‘Over Rs 1 lakh a month': Reddit post on maid's income triggers debate on India's middle class
A closer look at the numbers
According to the Reddit post, the domestic worker earns Rs 30,000 per month by working full-time across three households. Her husband, a daily wage laborer, earns Rs 35,000, while their eldest son makes Rs 30,000 per month at a saree shop. Their daughter, currently learning tailoring, earns Rs 3,000 but is expected to bring in Rs 15,000–Rs 20,000 monthly once she completes her training. The youngest son is learning plumbing and is expected to earn Rs 15,000–Rs 25,000 per month.
Together, the family currently earns Rs 98,000 each month. In a few months, their monthly income is projected to touch Rs 1.3–1.35 lakh. None of this income is taxed.
Government support adds to household income
The family also receives support through government schemes. They get free rations, pay only Rs 6,000 per month in rent, and own a rural house under a central housing scheme. Additionally, they expect to earn another Rs 30,000–Rs 40,000 every quarter by leasing out inherited land.
Salaried taxpayer questions class definitions
'I'm genuinely happy for her,' the Redditor wrote. 'She's worked hard all her life. But it does make you wonder, who really belongs to the
middle class
now?'
Live Events
The statement sparked a wide-ranging conversation online, especially among professionals earning fixed monthly salaries and paying income taxes. Many users pointed out the widening gap between formal and informal income, with some informal workers now earning more than white-collar professionals.
The middle class debate reopens
Commenters offered different viewpoints. Some supported the post's message, saying many informal sector families now take home more money than salaried ones. Others noted that such comparisons ignore key differences—such as job stability, employment benefits, healthcare coverage, and legal protections that formal workers receive.
Still, the post raised a fundamental question that many seem to be asking: as costs and taxes rise for salaried workers, and as informal sector incomes remain untaxed, is India's idea of who belongs to the 'middle class' shifting?
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
14 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Arts, science grads in Tamil Nadu buck trend, hit pay dirt
CHENNAI: Students pursuing science and arts courses in colleges in Tamil Nadu seem to have bucked the global trend of a lacklustre job market with record placements and impressive pay packages this year. The gambit to invite companies from across sectors for the placement sessions without relying solely on software firms has paid rich dividends to colleges as the average pay package offered doubled in most colleges and more than 90% of students got placed. Loyola College, one of Tamil Nadu's premier arts colleges, has managed to place 945 of 1,048 students who had opted for campus placements this year. Two MSc (chemistry) students from the college have bagged job offers from a pharmaceutical company, ACG World, for its Croatia location with a package of Rs 15 lakh per annum, while an MSc (zoology) student has received Rs 12 lakh per annum offer from an educational organisation based in the UAE. Similarly, some BSc and MSc (physics) students have been absorbed by the space startup, Angikul Cosmos, while IT companies have hired maths graduates and postgraduates. 'This trend should be an eye-opener for students and parents who are unable to think beyond computer science and AI-related courses. For any research work, there is a need for manpower with strong knowledge in core subjects like maths, physics, and chemistry,' said S Princely Samuel, director, placement cell, Loyola College.
Hans India
an hour ago
- Hans India
Concern over too much money in too few hands
Ranchi: Union minister Nitin Gadkari on Saturday expressed concern over the "rising" number of poor, and said wealth was getting concentrated in the hands of some affluent people. There is a need for decentralisation of wealth, Gadkari said during an event in Nagpur, where he touched upon a range of issues, including agriculture, manufacturing, taxation and public-private partnerships in infrastructure development. "Slowly the number of poor people is increasing and wealth is getting centralised in the hands of some wealthy people. It should not happen," the road transport and highways minister said. The economy must grow in a manner that creates jobs and uplifts rural areas, he said. "We are looking at an economic option that will create jobs and (give a boost to the) growth of the economy. There is a need for decentralisation of wealth, and many changes have happened in that direction," he said. The senior BJP leader also credited former prime ministers P V Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh for adopting liberal economic policies but cautioned against unchecked centralisation. "We have to be worried about it," he added. Referring to India's economic structure, he pointed out the imbalance in sectoral contributions to GDP. "Manufacturing contributes 22-24 percent, services 52-54 percent, while agriculture, despite engaging 65-70 percent of the rural population, contributes only around 12 percent," he said. Invoking Swami Vivekananda, Gadkari said, "Philosophy cannot be taught to someone whose stomach is empty." He highlighted the evolving role of chartered accountants, Gadkari said, "CAs can be the growth engines of the economy. Our economy is changing rapidly. It is not only about filing income tax returns and GST submissions." Talking about the infrastructure development, Gadkari highlighted his own initiatives in the transport sector. "I was the one who started the Build-Operate-Transfer system for road construction," he claimed. There is no shortage of funds for road development, he added. Sometimes I say I do not have a fund crunch but I have a shortage of work," Gadkari said. "Now, we earn nearly Rs 55,000 crore through toll booths and in the next two years, our income will go up to Rs 1.40 lakh crore. If we monetise it for the next 15 years, we will have Rs 12 lakh crore. New toll will add more money to our coffers," he said. The minister also spoke about projects aimed at enhancing regional connectivity and investment. "We are constructing a rope of Rs 5,000 crore in Kedarnath. The contractor is ready to spend the amount and give Rs 800 crore royalty to the Union government. When the Uttarakhand government asked us to share the royalty, I asked whether they would also share the loss-making units," he said. On domestic investments, Gadkari said he has raised funds through Infrastructure Investment Trust (InvIT) bonds without foreign assistance. "I am not accepting money from foreign countries like Canada or the US. I will build roads from the money raised from the poor people of the country," he said, adding that the share which was at Rs 100 has now jumped to Rs 160 and people will get nearly 18 to 20 percent returns.
Hans India
2 hours ago
- Hans India
Interest-free loans for SHGs in TG from July 12
Hyderabad: In keeping with its avowed quest to ring in economic empowerment of women, the State government will distribute interest-free loans to women Self Help Groups (SHGs) in all Assembly constituencies from July 12 to 18. It proposes to distribute Rs 20,000 crore interest-free loans to the identified women groups this year. As a further facilitation, the government will provide bank linkage, loan and accident insurance to SHGs. Deputy Chief Minister Mallu Bhatti Vikramarka pointed out on Saturday that the government was already supporting women groups economically by commissioning them works like running canteens, repair works in schools and orders for stitching school uniforms. To ensure that the economic gains reach SHGs, the government intends to purchase the products made by them. This translates to a guaranteed market for their investments. The minister was speaking at the 'Indira Mahila Shakti' celebrations, where he also distributed RTC rental cheques to women groups. Urging them to make full use of the encouragement and women-friendly facilities provided by the government and bolster Brand Telangana, Bhatti took potshots at the BRS regime for neglecting interest-free loans and incentives to SHGs in its 10 years in office. The deputy Chief minister said that in a welcome contrast, the Congress government has revived interest-free loans and is encouraging women groups to be engaged in special businesses. Cheques for interest-free loans have been distributed to women groups twice earlier in Hyderabad, he said. He expressed happiness that the government had enabled women groups to purchase buses and lease them to TGSRTC. In the first phase, ₹one crore was handed over to them as rent payments. In the coming days, larger earnings from RTC would be shared with those groups, he added. In line with this goal to turn one crore women into millionaires in the first year itself, interest-free loans worth ₹21,000 crore were disbursed to women's groups. Not less than ₹20,000 crore will be extended as interest-free loans to women groups every year, he averred.
