Huge update in the fight to keep one of Wales' top restaurant open
Paternoster Farm in Pembrokeshire has been facing eviction despite becoming a destination restaurant and being considered as one of Wales' best
Paternoster Farm, a critically acclaimed restaurant based in the village of Hundleton, announced on Instagram yesterday that its tenancy has been extended until August 2027 .
(Image: Paternoster Farm )
A top Welsh restaurant facing eviction has secured a temporary reprieve following months of public pressure and calls for transparency from Pembrokeshire County Council. Paternoster Farm, a critically acclaimed restaurant based in the village of Hundleton, announced on Instagram yesterday that its tenancy has been extended until August 2027 after what it described as 'productive discussions' with the council's chief executive.
The announcement follows a dispute over the council's decision not to renew the restaurant's lease, which sparked a groundswell of public support from locals and patrons.
Founded by former lawyer Michelle Evans, Paternoster Farm opened in 2021 and quickly gained national recognition. It earned praise from The Good Food Guide and The Times for its seasonal, locally sourced menu and unique setting in a converted milking parlour. The restaurant employs 12 staff and works closely with regional producers.
But in May 2025, Evans revealed that the business was facing closure after learning that Pembrokeshire County Council had offered the tenancy to another party, despite her belief that the lease was eligible for renewal.
However, in a significant development, Michelle announced on Instagram yesterday [July 7] that the family's tenancy has been extended until August 2027, following 'productive discussions' with Pembrokeshire County Council's Chief Executive, Will Bramble.
Content cannot be displayed without consent
Article continues below
'We are pleased to tell you we have had some productive discussions with Will Bramble, Chief Executive of Pembrokeshire County Council, and our current tenancy has now been extended until August 2027,' she wrote. 'This is a great start but we would, of course, like to stay longer, so still have a long way to go.'
Since receiving the initial news about the tenancy back in May, Michelle and her family have been desperately seeking answers from the local authority. They have documented their fight on social media, providing updates on a petition to the council and the overwhelming support from patrons and locals.
The founder of an award-winning restaurant in Pembrokeshire has said she is "mentally exhausted" after she received news that it would have to close later this year.
(Image: Paternoster Farm )
The mother-of-two has expressed frustration at the council's handling of the situation, claiming they haven't provided her answers on why the business's future was abruptly cut short and offered to another party without consultation.
"It's been mentally exhausting," Michelle told Wales Online last month. "When I already had a full life anyway – the farm work, the restaurant, admin, and kids – this happens.
"I'm constantly writing something. I'm doing FOI (freedom of information request), then another FOI, and then another FOI. It takes a lot out of you. I'm just exhausted by it all."
The family has been at Paternoster Farm since 2016, when Michelle and her husband decided to take over the small holding's tenancy for 10 years.
Former lawyer-turned-chef Michelle started her foodie journey with a beach hut that served street food before deciding to start a business in the farm's former milking parlour. She uses fresh produce and focuses on traditional Welsh cooking infused with Mediterranean flavours. For the latest restaurant news and reviews, sign up to our food and drink newsletter here
Times Journalist and restaurant critic Charlotte Ivers visited Paternoster Farm earlier this year and praised its culinary offerings
(Image: Paternoster Farm )
In a Wales Online review, our writer notes, "When you work this close to the very produce you put on a plate, there comes a deep and meaningful understanding evident in the way Michelle cooks and her food sings on the plates. It's a real treat to eat food cooked with so much respect."
Times Journalist and restaurant critic Charlotte Ivers was equally impressed and visited Paternoster Farm earlier this year and praised its culinary offerings.
In her review, Ivers enthuses, "There's a fine balance between countryside authenticity and fashionable cooking. It works extremely well."
Ivers describes the crumbling beef brisket as "hearty and rural yet elegant and cosmopolitan: the product of a big-city lawyer transplanted to the rolling fields."
In the same week as the Times' review, the restaurant learned that Pembrokeshire Council was not going to renew its tenancy.
The family said the council had already offered the tenancy at Paternoster to another party, even though they believed their lease was eligible for renewal.
In response, Pembrokeshire County Council said its proposals follow established policy, which aims to give new entrants smaller farms so they can gain experience before moving on to larger holdings and that tenancies are "not for life."
The family has been offered a larger farm in Solva, but Michelle claims that such a move would disrupt their business, livelihoods, and children's education.
"It's a terrible time for restaurants as it is but the cost of moving a restaurant and establishing somewhere else, as well as the cost of being closed for that time, will be huge."
During the Covid-19 lockdowns, Michelle initially opened a farm shop selling home-reared meat and pastries, which then evolved into a restaurant
(Image: Paternoster Farm )
Michelle says she has tried to get an answer on the council's decision not to renew their lease and has sent a request for records, including emails, reports, minutes, and transcripts of all meetings regarding the decision not to renew the lease.
However, at the time the local authority said it had searched its records and did not hold the information requested. Undeterred, Michelle spearheaded a petition calling for a full review and debate of Pembrokeshire's 'not fit for purpose' county farm policy.
The petition has attracted nearly 2,000 signatures, prompting councillors to schedule it for debate at a future meeting, still leaving the farm's future uncertain.
While the extension brings temporary relief, Michelle made clear that the family's fight continues, not just for their own business, but for wider reform of the council's farm tenancy system.
In her post, she urged supporters to attend a public meeting at County Hall in Haverfordwest on Thursday, July 17, when councillors will formally debate the petition.
'Just to be clear, our petition is not technically about whether our tenancy will be renewed,' she writes.
'Our petition challenges County Farm Policy and seeks that it be reviewed, on the basis it allows no flexibility to support farm businesses such as ours. If successful... it not only helps us in the longer term, but other new entrants, and the community as a whole.'
Michelle also thanked the community for its continued encouragement. 'I'd like to take this opportunity to say a massive thank you for everyone's ongoing support and kind words, over these last couple of months. It's given our morale such a boost.'
Article continues below
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
42 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Welsh drivers ahead of curve on electric vehicles
The national average was 31 per cent. And by 2035, 44 per cent of the country's drivers envisage themselves driving a BEV or PHEV. Of those who do want to plug in, more Welsh drivers want to go fully electric (28 per cent) than drive a plug-in hybrid (16 per cent). The survey was by CTEK of more than 1,000 UK drivers by Find Out Now. CTEK deals in battery chargers. Daniel Forsberg, marketing manager EVSE at the EV chargepoint manufacturer CTEK, said: 'Welsh drivers look set to be in the fast lane for switching both in five years' time and a decade from now. 'The Welsh Government and the local councils can do more to entice drivers to move from petrol or diesel to electricity, including by massively expanding the availability of public charging so ICE drivers feel confident that if they do switch to an EV they can charge easily and conveniently.'
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
Application for lawful development of HMO in Fields Road
The planning application was submitted by Mr Fernando Enrique Mendoza Contreras on June 6 this year for a lawful development certificate for a long-standing HMO at 4 Fields Road in Newport. The application seeks legal recognition of the property's use as a C4-class HMO. Mr Mendoza Contreras said the property has operated as a HMO since at least October 12, 2013. This is before the introduction of Class C4 under Welsh planning regulations in 2015 and well before Mr Mendoza Contreras acquired the property in 2018. The applicant said the property is run responsibly, with shared facilities and private rooms for tenants. Weekly safety inspections are carried out by an estate agent, and the property complies fully with housing and safety regulations. Mr Mendoza Contreras said: "The HMO plays a crucial role in providing affordable housing for students, young professionals, and individuals referred by local authorities." "No complaints have been received from neighbours since 2018. "We manage tenancy agreements properly, maintain strong community relations, and support tenants in achieving their personal goals." The application was prompted by a mortgage lender's request for planning documentation. Upon consultation with local authority representatives, Mr Mendoza Contreras was advised to apply for a lawful development certificate to clarify the legal use of the property. In support of the application, the applicant has submitted a copy of his Rent Smart Wales landlord licence which was granted on June 19, 2018, and was valid until June 18, 2023, with the property now under the care of an estate agent. The licence confirms his compliance with the Housing (Wales) Act 2014 and adherence to the national Code of Practice. No objections have been reported as part of the application to date. A decision from Newport City Council is pending.
Wales Online
2 hours ago
- Wales Online
I dropped out of university – my business turns over £6m a year
I dropped out of university – my business turns over £6m a year 'I make more in one hour on TikTok Shop than during a day in my physical store' Laura Mallows started off as a history student but now she is the founder of a multi-million-pound company (Image: Matthew Horwood ) Before her skincare brand became a TikTok sensation and hit the shelves of Boots and Superdrug Laura Mallows was just a girl from Cowbridge trying to figure out what to do with her life. "I was a fashion girly – I have done so many pivots in my life," Laura laughs, reflecting on her unconventional path. It is a winding journey that took her from a university dropout to founder of Mallows Beauty – one of the UK's fastest-growing self-care brands. If you've spent any time scrolling TikTok in the past couple of years chances are you've come across Mallows Beauty. Now turning over millions Mallows is instantly recognisable with its playful packaging, intriguing product names, and unapologetic commitment to self-love with its various body products. Yet behind the bright aesthetic is a story far from the glitz and glamour of a thriving entrepreneur but of self-doubt and starting over more than once. The Welsh entrepreneur has seen rapid expansion with her brand which has gone from her kitchen table to the shelves of Boots (Image: Mallows Beauty ) Speaking to WalesOnline from her bubble-gum pink office Laura claims she very nearly went down a different route. "When I was in school I was really good at history," she recalls. "My school encouraged me to go to Oxbridge to do it but I actually ended up picking Southampton because the nightlife was better." Article continues below However Laura quickly came to the realisation that this wasn't what she wanted to do with her life. "Three months into my history degree I was like: 'I don't like this'. I was falling asleep in my lectures. "There was a boy in my class and I told him: 'I'm going to have to copy your notes'. He just said: 'You're not listening in your lectures – you're snoring. This is bad – you need to stop.' "After that I just decided to drop out. I rang my mum and dad and was like: 'I'm not enjoying it.' They asked me what I wanted to do and I said: 'Fashion. I love fashion.'" Laura then switched to a fashion design degree and finally felt like she had found her place. After university she went on to land a job in London's Dune branch buying handbags and accessories. During this time, though, Laura was battling some internal demons. "I have always struggled with my body image," Laura admits. "From a young age I always wanted to be perfect. I struggled with eating disorders, yo-yo'ed in weight and was always trying to fix myself." Not long after her big city move she developed a case of acne, which only served to enhance her self-doubt. Read the biggest stories in Wales first by signing up to our daily newsletter here . "Every single product that I bought didn't work and every single counter I went to sold this dream," Laura says. "I just kept looking to these models and campaigns and thinking: 'Why don't I look like them? Why is my skin so bad? Why do I have such big pores?' I have suffered with anxiety for most of my life and had no idea why I felt the way I felt or what it even was." Her mental health hit a breaking point prompting Laura to have a complete breakdown. "It was really difficult but I came to realise that that wasn't real. That the girls in the pictures didn't actually look like that – they were airbrushed and filtered." The realisation sparked a question: what if there was a brand that embraced perfect imperfections? Laura says: "I started to think about how cool would it be if there was a brand that was showing spots and showing what real skin looked like – cellulite and stretch marks – so that people could look at their own stretch marks and breathe a sigh of relief." Laura wanted to make a brand everyone could see themselves in This thought stuck with her when she decided to move back to Wales. Laura briefly took on a job as a skincare buyer in Port Talbot. This lasted for just 20 days before she decided to quit with the dream of a genuine self-loving product still very much at the forefront of her mind. "There were so many influencers at the time doing that body-positive self-love thing but there was no brand doing it," she says. "That's when I decided I'd be the one to start it." Armed with little more than a homemade scrub recipe and her parents' credit card she started Mallows Beauty at her kitchen table in her former Llantrisant home. "Very naively might I add," she admits. In August 2020 she released her first product, a pineapple mask, and quickly orders started rolling in from big names like Skinny Dip and Harrods. Mallows can now be found across major retailers across the UK (Image: Mallows Beauty ) As the brand expanded Laura introduced a wider range of products including body butter, scrubs, and shaving butters sold both through her Cardiff flagship store and online via TikTok. A major turning point came in 2023 when Mallows Beauty won Superdrug's Marketplace of the Year award. "I remember it was at the top of the Gherkin. Around that time our TikTok Shop just boomed. At first it was steady but when affiliates really started working, and with the ads function, everything just exploded." Sales leapt from £50,000 a month to around £300,000. "Suddenly we were in 700 Superdrug stores. It just felt like we were going viral, viral, viral non-stop. It felt like magic. That was kind of my year I suppose." Mallows gained a cult following since going viral on TikTok with its brightly-packaged pink products (Image: Mallows Beauty ) When she realised she was making more in one hour on TikTok Shop than in a full day at her Cardiff store she shifted her entire strategy and closed the physical location to focus solely on her digital audience. It was a risk but it paid off. Five years later, at 33 years old, Laura has built a multi-million-pound brand with a fiercely loyal following. On Black Friday in 2024 alone she made £450,000. In the past two years Mallows Beauty has turned over about £6m (including VAT) and is now stocked at major retailers like Boots and Superdrug with a launch set for Morrisons in two weeks time. Online, though, remains a boom trade. "It has connected me with people from all over the UK and I'm expanding," says Laura. "I'm so lucky to have built such a supportive community online." To meet soaring demand the company initially employed 22 people but Laura has since streamlined the workforce to 15. "It was a lot to manage and there was crossover in roles," she explains. "Now it feels right. We're smaller, tighter – a real family. Everyone here cares about the brand. At some point they've all struggled with body image or mental health. They believe in me and the journey, which is beautiful." That shared passion has helped the team develop and launch a wide range of successful products – all rooted in Laura's personal experiences and instincts. "I just do what feels right to me," she says. "For example I wanted to make our pineapple facemasks because I wanted my skin to be glowing to help my blemishes and my scarring at the time. I was obsessed with pineapple enzymes – vitamin C, vitamin A." The Cardiff-based beauty brand has become well known for its quirky packaging and eclectic fragrances (Image: Mallows Beauty ) Her curiosity extended beyond the UK market too. "I saw shaving butters trending in the US and I thought: 'That's a really cool product – can I make it?' The US made them brightly coloured and smell incredible so it really aligned with our brand. So we made them but when I was using it I was using other branded razors so then I thought: 'We need our own.'" The result? A sell-out product. "I think we sold a razor every minute until we sold out of 10,000 units. It was nuts," says Laura. Today the brand has evolved to include everything from hair removal products to accessories like their increasingly popular makeup bags. And it's not just Laura leading the change – Mallows' customers have become co-creators in the brand's development. "Our shave butters are now customer-led," Laura says. "We ask our followers what fragrance they'd like to have next – what sort of product that they would like to see. This year everyone was obsessed with vanilla and they loved ice cream so things like ice cream flavours and banana splits became a priority." Some of the most successful ideas have come from Mallows' community. "Pool Side did incredibly well... I never expected it to do as well as it did. Same with banana, I didn't really think much of it but now I have all banana-fragranced products in my bathroom. We make sure to ask on our Tiktok Lives and make sure we take notes." The brand has taught Laura a lot about 'self-love' and body positivity, which she hopes to share with customers (Image: Mallows Beauty ) Social media, especially TikTok, has been instrumental in building that connection – not just for marketing but for cultivating a brand that feels real. "TikTok and Mallows go hand in hand – it kind of feels like if there wasn't a TikTok there wouldn't be a Mallows. "The massive spikes of success on TikTok come from showing the ins and outs of running the business – the good days and the bad days," she says. The tough days are all a part of the journey, which is what Laura wishes she could tell her younger self. "I'd love to go back and hold my own hand or give myself a hug. Tell myself that it's going to be okay. That I should enjoy the good moments more. "Managing a team, worrying about profits, keeping the lights on... I was always so terrified. I don't think I fully enjoyed the magical moments. That's the advice I'd give myself now: enjoy the journey a bit more. Really soak in the highs." In light of this Laura has clear advice for aspiring entrepreneurs. "If I was an entrepreneur starting out I would be just storytelling as transparently as I can. I saw an amazing new brand the other day and they were talking about their launch, visiting suppliers, how they've held events and no-one has turned up... I think that's the beauty of social media – it's that honest transparency that everyone loves to see and relate to. "It's hard to be that open – it's nerve-wracking. Especially as your brand grows you want people to believe you're doing great. But the community-building is so important – you'll find even in the bad days your fanbase will stick by you. Everyone really pulls together." Mallows is a testament to that having recently ticked off another major milestone with the brand's products now set for supermarket shelves. "Morrisons is a massive thing for me – I said that at the end of this year I wanted to see our product in a supermarket so it's surreal," says Laura. Article continues below From viral scrubs to supermarket aisles Mallows continues to grow not just as a brand but as a movement grounded in authenticity, self-love, and a whole lot of pineapple.
