Dark Laboratory: On Columbus, the Caribbean, and the Origins of the Climate Crisis – a trenchant account of colonialism
Author
:
Tao Leigh Goffe
ISBN-13
:
978-0-241-62855-3
Publisher
:
Hamish Hamilton
Guideline Price
:
£22
Montserrat is the only country aside from
Ireland
to celebrate
St Patrick's Day
as a public holiday. It's not just a chance to go on the beer but recalls the African rebellion against Irish slavers which took place in 1768. The rebels deliberately chose the date for the uprising, knowing that the Irish overseers and planters would be getting drunk at Government House.
Tao Leigh Goffe recounts this and many other stories of black and indigenous resistance to Caribbean slavery in this trenchant account of Caribbean colonialism. Goffe contends that race, labour and colonialism are absent from environmentalist debates and suggests the arrival of Christopher Columbus in the Caribbean in 1492 is not only the 'ground zero of colonial conquest', but the starting point for the modern-day climate crisis.
Along the way, the author takes a deserved swipe at western multinationals operating in the Caribbean for damage wrought on black and indigenous communities in places such as Jamaica – while strangely defending Chinese companies for the same sins – arguing that it is the 'global majority' who must lead the ecological conversation.
Only by interrogating the history of western scientific and anthropological inquiry in the region, Goffe adds, will a solution be found to the climate crisis. This leads her to decry archival research – European archives and natural history museums are described as 'evidence lockers full of crimes against humanity' and 'death cults of colonial worship'.
READ MORE
Goffe unashamedly argues from a subjective standpoint, drawing much on her own family's fascinating history, one which embraces not only the Caribbean, but also China, Hong Kong, Britain and the United States. This could have been the starting point of a more nuanced journey through those regions most affected by the climate crisis and an objective analysis of the environmental destruction wrought by European colonialism in the Americas.
[
From the archive: Meeting islanders with Irish ancestry on Montserrat
Opens in new window
]
Instead, while positing interesting ideas about the impact of colonial thinking on the Caribbean environment, Goffe often fails to support them, preferring to spend time on academic bunfights. Archival research may be 'cold, unethical and extractive' but it's also how one finds the bodies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
University fees hike controversy
Sir, – I see there is division in Government in relation to a potential increase in university fees. I think I know the perfect solution that will result in all parties including students being happy and nobody loses face. A special commission should be set up to produce a report on how universities should be funded. It will probably take a year or so to complete. In the meantime, no hard decision is required and we kick this thorny issue down the road yet again. Sound familiar? – Yours, etc, EAMONN BYRNE, READ MORE Dublin 15.
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
Parents' plan to raise €60,000 to employ extra teacher refused by primary school patron
A plan by parents at a Dublin primary school to privately employ a teacher for €60,000 to avoid pupils being educated in 'supersized' classes has been turned down by its patron body, the Archdiocese of Dublin . Belgrove Infant Girls' School in Clontarf, Dublin 3 , will lose a teacher in September following a drop in enrolments last year. It means pupils going into first class will be amalgamated from three classes into two for part of the school day, resulting in enlarged class sizes of 34 pupils. Average primary class sizes nationally are 22.5 pupils, and the Government has pledged to reduce the average to 19 pupils. READ MORE Eamonn Broderick, the parent of a six-year-old child who is due to progress to first class in September, said most parents were willing to fund the appointment of a teacher which they estimated would cost about €60,000 or €600 per family. 'We were confident we would have the money together quickly,' he said. 'This is a relatively affluent area. Earlier this the school was able to raise €40,000 to do up the yard in a week. The school indicated they would need about €60,000 for a 10-month contract, as well as PRSI, insurance, etc.' However, the school's patron body, the Archdiocese of Dublin, told the principal in recent weeks that the move was not possible on the basis that a 'school cannot appoint a mainstream teacher and pay via private funds', records show. The school, meanwhile, has told parents that several appeals against the reduction in teacher numbers were unsuccessful and that every effort had been made to make the transition to amalgamated classes as 'smooth as possible'. It said the arrangement was for one year only, as the school's enrolment figures have since rebounded, and it will regain a teacher in September 2026. A letter to Minister for Education Helen McEntee , signed by 237 parents, says the planned class sizes for first class pupils are 'too large' and increase the potential for 'negative impacts on learning quality and the teaching environment for students'. The letter states that enlarged classes will also 'further reduce the available special education teaching resources to an unacceptably low level'. A spokesman for the Department of Education said pupil enrolments on the previous September 30th are the key factor for determining staff resources at schools. While an appeal by the school had been considered by an independent primary staffing appeals board, it was unsuccessful. The board's decision is final. 'The configuration of classes and the deployment of classroom teachers are done at local school level,' the spokesperson added. 'The department's guidance to schools is that the number of pupils in any class is kept as low as possible, taking all relevant contextual factors into account [eg, classroom accommodation, fluctuating enrolment, etc].' Parents' representatives met the school principal and chair of the board on June 19th last to express their concerns over the move. Minutes of the meeting show parents asked the school to provide further communication so all information could be 'properly conveyed' to the wider school community. However, the school declined and said that they had been advised by Catholic school managers 'not to have a public meeting', according to minutes of a meeting on June 19th last. Mr Broderick, meanwhile, said many parents were worried that the new arrangement would disrupt and dilute children's education, but felt their concerns were not being listened to by those in authority.
Irish Times
13 hours ago
- Irish Times
Smaller apartments, with fewer features, to be allowed in attempt to tackle housing crisis
New guidelines to allow for smaller apartments and higher numbers of small units in individual developments are likely to be approved by the Government this week in a bid to cut the costs of apartment construction and reduce prices for buyers. The measures, reported in The Irish Times last month , are to be brought to the Cabinet by Minister for Housing James Browne . Mr Browne said the steps were among measures being introduced by him this summer to prompt a 'radical step-change' in the supply of housing. A new housing plan, he said, would be presented by Government as soon as possible, though that is not expected until after the updated National Development Plan is agreed later this month. Government sources expect the housing plan will not be ready until autumn. READ MORE The new rules for apartments will not affect standards for energy ratings, disability access and fire safety, but rather focus on design stipulations that the industry has said was adding cost to development. It is expected that the minimum floor area for apartment sizes would be reduced and the requirements for design features such as dual aspects and balconies would be relaxed. Developers say that the standards they are required to build to are the highest in Europe, making Irish apartments more expensive than anywhere else. Government sources say that changing the standards will enable developers to build more apartments in individual developments, cutting the final cost and leading to cheaper prices for purchasers. They hope that the measures could cut the final cost of apartments by between €50,000 and €100,000 each. The Government has repeatedly indicated that central to its housing strategy is an effort to attract more private investment into the market. Declining private investment has seen a slump in the number of apartments being built, especially in Dublin. 'We've been way too cautious and way too against getting the private sector involved,' Mr Browne told RTÉ One's The Week in Politics on Sunday. But Sinn Féin's housing spokesperson Eoin Ó Broin condemned the latest plans to change apartment standards as 'utter madness' that would do nothing to address viability challenges. He said the moves would push up the value of land and therefore developers' costs. Large crowds gathered in Dublin city on Saturday as part of an all-island housing demonstration urging the Government to act on the crisis . Led by the Community Action Tenants Union (CATU), and backed by more than 80 other trade unions and organisations, protesters marched through the city centre from the Garden of Remembrance towards Molesworth Street.
