&w=3840&q=100)
From biryani to Bharat: How Zohran Mamdani is cooking up chaos, falsehood and division
Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic nominee for New York City mayor, sparked controversy on social media after a video of him eating mutton biryani with his hands went viral. (Images: REUTERS/Mamdani's video screengrab)
Culture wars have found a bizarre new battleground — the humble plate of biryani. The trigger? Democratic nominee for New York City mayor, Zohran Mamdani, eating mutton biryani with his hands. Overnight, social media was ablaze with a debate on what was the correct way to eat the delicacy: with hands or via cutlery. A significantly large section of people residing in the west of the Atlantic, ironically home to the slogan 'Finger Lickin' Good', rose in fierce defence of cutlery, while many in the East, especially the metropolitans of Bharat — who for decades shamed hand-eating at prestigious venues — rediscovered pride in eating with fingers.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
This absurd battle reveals more than just culinary quirks. It exposes how identity can be weaponised, narratives twisted, and facts bent, all to feed divisive politics. And Zohran Mamdani stands right at this dangerous intersection, appropriating symbolic gestures to project a progressive persona while camouflaging his illiberal, divisive, and grievance-driven agenda.
Let's start with his rise. Mamdani, the son of a cerebral filmmaker mother and a socialist academic father, is celebrated in New York's political-socialite circles as a beacon of progressivism; he is hailed for championing the cause of the supposedly voiceless. Yet, scratch beneath this carefully constructed image, and a troubling pattern emerges: Exaggeration, fabrication and, worse, a dangerous tendency to manufacture convenient truth.
Last month, the 33-year-old Mamdani called Prime Minister Narendra Modi a 'war criminal' who orchestrated a 'mass slaughter of Muslims'. The result: 'There are no Muslims left in Gujarat,' he claims. This is indeed a sweeping, chilling assertion — except that they both are blatant, dangerous lies.
While Prime Minister Modi is a democratically elected leader of the world's largest democracy — not once but three times in a row — Gujarat remains home to over seven million Muslims, nearly 10 per cent of the state's population. Far from being wiped out, Gujarat's Muslims today run 22 per cent of the state's small and medium enterprises, despite forming just 9 per cent of the population. The Tendulkar Committee, set up by the previous Congress-led UPA government, found that only 7.7 per cent of Gujarat's rural Muslims lived below the poverty line — this is phenomenally better than the national average of 26.9 per cent. The Sachar Committee too acknowledged that Gujarat's welfare schemes extended robust support to Muslim communities.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Equally significant is what Mamdani doesn't say. Gujarat, once notorious for periodic communal riots (1969, 1985, 1987, 1992, to name a few), has not seen a single major communal violence in more than two decades. The Supreme Court, after exhaustive investigations, gave Narendra Modi a clean chit in the 2002 post-Godhra violence. But inconvenient truths find no place in Mamdani's narrative. His story needs villains, not nuanced facts. This also explains why he would repeatedly talk about Gujarat, but Godhra would be conspicuous by its absence in his statements.
Mamdani wears his opposition to 'Hindutva forces' like a badge of honour, constantly highlighting the plight of minorities (for him, and so many Left-'liberals', minority means Muslim) in Bharat. He is seen to be routinely criticising Bharat's democratic credentials, calling it on multiple occasions a state teetering toward fascism. Yet, he has nothing to say on the exodus of Kashmiri Pandits or the political violence faced by Hindus in West Bengal. The sorry state of minority affairs in Bharat's immediate neighbourhood—Pakistan and Bangladesh — rarely bothers him.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Even his association with Khalistani elements in the West doesn't bother him. He is more than happy to overlook their history of violence — from the Air India Kanishka bombing in 1985, which was the deadliest aviation terror attack before 9/11, to the bombings of Hindu temples across North America in recent years.
Why would a New York politician be so invested in demonising Bharat? The answer is as simple as it is cynical. By painting Bharat as a Hindu majoritarian dystopia and Modi as a villain, Mamdani secures instant celebrity status and applause from the global Left-'liberal' ecosystem. What would otherwise require years of grassroots work — conducting mass outreach programmes, building coalitions, and delivering local results — he achieves overnight by positioning himself as a moral crusader against the alleged fascism in a faraway land.
This is narrative politics at its most dangerous. It thrives on half-truths, selective empathy, and historical amnesia. Worse, it is designed to perpetuate victimhood. Mamdani's real genius lies not in policy, but in optics. Whether eating biryani with his hands or issuing sweeping pronouncements on another country's internal affairs, he has mastered the art of narrative over substance. It is a reel persona overtaking the real one — a carefully curated act designed to harvest outrage and votes.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Zohran Mamdani's blood may be Bharatiya, and he may relish a plate of biryani with his hands, but his mind seems consumed by disdain for Bharat and its civilisational/Sanatana identity — an idea far more inclusive and diverse than the bleak picture he paints. In the end, the real tragedy is not that a local politician in New York peddles convenient falsehoods and manufactured truths. It is that in doing so, he keeps real wounds from healing, real conversations from happening, and more importantly, real democracies from flowering.
Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect Firstpost's views.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
33 minutes ago
- Time of India
Shivakumar neither in hurry nor under pressure for CM post, says his brother Suresh
Former Lok Sabha member D K Suresh on Saturday clarified that his brother and Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister D K Shivakumar is neither in a hurry nor under pressure regarding the CM post . He made the remarks against the backdrop of Chief Minister Siddaramaiah 's recent assertion that he would complete his full five-year tenure. "D K Shivakumar is neither in a hurry (to become CM) nor under any pressure," Suresh told reporters here. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Play War Thunder now for free War Thunder Play Now Undo Earlier, it had been speculated that Shivakumar, who is also the Congress state president and considered a key contender for the top post in the state, would take over the chief minister's role midway in the present regime. Responding to queries, Suresh said, "There is no conflict in the Congress party . The high command, the chief minister and Shivakumar have already clarified the matter. Siddaramaiah has said he will continue in leadership. Yet we don't know why there is confusion in the media." Live Events He added that Shivakumar is sincerely carrying out the responsibilities given to him and working in accordance with the party's direction. "At present, the chief minister's post is not vacant. We don't know why this issue is being discussed repeatedly," Suresh said. He added that Shivakumar is a loyal party worker who respects the Congress high command. There was stiff competition between Siddaramaiah and Shivakumar for the chief minister's post after the declaration of Assembly election results in May 2023, and the Congress had managed to convince the latter and made him the Deputy CM. There were some reports at the time that a compromise had been reached based on a " rotational chief minister formula " according to which Shivakumar will become CM after two-and-half years, but they have not been officially confirmed by the party.


News18
36 minutes ago
- News18
'100%': Siddaramaiah Will Complete 5 Years As CM, Says Karnataka Minister Ramalinga Reddy
Reddy also told News18 that the Congress high command should crack down on leaders who speak to the media about the perceived power tussle in the party's state unit Karnataka chief minister Siddaramaiah will complete a full five-year term on the post, his cabinet colleague Ramalinga Reddy told News18 in an exclusive interview on Saturday. The state transport minister also asserted that the Congress government was stable and would retain power in the next assembly elections. Reddy advocated that the Congress high command should crack down on leaders who speak to the media about the perceived power tussle in the party's state unit. Edited excerpts: What is the status of the bike taxi issue? Commuters are confused. Will the ban on bike taxis be lifted? The matter is in court. I won't comment. That is his personal opinion. Take, for example, the Kantharaju report (the previous caste census)—there were many differences of opinion among ministers. Bengaluru's population is 1.4 crore. About 43 lakh people travel by our buses, around 8 lakh use the Metro, another 4 lakh use taxis, and 3 lakh use autos. We have a well-connected bus network everywhere. If you had used our bus today, you wouldn't have been late. Shakti was the first guarantee launched. But today, it is putting pressure on the state exchequer, and there are also reports of unpaid salaries. We started Shakti in June, and so far, 500 crore commuters have used the service since its launch in June 2023. The government's expenditure is around Rs 12,000 crore. We are paying salaries on the first of every month and have also recruited 10,000 new employees. Transport corporations have incurred losses, and there have been delays in paying salaries. We are paying salaries regularly. During the BJP government, they used to pay salaries once in two months. They didn't recruit a single employee. We have recruited 10,000 people, brought in 5,000 new buses, and more are expected to join the fleet. The BJP had cancelled 3,800 buses. It is the Congress that resumed the process. Compared to other corporations, we are doing 100% better. Before Shakti, the number of daily travellers was 80 to 85 lakh. Now it has reached 1.05 crore. Maharashtra has allowed e-bike taxis. Is your objection to the concept of bike taxis itself? You cannot compare with other states. Karnataka has 25,000 buses, and Maharashtra has 26,000. Rajasthan, UP, and other states don't even have 10,000 buses. The matter is in court—I won't comment. Is the auto union pushing for this? I won't comment. Will there be a change in the CM by December? CM Siddaramaiah visited Delhi two or three days ago. After his visit, he expressed that he will continue for five years. I will not make any further comments. As a minister, do you have confidence that Siddaramaiah will complete five years as CM? Our Congress government will complete five years, and another five years as well. When the CM has expressed that he will continue for five years, it's like a message from Delhi, I believe (from the high command). What about the morale of the party? The constant tussle is affecting the image of the government. Be it leaders or MLAs, they should not be speaking to the media about CM change, KPCC chief change, or having three deputy CMs. They should not speak like this—it will affect the party in future elections. What about leaders who continue to speak out? The high command should take strict action against them. Both the CM and deputy CM should ask everyone to refrain from speaking to the media. If they have anything to say, let them say it within four walls. In the interest of the party and the government, what they are doing is wrong. There are reports that there is no money in the government. Funds for the guarantees are being released only once in two or three months. Every week, the CM and deputy CM visit districts and inaugurate various projects. If there were no money, how would that be possible? We have sufficient funds. BJP and JD(S) are misleading the public. When Bommai left office, the state's debt was more than Rs 1 lakh crore. The BJP took over Rs 2.4 lakh crore in loans from banks. The current situation is due to the BJP's mismanagement. Is the government stable? 100 per cent stable. We will complete five years and return in the next elections too. Under whose leadership? Under the leadership of Siddaramaiah and DK Shivakumar. Mallikarjun Kharge is there, and so are Sonia Gandhi and Rahul Gandhi. As Muzrai Minister as well, the Temple Bill proposes that 10 per cent of earnings from temples earning between Rs 50 lakh and Rs 1 crore be given to the government. It is awaiting Presidential assent. This is in the interest of C-grade temples, temple priests, and their families. There are about 40,000 priests. The bill is currently with the President. Let's see what happens. It is being said that this is also being done to fund the guarantee schemes. We cannot transfer even one rupee from one temple to another. The BJP is misleading the public through social media. Will the full five-year term be completed under chief minister Siddaramaiah? 100 per cent. Under his leadership? Yes. Get Latest Updates on Movies, Breaking News On India, World, Live Cricket Scores, And Stock Market Updates. Also Download the News18 App to stay updated! tags : DK Shivakumar karnataka Rahul Gandhi Siddaramaiah view comments Location : Bengaluru, India, India First Published: July 12, 2025, 17:17 IST News politics '100%': Siddaramaiah Will Complete 5 Years As CM, Says Karnataka Minister Ramalinga Reddy | Exclusive Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.


Hindustan Times
41 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
‘Now you know who's calling the shots': Priyank Kharge's ‘September kranti' dig at BJP after RSS chief's age remark
Karnataka minister Priyank Kharge on Saturday took a veiled swipe at the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)-led NDA government, saying, 'now you know who is calling the shots.' Congress' Priyank Kharge's 'September Kranti' jibe after RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat's retirement age remark The Congress leader's remark came in response to a statement by Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) chief Mohan Bhagwat, who allegedly said that leaders should step aside after turning 75—a comment that has triggered political ripples, especially with Prime Minister Narendra Modi set to reach that age this September. Sharing a graphic of Bhagwat with the 'retirement age' quote alongside his image, Kharge posted on 'X': 'Now you know who is calling the shots in the Government. September Kranti is around the corner?' Bhagwat's comment, though not directly aimed at anyone, has been widely interpreted as a pointed message to the Prime Minister, who has himself previously endorsed the idea of a 75-year age cap for active politics. Also Read | Leaders should retire at 75, says Mohan Bhagwat, sparks Opposition speculation Kharge had earlier reminded the public of the Prime Minister's past statements on political retirement. Speaking to reporters on Friday, he said, 'We are not targeting the Prime Minister nor are we interested in the age of the Prime Minister; we are interested in his work and contribution to the country, but he has earlier said that the 75 years should be cut-off age for politicians so since he's turning 75 in a couple of months, people were speculating whether he will be sent to the 'margdarshak mandal'. It is the opinion of the Prime Minister himself,' news agency ANI quoted Kharge as saying. Congress attacks Modi, Bhagwat over turning 25 Several other Congress leaders also joined in the criticism. Congress MP and party communications head Jairam Ramesh said in a post on X, 'Poor, award-winning Prime Minister! What a homecoming – reminded by the RSS chief upon return that he will turn 75 on September 17, 2025. But the Prime Minister could also tell the RSS chief that he, too, will turn 75 on September 11, 2025! One arrow, two targets!' Meanwhile, Congress spokesperson Pawan Khera said Bhagwat's statement was "good news" for the country. 'Mohan Bhagwat gave good news yesterday. He said that a person should give others a chance after turning 75 years of age. This is good news because Mohan Bhagwat is becoming 75 years of age on September 11 and Narendra Modi is also turning 75 on September 17,' Khera said. 'The duo has affected the spirit of this country. Good times for the country will come and good times for the Indian Constitution will come soon, as both are leaving,' he added. (With ANI inputs)