Why Karen Millen Is Under Fire For Saying Parents Who Breastfeed After Six Months Are 'Addicted'
The designer appeared on Vanessa Feltz' Channel 5 show, Vanessa, and said there were 'no benefits' for the child and claimed it is the parents who become addicted. 'There's no benefit, is there, for a child to be breastfed beyond six months, really. I think it's quite a selfish thing on the mother's part. I just think that's not good emotionally for that child.'
Millen's comments were met with backlash online with some calling them 'mum shaming' and others accusing her of spreading misinformation. Of course, there are plenty of parents who are proud advocates of breastfeeding beyond infancy.
The following day, Millen issued an apology on social media, saying: 'The question was aimed at a three-year-old being breastfed and my thoughts on that and my answers reflected that, not the subject of breastfeeding. And as a woman to women, I do respect your choices and I do want to support you.'
However, these comments have also prompted widespread criticism. The Instagram account @boobtofood wrote, 'This isn't a full apology and it continues to spread misinformation. A 6 or 7 month old is not a toddler. Breastfeeding beyond infancy is normal, beneficial and recommended by the World Health Organisation.'
While @miswifemarley added, 'When discussing topics like this on TV, it would be beneficial to also have an expert in infant feeding available, to negate opinions that the general public may deem as truth.'
However, another viewer defended Millen and wrote, 'She was asked for her thoughts and gave her opinion. Chill out! I didn't breastfeed my child and my child has rarely been ill.'
The comedian Katherine Ryan also chimed in to say, 'Everyone knows: an infant baby becomes a FULL CALF at six months old and that's when milk from a natural source (cow) becomes more suitable than milk from its mother of the same birth species.'
A comment on the parenting forum Mumsnet perhaps best summarises the debate. 'You're not allowed to get it right as a mother, are you?' it reads. 'Bad if you don't breastfeed but also bad if you breastfeed for too long, apparently.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Times
12 hours ago
- Times
Would you try the coconut ‘cortisol cocktail'?
How will you unwind this evening? Nice cup of tea? Large gin and tonic? Or how about a 'cortisol cocktail', the latest viral sensation that promises to relieve stress without the use of alcohol and has got people on TikTok and Instagram frantically excited. The recipe is available in many different variations online but generally consists of coconut water, orange juice, lemon juice, magnesium powder, salt and sparkling water. It's billed as a potent concoction that apparently restores energy and regulates the stress hormone cortisol. 'You not only will feel 210 per cent happier, your memory increases, stress goes down, and you'll get those hormones in check,' says one gushing Insta post. Or how about: 'You will stop anxious feelings, stop depressive thoughts, regulate blood sugars and sleep better and longer.' • Feeling tired? How to boost your energy to avoid an afternoon slump While becoming '210 per cent happier' would be amazing — imagine! — even if my stress levels were slightly reduced I'd be delighted. So despite my scepticism, I find a recipe that looks doable and set about trying it for myself. I find magnesium citrate powder in the chemist on the high street (£17.99) and purloin some posh coconut water, plus a few ripe oranges and a lemon from the corner shop. It comes to about £20 — about the cost of a fancy cocktail in a bar. I measure out 200ml coconut water, add a teaspoon of magnesium, 50ml freshly squeezed orange juice, the juice of half a lemon, a quarter teaspoon of fine salt, and a few glugs of sparkling water. I mix it up — it's a pretty pale orange hue with a delicate froth — and serve it in a cocktail glass. Twenty minutes later I perhaps do feel a bit calmer, but I've somehow lost my wallet in my own home, my husband is griping about traffic on the North Circular, and my son is using a circular saw in the basement. At this moment, I wish the cortisol cocktail contained diazepam. I seek the opinion of Dr Mithu Storoni, a University of Cambridge-trained physician and neuroscientist and the author of Stress Proof and Hyperefficient. Just between us, I ask her, is it nonsense? 'Actually, I approve of this cocktail,' she says. 'I'd probably take it after exercise or before bed for maximum effect. It's much more calming and much better for your cortisol levels than an alcoholic cocktail, or even a high-sugar non-alcoholic alternative, most of which are really high in glucose syrup. They spike your insulin. They're horrible for you.' • Is my cortisol level to blame for my irritable mood? The cortisol cocktail contains no refined sugar, which is a plus for Storoni. 'I would definitely go for this if I had a cocktail menu in front of me. Coconut water is famous for having a very high amount of electrolytes — potassium especially, and sodium — which are great for hydration. And if you're dehydrated, that can raise your cortisol levels. In the hot summer, if you're dehydrated you are more likely to feel stressed, so having coconut water could help.' There's more. 'I like the addition of a quarter teaspoon of fine salt,' she says. 'For most healthy people who don't suffer from raised blood pressure, restricting your sodium too much can have net negative effects, which include an increase in adrenaline.' Plus, she adds, 'in the summer, when we're all sweating, exercising, at risk of low sodium levels but otherwise healthy, then low sodium can increase your feelings of anxiety and stress.' If this is the case, 'having sodium can lower your stress reactivity and make you calmer'. There's good data on magnesium too, she says. 'Magnesium has a very calming effect. It's been shown to improve sleep in people with insomnia.' In addition, 'combined with vitamin C, it reduced premenstrual or menopausal anxiety in one study'. • As a lifelong insomniac, can magnesium really help me sleep? Can men benefit too? Storoni cites a randomised controlled trial looking at reductions in cortisol concentrations in male rugby players following magnesium supplementation (500mg per day over four weeks — a little more than in a cortisol cocktail). Researchers found 'magnesium supplementation affected serum cortisol levels, most significantly before the game, pointing to magnesium's role in the reduction of stress-anticipating anxiety,' she says. As for the citrus elements of the cortisol cocktail, 'the lemon juice and orange juice both contain vitamin C, assuming they're fresh, and vitamin C has been shown to have an antioxidant effect which can improve your state of stress,' Storoni says. 'Antioxidants are always good for stress because when you have physiological stress you are also increasing oxidative stress at a cellular level, which they will then combat. And coconut water contains them too.' So when these wellness influencers swear this drink is regulating your cortisol, they're not wrong? 'If you get stressed your cortisol level rises,' Storoni says. 'Anything that has a calming effect, reduces your stress reactivity, will end up regulating your cortisol. All those TikTokkers may be on to something.'
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
'I couldn't sit up after catching suspected tropical disease'
Laura Angulo was visiting the Philippines as part of a four-month trip around South East Asia when she became ill A teacher was left "unable to sit up" after falling ill with suspected dengue fever during a nightmare holiday. Laura Angulo was touring the Philippines on a four-month South East Asia adventure when she became unwell on Palawan Island. The 29-year-old keen globetrotter initially suffered from "general malaise and fatigue". However, Laura's health rapidly worsened. "I remember we were on a beach and I was lying down eating ice cream because I didn't have the strength to sit up," Laura, who lives on Australia's Gold Coast, shared with What's The Jam. "The moment I started vomiting, we decided to go to the doctor, since we knew that in the Philippines, as in many other tropical countries, you can get dengue fever." Laura, originally from Spain, underwent a blood test which revealed "a very low percentage of platelets". She recalled: "They told us that this is one of the symptoms of dengue fever and that I probably had it. At that moment, I admit I was terrified. "I called my parents and they asked me to return to Spain. But, luckily, my sister and cousin were there for me when I needed them. "Doctors then performed another test on me, which came back negative, but that didn't mean I wasn't infected. I was able to go back to my hostel, but I had to return over the next three days for further tests to see if my diagnosis had improved, since one of the possible symptoms of dengue is internal bleeding "During those three days, the vomiting and diarrhoea worsened, but I didn't have any other symptoms. I was drinking saline and eating small amounts of rice and chicken when my body allowed it. "On the third day, we had to travel to another island where I felt ill for two or three weeks and I lost about 1.6 stone (10kg). It was never confirmed whether I was actually infected, but my platelet count suggests I was." Laura, who has more than 50,000 followers on Instagram and TikTok, shared with her online audience that dengue is spread by mosquito bites. She continued: "There are four different strains of the dengue virus and if you've had one of them and become infected again, your risk of severe symptoms increases. If you get bitten by two strains of dengue at the same time, internal bleeding and possibly death become more likely. "But don't be alarmed; the Philippines is a beautiful country that I highly recommend visiting. To prevent something similar from happening, my first recommendation is to go to a vaccination centre and always carry mosquito repellent and basic medicines as well as travel insurance. Remember to get informed beforehand, and travel responsibly."
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
Adam Thomas admits he 'lost hope' after painful diagnosis he hopes to 'cure naturally'
Adam Thomas has opened up about his arthritis diagnosis and how he plans to get his life back on track, thanks to a new medication and his desire to cure the condition naturally Adam Thomas "lost hope" after he was d iagnosed with an agonising health condition. The actor was just 34 when he was diagnosed with rheumatoid arthritis after experiencing pain following an injury to his knees. He initially believed he had pulled a ligament, but later experienced pain in his wrists. Blood test later confirmed his diagnosis, with Adam saying that he hadn't gone a day without being in pain due to the autoimmune condition. Arthritis causes pain and inflammation in a joint, affecting people of all ages, including children. The NHS states that osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis are the two most common types of the condition. The condition is managed by inflammatory medication, in the form of tablets or steroid injections. Now, the 36-year-old Waterloo Road star has opened up about his condition and how he's finally getting his life back on track. Taking to Instagram, the former Emmerdale actor shared a snap, injecting himself in the thigh with medication. Captioning his upload, he penned: "I lost hope… I never thought I'd get my old life back… I was wrong! "To anyone struggling with arthritis and is lost and can't seem to find hope… Stay strong! Its along and painful road but I promise you…You will! These meds have changed my life… I'm pretty sure this post will get taken down again, but before it does… I get so many questions asking what meds I'm on and I've been on several but the only one that has worked for me are biologic injections. "I have an injection once every two weeks, no side effects no brain fog no throwing up, nothing! Nothing but pain free!!! I know this isn't going to heal the disease but it's given me a life I never thought I'd have again!" He went on to write: "Still putting in the work and focusing on diet and recovery as I'd like to think this disease can be cured naturally and one day I'd like to not have to take any meds but until then… I want to bring hope to those who are suffering and also awareness to this disease as I feel like it's not talked about enough! I see you, I feel you and I know how hard it can be, but don't lose hope don't lose yourself to this disease. Too much love." His upload, which has been liked over 25,000 times, was flooded with messages of support from his followers. One penned: "Biologics changed my life." A second added: "Amjevita changed my life after the hell that was methotrexate! Biologics are the best/ Well done for highlighting it." Meanwhile, a third went on to write: "I have methotrexate & biotic injections to for my Rheumatoid Arthritis. They do and have made a big difference to the pain, swelling and suffering. I was diagnosed officially 8 years ago. These injections can make such a difference to someone life, the awareness is needed thank you." But one social media user was quick to acknowledge that the medication Adam is using may not be suitable for everybody. They said: "I think this type of awareness is amazing, but people should be aware that biologics are immunosuppressants, so definitely not without their risks or side effects. They also don't work for everyone, and there are many different versions. They are amazing, but not as certain for everyone as they have been for you. I'm happy you've had such a good success story!" But while Adam hopes that this diet and lifestyle change can help cure the condition naturally, there is no cure. The NHS states that while there isn't a cure, those with osteoarthritis can change their lifestyle, take medication and often have surgery to help slow down the progression. Meanwhile, for those with rheumatoid, various treatments including disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs and biological treatments can help slow down the progression, but not cure it.
