13MP review crucial to avoid policy pitfalls, say economists
KUALA LUMPUR: Finance Minister II Datuk Seri Amir Hamzah's main duty of finalising the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) will improve policy coordination between the Finance Ministry and the Economy Ministry, say economists.
Economist Professor Geoffrey Williams said it is essential for the 13MP to be a robust framework and, as such, it should undergo a comprehensive final review.
He said that increased external and independent scrutiny of the process would enhance the quality of the final document.
"Although there are no details on the exact content, it is important that each proposal is evaluated by independent experts to ensure there are no unintended consequences or obvious issues that need to be addressed.
"There is only a short time for the final review, but it is worth undertaking this exercise to avoid the risk of presenting a document that may attract criticism from the outset," he said.
He said the move would improve policy coordination between the Finance Ministry and the Economy Ministry, and also help in understanding the long-term financial implications and funding strategies.
Yesterday, Chief Secretary to the Government Tan Sri Shamsul Azhar Abbas announced that Amir Hamzah would assume the duties and functions of the Economy Minister with immediate effect.
He said Amir Hamzah's primary responsibility is to revise and reformulate the contents of the 13MP document, which will be tabled in parliament on July 31.
The portfolio became vacant after Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli resigned from the post on May 28, following his defeat in the PKR central leadership election, where he failed to retain the party's deputy president post.
However, Rafizi, in a statement, expressed concern over the move to revise and reformulate the document, warning that a last-minute decision could undermine public confidence in the national policy document.
Meanwhile, Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid said the review could improve policy coordination, as there would be greater connectivity between the Finance Ministry and the Economy Ministry.
"I'm sure the 13MP will reflect budget constraints and aim for a higher multiplier effect on growth, while at the same time remaining disciplined in managing government finances," he said.
He said Amir Hamzah, as a technocrat, would take a pragmatic approach to reviewing the document.
"In addition, the plans are being prepared by government machinery that is highly competent, so I suppose the changes would take into consideration the country's long-term growth interests," he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Fahmi: Final draft of 13th Malaysia Plan not rushed, backed by weeks of ministry input
KUALA LUMPUR, June 28 — The final draft of the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP) was not hastily prepared but has undergone weeks of inter-ministerial consultation and review, Datuk Fahmi Fadzil said today. According to Utusan Malaysia, the official spokesman for the unity government said the process of revising and coordinating the draft of the 13th Malaysia Plan began two weeks ago, following an instruction from Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. He added ministries were directed to study the preliminary draft submitted by the Ministry of Economy. 'The prime minister instructed all ministries to review the 13MP draft presented by the secretary-general of the Economy Ministry about two weeks ago, on a Wednesday. 'Subsequently, by the following Friday, all ministries were asked to submit written feedback to the Economy Ministry,' Fahmi reportedly said today. He was speaking to reporters after launching the Nadi Aspirasi Nasional Bersama Anak Muda (Nanba) programme organised by the Community Communications Department (J-KOM) at IWK Eco Park @ Pantai Dalam today. Fahmi, who also serves as minister of communications, said a special Cabinet session was convened early last week to consider the input from various ministries before the plan was finalised at Wednesday's full Cabinet meeting. He said the discussions yielded a range of proposals and adjustments that had to be incorporated into the final document. 'These included requests and adjustments from several ministries that required further consideration by the Economy Ministry. 'As such, the Cabinet agreed for Second Finance Minister Datuk Seri Amir Hamzah to take over the responsibilities and functions of the economy minister in finalising the 13MP draft before it is printed and tabled in Parliament,' Fahmi added. Rafizi, who resigned earlier this month, criticised the last-minute revisions yesterday, warning that rushing the process could undermine the credibility of national policy.
Free Malaysia Today
2 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Expediting reforms will make tax hikes easier to swallow, govt told
World Bank's lead economist for Malaysia, Apurva Sanghi, said reducing spending would not be easy as most of it involved 'rigid' costs such as wages, pensions and debt service. PETALING JAYA : The World Bank's lead economist for Malaysia, Apurva Sanghi, says expediting reforms – such as enacting a government procurement law – will make the public less hostile towards tax hikes. In a post on X on the expansion of the sales and service tax, Apurva pointed out that the auditor-general regularly uncovered losses in public funds, irregular payments and wastages across various ministries. While some reforms have been carried out, a specific law to oversee government procurement has been delayed, he said. Apurva said reforms would build public trust, which in turn would make it 'easier to swallow bitter tax hikes'. 'Tax hikes are painful but people can bear them, if they're meaningful. 'This means faster progress, especially on governance reforms and that would increase trust.' Apurva said trust was the ultimate currency for any government. On comparisons made between the SST and the goods and services tax, Apurva said that while both were regressive, it could be made progressive via targeted cash transfers and exemptions. 'The current SST expansion does include progressive elements.' On June 9, the finance ministry announced that a 5% to 10% rate would be imposed on non-essential goods from July 1, although basic necessities would not be taxed. The announcement has triggered brickbats. Apurva also responded to those questioning the government's decision to raise taxes instead of reducing spending. He said while it was a fair question, the country needed to spend more, which meant it needed to raise more revenue. The finance ministry previously said that the SST collection is expected to increase by RM5 billion in 2025 and by RM10 billion in 2026, following the expansion of its scope. Apurva noted that both revenue and spending had dropped by 30% since 2012, which was well below those of global peers. 'Spending needs are only growing, especially as Malaysia ages,' he said, adding that reducing spending would not be easy as most of it involved 'rigid' costs such as wages, pensions and debt service which accounted for 57% of operation expenditure.
The Sun
3 hours ago
- The Sun
Move to strengthen TVET enrolment, future workforce
PETALING JAYA: The Government-Industry TVET Coordination Body (GITC) has outlined key priorities for the next two to three years as part of its mission to strengthen Malaysia's Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET) ecosystem and future-proof the workforce. Its chairman Tan Sri Soh Thian Lai said while Malaysia currently records between 250,000 and 300,000 new TVET admissions annually across both public and private higher learning institutions, efforts are under way to boost these numbers further. 'This includes better coordination, more industry sponsorship and stronger job outcomes to attract more students into TVET. 'GITC is focused on aligning TVET programmes with industry needs by co-designing courses and expanding hands-on training through Work-Based Learning and the Dual Training Model nationwide,' he added. Soh said GITC is working with employers and professional bodies to promote skills-based hiring and industry-recognised certifications, ensuring that individuals are recognised for their skills, not just academic results. 'To support job opportunities abroad, GITC is also collaborating with Asean partners and global accreditation bodies to ensure Malaysian TVET graduates can have their skills recognised regionally.' He said digital and emerging technologies are also being integrated into TVET programmes, including artificial intelligence (AI), green tech, electric vehicles and data centre skills, through Centres of Excellence and industry partnerships. Soh said in addressing Malaysia's most critical skills gaps, GITC is prioritising areas such as digital and automation skills particularly in AI, robotics, data analytics and smart manufacturing. He also said Malaysia urgently needs talent in data centres, cloud services and skilled technicians for high-tech sectors such as semiconductors, aerospace, precision tooling and medical devices. 'Soft skills such as communication, critical thinking and adaptability are equally important as these are essential for producing industry-ready graduates who can thrive in an increasingly fast-paced and competitive job market.' Universiti Teknologi Mara Civil Engineering Faculty senior lecturer Dr Nuryantizpura Mohamad Rais said TVET is expected to become a key driver of Malaysia's talent development agenda over the next decade, especially as the country embraces advancements in automation, sustainable infrastructure and transport technology. Nuryantizpura, who is also serving as an industry adviser in railway infrastructure and renewable transport, said Malaysia will require a workforce that is not only technically skilled but also adaptable and aligned with industry needs. 'TVET institutions will be instrumental in preparing professionals to meet these demands whether it's operating hydrogen-powered rail systems or supporting large-scale infrastructure initiatives under public-private partnerships. 'Malaysia's progress will rely not only on academic excellence, but on the strength of a skilled, hands-on workforce capable of building, maintaining and innovating. That is the future TVET is preparing us for.' She said while academic degrees remain a preferred choice among many students and families, there has been a slow but steady shift in attitudes as more students are now opting for TVET pathways, particularly in technical and industry-driven sectors. 'TVET is no longer a dead-end track, as graduates today can transition to diploma and degree programmes through structured pathways, especially under the Malaysian Qualifications Framework.' She added that Accreditation of Prior Experiential Learning and micro-credentials support flexible, continuous learning that enables TVET graduates to pursue higher qualifications without leaving the workforce. 'Fresh TVET graduates typically earn between RM1,800 and RM2,500 a month, with higher pay in sectors like transport, energy, and engineering especially for those with industry-recognised skills or hands-on experience,' she said.
