulting Mr McHale during the bail hearing in the High Court in Dublin for the murder charge.
He told the judge he thought the matter was over after meeting and discussing it with Gda Coughlan the previous December.
In his ruling, Judge Aylmer cited the absence of CCTV footage, saying that Gda Coughlan had been told there was possible footage of the alleged assault, but did not seek to obtain it.
The judge said the footage was not available to the accused to support his defence at this trial and that he was satisfied on the evidence before the court it was not possible for Mr Phelan to have a fair trial.
He stuck out the charge of assault against Mr Phelan.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
How do I approach Revenue about modest tax debt stretching back many years?
I am writing to you on behalf of an elderly neighbour who confided to me that he is worried about unpaid taxes over a period of two decades. This man returned to Ireland approximately 20 years ago and initially paid tax as a PAYE worker. He later worked ad hoc as a consultant, engaging a local accountancy firm to do his tax returns. It subsequently transpired that the money he paid to the accountant to pay Revenue had not been paid. He has no pension pot or assets and has basically fallen on hard times after complying, he says, with all tax requirements throughout his working life. I gather that instead of contacting Revenue to find a solution, he buried his head in the sand and somehow fell through the tax net. READ MORE His only other employment was a number of casual cash-in-hand jobs until he reached pension age, which he did well over a decade ago. He has paid no tax on his Irish pension or on his UK pension. He wants to rectify the situation, but is not in a position to pay back the unpaid tax and any additional fines. He has no assets aside from modest savings, which he wants to be used for his funeral. Someone told him that his family in England will have to pay the taxes. He is deeply worried that he will face public shame, prosecution and imprisonment. [ Long delays in UK pension buyback programme leave people worrying they could miss out Opens in new window ] Any suggestions on how he can approach Revenue and how they might handle the situation would be much appreciated. Ms P.S. Your neighbour has found himself in a very unfortunate position which, inadvertently or not, he has actually made worse. However, it is important that he realise there will be no shaming, no imprisonment and, as long as he approaches them – rather than waiting to see if they will catch him – no prosecution. And no one is going to be chasing his family in the UK. If he dies with all this balance outstanding, Revenue could demand payment from his estate. If there were not enough to meet the full bill, that would be Revenue's loss at that stage, not an issue for his family – although there clearly might be no inheritance. You can certainly see how it happens. A compliant taxpayer finds himself in Revenue debt through absolutely no fault of his own but, given limited means, chooses to hunker down rather than engage. Almost always, the intention is to 'get around to doing something about it', but weeks become months, months become years, and making that call just seems to get more difficult. Passage of time makes the taxpayer feel almost complicit in the crime and the non-payment. From what you say, the initial 'problem' concerned a period of a little over a year and, given what you say about the issue being the failure of his accountant to pass on funds handed over to meet tax liabilities, rather than any active omission, he would have been assured of a very sympathetic hearing. Yes, the legal onus for meeting tax liabilities is his, not his accountant's, but in the circumstances outlined, an accommodating payment plan would have been easy to arrange. His failure to do so then, or at any time since, has created the potential to exacerbate the issue. Firstly, Revenue will want to know what he did after that time. From the timeline you provide, there would not have been much time between his accountant's fraud against him and his reaching retirement age, but even so, they'll be curious. Then there is the pension income. You don't indicate how much this is, but he apparently has pensions from both Ireland and Britain, so may well be over the tax exemption limit of €18,000 – even if he is not on a full pension from either state. [ Why are some people paying income tax at almost 70%? Their pension pot is too big Opens in new window ] It's important not to exaggerate the issue. At all times, he appears to have been living fairly modestly with little spare cash or savings – so much so that he never felt able to even agree a repayment plan with Revenue. In terms of shame and fear, I have no doubt he is feeling far worse now than he ever would if this had been resolved. As his tax debt is very unlikely to be beyond €50,000, he needs to know that he will not appear in any tax defaulters' list, never mind face imprisonment. If only for the sake of his own mental health, he really does need to sort all this out. The good news for him is that there is help out there. My strong advice is that he go initially to the Money Advice and Budgeting Service (Mabs). This State-funded network specialises in dealing with people who are struggling with debt. It is free of charge and totally confidential. Mabs are contactable by phone and also have a network of offices across the State, providing face-to-face meetings which, I would suggest, would make more sense for this gentleman. You can find his local office here , together with their phone numbers, to arrange an appointment. Otherwise, he can call their national helpline on 0818 07 2000 or email helpline@ . That helpline is open from 9am to 8pm. He should first gather any relevant documents he has and a list of the relevant dates. If some paperwork is missing or the dates are fuzzy, no worries – don't let that put him off meeting Mabs. The service can help him with contacting the Revenue. Once that is done, there are various approaches available under personal insolvency legislation. These include a debt relief notice, a voluntary arrangement, a debt settlement arrangement, or a personal insolvency arrangement. If your neighbour's means are as limited as he tells you, he may in fact not end up paying anything but, even if his means do allow repayment of some of the debt over time, the arrangements under the personal insolvency legislation are designed to ensure he has sufficient money for his personal needs. These arrangements were not in place when your neighbour's woes began, but they offer him a structured and dignified way to put all this behind him and not live with the stress that currently has him living in fear. Please send your queries to Dominic Coyle, Q&A, The Irish Times, 24-28 Tara Street, Dublin 2, or by email to , with a contact phone number. This column is a reader service and is not intended to replace professional advice
Irish Times
7 hours ago
- Irish Times
Gardaí investigate discovery of bodies of couple (80s) in their Cork home
Gardaí have begun an investigation to try to establish what led to the deaths of an elderly couple whose bodies were found in their house on the outskirts of Cork city on Monday evening. The bodies of the couple, who were both in their 80s, were found in the house in Glounthaune, between Cork and Carrigtwohill, by relatives when they called to the house at about 5pm. The relatives broke down the door when they got no reply and discovered two bodies near the stairs. They immediately alerted the gardaí who cordoned off the scene. According to a garda source, there is nothing at this stage to suggest that the couple were the victims of foul play, but they are keeping an open mind as to what may have happened to them. READ MORE 'We tested the house for gas but there was no evidence of any gas leak there,' said the source. 'We don't know at this stage what happened, but it doesn't appear as if they were the victims of foul play.' Garda forensic experts are due to carry out a technical examination of the scene on Tuesday while gardaí hope post-mortem examinations will help explain what happened to the couple. Gardaí have begun door-to-door inquiries and have established the couple spoke to someone as recently as Sunday. They have also begun harvesting CCTV footage from the area.
Irish Times
8 hours ago
- Irish Times
Former garda carries out ‘predatory act of violence' by impersonating colleague online
A former garda has said a colleague carried out a 'calculated, predatory act of violence' by impersonating her online and inciting men to come to her home and rape her. Shane Flanagan (39) with an address in Co Clare impersonated the woman on the fetish website, and on Facebook for the purpose of arranging for people to come to her home and rape her. He created the accounts using the woman's personal information, and shared details including her address, and photographs of her and her daughters. Det Garda Paul English told Anne-Marie Lawlor SC, prosecuting, that the woman and Flanagan were friends and there had never been any romantic or sexual history between them. READ MORE Det Garda English said the woman was extremely shocked to find out that Flanagan was the one who had been impersonating her online. 'If you gave me a list of 500 names of people that could have done this to me, I would never have guessed it was him,' the woman told the investigation. Flanagan pleaded guilty to two counts of inciting two men to rape the woman on dates between November and December 2020. He also pleaded guilty to six counts of endangerment, in that he intentionally or recklessly engaged in impersonating the woman in Facebook communications, and on the website in which communications invited persons unknown to visit violence upon her and two others, thereby creating a substantial risk of death or serious harm on dates between 2018 and 2020. Flanagan also pleaded guilty to one count of possession of four images of child sexual abuse material, known in law as child pornography, on January 7th, 2021. He has no previous convictions. Reading her victim impact statement, the woman said Flanagan was a fellow garda, someone she had trusted and called a friend, who was supposed to uphold the same professional values. She said he not only betrayed her, but also took her career. She said Flanagan 'plotted' to have her and her daughters attacked, and that he 'planned for men to find us and carry out unspeakable acts of violence'. She said this was a 'betrayal beyond words'. She said she no longer feels safe in her own home, has developed anxiety and panic attacks, and that her trust in others has been damaged. She said no sentence could undo the harm caused and told the court this was not just a 'betrayal of friendship' but a 'calculated predatory act of violence that has left lifelong scars' for her and her daughters. The woman asked the court to impose a just sentence to reflect the safety of others and restore trust in the institution of An Garda Síochána. The court heard that the woman became aware that someone was using her image on after a user of that website contacted her on her genuine Facebook page in 2020. In December 2020, she created an account on Fetlife and, while pretending to be male, interacted with the user pretending to be her. The court heard during this interaction, information was shared about her, her address and that she has two teenage daughters. She then made a complaint to gardaí. Evidence was heard of an extensive investigation, which connected the Fetlife account impersonating the woman to Flanagan. His home was searched on January 17th, 2021, and items, including a phone and laptop, were seized. Flanagan provided passwords for these devices and an email address. An analysis of these devices by the Garda National Cyber Crime Unit identified more than 2,000 screenshots from Pulse, 32 records of missing persons and 18 images of Garda age identification documents. The login details for the account were autosaved to the browser and this site was accessed 4,089 times between October 2020 and mid-January 2021. Four images of child abuse material were also found on the laptop. The investigation also found that Flanagan had created a false Facebook account in the name of Laura O'Riordan, again using the injured party's information. Det Sgt English told the court that hundreds of images of the woman, including 219 doctored ones, were found as part of the search. Two of the users of who interacted with Flanagan while he pretended to be the woman provided statements to gardaí. Flanagan incited them to break into the woman's house and rape her. He also shared information including the woman's address, a Google Street view of her home and invited the users to come to the woman's home to rape her. He also told these users that the woman was a single parent with two teenage daughters. Det Sgt English agreed with Pádraig Dwyer SC, defending, that his client retired from the gardaí in March this year and had an 'unblemished' record of service. Testimonials from family members, probation and psychological reports were handed to the court. Mr Dywer read a letter of apology from his client to the court. Ms Justice Eileen Creedon remanded Flanagan in custody for finalisation of sentence next month.
