Dentist being fined £150K by NHS for keeping patients' teeth too healthy
Britain has a hidden oral health crisis with children who've never seen a dentist needing multiple teeth removed after their first appointment.
NHS dentist Rob Mew today reveals the upsetting cases he has encountered since opening his books to new child patients every Thursday. The Mirror came to Devon - one of Britain's worst 'dentistry deserts' - for the first of a series of special reports for our Dentists for All campaign. We visited Fairfield House Dental Surgery in Exmouth which is one of the few in Devon still seeing NHS patients. Its owner Rob believes passionately in the NHS and its founding principle that it should care for patients from 'cradle to grave'.
But that is the only reason his practice still treats NHS patients. It could earn hundreds of thousands of pounds more going private.
Rob is currently being fined £150,000 by the NHS in a funding 'claw back' effectively for keeping his patients too healthy with regular check-ups and preventative work. It is an example of the widely discredited NHS dental payment contract which is causing dentists to quit the health service in their droves to see only private patients.
Every Thursday the practice opens its NHS books to local kids who have not seen a dentist in years - and in some cases have never seen one.
Rob, who himself has three children aged ten, eight and four, said: 'That's one of the reasons I do it because I have young children but it's quite emotional. We were seeing four and five year olds who had so much decay we just had to send them to hospital to get extractions. There's such a backlog of sending these kids to have general anaesthetic to get the teeth out so we're trying to maintain them until they get their teeth extracted.
'One of the dentists saw a seventeen year old who hadn't seen a dentist in ten years and needed 28 fillings. You've got really emotional parents that are feeling really guilty that they have got themselves into this position. One of our nurses said she couldn't work on that list because it was too upsetting because she has kids of a similar age. It's a really sad situation.'
Fairfield House Dental Surgery has been running for over 100 years. Rob became a partner in 2012 before becoming owner when another partner retired in 2017. The practice does free supervised tooth brushing at local primary schools as well as sending practitioners to breast feeding and toddler groups to educate parents.
Rob, 43, said: 'We're blessed with a group of patients who've been with us for a long time, some have been coming here for more than 50 years. So that's why I'm still with the NHS because it feels like the right thing to do, to keep going for them. It's a kind of cradle to grave service which is what the NHS was supposed to be. But that's the only reason we're doing it - out of good will.'
Why is top dentist being 'fined' £150,000 for keeping his patients' teeth too healthy?
Rob Mew owns a rare example of a thriving NHS dental practice in the middle of a dental desert. Fairfield House Dental Surgery employs ten dentists and does free outreach work in the local community to improve oral health.
However when we visited the surgery was in the process of returning £150,000 to the NHS because it had not carried out enough Units of Dental Activity (UDA). It was having to pay £50,000 a month over three months.
UDAs are the metric used by the NHS in its dentistry payment contract which has been deemed 'not fit for purpose' by Parliament's Health and Social Care Committee.
The contract requires practices to agree to perform a set number of UDAs - and they are penalised if they come in below or above this. A check-up is worth one UDA while giving a patient a filling racks up three UDAs.
Rob told the Mirror: 'We are being penalised for preventing patients requiring more UDAs. We have £150,000 'claw back' this year but we have 19,000 NHS patients which is more than the practice has ever had. The clawback is for not doing enough UDAs but when patients are being looked after better they don't have as much need for dental work.'
Fairfield surgery gives his patients a check up every 12 months whereas other practices call lower risk patients back for check ups every two years. Rob said: 'We are seeing them yearly and that's one UDA. We are preventing loss of tooth. A GP practice is paid for how many patients they have on their list. That's how they should be funding dentistry.'
Rob says between five and ten people call the practice every day desperate to be seen by an NHS dentist. He has taken on as many as he can but has just started a waiting list. He said: 'We have got patients travelling to be seen here from as far away as north Wales, Manchester and Sheffield.
"The NHS dental contract in England only funds enough for half the population to be treated so these patients have moved away but can't get a dentist. And the Exmouth population is exploding and we have a load of new housing but no more dentistry money to treat the people in those houses.'
A key Mirror campaign demand is reform of the hated NHS payment contract which disincentivises dentists from treating the patients who need it most. Dentists get paid the same for delivering three or 20 fillings, often leaving the practice treating NHS patients at a loss.
Last week the Government published its Ten Year Health Plan which pledged that "by 2035 the NHS dental system will be transformed" - but the British Dental Association insists contract reform must happen much sooner.
Rob said: 'With these most vulnerable patients with high needs it's really tricky for the practice to to make that work [financially].
'We had a family last Thursday with three kids and they had never been seen by a dentist. There was decay everywhere and they clearly need a lot of work and the parents are saying we haven't been able to be seen anywhere. And they're just tired because they've been calling around practices trying to get in and it kind of gets put on the back burner.
'We had a 14 year old girl come in a couple of weeks ago and she had four crowns put on her back teeth. And you're thinking, if we hadn't handled that soon she would have a couple of back teeth missing and then a lower denture.'
Dental practices have high overheads with staff costs and materials. Fairfield House Dental Surgery is currently trying to find the funds for a new dentist chair which will cost £30,000.
Rob has worked in the NHS in some form for 28 years, starting at the age of 15 in a hospital kitchen. He added: 'I've got a lot of good will towards the NHS so yeh I try my best to make it work.'
But NHS dentistry cannot rely on good will alone.
The British Dental Association warned the Public Accounts Committee earlier this year that the Treasury has become reliant on practices delivering care at a loss - fuelling an exodus of NHS dentists into lucrative private work. The professional body estimates a typical practice loses over £40 delivering a set of NHS dentures and £7 for every new patient exam. A Parliamentary report by the Health Select Committee has described the state of NHS dentistry as "unacceptable in the 21st century".
The NHS contract effectively sets quotas on the maximum number of NHS patients a dentist can see as it caps the number of procedures they can perform each year.
At the same time over a decade of real terms funding cuts under the Tories means the £3 billion NHS dental budget for England is only enough to treat around half of the population.
Devon worst 'Dental Desert'
Data from 700,000 participants in last year's GP Patient Survey showed it is hardest to get an NHS dentist appointment in South West England.
Questions on dentistry focused on respondents who had attempted to get an NHS dental appointment in the last two years suggests Devon may be one of the country's worst dentistry deserts.
Survey responses were grouped by regional Integrated Care Boards (ICBs) which include NHS bodies, local councils and voluntary organisations. The One Devon ICB is responsible for the health of the population in the county. Among people who were already in with an NHS dentist, Devon saw just 72% of people successfully get an appointment. In the wider South West region this was 74% while for England as a whole it was 84%.
Dentists for All campaign
Save NHS Dentistry petition
Sign our petition to save NHS dentistry and make it fit for the 21st century
Our 3 demands
Everyone should have access to an NHS dentist
More than 12 million people were unable to access NHS dental care last year – more than 1 in 4 adults in England. At the same time 90% of dental practices are no longer accepting new NHS adult patients. Data from the House of Commons Library showed 40% of children didn't have their recommended annual check-up last year.
Restore funding for dental services and recruit more NHS dentists
The UK spends the smallest proportion of its heath budget on dental care of any European nation. Government spending on dental services in England was cut by a quarter in real terms between 2010 and 2020. The number of NHS dentists is down by more than 500 to 24,151 since the pandemic.
Change the contracts
A Parliamentary report by the Health Select Committee has branded the current NHS dentists' contracts as 'not fit for purpose' and described the state of the service as "unacceptable in the 21st century". The system effectively sets quotas on the maximum number of NHS patients a dentist can see as it caps the number of procedures they can perform each year. Dentists also get paid the same for delivering three or 20 fillings, often leaving them out of pocket. The system should be changed so it enables dentists to treat on the basis of patient need.
Have you had to resort to drastic measures because you couldn't access an NHS dentist? Are you a parent struggling to get an appointment for a child? Email martin.bagot@mirror.co.uk or call 0800 282591
Of those who attempted to get an appointment at a practice they had not been seen at before, only 14% were successful in Devon. This compared to 19% in the South West region and 33% as the average for England.
The big caveat is that many will not have tried to get an appointment if they thought they had no chance.
The data shows only a minority of dentists are taking on new adult patients, and in Devon and the South West, hardly any are.
British Dental Association chair Eddie Crouch said: 'This shows why the government is right to commit to major surgery for NHS dentistry, rather than mere sticking plasters. But we need pace. This service is on the critical list, and demoralised dentists are walking away every day this contract remains in force. If we don't make a break in this Parliament there may not be a service left to save.'
A spokeswoman for the Department of Health and Social Care said: 'This government inherited a broken NHS dental system but we are getting on with fixing it through our 10 Year Health Plan.
'We have already begun the rollout of 700,000 extra urgent dental appointments, a 'golden hello' scheme is underway to recruit dentists to areas with the most need and we are reforming the NHS dental contract, with a shift to focus on prevention and the retention of NHS dentists - including introducing tie-ins for those trained in the NHS."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Higham campaigners hope 10-year NHS plan will save GP surgery
Campaigners fighting to save their local GP surgery believe the government's 10-year plan for the NHS will help them Medical Practice in north Kent has applied to close one of the four sites it operates from, in Higham, which it said is financially unsustainable.A campaign and petition have been launched to save practice said closing one surgery was the only way to safeguard its three other sites. On 2 July Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer launched a series of wide ranging reforms to the NHS, to be carried out over the next Angell, who started the petition to save Higham surgery, said: "It mentions communities and villages having direct access to care."I'm hopeful that means, whether the surgery does or does not close, there will be a replacement service." The application to close the surgery will now be considered by the NHS Kent and Medway Integrated Care Board (ICB).Ms Angell said she and fellow campaigners would be lobbying the board."I'm hopeful" she said, "the fight isn't over."I just hope the ICB give us the time we need to be able to express our concerns and take them on board."Highparks also runs surgeries in Cliffe Woods, Cliffe and Wainscott. 'Struggled with challenges' A spokesperson for Highparks Medical Practice said: "All four sites work together as a single practice serving over 15,000 patients, who can be seen at any location regardless of which site is nearest their home."Both this government and the previous one have prioritised general practice at scale. The latest plans focus on large health hubs like the Healthy Living Centres in Medway but do not address how to sustain small rural surgeries like ours."As a partnership, we have struggled with these challenges for years and are saddened by the need to close one site. Despite extensive discussions with the local Integrated Care Board and political representatives, no alternative has been found."Unless the government addresses rural primary care challenges, practices like ours will continue to face difficult decisions. This decision safeguards the future of the practice and the care of over 15,000 patients."
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Health secretary won't give timing for dental contract reform
The health secretary has refused to set out a timetable to fulfil one of Labour's main manifesto election promises on the part of the election campaign, the government had said it would reform the dental contract - the framework which pays NHS beginning talks with the British Dental Association (BDA) a year ago, Wes Streeting told the BBC during a visit to Bedfordshire that "unless I am 100% certain I can achieve the promise, I don't make it".Pam Widdison, from Norfolk, said she was in pain for months because she did not have an NHS dentist and was "sick of MPs promising the earth" then failing to deliver. The dental contract was recently highlighted by the Public Accounts Committee as one of the main reasons for the NHS dentistry access crisisSpeaking on a visit to a GP surgery in Leighton Buzzard, Streeting told the BBC he was "hesitant to make specific promises about dates and deadlines" unless he knew he could fulfil them."There's one thing that is in even shorter supply than dentists and money in this country and that's trust in politicians," he government's newly published 10-year health plan said by 2035 a new dental contract would be at the heart of a "transformed" NHS Streeting said in the short term it would concentrate efforts on creating urgent dental appointments for people without a dentist and rolling out tooth brushing in stressed that the NHS was the "standout" winner in the recent spending review, giving the health department "a bit of extra capacity".But he admitted the situation was "challenging" and said he was looking at existing budgets to see how he could release money that was being "wasted".To reduce what it called "bureaucracy", the government has decided to abolish NHS England. Forty-two integrated care boards across the country have also been told to reduce their running costs by 50% by the end of the year and thousands of support roles are going at NHS trusts including hospitals. Counties such as Norfolk have been labelled "dental deserts" because of the shortage of NHS Widdison, a retired teacher from Watton, said she was in pain for seven months. She managed to get an emergency appointment for a tooth extraction but had to travel 20 miles to King's Lynn and still did not have an NHS dentist. "It's a two-tier system in this country," she said. "I'm sick of MP's promising us the earth... why should we have to suffer? We've got an increased population where I live, there should be equality of care. "I do not want anyone to experience what I have been through."She said she believed dentistry was a "vital infrastructure" and could not understand why the NHS was paying for weight loss injections while her town did not have an NHS dentist. To improve access, the University of East Anglia (UEA) in Norwich has been lobbying for the first dental training school in the east of for medicine, Prof Philip Baker, admitted it would not solve everything overnight but would be "one contributor to really make a difference". The nearest dental school to Norwich is 100 miles away in London. The UEA had its course approved by the General Dental Council but needed the government to rubber-stamp its 10-year-plan said that newly-qualified dentists could be required to practice in the NHS for a minimum period of three Baker said the UEA would do all it could to convince trainees to stay in the NHS permanently."Our dental graduates will understand the needs of their communities, understand how important having an NHS dental service is to the region."I guess we really want to instil that pride and that loyalty to the community."Streeting said he "would consider the case very carefully." Follow East of England news on X, Instagram and Facebook: BBC Beds, Herts & Bucks, BBC Cambridgeshire, BBC Essex, BBC Norfolk, BBC Northamptonshire or BBC Suffolk.
Scotsman
an hour ago
- Scotsman
Almost £2bn spent on temporary nurses and midwives over five years
Scottish Labour said the figures are 'unsustainable' Sign up to our Politics newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... SNP ministers have been accused of 'failing Scotland's health service' after it emerged nearly £2 billion has been spent on agency and bank nurses and midwives over the past five years. Figures highlighted by Scottish Labour show a bill of £1,904,286,884.04 was racked up between April 2020 and March 2025. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The spending was accumulated across all of Scotland's 14 health boards, as well as in specialist services including the Scottish Ambulance Service, NHS 24, the State Hospital and the National Waiting Times Centre. Staff on an NHS hospital ward | PA Despite improving on the previous year, the annual cost of agency and bank nurses in 2024/25 was still more than double the cost in 2018/19 and close to triple the cost in 2014/15, Scottish Labour said. The party's health spokeswoman Jackie Baillie said the figures are 'unsustainable'. She said: 'The SNP has spent almost two decades mismanaging our health service, opting for short-term fixes, rather than coming up with a solution to address long-term challenges. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'The use of temporary staff is an expensive sticking plaster and cannot be a substitute for a proper plan aimed at tackling the significant problems facing the NHS. 'This is an unsustainable way of managing our health service and ministers must listen to calls for a workforce plan to meet recruitment needs.' The total bill rose from £235,881,479 in the year ending March 31, 2021, to a height of £489,997,556 in the year to March 31, 2024, before falling in 2025, according to the analysis. Of the 14 Scottish health boards, NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde - the largest in Scotland - spent the most, followed by NHS Lothian. But NHS 24 was the biggest spender of any individual service. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Scottish Labour has repeatedly highlighted the level of spend on agency nurses and locum doctors, arguing it shows the NHS is 'haemorrhaging money because of the SNP's failure to recruit and retain frontline staff'. Ten-year plan The party has said it will ensure the NHS has a ten-year workforce plan that 'creates domestic medical and nursing training places, values nurses, doctors and all NHS staff, and meets the needs of future generations of patients'. The state of the health service is expected to be a key battleground in the run-up to the Holyrood election next year. A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'NHS Scotland's overall workforce, including nursing and midwifery staffing, has increased over the last year, whilst the latest workforce statistics show a 62 per cent reduction in nurse agency usage and spend across 2024/25, decreasing for the second year in a row. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'These figures show the progress being made to reduce NHS Scotland's reliance on agency workers and focus resources on frontline services, which has enabled boards to re-invest upwards of £94 million in the delivery of those services most valued by the Scottish public.
