logo
Tribals in Great Nicobar not against development but lack info about mega project: NCST member

Tribals in Great Nicobar not against development but lack info about mega project: NCST member

The Hindu30-06-2025
Tribal communities in Great Nicobar are not opposed to development but lack sufficient information about a proposed mega infrastructure project on the island, National Commission for Scheduled Tribes (NCST) member Asha Lakra has said.
The project, titled Holistic Development of Great Nicobar, involves the construction of a transshipment port, an international airport, a township and a power plant over more than 160 sq. km of land. This includes around 130 sq. km of pristine forest inhabited by the Nicobarese, a Scheduled Tribe (ST), and the Shompens, a Particularly Vulnerable Tribal Group (PVTG), whose population is estimated to be between 200 and 300.
In an interview with PTI, Ms. Lakra said she led an NCST team to the Andaman and Nicobar Islands from June 5 to 7 to review the issues faced by the tribal communities.
She said the Commission held a detailed meeting with representatives of all tribal groups, including the Great Andamanese, Jarawa, Nicobarese and Shompens.
"We met everyone.... We also had talks with both Shompen and Nicobarese people living on Great Nicobar Island. Most of the people have no idea about the project. They are busy with their own lives.... They demand more ferries to travel between islands," Lakra said.
Asked about her interaction with the residents of Great Nicobar, she said, "They have no other problems. All they need is development.... Better transport, education and health facilities. This is what they told us. Everyone, barring the Sentinelese, said the same thing. They are in favour of development." "They want employment and their financial situation to improve," Ms. Lakra added.
She, however, stressed the need for a stakeholders' meeting with educated people from the island regarding "such a big project" and said all necessary information should be shared with them.
However, Barnabas Manju, chairman of the Little and Great Nicobar Tribal Council, told PTI over the phone that the council was not invited to the meeting and came to know about it through the local media.
The Council had written to the Union Environment Ministry and the Andaman and Nicobar administration in November 2022, withdrawing the no-objection certificate (NOC) it issued in August that year for the denotification of 84.1 sq. km of tribal reserve and the diversion of 130 sq. km of forest for the project. It alleged that crucial information was withheld while seeking the NOC.
The Tribal Council had expressed shock on learning that parts of their pre-tsunami villages would be "denotified and diverted" under the project.
During a public hearing held at Campbell Bay in January 2021, the Council's chairman had said that although they support the development plan, "we want to go back to our ancestral villages".
Tribal Councils in the Andaman and Nicobar Islands are statutory bodies established under the Andaman and Nicobar Islands (Tribal Councils) Regulation, 2009. They have limited advisory and executive powers, unlike autonomous councils under the Sixth Schedule of the Constitution, which have legislative, executive and limited judicial powers and enjoy greater autonomy.
Around 853 sq. km of the island's total 910-sq. km area is designated as a tribal reserve under the Andaman and Nicobar (Protection of Aboriginal Tribes) Regulation, 1956.
In tribal reserves, the tribal communities own the land and have full rights to use it for their daily needs. However, transferring, acquiring or selling land in these areas is strictly prohibited.
Asked whether the commission looked into complaints of Forest Rights Act (FRA) violations related to the project, Ms. Lakra said, "The only kind of FRA violations that has been reported involves non-tribal outsiders, who come for construction work, marry ST women and settle on tribal land." This allows non-tribals to gain de-facto control over land protected under the FRA, she added.
In April 2023, the NCST issued a notice to the Andaman and Nicobar administration, seeking "facts and an action-taken report" on allegations that the mega project would violate the constitutional mandate and "adversely impact" the lives of local tribals.
Ms. Lakra said the Commission would check whether a response has been received.
At a media interaction earlier this month, Union Tribal Affairs Minister Jual Oram said his Ministry is examining objections raised by tribal communities regarding the proposed project.
"Yes, it is under examination. I had also answered a question [in this regard] in Parliament. We are currently examining the documents they have submitted. After that, we will decide the course of action," he had said, replying to a question.
On further questioning about what the Ministry seeks to ascertain, Mr. Oram had said, "First, we need to determine whether the gram sabha (tribal council in this case) was held, what the gram sabha recommended and whether there have been any violations."
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

FirstUp: Modi to visit UK, Ukraine-Russia to hold new round of peace talks… Big events of the day
FirstUp: Modi to visit UK, Ukraine-Russia to hold new round of peace talks… Big events of the day

First Post

timean hour ago

  • First Post

FirstUp: Modi to visit UK, Ukraine-Russia to hold new round of peace talks… Big events of the day

Prime Minister Modi will depart for a visit to the United Kingdom today, where he will meet his British counterpart Keir Starmer and sign the India-UK free trade agreement (FTA). Russia and Ukraine will hold a third round of ceasefire negotiations today. The Indian cricket team will take on England in the fourth Test match at Manchester. Here's what else to expect read more Prime Minister Narendra Modi meets UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer on the sidelines of the G7 Summit at Kananaskis, in Alberta, Canada. File image/PTI Are you prepared for a news-packed day? Wednesday, July 23, is set to be a busy, busy day in the world of news as well as sports. Prime Minister Narendra Modi will embark on a two-nation tour to the United Kingdom and the Maldives from July 23 until July 26. Today, Russia and Ukraine are also all set to hold new peace talks as a follow-up to the two rounds of peace talks held in Istanbul. Also, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz will hold talks with French President Emmanuel Macron in Berlin on July 23, German government spokesperson Steffen Meyer said. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD In India, the funeral of VS Achuthanandan, Kerala's former chief minister, will be held today. Moreover, the Indian Air Force (IAF) will conduct a major, large-scale exercise in Rajasthan along the India-Pakistan border. Owing to this, a Notice to Airmen (Notam) has been issued in connection with the exercise. Today, also marks the start of the fourth Test match between India and England scheduled to be played in Manchester. Here's what to expect from this very busy Wednesday. Modi embarks on UK visit Starting today, July 23, PM Modi will begin his two-nation tour to the United Kingdom and Maldives. The Ministry of External Affairs said that Modi's visit to UK comes at the invitation of his British counterpart, Keir Starmer. This will be PM Modi's fourth visit to the nation since assuming office in 2014. 'The PM will embark on an official visit to the United Kingdom tomorrow, 23rd July, for discussions with Keir Starmer, the Prime Minister of the United Kingdom. He will also call upon King Charles III. Interaction is also planned with the business leaders, both from India and the UK. This will be Prime Minister's fourth visit to the UK since assuming office,' Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri announced. Modi's visit to UK will see him signing the much-awaited Free Trade Agreement (FTA). Moreover, he will hold wide-ranging discussions with Starmer on the entire gamut of India-UK bilateral relations, including the issue of Khalistani elements on British soil. Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has said that a third round of negotiations will be held today in Turkey. File image/Reuters Russia-Ukraine peace talks On Wednesday, a third round of ceasefire negotiations between Russia and Ukraine is set to take place in Istanbul, Turkey. This comes after previous talks in May and June failed to yield any results. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy announced that talks will be held today. Meanwhile, the Kremlin has downplayed any chances of a positive outcome from the meeting. The Russian side said on Tuesday that there was no basis to expect miracles from a proposed third round of direct Russian-Ukrainian peace talks, and declined to give any time frame for a potential agreement to end the war. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Macron to meet Germany's Merz in Berlin French President Emmanuel Macron will travel to meet German Chancellor Friedrich Merz on Wednesday in Berlin, where the two will discuss the 30 per cent tariffs Trump has threatened on all EU goods if no agreement is reached. The two leaders, according to a report in Le Monde, will also discuss nuclear energy at the meeting today. The meeting is intended to lay the groundwork for the Franco-German Council of Ministers, planned for late August. France has long advocated that nuclear energy should not be penalised in Brussels, as atomic power accounts for nearly 70 per cent of its primary energy production. After years of fierce debate between Berlin and Paris, France hopes for a policy shift with the return of conservatives to power in Germany, especially since Merz presented himself as a staunch supporter of nuclear energy. The Indian Air Force is set to carry out a major military exercise in Rajasthan. Representational image/PTI IAF to hold exercises in Rajasthan A Notice to Airmen (Notam) has been issued for a large-scale Indian Air Force (IAF) exercise scheduled for July 23–25 in Rajasthan along the India-Pakistan border. According to sources, the Indian Air Force is set to carry out a major military exercise in Rajasthan, covering areas from Barmer to Jodhpur. 'The exercise is scheduled to take place in Rajasthan near the International Border, is part of the IAF's regular operational readiness drills. It could be between two or three commands of IAF. We keep issuing Notam during such exercise to keep airspace cleared of any civilian aircraft,' said the official. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The intensive drill will including frontline fighter jets including Rafale, Mirage 2000, and Sukhoi-30 aircraft, along with air-defence system and support systems. The drill will also involve preparedness during night operations. VS Achuthanandan's funeral in Kerala The state of Kerala in India is in mourning after news broke that former chief minister and Communist stalwart VS Achuthanandan passed away. Achuthanandan, known widely as VS, will be cremated today at the Valiyachudukadu funeral ground in his home district of Alappuzha. Earlier on Monday, his remains were kept at the party's former state headquarters, AKG Study Centre, in Thiruvananthapuram before being taken to his house. Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan said VS's death marked the end of an era. 'His death is a loss for the party and the state. His life was a remarkable chapter in the history of Kerala as well as of the revolutionary movement. He has been a symbol of struggle, unflinching determination and uncompromising fighting spirit. As chief minister, he had been instrumental in taking Kerala forward. He got involved in several issues, including human rights, women's rights and the environment. He played a crucial role in bringing several social issues to mainstream politics,' Vijayan said. Indian captain Shubman Gill and coach Gautam Gambhir during a practice session. File image/PTI India take on England in fourth Test match The historic Old Trafford ground in Manchester will play host to the penultimate Test of the Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy from Wednesday. While India strive to bounce back from their painstaking defeat at Lord's and draw level at 2-2, the hosts will aim to seal the fate of the series with a decisive lead. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD However, things won't be easy for the Indian side. Nitish Kumar Reddy has been ruled out of the remainder while Arshdeep Singh will also miss it due to injury. England, meanwhile, has made just one change to their squad; Liam Lawson will replace Shoaib Bashir, who has also been ruled out of the remainder due to finger injury sustained in the 3rd Test. The match will start today at 3.30 pm IST. With inputs from agencies

7/11 blasts: HC disbelieved recovery of RDX on hyper-technical ground, Maha govt tells SC
7/11 blasts: HC disbelieved recovery of RDX on hyper-technical ground, Maha govt tells SC

The Print

time2 hours ago

  • The Print

7/11 blasts: HC disbelieved recovery of RDX on hyper-technical ground, Maha govt tells SC

Earlier in the day, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, on behalf of the state government, mentioned the plea before an apex court bench headed by Chief Justice B R Gavai and sought an urgent hearing. The court agreed to hear it on July 24. The state government rushed to the top court a day after the high court acquitted all the 12 accused, saying the prosecution utterly failed to prove the case against them and it was 'hard to believe' that the accused had committed the crime. New Delhi, Jul 22 (PTI) The Maharashtra government has assailed a Bombay High Court judgment acquitting all 12 convicts in the 2006 Mumbai train blasts case in the Supreme Court on grounds including that the recovery of RDX from an accused was disbelieved on a 'hyper-technical ground' that the seized explosives were not sealed with a lac seal. The state government, in its appeal, has raised several serious objections to the high court's order of acquittal. The plea has asserted that due procedural safeguards under Section 23(2) of Maharashtra Control of Organised Crime Act (MCOCA) were observed, including proper sanctioning by senior officers like prosecution witness (PW) no. 185 Anami Roy. It said the high court overlooked the validity of these approvals despite no substantial contradiction in the prosecution's evidence. The plea has assailed the high court's rejection of the recovery of 500 grams of RDX from one of the accused on the ground that it lacked a lac seal. The plea has said that RDX, being highly inflammable, was not sealed for safety reasons and the recovery was duly sanctioned and documented. 'That, the Hon'ble High Court has disbelieved the recovery of 500 gms of RDX from Accused No. 1 on a hyper-technical ground that the RDX which was seized was not sealed with a lac seal. It will be pertinent to note that the same was not sealed with a lac seal because RDX is an inflammable substance. 'It is pertinent to note that the High Court records that the sanctioning authority for explosive substances has been examined by the prosecution. However, the Hon'ble High Court has not found any infirmities in the evidence of PW 26, who is the sanctioning authority under the Explosive Substances Act for seizure of RDX from Accused No. 1. Therefore, the High Court has erred in disbelieving the recovery of RDX from Accused No. 1,' the plea has said. It has also disputed the high court's dismissal of the confession of an accused for lacking minute details, such as the date of arrival of the Pakistani co-conspirators in India, the description of the six Pakistanis and information like whether they had trained in terrorist camps. 'The entire confessional statement has been disbelieved which is an unacceptable conclusion,' the plea has said, adding that omissions regarding the identities and origins of the Pakistani co-conspirators do not invalidate the overall confession. The appeal also challenges the high court's disregard of the recovery of detonators and explosive granules from another accused, pointing out that these items cannot be easily procured or planted, and their evidentiary value should not have been dismissed over technicalities. The petition says the high court failed to address the validity of the convictions under various provisions of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act (UAPA) and relevant provisions of the Explosive Substances Act. It says the high court ignored key findings and legal interpretations from previous landmark judgments. The plea addresses the defence's contention that the accused did not meet the definition of 'continuing unlawful activity' under the MCOCA due to earlier offences being punishable by less than three years. Citing Supreme Court precedents, the plea says the conspiracy and scale of the attack clearly fall under MCOCA provisions. Of the 12, five were sentenced to death and seven to life imprisonment by a special court. One of the death-row convicts died in 2021. More than 180 people were killed when seven blasts ripped through Mumbai local trains at various locations on the western line on July 11, 2006. PTI SJK RC This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.

Modi govt has ‘consistent policy of betrayal' for J&K: Cong
Modi govt has ‘consistent policy of betrayal' for J&K: Cong

The Print

time2 hours ago

  • The Print

Modi govt has ‘consistent policy of betrayal' for J&K: Cong

Also, former Congress president Rahul Gandhi, along with Kharge, met and deliberated with party leaders from Jammu and Kashmir at Indira Bhawan here. His remarks came after Congress' Jammu and Kashmir unit staged a protest at Jantar Mantar here, demanding restoration of full statehood to the Union Territory. New Delhi, Jul 22 (PTI) Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge on Tuesday alleged that the Modi government has a 'consistent policy of betrayal' for Jammu and Kashmir, and asserted that people of J&K deserve full statehood. The Congress is fully dedicated to protecting the rights of the people of Jammu and Kashmir and their interests, Gandhi said in a post in Hindi on Facebook after addressing the gathering. Posting pictures on X from the gathering, Kharge said the people of Jammu and Kashmir deserve full statehood, and added that it is their constitutional right. 'We have written to the PM demanding the same. Modi Govt has a consistent policy of betrayal for Jammu and Kashmir,' he said. Kharge said the Pahalgam terror attack is a grim reminder of intelligence failure. 'We stand strongly with the people of J&K, demanding adequate compensation and protection for them, especially those families who have lost their loved ones in cross-border shelling. They are martyrs,' he said. Jammu and Kashmir Pradesh Congress Committee is on the streets fighting for the people, he said. 'It is the duty of every Congress worker to strengthen the organisation. Your determination can go a long way in changing the lives of the people in this beautiful border region,' the party chief said. Congress general secretary (organisation), K C Venugopal, AICC in-charge of J&K Naseer Hussain and J&K Congress chief Tariq Hameed Karra, among others, took part in the protest at Jantar Mantar. 'Jammu and Kashmir is the first instance of a state being downgraded into a Union Territory. Such democratic backsliding and insult to the people of a state is unacceptable,' Venugopal said in a post on X after the protest. 'J&KPCC is protesting at Jantar Mantar, to demand restoration of full statehood to J&K. I joined in the protest and spoke about the need to defend the Constitution and restore the dignity of the people of J&K. The promises made in Parliament must be fulfilled without delay,' he said. The Congress on Sunday said the party will raise the demand for restoration of full statehood to Jammu and Kashmir in the Monsoon session of Parliament. Kharge and Gandhi had last week written to Prime Minister Narendra Modi to press for a legislation in the Monsoon session to grant full statehood to Jammu and Kashmir. In their joint letter to Modi, Kharge and Gandhi had said that for the past five years, the people of the UT of Jammu and Kashmir have consistently called for the restoration of full statehood. This demand is both legitimate and firmly grounded in their constitutional and democratic rights, they had said. PTI ASK KVK KVK This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store