Spain court shelves Ryanair's €107 million fine for 'abusive practices'
The Madrid court said it accepted their appeals against the respective fines of €107 million ($125 million) and €1.6 million while the basis of the case was still being resolved.
The court also justified its decision by the costliness of the fines which would "cause a mismatch and difficulties for the treasury" of the companies.
The airlines will meanwhile have to pay guarantees collectively totalling almost €112 million.
The consumer ministry announced fines against five companies in November for what it identified as "abusive practices", including charging for hand luggage, providing misleading information and a lack of price transparency.
Irish no-frills carrier Ryanair was specifically fined for charging passengers a "disproportionate amount" for printing their boarding passes at terminals when they did not have them.
EasyJet and Spanish airlines Volotea and Vueling were also among the punished firms.
Ryanair boss Michael O'Leary slammed the "political" fines at the time as "illegal and baseless".
Far-left consumer rights minister Pablo Bustinduy, who has become embroiled in a spat with Ryanair over his policies, conceded the practices would continue until the courts decided the affair.
The successful appeals were "normal and predictable under the rule of law", but "charging for hand luggage is illegal", he insisted on social network Bluesky.
The European Parliament's transport commission has proposed allowing passengers to bring a personal object such as a handbag or backpack on board, as well as another piece of luggage weighing seven kilograms at most.
But the sector association Airlines for Europe says the move would increase the cost of tickets for passengers who choose to travel light.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Local Spain
a day ago
- Local Spain
80 flights cancelled on third day of easyJet strikes in Spain
As of 10am on Friday, the third day of the strike at easyJet, the airline has cancelled 40 flights across its four Spanish bases: Palma de Mallorca, Barcelona, Alicante and Málaga. The 40 cancelled flight routes - 80 total as they are roundtrips - are as follows: 17 in Palma de Mallorca : Geneva (two), Basel (three), Naples, Berlin, Bordeaux, Zurich, Nice, London Gatwick (two), Palermo, Nantes, Toulouse, Leeds Bradford and Paris Charles de Gaulle 11 in Málaga: Geneva (two), London Gatwick (two), Basel, Zurich, Bristol (two), Marrakech, Manchester and Nantes 4 in Alicante : Bristol, Basel, Southend and Lyon 8 in Barcelona : Berlin, Basel, Strasbourg, Naples, Geneva (two), Lisbon and Nice The cabin crew protest began on Wednesday with the intention of ending today (Friday June 27th), although if there is no agreement, they have not ruled out an indefinite strike in August. The previous two days of strikes have resulted in 124 cancelled flights, 62 on each day. Therefore, the total number of grounded flights over the three days numbers 204. Called by Spanish workers' union USO, the purpose of the stoppage is to demand improved pay for easyJet's Spain-based cabin crew, equalling their wages to that of their counterparts across other European countries where the budget airlines has bases. However, the airline's management maintains that "it is not possible to compare working conditions between different countries," since its staff are governed by local contracts. Pier Luigi Copello, the general secretary of USO at easyJet Spain, explained that the workforce is demanding fair and equitable working conditions, "in line with the European standards that easyJet maintains in other countries, given the exorbitant increase in the cost of living in Spain', especially in cities such as Málaga, Palma de Mallorca, Barcelona and Alicante. According to Copello, easyJet flight attendants' salaries in Spain get paid around the minimum wage.
Local Spain
a day ago
- Local Spain
Spain court shelves Ryanair's €107 million fine for 'abusive practices'
The Madrid court said it accepted their appeals against the respective fines of €107 million ($125 million) and €1.6 million while the basis of the case was still being resolved. The court also justified its decision by the costliness of the fines which would "cause a mismatch and difficulties for the treasury" of the companies. The airlines will meanwhile have to pay guarantees collectively totalling almost €112 million. The consumer ministry announced fines against five companies in November for what it identified as "abusive practices", including charging for hand luggage, providing misleading information and a lack of price transparency. Irish no-frills carrier Ryanair was specifically fined for charging passengers a "disproportionate amount" for printing their boarding passes at terminals when they did not have them. EasyJet and Spanish airlines Volotea and Vueling were also among the punished firms. Ryanair boss Michael O'Leary slammed the "political" fines at the time as "illegal and baseless". Far-left consumer rights minister Pablo Bustinduy, who has become embroiled in a spat with Ryanair over his policies, conceded the practices would continue until the courts decided the affair. The successful appeals were "normal and predictable under the rule of law", but "charging for hand luggage is illegal", he insisted on social network Bluesky. The European Parliament's transport commission has proposed allowing passengers to bring a personal object such as a handbag or backpack on board, as well as another piece of luggage weighing seven kilograms at most. But the sector association Airlines for Europe says the move would increase the cost of tickets for passengers who choose to travel light.
Local Spain
2 days ago
- Local Spain
Spain's Interior Minister and UK's Home Secretary join call for Brits to get TIEs
Brexit For Members The push to get UK nationals living in Spain since before Brexit to exchange their old green residency certificates for TIEs has reached new heights, with Spain's Interior Minister and Britain's Home Secretary now both urging Brits to make the swap. The two most important officials in Spain and the United Kingdom's internal affairs have joined the call to get all Britons in Spain to exchange their old Spanish residency documents for new ones. This is ahead of changes to the EU's border systems that could mean Brits residing legally in Spain are "treated as overstayers" by border authorities. The EU's much-delayed EES system of biometric passport checks could begin in October this year, after an agreement was reached in March between member states. Spain's Interior Minister, Fernando Grande-Marlaska, and the British Home Secretary, Yvette Cooper, discussed the issue at a meeting held on Wednesday in Madrid. As such, they are the officials highest up in each country's government to address the TIE matter, as previous calls have largely been made by the UK Embassy in Madrid. With the implementation of the new EU Entry/Exit System (EES), the TIE (Tarjeta de Identidad de Extranjero) will become the only valid travel document for UK nationals in Spain so they aren't recorded in the EES and subject to the 90-day rules in the Schengen Area. Therefore, the Spanish government is now also upping the pressure on Brits who have so far stuck to their green certificates and ignored the countless calls to make the swap. According to Spain's Interior Ministry, the TIE will better 'facilitate their international travel once the new Schengen border control system comes into operation next autumn.' According to a ministry statement, Grande-Marlaska and Cooper agreed on the importance for British citizens who are beneficiaries of the EU Withdrawal Agreement and who have not yet applied for it to ensure that they get the TIE, as the current EU Citizen Registration Certificate, often referred to as a 'green card' or 'green certificate' that many thousands still use, will not give travellers exemption from registration once the new EES comes into force. As per the Ministry website: 'The EES will register the border crossing of citizens who identify themselves with the 'green card', which will limit their time of stay in the Schengen area to a maximum of 90 days in 180 days. In order to exceed this limit, these citizens will have to go to a National Police station to prove their resident status and ask for the rectification of the EES registration, otherwise they could face problems at the border when leaving and returning to the Schengen zone as they will be identified by the EES system as 'overstayers'.' The TIE, a more durable biometric card that includes and a photograph (unlikely the paper or cardboard green certificates) will be the only document that allows UK citizens residing in Spain to bypass EES and avoid the 90-day limit. This card "is the identification document for non-EU citizens resident in Spain that gives them access to all the rights recognised by current legislation," said Grande-Marlaska. Per Ministry figures, between 2020 and June 2025, the Spanish authorities have already issued 138,106 permanent residence cards for beneficiaries of the Withdrawal Agreement and 1,890 for their family members, as well as a further 101,094 temporary residence cards and 3,665 for their family members. 'Estimates suggest that some 50,000 British citizens resident in Spain have not yet applied for their TIE,' the ministry estimates. The British Embassy in Spain has previously called on British residents specifically in Málaga and Alicante provinces to make the exchange. In all, some 403,925 UK nationals were officially registered as residing in Spain in 2024. In order to speed up the process, Spanish police have reportedly increased staff numbers, particularly in areas with a strong British presence, such as Valencia, Andalusia and the Balearic Islands. However, some of our readers have previously commented that they've found it impossible to get a cita previa (appointment) on the government website, making it impossible to carry out the exchange. This may be due to the fact that there organised crime groups which use bots to block all appointments the moment they're made available, in order to then sell them to desperate foreigners.
