
What can the Club World Cup tell us about the strength of leagues around the world?
Led by their chief of global football development, Arsene Wenger, the panel contains former players and coaches — with Esteban Cambiasso, Aliou Cisse, Tobin Heath, Jurgen Klinsmann, Roberto Martinez, Gilberto Silva and Pascal Zuberbuhler unpicking the key insights from each game.
Advertisement
A recent media release from the TSG saw the panel offer their views on the tournament at the midway stage, and the conclusions were rather… jarring in places.
'The competition is much tighter than expected. We wanted to create this Club World Cup to give the big clubs from all over the world the opportunity to come here,' said Wenger. 'It looks like it's the start of something that will never stop again.'
Yes, it is FIFA's job to promote the success of the tournament — even if some of what they are saying comes across as downright propaganda. In mitigation, the competition has not been without its significant moments — with Inter Miami's 2-1 group-stage victory over Porto soon followed up by Botafogo's 1-0 win over European champions Paris Saint-Germain (though the French club did heavily rotate for the match).
The Brazilian sides have been particularly impressive this summer, with Flamengo seeing off Chelsea in the group stage, before Fluminense's last-16 win over Inter Milan and subsequent victory over Al Hilal further highlighting the fact that clubs from the biggest country in South America should not be underestimated.
The most notable triumph was Saudi Arabian side Al Hilal's last-16 victory over Manchester City, in a game that accrued the highest cumulative expected goals (xG) in the competition so far — with 47 shots to feast your eyes on across the 120-plus minutes.
Did Al Hilal deserve the victory? Yes. Does that make Simone Inzaghi's side a better team than Pep Guardiola's? Well, no — football does not work in a ladder system where rankings swap if one team beats another.
Does it make the Saudi Pro League better than the Premier League? Again, not quite — even if Cristiano Ronaldo's recent comments might have you believe it.
Al Hilal's celebrations were ultimately short-lived, after Renato Gaucho's Fluminense beat them 2-1 in the quarter-finals and in doing so became the only non-European team to make the last four of the tournament.
Advertisement
In some ways, this backs up FIFA's media release that states this summer's tournament has 'shown that high-quality football is played all over the world'.
This is a sentiment shared by Real Madrid head coach Xabi Alonso. 'The (Club) World Cup is showing us the high level of competition in other leagues,' Alonso said ahead of Madrid's quarter-final with Borussia Dortmund. 'Maybe we Europeans are not so familiar with it. The Saudi, Brazilian and even the Argentinian leagues. Sometimes in Europe we are too 'Championsised''.
That is true to an extent. We should not ignore how good certain clubs are across global football, but what these isolated cases in a summer tournament can teach us about the quality of leagues across the world is another question altogether.
Do FIFA's conclusions live and die within the confines of the competition itself? Or can we extrapolate each team's performances as indicative of their league's strength?
As The Athletic has previously analysed, footballing inequality can exist within any country, such that the strength of the best teams does not always represent the competitiveness, or quality, of the entire league itself — think Celtic and Rangers in the Scottish Premiership.
Using data from Twenty First Group, a sports intelligence firm that advises clubs, leagues and investors, we can look at the spread in quality across selected leagues whose teams have reached the latter stages of the Club World Cup — and we have thrown MLS in there for good measure.
Twenty First Group's World Super League model uses a machine-learning algorithm to generate a single rating for every team in world football. League strength can then be calculated from the average rating of each team.
As you can see below, there is plenty of spread across each league, but some clubs separate themselves from the pack more than others.
The Brazilian league is an interesting case. 'We currently rate Brazil's Serie A as the sixth-best league globally, so we expected the four Brazilian teams to be competitive pre-tournament,' said Twenty First Group's Senior Data Scientist, Aurel Nazmiu.
Crucially, it is not just the strength of the league but the compact distribution of teams within the Brazilian top flight that highlights the competitiveness of the division from top to bottom. As the strongest teams in the league, Palmeiras and Flamengo are not worlds apart from Juventude — the lowest-rated team.
Advertisement
This is made clear when comparing the 'standard deviation' of team ratings across each league. This statistical term simply looks at the variability of a set of numbers. The larger the standard deviation, the more spread out the ratings are within the respective league.
Owing to the salary-cap system in the United States, MLS comes out with the lowest standard deviation and the highest competitiveness statistically. A close second is the Brazilian league, which can give us confidence that this summer's impressive performances by its four representatives at the tournament are proof of the quality of its league.
By contrast, the Saudi Pro League has the highest standard deviation across the division, with the riches of Al Hilal — and their fellow three clubs controlled by Saudi Arabia's Public Investment Fund (PIF) — dwarfing others within the country.
'Although we rate the Saudi Pro League as the 50th-best league globally, Al Hilal are significantly better than the rest of the league at the moment — ranked 132nd in the world in our models,' Nazmiu says. ' For context, the second-best Saudi team, Al Ahli, are much lower at 279.'
Among the top 50 leagues worldwide, the Saudi Pro League is ranked as the fifth-most unequal in terms of quality.
Contrast Al Hilal's global ranking of 132nd — sandwiched between the Bundesliga's Union Berlin and Spain's Las Palmas — with the lowest-ranked team in the Saudi Pro League in 2024-25, Al Orobah, who come in at 2,405th in the world. Al Orobah finished 17th last season with an average attendance of 2,307, lower than the average at Barnet (2,315) in England's fifth tier in 2024-25.
So Al Hilal's success this summer does not yet prove that the quality of the entire Saudi Pro League is on the rise.
Of course, European football is not exempt from such inequality, with Paris Saint-Germain dominant in France and the Portuguese trio of Benfica, Porto and Sporting CP dominating their top flight. You could very easily throw Bayern Munich in Germany into that argument across a 10-year window.
FIFA president Gianni Infantino said that 'a new era of football has definitely started' on social media after Al Hilal's victory over Manchester City last week — but is that an accurate declaration?
Yes, there has been some excellent football on show and some memorable support from die-hard fans who have made the journey from around the world. There has been drama, shocks, and some notable upsets.
However, to use this tournament as an advertisement for the increased competitiveness of the global game might just be a stretch too far.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Times
30 minutes ago
- New York Times
Sudan soccer league returns despite ongoing Civil War
Sudan's soccer league has returned to the country for the first time since civil war broke out in 2023. The Sudan Football Association (SFA) has organised the eight-team Sudan Elite League, which will be played over the course of one month and which will determine the Sudanese clubs to compete in continental club competition for the 2025-26 season. Advertisement Sudanese rivals Al Hilal and Al Merrikh — who have between them won 49 of the previous 53 league titles — have both been temporarily playing league football in Mauritania, in north west Africa, due to the unstable political situation in Sudan. Last season, Al Hilal were CAF Champions League quarter-finalists and won Super D1, the top division of Mauritanian football, in 2024-25 with Al Merrikh finishing sixth. However, this did not allow either club to qualify for continental competition, with second-place FC Nouadhibou qualifying for the CAF Champions League courtesy of them being the top ranking Mauritanian side. The league started on Friday, July 4, with Al Hilal defeating Al Mirigani 2-0 while Al Merrikh beat Al Hali Madani 1-0. The derby between Al Hilal and Al Merrikh is set for the last day of competition on July 22, with Hay Al Wadi, Al Zamala, Al Amal Atbara and Marikh Al Obeid the other competing clubs. No matches are being staged in the capital Khartoum, which has been badly damaged by the civil war, with games instead being played at Atbara, 320km north of Khartoum, and Ad-Damer, 430km to the north east of the capital. Sudan, a nation in north east Africa of over 48million people, has been wracked by civil war between the Sudanese Armed Forces and the paramilitary Rapid Support Forces since April 2023. Precise casualty figures are difficult to establish, with more than 150,000 people killed and around 12 million others displaced. Local media have reported over 500,000 children have died due to malnutrition. Widespread hunger, famine, and disease outbreaks have been reported to the United Nations Security Council. In October 2024, UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres said the Sudanese population were trapped in a 'nightmare of violence, hunger, disease and displacement' and said almost 25m people in the country were in need of humanitarian assistance. Advertisement In November, Sudan secured qualification for the 2025 Africa Cup of Nations (AFCON) despite the nation's ongoing civil war. Sudan won AFCON when they hosted the tournament in 1970, but have advanced beyond the group stage of the competition only once and have qualified for just four of the most recent 25 editions of the tournament. Morocco will host the next AFCON which is scheduled to begin on December 21, 2025 and run until January 18, 2026. (Top image of Sudanese side Al Hilal: Mahmoud Hjaj/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)


New York Post
31 minutes ago
- New York Post
FIFA slashes ticket prices for Chelsea-Fluminense Club World Cup semifinal at MetLife Stadium
EAST RUTHERFORD, N.J. — FIFA cut standard ticket prices for the semifinal between Chelsea and Fluminense at MetLife Stadium in East Rutherford, New Jersey, on Tuesday to $13.40 from $473.90 earlier in the past week. FIFA has used dynamic pricing for the 63-game tournament. The cheapest tickets as of Monday morning were $22.30. Advertisement 3 MetLife Stadium, which hosted the Real Madrid-Borussia Dortmund quarterfinal, is hosting the FIFA Club World Cup semifinals and final. FIFA via Getty Images Standard ticket prices for Wednesday's semifinal between European champion Paris Saint-Germain and Real Madrid in New Jersey start at $199.60. FIFA had dropped ticket prices to $11.15 for a quarterfinal in Orlando, Florida, between Fluminense and Al Hilal. and in Philadelphia between Chelsea and Palmeiras. Advertisement 3 Pedro Neto of Chelsea in action during the FIFA Club World Cup quarter-final game between Palmeiras and Chelsea on July 4, 2025. Anadolu via Getty Images 3 Hercules of Fluminense FC celebrates after winning the FIFA Club World Cup 2025 quarter final match between Fluminense FC and Al Hilal on July 4, 2025. FIFA via Getty Images The dramatic drop in prices was first reported by The Athletic. Many matches during the tournament have had sparse crowds. Real Madrid has been an exception, drawing at least 60,000 for all five of its matches, including 76,611 for its quarterfinal win Saturday over Borussia Dortmund in New Jersey.
Yahoo
40 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Roma consider summer move for Brighton midfielder
Roma Exploring Move for Brighton Midfielder Matt O'Riley Roma reignite interest in Premier League talent According to La Gazzetta Dello Sport, Roma are exploring the possibility of signing Brighton midfielder Matt O'Riley this summer. The report suggests that Roma head coach Daniele De Rossi is a long-time admirer of the Denmark international, with his interest tracing back to Gasperini's desire to sign O'Riley during his Atalanta days. Photo IMAGO Advertisement Roma are said to be 'trying to understand if there is room to start a negotiation with Brighton', who remain guarded about parting with one of their more consistent performers. The 23-year-old enjoyed a strong campaign in 2023–24 and remains under contract with the Seagulls. Brighton's stance is currently unclear, but Roma are expected to test the waters in the coming weeks. Our View – EPL Index Analysis Reports linking Matt O'Riley with a move away will cause understandable concern for Brighton supporters. At a time when the club is seeking stability and a clearer identity under new leadership, losing a composed, technically intelligent midfielder would feel like another step backward. O'Riley has grown into a reliable figure in the Brighton engine room, capable of dictating tempo and offering composure in high-pressure moments. His tactical discipline and underrated passing range have allowed others to play with freedom, which makes his potential departure particularly damaging. Advertisement Moreover, if this interest from Roma becomes formal, there is always the risk that a player's head could be turned. Trigoria is an attractive destination, especially under De Rossi, who knows how to inspire confidence in young talent. Tthe bigger question is whether Brighton can genuinely compete in keeping their top assets when foreign clubs come calling. This summer should have been about building on the club's identity, not further chipping away at it. Losing O'Riley might suggest that the cycle that brought European football to the Amex has reached an uncertain turning point.