Live Aid at 40: Hope, hype and hard questions – DW – 07/11/2025

DW

11-07-2025

Though often seen as a moment of unity, Live Aid wasn't devoid of cultural blind spots. What is today's view of the global gig that made history?
"It's 12 noon in London, 7 a.m. in Philadelphia, and around the world it's time for Live Aid."
This television announcement on July 13, 1985, heralded over 16 hours of music that united close to 2 billion people across over 100 countries.
Live Aid was no ordinary gig. With the primary aim of raising funds for famine relief in then drought-stricken Ethiopia, it was the largest satellite link-up and television broadcast of its time.
It featured an unprecedented lineup of music's biggest names across diverse genres, featuring luminaries — some since departed like Freddie Mercury, David Bowie and Tina Turner— all of whom performed for free.
Held simultaneously between Wembley Stadium in London and JFK Stadium in Philadelphia, people around the world watched agog as Mercury cued Wembley's 72,000 fans with those iconic overhead claps during the chorus of Queen's 1984 hit "Radio Ga Ga"; as U2's Bono jumped off-stage and danced with a teenage fan; as Bob Geldof impassionedly urged viewers to donate money.
And to set the record straight about the oft-repeated Live Aid lore: Sir Bob said, "Give us your f***ing money." He was misquoted.
Conceived and executed by Irish musician Geldof and Ultravox's Midge Ure, Live Aid was put together at astonishing speed, the momentum having come from the 1984 Band Aid single "Do They Know It's Christmas?," a now-contentious song that they also co-wrote.
Ure later recalled to how much of the Live Aid planning unfolded on instinct and goodwill rather than strategy or budget. Consequently, it set a template that was later emulated by events like Farm Aid (1985), Live 8 (2005) and Live Earth (2007).
Speaking in 2004 when a DVD box set of the event was launched, Geldof said: "We took an issue that was nowhere on the political agenda and, through the lingua franca of the planet — which is not English, but rock 'n' roll — we were able to address the intellectual absurdity and the moral repulsion of people dying of want in a world of surplus."
While many boomers and Gen Xers may still recall Live Aid fondly as a unique moment of global unity pre-social media, in retrospect it wasn't without its flaws. Especially when viewed through the lens of diversity and representation.
Despite being a benefit for Africa, no African performers were featured on stage in 1985. Ditto female representation, where aside from Sade, Tina Turner, Madonna and Patti LaBelle, the line-up was overwhelmingly white and male.
Geldof defended the choices, saying the artists were selected based on their star pull to maximize donations.
In 2005, Geldof organized Live 8 — a series of concerts that coincided with the G8 summit that aimed to get leaders of the eight major industrialized countries to "Make Poverty History" — but it wasn't representative again. The original line-up featured only Senegalese singer Youssou N'Dour, with Geldof trotting out the star bankability trope again.
Andy Kershaw, the DJ who helped with the TV presentation of Live Aid, said: "This is outrageous and deeply smug. They are saying, 'Don't neglect Africa' — but that's just what they are doing here."
Subsequently, the Africa Calling concert was organized. Hosted by N'Dour, it featured prominent African artists like Somali singer Maryam Mursal and Beninese vocalist Angelique Kidjo.
Moky Makura, executive director of Africa No Filter, was in her late teens when she watched the original concert. She wrote in in 2023, "As a Nigerian born in Lagos and educated in the UK, it took me a moment to realize that the version of Africa that Live Aid was selling the world was very different to the one in which I grew up."
She added, "Live Aid remains the unfortunate and inadvertent poster child for a development approach to Africa that still drives much of the sector today; the desire to identify and fix the challenges of poor countries and the belief that money is the primary solution."
Consequently, Geldof has often been described as having a "white savior complex," which he rejects.
Dismissing a critical comment in last year about how some viewed Live Aid as reinforcing "a patronizing image of Africa as a continent desperate for, and dependent on, Western aid," Geldof retorted that it was "the greatest load of b****cks ever."
Live Aid did raise millions for famine relief, with some political ripple effects. It inspired the set-up of the US President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief (PEPFAR) in 2003. The program was recently gutted following Trump's financial cuts.
A current documentary, "Live Aid at 40: When Rock N Roll Took On The World," also reveals how Geldof's, and fellow Irishman Bono's, relentless lobbying of G8 leaders saw them eventually agree to cancel $40 billion of debt owed by 18 of the world's poorest countries after Live 8, and promise to increase aid to developing nations by $50 billion a year by 2010.
Meanwhile, 73-year-old Geldof, who is currently doing the interview circuit commemorating Live Aid's 40th anniversary, doubts the ethos of Live Aid can be replicated in the age of social media.
"It's an isolating technology, unlike rock 'n' roll which is a gathering technology," Geldof told NME. Condemning a recent statement by Elon Musk that the "great weakness of Western civilization was empathy," he said: "No Elon, the glue of civilization is empathy. We're in the age of the death of kindness, and I object."
But the rocker remains hopeful: "You can change things, you really can actually change things … the individual isn't powerless, and collectively, you really can change things."