Concerns grow over rise in foreign player quota in Singapore Premier League
This marks the highest number of foreign players allowed in the league since its inception in 1996.
The move is part of FAS's broader strategy to enhance the SPL's competitiveness and attract more spectators and investment.
The changes will take effect from the new season beginning on 16 August.
Increased incentives and new league structures introduced
In addition to the player quota, the FAS announced the total prize money for the league will more than double, rising to S$600,000.
A new reserve league, SPL2, will also be introduced with the aim of nurturing young footballers.
The SPL will now consist of eight teams, following Brunei DPMM FC's withdrawal from the league in May.
While these reforms are positioned as steps to revitalise local football, the decision to raise the foreign player quota has sparked considerable debate among football fans, former professionals, and local stakeholders.
Public and expert reactions reflect concern over local talent
Many netizens and commentators voiced concern that the rise in foreign players may come at the expense of local talent, reducing meaningful game time and stifling youth development.
One Facebook user and entrepreneur questioned whether the move truly addressed the root causes of the domestic talent shortage, asking, 'Will this be enough to sustain professional football in Singapore?'
A widely held view expressed in comments on The Straits Times and CNA platforms was that football development in Singapore requires a more fundamental overhaul.
Commenters stressed the importance of first bringing fans back to the stadiums through entertaining football, followed by ensuring long-term financial stability for clubs, and only then focusing on youth development.
One commentator wrote, 'You need top talent in football management here. The S.League was plagued by unqualified incompetents running it for too long.'
Mixed views on foreign players' benefits
Some users defended the foreign player increase, suggesting it could raise the standard of competition and benefit local players through exposure to higher-quality opposition.
Others felt it could simulate an 'overseas stint' experience without players having to leave Singapore.
However, these arguments were met with scepticism.
One user pointed out that the impact depends on the quality of foreign players brought in, advocating for talent from second- or third-tier European leagues.
He criticised the semi-professional nature of local clubs, noting that unlike European teams which train full-time and play several times a week, SPL players often balance football with full-time jobs.
He argued for exemptions from National Service (NS) for promising players, allowing them to fully commit to a professional football career.
Suggestions for community-focused alternatives
Beyond criticism, some proposed alternative approaches.
One idea was to use the additional funds not to import more foreign players but to organise community-based competitions such as a Majulah Cup or Merlion Cup.
These could be aimed at local clubs, age-group teams, and community organisations to scout and develop young talents in a more inclusive and grassroots-driven manner.
Adjustments such as shorter match formats—60 or 30 minutes—were also suggested to encourage broader participation.
Former players and coaches warn of long-term damage
In response to CNA's queries, former professional footballer and coach Shasi Kumar expressed concern that the increased quota could demoralise young players.
He questioned whether parents would still encourage their children to pursue football, given shrinking opportunities for locals in the professional scene.
He also cited a growing gap between under-21 teams and the senior level, noting that many youth players 'fall by the wayside.'
He called for clearer, more inspiring messaging for young athletes in national programmes like the National Development Centre and Unleash the Roar.
Instead of expanding foreign slots, he suggested reducing them to four.
Richard Harcus, formerly with Balestier Khalsa, highlighted that foreign players often occupy pivotal roles such as striker and central defender.
This, he warned, could limit local players' growth in those positions and ultimately undermine national team development.
Rhysh Roshan Rai, a former player and football commentator, emphasised that the quality of playing time matters.
He noted that younger players risk missing out on critical match experience that helps them grow and gain confidence.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
5 hours ago
- Straits Times
England must be fearless to get past the Netherlands, says Russo
ZURICH - England will need to be fearless in their crucial Group D match against the Netherlands at the Women's Euros on Wednesday, said striker Alessia Russo, who insisted the team's confidence had not wavered since the 2-1 loss to France in their opener. England's defeat was their first in the group stage in a European Championship in 10 years and they now face becoming the first holders eliminated before the knockout round. England will be out if they lose and France are not beaten by Wales. "Massively," Russo said on Tuesday, when asked if England must play without fear. "We want everyone to be as free as possible out on the pitch and going forward. "It's a big part of what we are as a team. We have players who can create something out of nothing, and making sure everyone is in a good head-space is important. "Ultimately we have a game plan but we have individuals as well who can create a bit of magic." Russo and manager Sarina Wiegman said they knew before the tournament kicked off that their group would be tough, with three of the four teams ranked in FIFA's top 11. So while the loss to France was frustrating, it was not entirely deflating. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore NDP celebrations to be held at 5 heartland sites, including Bishan and Punggol, on Aug 10 Singapore Keep citizens at the centre of public service, Chan Chun Sing tells civil servants Singapore Man arrested for allegedly throwing bottle at SMRT bus, injuring passenger Asia As Trump plays tariffs hard ball, Asean has little choice but to play on Asia PM Anwar called out by his own lawmakers as Malaysia's judicial crisis heats up Singapore SIA flight from Brisbane to Singapore diverted to Perth due to technical issue Sport Speeding likely cause of Diogo Jota car crash: Police Business Great Eastern could resume trading after delisting vote fails to pass; OCBC's exit offer lapses "No, it's tournament football and you go through lots of highs and lows to where you want to be," Russo said. "We came up against a great France team but we know we can be better and we have high standards as a team." Wiegman is predicting an "intense game" on Wednesday at Stadion Letzigrund as England try to bounce back against the Dutch, a team she led to the European title in 2017. "We knew this was going to be a hard group," she said. "What we are focusing on is our game plan and executing that, doing your task and having conversations with players together and talking together and that is what we want to do in the game too. "What we are occupied with is playing football, executing a task and sticking together, getting the right connections, working really hard and doing everything to win the game." Asked if she reminds her players of the high stakes, Wiegman said: "We don't talk about consequences. We talk about the game plan, what we have to do to be at our best and how we can exploit spaces that the Netherlands leave behind." England face debutants Wales in their final group game on Sunday. REUTERS
Online Citizen
20 hours ago
- Online Citizen
Concerns grow over rise in foreign player quota in Singapore Premier League
On 2 July 2025, the Football Association of Singapore (FAS) announced a set of sweeping changes to the Singapore Premier League (SPL), including an increase in the foreign player quota from six to seven per match. This marks the highest number of foreign players allowed in the league since its inception in 1996. The move is part of FAS's broader strategy to enhance the SPL's competitiveness and attract more spectators and investment. The changes will take effect from the new season beginning on 16 August. Increased incentives and new league structures introduced In addition to the player quota, the FAS announced the total prize money for the league will more than double, rising to S$600,000. A new reserve league, SPL2, will also be introduced with the aim of nurturing young footballers. The SPL will now consist of eight teams, following Brunei DPMM FC's withdrawal from the league in May. While these reforms are positioned as steps to revitalise local football, the decision to raise the foreign player quota has sparked considerable debate among football fans, former professionals, and local stakeholders. Public and expert reactions reflect concern over local talent Many netizens and commentators voiced concern that the rise in foreign players may come at the expense of local talent, reducing meaningful game time and stifling youth development. One Facebook user and entrepreneur questioned whether the move truly addressed the root causes of the domestic talent shortage, asking, 'Will this be enough to sustain professional football in Singapore?' A widely held view expressed in comments on The Straits Times and CNA platforms was that football development in Singapore requires a more fundamental overhaul. Commenters stressed the importance of first bringing fans back to the stadiums through entertaining football, followed by ensuring long-term financial stability for clubs, and only then focusing on youth development. One commentator wrote, 'You need top talent in football management here. The was plagued by unqualified incompetents running it for too long.' Mixed views on foreign players' benefits Some users defended the foreign player increase, suggesting it could raise the standard of competition and benefit local players through exposure to higher-quality opposition. Others felt it could simulate an 'overseas stint' experience without players having to leave Singapore. However, these arguments were met with scepticism. One user pointed out that the impact depends on the quality of foreign players brought in, advocating for talent from second- or third-tier European leagues. He criticised the semi-professional nature of local clubs, noting that unlike European teams which train full-time and play several times a week, SPL players often balance football with full-time jobs. He argued for exemptions from National Service (NS) for promising players, allowing them to fully commit to a professional football career. Suggestions for community-focused alternatives Beyond criticism, some proposed alternative approaches. One idea was to use the additional funds not to import more foreign players but to organise community-based competitions such as a Majulah Cup or Merlion Cup. These could be aimed at local clubs, age-group teams, and community organisations to scout and develop young talents in a more inclusive and grassroots-driven manner. Adjustments such as shorter match formats—60 or 30 minutes—were also suggested to encourage broader participation. Former players and coaches warn of long-term damage In response to CNA's queries, former professional footballer and coach Shasi Kumar expressed concern that the increased quota could demoralise young players. He questioned whether parents would still encourage their children to pursue football, given shrinking opportunities for locals in the professional scene. He also cited a growing gap between under-21 teams and the senior level, noting that many youth players 'fall by the wayside.' He called for clearer, more inspiring messaging for young athletes in national programmes like the National Development Centre and Unleash the Roar. Instead of expanding foreign slots, he suggested reducing them to four. Richard Harcus, formerly with Balestier Khalsa, highlighted that foreign players often occupy pivotal roles such as striker and central defender. This, he warned, could limit local players' growth in those positions and ultimately undermine national team development. Rhysh Roshan Rai, a former player and football commentator, emphasised that the quality of playing time matters. He noted that younger players risk missing out on critical match experience that helps them grow and gain confidence.
Straits Times
a day ago
- Straits Times
Relentless Spain reach Women's Euro quarters after thumping Belgium
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox THUN, Switzerland - Spain reached the quarter-finals of Women's Euro 2025 on after the world champions' hammered Belgium 6-2 while Italy were held to a 1-1 draw with Portugal. A brace from the magnificent Alexia Putellas and further goals from Irene Paredes, Esther Gonzalez, Mariona Caldentey and Claudia Pina gave Group B leaders Spain a second thumping win. Montse Tome's team will win the group if they avoid defeat to Italy, who are two points behind La Roja in second after being denied qualification late on by third-placed Portugal, on July 4. Few would bet on Spain failing to secure first place after two blistering performances in which they have netted 11 times. 'We knew they would try to sit back and hold us off at the beginning, we could have been better, sure, but you need to adapt during the game. We managed to do that and create good opportunities,' Tome told reporters. 'We have to improve but we did what we planned to do.' Belgium, who twice levelled through Justine Vanhaevermaet and Hannah Eurlings, are close to going home after eventually being blown away by relentless waves of attacking football. They acquitted themselves well until Caldentey forced home Spain's fourth in the 61st minute, defending with grit and causing problems with some punchy breakaway football. 'It was difficult because I really believed in what we were doing and I loved seeing my players give everything they had,' said Belgium coach Elisabet Gunnarsdottir. 'I really think we gave them a game for at least 60 minutes, a really good game... I'm proud of them.' When Putellas finished off a beautiful spell of quick passing in the 22nd minute it looked like the beginning of a thumping win similar to the 5-0 destruction of Portugal in the opening round. Spain's Alexia Putellas scores their sixth goal. PHOTO: REUTERS Spain rampant Yet seconds later Vanhaevermaet levelled with the simplest of goals, nodding home Tessa Wullaert's corner. Paredes put Spain back in the lead six minutes before the break with a bullet header from Pina's deep corner. Again Belgium hit back, this time through Eurlings who sprung the offside trap before rifling home in the 50th minute. Gonzalez netted her third goal of the tournament two minutes later after collecting Putellas' neat through ball. The game was up when Caldentey bundled home from a corner just after the hour. Pina smashed in her first goal of the tournament with 10 minutes remaining, and appropriately it was Putellas' deft flick which completed the rout shortly afterwards. Spain's forward Claudia Pina (left) fights for the ball with Belgium's midfielder Justine Vanhaevermaet. PHOTO: AFP On this form Spain look a class above the rest of the tournament and clear favourites to win the country's first ever women's European crown. Italy thought they were joining Spain in the quarters when Cristiana Girelli opened the scoring in Geneva with a brilliant curling effort with 20 minutes remaining. The Azzurre were saved 10 minutes later when Diana Silva was denied a leveller when she was ruled offside by VAR following her rebound finish from a corner. But in the 89th minute Diana Gomes lobbed home a leveller which gave Portugal a point and kept them in the competition moments after Carole Costa headed onto the crossbar. That goal could be huge as Portugal face Belgium while Italy take on Spain. Italy currently have a goal difference which is six better than Portugal but with Spain up next a big swing is not that to imagine. AFP
