MNC mutual funds struggle to perform, lose 3% in 1 year. What's driving the underperformance?
With MNC theme based mutual funds losing out an average of around 2.94% in the last one year, a market expert mentions that as MNC funds have heavily invested in the underperforming sectors, their overall returns have naturally been impacted.'Over the past year, MNC funds have delivered returns much below their benchmarks. The Nifty MNC index has itself seen low returns. MNC funds invest mostly in companies that are part of the Nifty MNC index. This index is heavily weighted in two main sectors: FMCG at 35.13% and Capital Goods at 23.80%. Both these sectors have not done well over the past year,' Arjun Guha Thakurta, Executive Director, Anand Rathi Wealth Limited shared with ETMutualFunds.According to Thakurta, the Nifty FMCG Index, which fell nearly 3% over the past year, includes a 2.06% drop from April to May and a further 0.3% decline from May to June. Similarly, the S&P BSE Capital Goods Index fell around 2% in the past year and dropped 0.2% from May to June. Nifty India Manufacturing Index, which also reflects capital goods and industrial exposure, declined by nearly 5% over the last year and with MNC funds heavily invested in these underperforming sectors, their overall returns have naturally been impacted, Thakurta mentioned.He further adds that the MNC funds are also restricted to a relatively small universe of MNCs listed in India, which limits diversification and can lead to underperformance if the broader market rallies but MNC stocks do not.These funds were the second biggest losing category in the said period after auto sector based funds lost 7.15% on an average in the same period. There were around five schemes in the MNC category that completed one year in the market.HDFC MNC Fund lost the most at around 9.75% in the last one year, followed by UTI MNC Fund which lost 2.68% in the said period. Aditya Birla Sun Life MNC Fund lost 1.65% in the mentioned period.And lastly, SBI Magnum Global Fund and ICICI Prudential MNC Fund lost 0.59% and 0.04% respectively in the same time period.After comparing the performance of MNC funds with that of Nifty50 where Nifty MNC has failed to beat Nifty 50 in 3 out of the past 5 years, and is lagging behind this year as well, Thakurta advises investors not to invest solely in any single sector, as it increases the concentration risk.He further advises investors to invest in broad based diversified equity funds such as market cap based funds and strategy based funds which gives exposure across the sectors, categories and market caps & helps to reduce the concentration risk associated with performance of any single sector and additionally strategy based diversification helps to ride across the market cycles.These funds are benchmarked against NIFTY MNC - TRI which went down by 4.28% in the last one year. In the last three years, MNC based funds gave double-digit returns upto 17% with ICICI Prudential MNC Fund being the topper and SBI Magnum Global Fund offering the lowest return of around 13.36% returnA similar picture was seen in the returns offered by these schemes in the last five years. On the other hand, in the last three months, only two funds gave double-digit returns. Aditya Birla Sun Life MNC Fund and Kotak MNC Fund gave 12.24% and 10.68% returns respectively in the last three months. ICICI Prudential MNC Fund gave the lowest return of 5.96% in the last three months.Post observing the recent trends or returns offered by these funds, Thakurta said that the outlook for MNC funds remains cautious and while these funds appear to offer steady, long-term returns due to the strength of multinational companies, historical data suggests that strong outperformance is unlikely in the near term unless MNC stocks come back into favor or global conditions improve.He further added that even if these positive shifts occur, the performance of MNC funds is expected to remain cyclical rather than consistently strong and such funds are riskier than diversified funds due to their concentrated exposure therefore, investors are advised to avoid investing in a single sector and should opt for more diversified funds which invest across multiple sectors and market caps.We considered all MNC theme based funds. We considered regular and growth options only. One should always make investment decisions based on their risk appetite, investment horizon, and goals.: Recommendations, suggestions, views and opinions given by the experts are their own. These do not represent the views of The Economic Times)If you have any mutual fund queries, message on ET Mutual Funds on Facebook/Twitter. We will get it answered by our panel of experts. Do share your questions on ETMFqueries@timesinternet.in alongwith your age, risk profile, and twitter handle.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
4 days ago
- Time of India
Improved consumption trends bring cheer to FMCG counters
Mumbai: Shares of fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) firms advanced Monday after Godrej Consumer's quarterly business update pointed to improved demand prospects. Godrej is the third company after Dabur and Marico to signal a stronger-than-expected growth outlook, but some analysts warn against painting these performances as an industry-wide trend. "A sequential improvement in volume growth and revenue growth indicated by Godrej Consumer Products , Dabur and Marico led to renewed investor sentiment," said Ajay Thakur, research analyst - FMCG, Anand Rathi Institutional Equities. "A good monsoon is seen propping up rural demand and an uptick in urban demand also supports sentiment." by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 5 Books Warren Buffett Wants You to Read In 2025 Blinkist: Warren Buffett's Reading List Undo The Nifty FMCG Index gained 1.7% on Monday, while the benchmark Nifty remained flat. Of the 15 stocks on the FMCG Index, 13 advanced and two declined. Agencies Godrej Consumer jumped 6.4%, leading the gains in FMCG stocks. Dabur gained 3.5%, while HUL and Emami rose over 2.5% each. Britannia Industries climbed 2.1%, and Varun Beverages and Tata Consumer advanced 1.7% and 1.5%, respectively. While the pickup in volumes is expected to stronger in the second half of FY26, gains might be limited to stocks that offer better growth prospects. "The positive guidance was largely for Godrej Consumer and Marico but since the FMCG stocks have been beaten down, the other stocks also rose in hopes of a recovery," said Amit Purohit, VP, Elara Capital. "Although second half is anticipated to be better, Q1 is expected to be muted." Live Events Godrej Consumer Products said in its quarterly update that the volume growth is improving from the previous quarter, and the company expects double-digit rupee revenue growth on the back of high single-digit volume growth. Dabur's growth guidance is softer than that of Godrej, but investors were expecting far worse. "There were expectations of flat to declining growth in Dabur, but the company expects low single-digit growth, which might be perceived optimistically in the otherwise lacklustre quarterly update," said Purohit. So far this year, the Nifty FMCG Index has declined 2%, while the benchmark Nifty has gained 7.7% in the same period. Thakur said he prefers Godrej Consumer among large cap FMCG stocks, while Dabur's valuations are attractive. Purohit said investors should focus on specific stocks in the sector based on their reported growth. "Godrej Consumer Products and Marico are clear standouts and as the market rewards growth, gains are likely in these stocks," said Purohit. "Other stocks may move up as the narrative around the government focus on consumption, good monsoon, and base effect to play out."
Economic Times
4 days ago
- Economic Times
Improved consumption trends bring cheer to FMCG counters
Mumbai: Shares of fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) firms advanced Monday after Godrej Consumer's quarterly business update pointed to improved demand prospects. Godrej is the third company after Dabur and Marico to signal a stronger-than-expected growth outlook, but some analysts warn against painting these performances as an industry-wide trend. ADVERTISEMENT "A sequential improvement in volume growth and revenue growth indicated by Godrej Consumer Products, Dabur and Marico led to renewed investor sentiment," said Ajay Thakur, research analyst - FMCG, Anand Rathi Institutional Equities. "A good monsoon is seen propping up rural demand and an uptick in urban demand also supports sentiment." The Nifty FMCG Index gained 1.7% on Monday, while the benchmark Nifty remained flat. Of the 15 stocks on the FMCG Index, 13 advanced and two declined. Godrej Consumer jumped 6.4%, leading the gains in FMCG stocks. Dabur gained 3.5%, while HUL and Emami rose over 2.5% each. Britannia Industries climbed 2.1%, and Varun Beverages and Tata Consumer advanced 1.7% and 1.5%, respectively. While the pickup in volumes is expected to stronger in the second half of FY26, gains might be limited to stocks that offer better growth prospects."The positive guidance was largely for Godrej Consumer and Marico but since the FMCG stocks have been beaten down, the other stocks also rose in hopes of a recovery," said Amit Purohit, VP, Elara Capital. "Although second half is anticipated to be better, Q1 is expected to be muted."Godrej Consumer Products said in its quarterly update that the volume growth is improving from the previous quarter, and the company expects double-digit rupee revenue growth on the back of high single-digit volume growth. ADVERTISEMENT Dabur's growth guidance is softer than that of Godrej, but investors were expecting far worse. "There were expectations of flat to declining growth in Dabur, but the company expects low single-digit growth, which might be perceived optimistically in the otherwise lacklustre quarterly update," said Purohit. So far this year, the Nifty FMCG Index has declined 2%, while the benchmark Nifty has gained 7.7% in the same period. Thakur said he prefers Godrej Consumer among large cap FMCG stocks, while Dabur's valuations are attractive. ADVERTISEMENT Purohit said investors should focus on specific stocks in the sector based on their reported growth."Godrej Consumer Products and Marico are clear standouts and as the market rewards growth, gains are likely in these stocks," said Purohit. "Other stocks may move up as the narrative around the government focus on consumption, good monsoon, and base effect to play out." (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel)
New Indian Express
5 days ago
- New Indian Express
When are ULIPs the Right Choice
Based purely on content from a search engine's results, one could form an opinion that Unit Linked Insurance Plans (ULIPs) offered by insurance companies are costlier and lack the same transparency as mutual funds, besides generating much lower returns after 5 years, which is usually the lowest installment premium paying term for a ULIP investor. Now, if one shifted the needle from 5 to 10 or 12 years, much of the above criticism stands weakened. To understand a financial product better, one must determine its optimal holding period first, and then compare costs. At the end of a 10 to12-year period, the cost of a ULIP which may seem costlier at the end of a 5-year period due to front loading of costs as against mutual funds that charge evenly throughout the holding tenure, will appear to be similar. In certain cases, it may even seem less costly as ULIP costs start dipping during the second half of a dozen year tenure. The myth around cost and transparency is thus no longer an entirely fair one and as for returns, take a good look at the comparative numbers and decide whether a ULIP's net returns are better or worse at the end of a 10 to 12-year term or that of a balance advantage mutual fund. So, does this mean, ULIPs are superior to mutual funds as an investment vehicle. The simple answer is yes and no. It depends on whether one prefers apples or oranges, as that is the nature of the comparative studies that one reads on many financial websites. The simpler way to look at it is to select based on the appropriateness of a product to the temperament of an investor. Allow me to cite an example to buttress my point. A successful businessman and Ultra HNI investor who is my client now told me how, just before the current stock market rally commenced in 2013, he got fed up of waiting for good returns from the mutual funds he invested in after just 15 months and sold all of them. With the not so inconsiderable proceeds, he purchased an exotic painting on the advice of his then 'wealth manager' from an MNC private bank. He was assured that the artist was the next MF Hussain and that in 25 years he would earn an extraordinary return from this investment. Now that is something only time will tell, but my hunch is that 7 years down the line, there has been no significant appreciation in either the value of the painting or the standing of the artist. Worse still, his wife, a far more astute investor, hated the painting and he now pays handsome locker rent to his bank for hosting the 'masterpiece'. So, would he have been better off, if notwithstanding his impulsive temperament, he held a less liquid ULIP investment in 2013? Let us go deeper into this discussion, in my next column. (Ashok Kumar heads LKW India. The views expressed here are his own)
