Prominent Muslim groups claim reaction to Sydney nurses video is ‘selective outrage'
The edited video, which was posted by Israeli influencer Max Veifer, sparked widespread condemnation, including by the prime minister, Anthony Albanese, who called the footage 'sickening and shameful'.
The video features nurse Ahmad Rashad Nadir saying he had sent Israeli patients to 'Jahannam' or hell. The woman in the video, nurse Sarah Abu Lebdeh, when asked by Veifer what she would do if an Israeli patient attended the hospital, said: 'I won't treat them, I will kill them.'
The two nurses have since been stood down and police are investigating.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
The coalition of Muslim groups said in a statement on Sunday the 'speed, intensity and uniformity of responses from certain political leaders and media outlets' was 'revealing'.
They said the same voices that condemned the nurses had 'provided active diplomatic and journalistic cover for ongoing crimes by the Zionists'.
The coalition said: 'This statement is not about defending inappropriate remarks. It is about pushing back against the double standards and moral manipulation at play while the mass killing of our brothers and sisters in Gaza is met with silence, dismissal, or complicity.'
The Muslim Vote – established in response to community anger at Labor's handling of the war in Gaza – plans to back candidates in Watson, Blaxland and Werriwa in this year's federal election.
Signatories included mainstream bodies such as the Australian Federation of Islamic Councils and the Islamic councils of Victoria and Western Australia, as well as more controversial groups such as Hizb Ut-Tahrir Australia and the Al Madina Dawah Centre in Bankstown and its founder, Wissam Haddad.
Separately, other Muslim organisations and medical professionals have condemned the nurses' remarks without reservation.
In October, the nation's peak Jewish group, the Executive Council of Australian Jewry (ECAJ), filed a case in the federal court against Haddad and the Al Madina Dawah Centre over alleged antisemitic speeches.
The ECAJ alleges the speeches made 'derogatory generalisations about the Jewish people', including calling them 'vile' and 'treacherous'.
Haddad claims in his response to the federal court filing that the speeches did not contravene the Racial Discrimination Act and they were made for purpose of 'delivering religious, historical and educational lectures or sermons, to congregants of the AMDC and other practising Muslims.'
The coalition of Muslim groups also attacked what they described as the 'weaponisation' of antisemitism, saying criticism of and 'frustrations' with Israel should not be conflated with hatred towards the Jewish community.
They said that the 'frustration and anger directed at Israel is a direct response to its violent and inhumane policies – not an expression of hatred towards Jewish people'.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
'Attempts to weaponise accusations of antisemitism to silence dissent are not only intellectually dishonest but also dangerous.'
The group said the statements made by the nurses in the video, which included alluding to killing Israelis that presented to the hospital, were 'clearly emotional and hyperbolic'.
NSW Police say investigations into the video and the two nurses are ongoing.
The former Labor senator Fatima Payman earlier claimed in an Instagram post there were 'double standards' in the reactions to the video.
She said what nurses' remarks were 'wrong'.
'No one should be ever be denied medical care based on their race, religion or nationality. There is never an excuse for that.'
However, Payman claimed there was not 'the same level of anger and vitriol when the roles are reversed'.
'When Muslims face discrimination, when Islamophobic or anti-Palestine attacks happen where is the prime minister? Where is the full scale media outrage?
'This is the double standards that must end. If we're to condemn one, we must condemn the other, otherwise we're not standing for justice, we're just picking sides.'
Payman left Labor last year over its response to the war in Gaza.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
5 hours ago
- The Guardian
Growing number of Jewish American groups speak out over Gaza famine
As global outrage intensifies over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza, a growing number of prominent Jewish American organizations, including some traditional defenders of Israel, are speaking out and imploring the country to ensure that humanitarian aid is allowed into Gaza. This week, a UN-backed food security group warned that a 'worst-case scenario of famine' is unfolding in Gaza and health authorities there report dozens of deaths from starvation. On Sunday, the American Jewish Committee, a prominent Jewish advocacy organization, released a statement affirming that it stands with Israel in what it described as 'its justified war to eliminate the threat posed by Hamas and secure the release of the remaining hostages'. At the same time, the group called for Israel to take steps to alleviate civilian suffering. 'We feel immense sorrow for the grave toll this war has taken on Palestinian civilians, and we are deeply concerned about worsening food insecurity in Gaza,' the statement read. 'We urge Israel, the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, the UN, and all responsible parties involved in aid distribution to increase cooperation and coordination in order to ensure that humanitarian aid reaches Palestinian civilians in Gaza.' The GHF is an Israel- and US-backed aid group that has attracted condemnation for the killings of hundreds of civilians seeking food at the hands of Israeli forces and private contractors. The AJC statement reflected a cautious critique of Israel's aid blockade echoed by other groups noteworthy for their typically staunch support of the country, even as their statements condemned Hamas for refusing to release the Israeli hostages it continues to hold. The Reform movement in North America, which represents the largest Jewish denomination in the US, also issued a lengthy statement: 'Neither escalating military pressure nor restricting humanitarian aid has brought Israel closer to securing a hostage deal or ending the war,' it read. 'Hamas has repeatedly demonstrated its willingness to sacrifice the Palestinian people in its pursuit of Israel's destruction, but Israel must not sacrifice its own moral standing in return. Starving Gazan civilians neither will bring Israel the 'total victory' over Hamas it seeks, nor can it be justified by Jewish values or humanitarian law.' The Rabbinical Assembly, a New York-based association of conservative rabbis, said last week that they were 'increasingly concerned about the worsening humanitarian crisis in Gaza' and called for 'urgent action to alleviate civilian suffering and ensure aid delivery'. 'Even as we believe Hamas could end this suffering immediately through the release of the hostages and care for its civilian population, the Israeli government must do everything in its power to ensure humanitarian aid reaches those in need,' it added. 'The Jewish tradition calls upon us to ensure the provision of food, water, and medical supplies as a top priority.' Jewish groups associated with the left have been prominent fixtures at protests against Israel's offensive since it began. On Tuesday, 27 rabbis and Jewish clergy affiliated with the group Jews for Food Aid for People in Gaza were arrested at a protest in the Washington office of the Senate majority leader, John Thune. But it appears clear that discomfort has significantly broadened outside the Jewish left. On Monday, eight rabbis were arrested outside the Israeli consulate in New York while protesting against the humanitarian crisis in Gaza – including clergy who had not been so outspoken before. 'The protests we've typically seen at the Israeli consulate in places like that are from the further left of the community,' Phylisa Wisdom, executive director of New York Jewish Agenda, told Gothamist. 'This represents an escalation from rabbis in this political lane.' More than 1,200 rabbis have signed a public letter calling on Israel to allow more humanitarian aid into Gaza. 'The Jewish people face a grave moral crisis, threatening the very basis of Judaism as the ethical voice that it has been since the age of Israel's prophets,' reads the letter. 'We cannot remain silent in confronting it.' The developments reflect shifting public support for Israel and the Israeli government within the US, which has accelerated as the war has gone on. A recent Gallup poll reported that support for Israel's military action in Gaza has precipitously declined among US adults, and is now at 32% – the lowest reading since Gallup first asked the question in November 2023. Support for Israel drops further among younger Americans – including US Jews. 'It's a tense time in the Jewish family group chats,' Ezra Klein wrote in a recent New York Times column. 'The consensus that held American Jewry together for generations is breaking down.' While emotional attachment to Israel is widespread among Jewish Americans, polling has consistently found that support for the state's current policies drops with age, a phenomenon perhaps best reflected in the community's support for the New York Democratic mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani, whom opponents have sought to tar with accusations of antisemitism over his vocal support for Palestinian rights. Despite those accusations, however, a recent poll found him leading with 67% of the votes of American Jewish voters in New York under the age of 44. That figure dropped to 25% of voters over 45. 'Zohran Mamdani's triumph in New York City's Democratic primary for mayor has forced, among many Jews, a reckoning with how far they have drifted from one another,' Klein wrote. Organizers of an action planned for Monday in New York City hope that groups that have not turned out before will do so to protest under the banner 'Jews Say: No More'. 'Our tradition teaches us that if we can protest [against] our people's actions and we don't, we are responsible,' said IfNotNow's executive director, Morriah Kaplan, in a statement to the Guardian. The group is helping organize Monday's action. 'As Jews and as Americans, whose government is funding this atrocity, we all must choose whether we want to bear responsibility for a policy of forced mass starvation.' The shift is also playing out within institutions whose members want their leaders to take a tougher stance on a country many had long reflexively supported. More than 200 alumni from Young Judaea, a Zionist youth group, this week called on the organization in an open letter to depart from its pro-Israel line to speak out against starvation in Gaza and call for a permanent ceasefire, including a release of the hostages. 'We see our families and friends, colleagues and teachers, rabbis and Jewish institutions – in Israel and abroad – join a growing movement to stand courageously in opposition to these policies,' the letter reads. 'Young Judaea cannot remain silent in this moment and maintain any moral credibility.'
Daily Mirror
5 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Benjamin Netanyahu under increasing pressure to accept Gaza ceasefire amid famine
Intelligence analysis reveals Israel's aid blockade and constant air attacks on Gaza have backfired, leaving Benjamin Netanyahu nearer isolation from his ally, the US Israel's PM Benjamin Netanyahu is facing rising pressure to accept a ceasefire because of the famine horror in Gaza. Intelligence analysis reveals Israel 's aid blockade and constant air attacks have backfired leaving him nearer isolation from his ally, the US. The Soufan Centre, run by Middle East expert Ali Souffan, says he 'is coming under broad pressure to wind down Israel's military involvement in Gaza' as US President Donald Trump draws back from his support because of the famine. 'Trump has not urged him to end the war,' says the independent analysis organisation's report. 'But he has broken with him on the humanitarian situation.' The report adds that Mr Trump's aides 'appear to be pressing on with efforts to forge another temporary ceasefire'. It came as a United Nations Food Security panel claimed 'the worst-case scenario of famine is playing out in the Strip'. Meanwhile there was more anguish in Gaza yesterday as hospitals reported the killing of at least 18 people by Israeli fire, eight of them food-seekers. Close to a Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) distribution site, Yahia Youssef, looking for aid, described how he helped carry out three people with gunshot wounds. He said he saw many others lying on the ground bleeding. 'It's the same daily episode,' Mr Youssef said. The GHF media office said 'nothing [happened] at or near our sites'. It came a day after US officials visited one site and the US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee called the GHF's distribution 'an incredible feat'. International outrage has mounted as the group's efforts to deliver aid to hunger-stricken Gaza have been marred by violence and controversy.
Scottish Sun
10 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Hamas vows to never lay guns down unless demand is met as thugs share sick clip of hostage ‘forced to dig his own grave'
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) HAMAS says it will never lay guns down unless an independent Palestinian state is established and its capital is Jerusalem. It comes as the militant group - declared a terrorist organisation by the UK and the US - released a sick video showing an emaciated Israeli hostage in a tunnel. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 5 Hamas fighters stand in formation ahead of a hostages' release in Khan Younis, Gaza Strip in February Credit: AP 5 The distressing video shows an emaciated Evyatar holding a shovel and saying this is where he thinks he'll be buried 5 Palestinians wait to receive food from a charity kitchen amid a hunger crisis in Gaza on Saturday Credit: Shutterstock Editorial The militant group said it was giving a statement "in response to media reports quoting US envoy Steve Witkoff, claiming [Hamas] has shown willingness to disarm". It said: "We reaffirm that resistance and its arms are a legitimate national and legal right as long as the occupation continues. "This right is recognised by international laws and norms, and it cannot be relinquished except through the full restoration of our national rights - first and foremost, the establishment of an independent, fully sovereign Palestinian state with Jerusalem as its capital." Hamas also released a video showing an Israeli man - Evyatar David - being held hostage in what looks like a tunnel. Evyatar, 24, was kidnapped from the Nova Music Festival on October 7. The distressing video shows him telling the camera that he is digging his own grave. His family have given permission for media outlets to show the video. It comes as at least 51 people - including 27 aid workers - have been killed so far on Saturday in Israeli attacks across Gaza. Over 60,000 Palestinians have been killed in the devastating war on Gaza amid a deepening hunger crisis - coupled with Israel's cruel blockage of aid delivery. Last week, indirect talks between Hamas and Israel ended in deadlock, stalling efforts to secure a 60-day ceasefire in Gaza and a deal for the release of hostages. Starmer vows UK will recognise Palestine in weeks unless Israel ends crisis – but critics blast 'reward' for Hamas Hamas has dominated Gaza since 2007, but has been militarily weakened by Israel in the war. Israel considers the disarmament of Hamas a key condition for a deal to end the war. But Hamas has repeatedly said it will not lay down its guns. Last month, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said a future independent Palestinian state would be a platform to destroy Israel. For this reason, Netanyahu added, Israel must have security control over Palestinian territories. He also criticised the UK and Canada, among other countries, for their plans to recognise a Palestinian state. The war began when Hamas militants stormed into southern Israel on October 7, 2023, killing 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages back to Gaza. 5 A Hamas fighter next to displaced Palestinians in January Credit: AP 5 A plane drops humanitarian aid in Gaza on Saturday Credit: Getty More to follow... For the latest news on this story, keep checking back at The U.S. Sun, your go-to destination for the best celebrity news, sports news, real-life stories, jaw-dropping pictures, and must-see videos. Like us on Facebook at TheSunUS and follow us on X at @TheUSSun
