logo
Crossing a river to get photocopies, paying money to get form filled — issues pile up at panel on voter list revision

Crossing a river to get photocopies, paying money to get form filled — issues pile up at panel on voter list revision

Anuj Kumar Choudhary from Rivilganj in Bihar's Saran district says there are nine voters in his family. However, Booth-level Officers (BLO), who are responsible for carrying out the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise of voters on the ground, only gave the family two enumeration forms that will now become the basis for exercising their right to vote.
He claims that the remaining seven forms had already been uploaded online without their knowledge.
'I am one of few educated people among the Dalit community in my area, where barely 30-40% people have got enumeration forms… Will submission of forms without documents keep us in the final electoral roll?' asks Chaudhary. He is one of the 250 people from 14 districts who have come to Patna Monday for a public hearing on SIR by a panel.
The panel was organised Bharat Jodo Abhiyan, National Alliance of People's Movement, Swaraj Abhiyan, Kosi Navnirman Manch, Summer Charitable Trust and Jan Jagran Shakti Sangathan. On stage were Justice (Retired) Anjana Prakash (former judge, Patna High Court); Wajahat Habibullah (former Central Information Commissioner and Chair, National Commission for Minorities); Professor Jean Dreze (Economist); Professor Nandini Sundar (Sociologist, Delhi School of Economics), D M Diwakar (ex Director, A N Sinha Institute, Patna) and Bhanwar Meghwanshi (Writer).
Social activist and Swaraj India's president Yogendra Yadav, who is one of the petitioners in the Supreme Court challenging the SIR exercise, was part of the audience.
As the July 25 date for the submission of enumeration forms approaches, many like Choudhary came to the event with issues — from running post to pillar to secure a document, to the difficulties in filling up a form, to the costs incurred to get the process done.
Phool Kumari Devi from Hasanganj in the Katihar district says she has had to sell rice at home for the process.
'I am a daily wage worker. I had to sell rice to bear the cost of photocopies of my Aadhar Card and also had to pay a neighbour Rs 100 to fill up my form because I am illiterate. I had no document other than Aadhar. I could not earn for two days because of this unnecessary exercise,' says Devi.
Rajesh Kumar from Madhepura speaks of the washing away of belongings — including important documents — due to the recurrent flooding in the Kosi belt.
'In our area, people have to cross a river to get a photocopy. Most of my villagers could submit enumeration forms. But in most cases, they only had Aadhar Cards and that is not among the 11 documents prescribed for the exercise. We do not know how we will submit required documents if asked between 1 August and 31 August,' said Rajesh who has been voting after the 2003 prescribed cut-off.
With seven districts of Bihar sharing a border with Nepal, an Araria resident talks about concerns of people married to non-Indians.
'Someone I know from Nepal married a man from Araria 20 years ago. She has voted in India in the last three elections. Now, she is being asked to bring documents of her parents. As per law, she will not be treated as an Indian citizen,' she says.
Summing up the arguments, Prof Dreze says: 'Most people talked about four things — BLOs not reaching out to most of them, not giving them receipts, the submission of forms without documents, and a large number of forms getting submitted without the knowledge of voters.'
Yadav adds: 'The Election Commission of India (ECI) has been accepting forms without one of 11 documents without having modified its order. When its original order said 'duly-filled' forms, it could imply documents attached. It is now the sole discretion of ECI to accept or reject the form…. The Law says a voter remains a voter… Barring some exceptions. Now, the onus is not on ECI but on voters to prove themselves as voters. We have apprehensions of the SIR targeting certain regions and certain communities'.
As per a sample survey conducted by an organisation named Jansumvai of over 300 migrants, 72% had no idea what the SIR was, while 70% had not heard about the online application process.
About 50% of them had voted in the Bihar 2020 Assembly polls and 74% of them wanted to vote in the forthcoming Assembly polls.
Santosh Singh is a Senior Assistant Editor with The Indian Express since June 2008. He covers Bihar with main focus on politics, society and governance. Investigative and explanatory stories are also his forte. Singh has 25 years of experience in print journalism covering Bihar, Delhi, Madhya Pradesh and Karnataka.
... Read More
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Nitish, Tejashwi clash in House on third day of monsoon session
Nitish, Tejashwi clash in House on third day of monsoon session

Time of India

time37 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Nitish, Tejashwi clash in House on third day of monsoon session

Patna: The third day of the monsoon session of state assembly on Wednesday was dominated by an intense and combative showdown between chief minister Nitish Kumar and leader of opposition Tejashwi Prasad Yadav . What began as a focused debate on the Election Commission's (EC) special intensive revision (SIR) of the electoral roll soon escalated into a fierce political slugfest, with Nitish invoking his two-decade governance record and launching a sharp attack on Tejashwi, while he questioned the intent, timing, and transparency of the exercise. Tejashwi had managed to secure an all-party discussion on the matter with the approval of speaker Nand Kishore Yadav and the assent of the CM. But as the debate unfolded, Nitish seized the floor to mount a strong defence of his over two-decade governance record, arguing that it was "the work done by us" since 2005 that would ultimately shape the people's verdict in the polls. Downplaying his past association with the Grand Alliance—which he had twice headed with Tejashwi as his deputy—Nitish distanced himself from the alliance's governance performance, asserting: "It is true, I was with you, but you all were not functioning properly, and I went my own way. " He launched a direct attack on Tejashwi's: "You are still a child, and you were the same even when your father (Lalu Prasad) and mother (Rabri Devi) ruled the state from 1990 to Nov 2005. He accused the erstwhile RJD regime of allowing lawlessness to flourish, saying, "Even in Patna, people feared venturing out after sunset." Citing the state's transformation under his leadership, Nitish highlighted a manifold rise in the size of the state budget since the early 1990s, as well as initiatives for women's empowerment. "We will go to the people with what we have done," he said, brushing aside Tejashwi's allegations on the electoral roll revision exercise as political noise: "You will be speaking 'and-band' (nonsense). The people will count the work done by us. " Tejashwi, on his part, trained his guns on the timing and transparency of the SIR, questioning why the exercise was being carried out so close to the elections and alleging that it lacked accountability. "We are not opposed to the SIR, but the manner of the exercise is objectionable. Why wasn't it conducted months earlier?" he asked, raising concerns about the availability of documents being sought by the EC and the alleged narrative around fake voters. "Only 2-3% of people possess the documents the EC is asking for. And if there are fake voters, then did Narendra Modi become PM and Nitish Kumar CM because of them?" Tejashwi quipped, referring to BJP and JD(U)'s electoral successes. He further pointed out that although foreign nationals from Bangladesh and Myanmar were repeatedly cited as concerns, the EC had made no mention of them in its voluminous affidavit submitted to the Supreme Court on Tuesday. Raising the issue of migrant voters, Tejashwi said, "What happens to the 4.5 crore Bihari voters who work outside the state but return during elections? The EC is now threatening to delist voters not found at their registered addresses." Following the adjournment of the morning session, Tejashwi convened a meeting with alliance partners at his residence, and later claimed that the CM's intervention had derailed the House discussion on the SIR. Demanding the continuation of the debate on Thursday, GA members staged a brief protest during the post-lunch session, meant for passage of bills, before staging a walkout.

Bihar's 98.01 percent electors covered under SIR: EC
Bihar's 98.01 percent electors covered under SIR: EC

United News of India

timean hour ago

  • United News of India

Bihar's 98.01 percent electors covered under SIR: EC

New Delhi, July 23 (UNI) Election Commission today announced that 98.01 per cent of voters in Bihar have been covered under the ongoing Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise. According to an official release issued here, the EC also said that so far as many as 20 lakh deceased voters have been reported, while 28 lakh of them have permanently migrated to other states. While 7 lakh electors were found to be enrolled in more than one place, 1 lakh of them were marked untraceable, it said. The poll panel said it has received and digitised 7.17 crore enumeration forms, accounting for 90.89 per cent of the state's voters. However, 15 lakh forms were not returned. The EC also said the lists of incorrectly included electors and those who have not returned their enumeration forms were shared on July 20 with 1.5 lakh Booth Level Agents (BLAs) nominated by district presidents of the 12 major political parties in the state, which is scheduled to have election later this year. Bihar voters temporarily residing outside the state and not registered elsewhere can submit their forms online at through the ECINet mobile app, or by filling a printed form, it announced. The completed and signed printed form can be sent to the respective Booth Level Officer (BLO) via a family member or through WhatsApp, the EC document said. Voters who have submitted their Enumeration Forms will be included in the Draft Electoral Roll, to be published on August 1, marking the end of the first phase of SIR. In case of any discrepancies in the draft roll, voters or political parties can file objections with the concerned ERO or AERO by September 1, it added. Eligible individuals whose names are missing can also file claims until the same date, it said urging people to participate actively in the verification process of electoral rolls. UNI SK SSP

JSP workers injured in alleged lathi charge as police stop march to CM Nitish's residence
JSP workers injured in alleged lathi charge as police stop march to CM Nitish's residence

New Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • New Indian Express

JSP workers injured in alleged lathi charge as police stop march to CM Nitish's residence

PATNA: Several workers of the Jan Suraaj Party (JSP) were allegedly injured during a protest in Patna on Wednesday, after police allegedly resorted to a baton charge to stop them from marching towards the chief minister's residence. The protest, led by JSP founder Prashant Kishor, was part of a 'CM residence gherao' stir to press for a three-point charter of demands. JSP supporters who gathered there to take part in 'CM residence gherao' were stopped by police near Chitkohra Overbridge while they were heading towards the Gardanibagh dharna site. Police had erected barricades the march, leading to a scuffle between personnel and JSP protestors. Videos of the clash quickly went viral on social media. JSP later claimed that several of its supporters sustained injuries in the police action, alleging they were lathi-charged during the protest. Prashant Kishor attacked the state government for using force against peaceful demonstration and attempt to suppress the voice of the people. 'We will not allow this to happen. We will fight against them,' he said. The agitation was organised to protest, what Prashant Kishor called, 'three critical failure of the state government. Later addressing workers, Kishor raised three questions: Why have poor families not received the promised Rs.2 lakh employment aid? Why have Dalit families not been allotted three decimals of land? And why there is silence on alleged corruption in the ongoing land survey? Prashant Kishor, who met the injured supporters shortly after the incident, slammed the state government, accusing it of suppressing genuine public concerns through police force. 'They (government) think that it will impact our fight for justice. But they are under the shadow of illusion. Our fight will continue till demands are met,' he asserted. Meanwhile, Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP), Patna, denied the lathicharge and said that the protestors were prevented from marching towards prohibited area. 'Holding agitation is completely banned in prohibited zone,' he told the media while defending police action.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store