CB examines IDPs rehab in super tax case
A five-member CB led by Justice Aminuddin Khan on Tuesday resumed hearing a slew of petitions filed against imposition of a super tax in 2015 for the rehabilitation of the people internally displaced by the military operation.
During the hearing, Justice Jamal Khan Mandokhail asked about the government's plan for the rehabilitation of areas affected by the operation.
"Was any PC-1 [Project Concept-1] prepared for the resettlement of the affected areas? Was any estimate made for the rehabilitation of the affected regions?' He also asked if a tax on services can be imposed through a money bill.
One of the lawyers of the companies which challenged the tax, Makhdoom Ali Khan, argued that the government initially enforced the super tax as a one-time measure through the 2015 Money Bill.
"However, its implementation continued from 2015 to 2022. The government's initial estimate was to collect Rs80 billion. It is unclear how much revenue was actually generated under the Super Levy Tax," he added.
He stated that the government had already collected income tax on earnings, and to avoid double taxation, it was named a "super tax." He argued that social welfare is now a provincial subject and that this was not a super tax but simply another tax.
Justice Muhammad Ali Mazhar inquired whether the Super Levy Tax was imposed for a single year. The companies' lawyer responded that it was initially implemented for one year.
Justice Mandokhail asked if there was any record of the total amount collected under the super tax. Justice Mazhar remarked that the super tax was imposed once for a specific purpose and questioned whether it would continue indefinitely.
Makhdoom Ali Khan argued that the rehabilitation of areas affected by the military operation was a local and provincial matter. The case hearing will resume today at 9:30am.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
4 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Section 144 imposed in Rawalpindi ahead of PTI protest
Listen to article Authorities in Rawalpindi have imposed Section 144 across the district, banning all public gatherings, motorcycle pillion riding, and rallies from August 4 to August 10, citing security concerns ahead of Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf's (PTI) August 5 protest. The Deputy Commissioner's office issued a formal notification on Monday, stating that the restrictions are aimed at maintaining law and order during a sensitive period. According to the notification, 'There will be a complete ban on political gatherings, rallies, and processions in Rawalpindi district. Pillion riding on motorcycles will also be prohibited from August 4 to 10.' The notification also prohibits the display of arms and the use of loudspeakers in public spaces. Any attempt to remove official roadblocks placed on major thoroughfares will result in legal action, officials warned. The administrative clampdown comes amid PTI's continued mobilisation efforts despite ongoing political and legal challenges. The party has not officially announced a rally in Rawalpindi, but authorities appear to be taking preventive measures. It is worth noting that after a series of failed protests, the PTI founder has once again decided to demonstrate street power to campaign for the rule of law and the release of imprisoned party leaders and workers. However, the party appears divided on key policy matters, with dissenting voices increasingly surfacing in public. Days ahead of its planned protest on August 5, the PTI is facing a widespread crackdown, with party leaders going into hiding, workers reporting home raids and several bank accounts reportedly frozen. Party leaders and workers allege that police across Punjab have intensified efforts to suppress the protest by launching a campaign of intimidation. Many party workers lament that since August 1, police have been knocking on doors, forcing workers to sign affidavits promising not to participate in the protest. The raids have led to panic within PTI ranks, with multiple leaders choosing to go underground to avoid arrest. Party sources claim that the "door-knocking" campaign has expanded rapidly over the past few days. In addition to the pressure tactics on the ground, several reports have emerged of financial restrictions being imposed on PTI leadership. The bank account of Hafiz Zeeshan Rasheed, a senior PTI office-bearer in Punjab, has reportedly been frozen, one of many such cases, according to the party.
Express Tribune
5 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Imran Khan behind bars, PTI behind the Lines: what to expect on August 5
Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf has announced a nationwide protest on August 5 to demand the release of their imprisoned leader and former prime minister Imran Khan, and dozens of party activists convicted under anti-terrorism laws. Party spokespersons have framed the rallies as a fight for 'justice, not confrontation,' accusing the establishment of orchestrating politically motivated trials to sideline PTI from future elections The party's central vote banks in Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa and Punjab have historically turned out in massive numbers, most notably during the no confidence demonstrations of April 2022 and 'fill the jails' campaign launched in Feb 2023. Yet this year, state measures like curfews in various parts of the country, mobile internet shutdowns, and the recent convictions of more than 100 PTI members are deterring people from showing up, and are raising fears of fresh crackdowns. Read: PTI alliance mobilises for August 5 'power show' Public sentiment is divided. Rural areas still rally behind PTI's narrative, but many urban middle-class citizens worry that more street action will aggravate economic woes and security disruptions. Analysts point to a growing faction within PTI openly voicing difference of opinion over protest tactics - an internal rift that could dampen turnout further unless leadership unites behind a clear strategy. Meanwhile, Imran is embroiled in multiple legal battles and remains incarcerated. In the Toshakhana case, he was accused of under-declaring and selling state gifts worth over Rs140 million while the Al-Qadir Trust case centers on a Rs7b land donation from developer Malik Riaz, for which the former premier was sentenced to 14-years in prison. Read more: Imran Khan, Bushra Bibi indicted in Toshakhana case Separately, Imran Khan was initially convicted for leaking a classified diplomatic cable (cipher case) and for an 'unlawful marriage' trial, both verdicts later overturned or suspended, though related appeals persist. Following his May 9, 2023 arrest, violent PTI-led protests led to over 150 anti-terrorism and incitement charges that carry long sentences, keeping him behind bars as these cases wind through the courts. Can PTI pull it off? As August 5 approaches, PTI's protest faces high expectations but also significant obstacles. The party's ability to translate loyalist energy into visible street action will depend on leadership cohesion, grassroots coordination, and how forcefully the state chooses to respond. Here's what our analysts had to say. Speaking to The Express Tribune, Prof Tahir Malik emphasized that 'there's been no real change in ground-level capacity since May 2023,' but warned that 'a divided leadership and a largely secretive strategy will hamper efforts to rally the masses'. He pointed out that recent 10-year sentences have 'made people fearful of getting arrested and convicted,' which will inevitably dampen turnout. Also read: 'No political space in sight for PTI' Meanwhile, Majid Nizami predicted a smaller turnout. 'Without clear coordination between Imran Khan's central command and party workers, turnout will shrink further,' he said. He noted the absence of any fully operational Federal Constabulary personnel despite high-profile announcements as evidence that security forces are likely treating August 5 'more as a routine matter,' deploying regular police units instead of the new paramilitary force. Both analysts foresee localized sit-ins and rural pickets rather than a single, sweeping demonstration. Prof Malik expects 'small-scale protests, more intense in villages than in cities,' while Nizami believes the event will amount to 'symbolic roadblocks and provincial pickets,' falling short of a mass-mobilization that could shift the country's political dynamics.
Express Tribune
8 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Opposition alliance urges CJP to act on Rs300bn sugar scandal
The Tehreek Tahaffuz-e-Ain has written to Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Yahya Afridi, urging him to take suo motu notice of an alleged sugar industry scandal in which mills reportedly profited by Rs300 billion due to recent price fluctuations. In a letter addressed to the CJP, Vice Chairman Mustafa Nawaz Khokhar called for the formation of a commission under Article 184(3) of the Constitution to investigate suspected policy manipulation and regulatory failures. Khokhar requested that the issue be urgently referred to a three-member committee or that the letter be treated as a formal petition to initiate judicial proceedings. "The future of the country's economic stability and citizens' trust in governance hinges on prompt and decisive action," the letter added. It further highlighted that the Public Accounts Committee was informed on Tuesday, July 29, that sugar mills had earned Rs300 billion through recent rate hikes. CCP reschedules hearing The Competition Commission of Pakistan (CCP) has postponed the hearing of the sugar cartel case after over 70 sugar mills requested a delay, citing the unavailability of legal counsel due to the Supreme Court's summer recess. In a statement issued on Monday, the CCP announced that the hearing will now take place from September 22 to 25. The decision follows multiple adjournment pleas submitted by sugar mills. More than 50 mills have also filed appeals in the Supreme Court challenging the tribunal's decision directing the CCP to rehear the case. The commission clarified that the hearing has been deferred once to fulfil the requirements of a fair trial. However, it emphasised that no further delay or adjournment would be granted. The CCP stated that the case proceedings will be conducted daily. Read: CCP to hear sugar pricing case today Earlier in May, the Competition Appellate Tribunal had returned the case to the CCP for rehearing after announcing its verdict on the appeals filed by the sugar mills and the association against a Rs44b fine. The tribunal instructed that the case be reheard under the supervision of the CCP chairperson or any other member who was not previously involved in the hearings. The tribunal also ordered the commission to complete the rehearing and issue a verdict within 90 days. In 2021, the CCP imposed a Rs44 billion fine on the PSMA and its member mills for forming a cartel to fix sugar prices and engaging in other anti-competitive practices.
