Opposition MP, govt backbencher clash over May 13 remark
KUALA LUMPUR : A war of words broke out between a government backbencher and an opposition MP after the latter mentioned the May 13 racial riots while criticising the 13th Malaysia Plan on grounds that it lacked initiatives for the Bumiputera community.
Awang Hashim (PN-Pendang) questioned the government's emphasis on New Villages, when debating the 13MP, tabled last Thursday.
He said while Perikatan Nasional had no issue with funds for New Villages, there was no specific development for the Bumiputera community.
'When we look back at the May 13 incident, one of the elements was economic pressure on the Bumiputeras. That's why the 1MP to 13MP exist, to balance income and the economy among the races. But the 13MP has nothing specific for the Bumiputera community.
'Is the government trying to bring back another May 13 incident?'
This prompted RSN Rayer (PH-Jelutong) to cite Standing Order 36(9)(c), which prohibits statements that can provoke hostility or hurt the feelings of any race.
'Pendang is suggesting May 13 can happen again,' Rayer said, urging deputy speaker Alice Lau to make a ruling.
Awang denied making any provocative statement, saying such accusations were slanderous.
'I didn't say what you claimed I did. That's why even DAP people don't accept you anymore – you lost the (party's) central executive committee election,' he said.
Rayer replied: 'We accept your point about Chinese New Villages, but why repeat that May 13 can happen again?'
Defending his comments, Awang said: 'I quoted the point made by the prime minister, that the socio-economic level of New Villages will be strengthened through a development master plan. So, is it racist to mention that? If I say 'Bumiputera', is it racist? If I say 'Chinese', is it racist?'
Rayer continued to press for a ruling, but Lau said she 'will let the minister respond', likely alluding to the economy minister.
She said Rayer could submit a motion to the Speaker for further action.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
18 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
MyKad or full price: Targeted RON95 subsidy plans to be unveiled by end-Sept, says MoF
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 5 — The Ministry of Finance (MoF) said the detailed implementation plans for targeted subsidies for RON95 petrol will be announced by end-September 2025, in line with Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim's statement on July 23, 2025. In a written parliamentary reply, MoF said the government is actively developing and testing the subsidy targeting mechanism to ensure smooth execution upon rollout. 'This includes refining data from agencies such as the National Registration Department, Road Transport Department (JPJ), and the Department of Statistics Malaysia (DoSM),' it said. 'The government aims to adopt a more comprehensive approach to ensure RON95 subsidies reach the intended target groups.' MoF was responding to a question from Hulu Langat Member of Parliament, Pakatan Harapan's Mohd Sany Hamzan, who asked for an update on the subsidy retargeting implementation, particularly the front-end and back-end phases announced by the Ministry of Economy. According to MoF, once implemented, the retargeted subsidy mechanism will allow eligible Malaysians to enjoy RON95 at RM1.99 per litre through MyKad verification. Non-citizens and those ineligible for the subsidy will pay the unsubsidised market rate. — Bernama
Malay Mail
18 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
RMK13 on watch: Execution, discipline, and delivery — Ahmad Faiz Yazid
AUG 5 — The 13th Malaysia Plan (RMK13) outlines ambitious targets for 2026–2030: **4.5–5.5 per cent annual GDP growth and a fiscal deficit under 3 per cent by 2030**. It packages RM430 billion in five-year development expenditure (about RM86 billion per year) to drive these goals. Yet history reminds us that even large plans can stumble. RMK13's success will hinge on rigorous execution and fiscal discipline. We must not let it become another 'shelf document' of slogans and wish lists. Emphasising execution and fiscal discipline A recurring concern is that Malaysia's development blueprints often face a familiar hurdle: the implementation gaps. RMK13 itself warns that its effectiveness 'will depend more on how the money is spent' than the budget size. In other words, pouring cash into projects is not enough; we need strict controls to ensure timely, cost-effective delivery. This starts with reining in the ever-growing operating expenditure (OE) of the government. Under RMK13, operating costs (on wages, subsidies and debt servicing) are projected at a staggering RM1.81 trillion, much larger than the DE budget. If we fail to control these recurring expenses, even well-planned development spending cannot restore fiscal balance. In fact, interest payments alone now consume about 15 sen of every ringgit of revenue. Such non-productive debt servicing crowds out funds for schools, hospitals and infrastructure. Civil servants watch the live broadcast of the 13th Malaysia Plan (RMK13) presentation by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim during a Bernama survey today. — Bernama pic In practical terms, each additional ringgit borrowed for debt repayment is a ringgit not available for growth initiatives. Over time, this undermines Malaysia's fiscal flexibility and risks crowding out investment. To keep the debt path sustainable, RMK13 must target a lower OE share of the budget. Any liberal subsidies or unchecked wage growth would dilute the gains from development projects. Hence, the plan's goals like halving the deficit mandate tough measures on spending. We should insist on annual budget reviews that explicitly map every expenditure line to the plan's targets, ensuring each ringgit advances a strategic outcome. History shows this is not a mere theory. Past auditor-general reports have exposed cost overruns and inefficiencies in state projects, with recent audits revealing irregularities in projects worth over RM48 billion. If RMK13 is to deliver its promise of productivity boosts and better living standards, it must include value-for-money checks on its biggest programs. For example, major infrastructure tenders and government-linked company ventures should be subject to rigorous audits and clear timelines. Transparent scorecards of progress (to be released each year) would keep implementation honest. In practice, this means linking the national budget to the plan's priorities so that voters and legislators can see exactly how policy commitments are funded. Beyond rhetoric: Linking plans to action Another risk is that RMK13 falls into the old ritual of planning without doing. In recent years, Malaysia's Five-Year Plans have become overloaded with frameworks and buzzwords, what critics call 'strategy soup'. Citizens outside the policy circles can barely recall the pillars of RMK12 or its '17 Big Shifts' under the Madani vision. This is not just an academic point: if people and even officials lose sight of the plan's core messages, implementation inevitably suffers. Therefore, RMK13 must break this cycle. It should be treated as a living contract with the nation, not a decorative launch event. The plan's authors (consisting of many government officials) and Cabinet must commit to institutional accountability. A first step would be to publish a frank 'report card' on RMK12, spelling out what policies worked, which fell short, and why. This would not only build trust but also guide better policy design. Going forward, every ministry budget (from 2026 onward) should be tagged against the plan's priorities, effectively making the budget a GPS to track the plan's journey. In other words, spending decisions cannot be made in a vacuum: each ringgit should contribute to specific plan targets (as if raising exports, cutting poverty, improving human capital). The plan's presentation itself should become simpler and more results-focused. Instead of drowning readers in dozens of sub-themes, it is recommended to focus on four or five outcomes that matter most to Malaysians, such as wage growth, affordable energy, efficient public services, digital skills and effective social safety nets. Clear KPIs (key performance indicators) for each outcome would then be set and publicised. For instance, goals like 'full employment by 2030' or 'average household income of RM12,000' should have intermediate milestones and timelines, not be vague ambitions. Other countries serve as proof of concept: South Korea runs a national dashboard tracking every agency's five-year targets, while Indonesia's planning agency links its development plan to real-time implementation updates. Malaysia can do the same. By reporting on progress quarterly or annually, perhaps via a user-friendly online portal, we turn the plan from a static document into an ongoing monitoring process. An empowered existing Economic Planning Unit under the Ministry of Economy or secretariat should be charged with keeping this data updated and public. Critically, citizen engagement must be built into RMK13. The plan should launch with an online platform where any Malaysian can check progress, download data, and even give feedback. Such a portal would help move away from opaque decision-making. If people can see which projects are on schedule and ask questions (or flag issues), political leaders will feel more accountable. Transparency breeds trust: a development plan becomes a genuine social contract with the rakyat, rather than an elite blueprint gathering dust. * Ahmad Faiz Yazid holds a Bachelor of Economics from Universiti Malaya and is currently a Graduate Executive Trainee at Permodalan Nasional Berhad (PNB). ** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.
Malay Mail
18 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
‘Fake and fraudulent': Viral RM26m gratuity letter ‘never issued', says works minister
KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 5 — Works Minister Datuk Seri Alexander Nanta Linggi has denied the issuance of a letter dated July 28, 2025, which has gone viral on social media, that was supposedly from the ministry regarding a gratuity payment to an individual. Nanta said that the letter was fake and was never sent out by the ministry or by him as the minister. 'The ministry never issued any official invitation for such a gratuity payment ceremony. As such, I advise the public not to be deceived by such documents, which clearly contain elements of fraud and impersonation,' he said. He said the ministry had taken note of the matter and is working together with the authorities to conduct further investigation. Those who have any doubts about the authenticity of documents or communications allegedly from the ministry are advised to contact the ministry's official channels via its website at or the ministry's official hotline. Previously, a letter had gone viral on social media claiming that a gratuity payment of over RM26 million was supposed to be presented to the next of kin of an individual at a ceremony to be held at the ministry here today. — Bernama
