Playmakers are now a protected species. It's making rugby league boring
It's been on two fronts, especially. Halves and playmakers getting smashed in the back after they've passed, and kick chasers diving at the legs of a player when they kick long.
Now I think we've gone too far. In 2025, halfbacks can now play the game wearing a koala suit – they've officially become a protected species.
Rugby league is built on the contest and competing as hard as you can. We can't take that out of the game just because that is naturally going to lead to some accidents.
Kicking games have never been more important, but under the current rules, all the advantage is with a playmaker and an attacking kicker, to the point that there is no longer a reward for a good defensive set.
Think about a good defensive set from 10 or 20 years ago. If a defensive team were on top, you would see a kicker having to sit 10-15 metres behind the advantage line, or even having to run sideways to get their kick away. That was the reward.
Under the current rules, kickers are happy to sit up closer to the defensive line and hammer a long kick because they know defenders can't touch them.
Mitchell Moses played out of his skin in Origin II last year, but we saw exactly this early in the game. A solid Queensland defensive set had them win each play-the-ball, and Moses was kicking from his own 40-metre line.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘Absolute disgrace': NRL icon owed an apology amid unthinkable success
Ricky Stuart has bagged refs, snarled at journalists and angrily thrown plastic bottles in to the bleachers - and it's time we all returned him some gratitude and an apology. The Raiders coach often finds himself public enemy number one, but his achievements in 2025 are a reminder this prickly pear is also an ingenious mentor who can produce a mean footy team. And while it may not be obvious to us outsiders, it also highlights his massive contribution to the game, and we're not talking about all the new NRL offices he funds with breach fines. Despite beginning the season as friendless outsiders, Stuart has transformed a Raiders side that was wooden spoon favourites in to bona fide premiership frontrunners. And while Cameron Ciraldo has done a bang-up job at Canterbury and Kristian Woolf has worked wonders creating a Dolphins team that can score from the carpark, all signs point to one thing: If Stuart's titanic deed doesn't win him the Coach of the Year award, then it would be an absolute disgrace. As we know, everyone involved in rugby league has at some point been offended by the Canberra legend, Canberra fans included. Whether slagging off opposition players, sacking blokes by overhead projector or merely picking Jamie Buhrer for NSW, chances are Sticky's done something to get up your nose. But if you look past his tightly-wound exterior and repeated sideline loogies, you'll see a passionate man manager with a deep love for his players who has worked outrageous juju. For a modestly financed club that doesn't swing its manhood around on the player market, any winning Raiders season should be considered a fine accomplishment. But in orchestrating Canberra's unlikely title drive, Stuart has cracked one of rugby league's toughest riddles by somehow syncing every player in his squad to deliver personal best form all at the same time. And by inspiring this unheralded bunch in to pole position, he's in touching distance of an iconic moment in Canberra's modern history to rival the 2019 Grand Final and that photo of Terry Campese bathing in milk. The Raiders usually struggle to convince anyone of the benefits of Burley Griffin over Bondi, but Stuart has flipped the script by nurturing a team of self-made stars that have no reservations living in a city that requires a wardrobe of 75% Gore-Tex. In addition to the steady hand of Jamal Fogarty, the emergence of Ethan Strange and an electric back five lead by Kaeo Weekes, this Raiders side is anchored by a Stuart calling card: A motherload of girthy grumpy street-smart forwards. Lead by brute bookends in Joe Tapine and Josh Papali'i, this is a pack that has voraciously played like they'd crash through their own mother just to get a quick play-the-ball. And to be fair, we should've known in pre-season they were primed for a scrap when Morgan Smithies and Hudson Young were caught in a Vegas elevator brawling over an inflatable baseball bat. In basic terms, they're all competitive, cranky and a little bit crackers, ie an extension of their coach. And this is where Stuart's secret ingredient lies. For a bloke who'd hold a grudge against Gandhi, he has so much love for his players that the infamous 'weak gutted dog' sledge at Jaeman Salmon that shocked the footy fraternity in 2022 was actually conveyed by his players as a big warm cuddle, albeit one that cost $25,000. As such, many may consider Stuart's finest work to be in the nuts and bolts of coaching, but his proudest achievements arguably come in being a patch-protective father figure full of love and care, even if he shows it by kicking plastic chairs down the sideline.
The Australian
8 hours ago
- The Australian
Panthers coach Cleary warns rivals of more improvement to come
Penrith coach Ivan Cleary is saying all the things that should create a little bit of fear among the NRL frontrunners as his team looks to make it eight wins straight against the Titans on Saturday. The four-time reigning premiers are still 'hunting' after their shock slow start, can still 'get a lot better' and have several dominant seasons worth of late-season success driving a growing confidence they can contend for five. Having spent time on the bottom of the NRL ladder in 2025, Cleary and his men know the job remains ahead of them to just stay in the top eight, with matches against top-four teams the Storm, Raiders and Bulldogs in the run to the finals. Panthers coach Ivan Cleary says his in-form team can still play better. Picture: Tom Parrish But what Cleary has seen in recent weeks, and past years, as well as what his players have done, has given him confidence about what's to come for his side that sits just outside the top four. 'Even over the last seven weeks our performances have continued to grow and I feel like there's more in us,' he said on Thursday. 'We've come through the Origin period where you team is just not together, sometimes they play, but they don't train throughout the week, so in terms cohesion and connection, I definitely think we can get better. It's exciting times for us.' Cleary said there was 'definitely' a confidence that came with previous achievements, if only as a reminder to his players what they were capable of when they put the work in. 'We've got confidence from the past in terms of the core of our team have produced in big games over many years,' he said. The Panthers are surging again. Picture:'But also this team, new circumstances, and it has grown in confidence over the last couple of months. 'If we can connect all of that together, it gives us a lot of belief we continue to work hard on the fundamentals. We have got a lot of belief that will hold up when it counts.' But Cleary also knows his team needs to maintain the desire that has propelled them back to this point. 'We have come from the bottom and we are still in the bottom of the eight. We feel like we are still hunting,' he said. 'I'm honestly not really worrying about the ladder. We are worrying about the Titans. 'We will finish where we deserve. If that's in the eight, then a new competition begins.'
The Australian
8 hours ago
- The Australian
Melbourne Storm defeat Parramatta Eels 16-10
The Storm have passed their first test without injured halfback Jahrome Hughes, but it wasn't the sort of performance that will strike fear into their premiership rivals after they survived an off night with the boot from Ryan Papenhuyzen to edge the Eels. The 16-10 win moves Melbourne into second spot for now but there are still major questions over their attack with Storm fans hoping to see their re-signed playmaker back in time for the finals. Cameron Munster set up the first try of the night with a perfect kick for Eli Katoa and then set up the high-flying Xavier Coates for the winner with another kick that saw the winger sail over Zac Lomax to cross with 11 minutes to go. But they clearly missed the reigning Dally M Medal winner on the right edge, with Tyran Wishart not having much of an impact. Jonah Pezet came on with 12 minutes to go and could be an option given he's a traditional halfback which would allow Wishart to go back to the bench and carve up against tiring forwards. While the attack wasn't at its clinical best, Craig Bellamy would have been thrilled with Stefano Utoikamanu who had his best game for the club, with the recruit busting four tackles in a crucial run a couple of plays before Coates scored the winner. BLUE AND GOLD STANDARD Honourable losses late in the season don't often mean much, but it's a slightly different story for the Eels who have come a long way in 2025 under new coach Jason Ryles. While finals are out of the question, you only have to go back to their round one loss in Melbourne to see how far they've come under the rookie coach who has made sweeping changes to the team that will help them in the long run. The Storm put 56 points on them in round one but struggled to break them down in greasy conditions, with Parramatta's defence backing up their effort against Brisbane last week. Their attack wasn't as crisp as we've seen this year but the past couple of weeks will give Ryles the confidence that his side has the temperament and the game plan to match it with the top teams. RYAN WHERE? Ryan Papenhuyzen celebrated his return from a calf injury with a couple of threatening early carries, but it wasn't a happy comeback for the man who has been linked with a move to a rival code. In his first game in a month, the Storm fullback missed three shots at goal, including a conversion attempt from next to the posts that struck both uprights. He sprayed a long-range penalty goal and then missed another shot that would have given them the lead late on, with Nick Meaney replacing him to slot a tricky conversion to give them a crucial six-point lead. GUESSING GAME Only Charlie Guymer will know if he got the ball down for Parramatta's second try, because fans are none the wiser despite 20 replays which showed us nothing. Guymer threw a pass that was knocked down by Coates and brilliantly regathered to score what looked like a try which was awarded by the referee. The Bunker spent a couple of minutes looking at a stack of angles that never showed the ball on the ground, but the on-field decision was supported and thankfully didn't decide the game. NRL Superstar prop Payne Haas could be a shock withdrawal for the Broncos' clash with the Rabbitohs after being struck down by illness, in what could be a double blow for the side after the loss of another forward. NRL Amid claims of declining standards after their fourth-straight loss to start the year, players and staff at the Raiders have come together for an honesty session in a bid to address their issues and save their NRLW season.
