Retail traders provide liquidity but need guardrails, warns Sunil Subramaniam
ADVERTISEMENT Not once, not twice, but for as long as markets have existed, we know that trading, over the long term, does not create wealth. It only destroys it, causes stress, and impacts an individual's overall wealth positioning. So, if the data clearly shows that trading is not favorable for retail investors, why is this activity still growing?
Sunil Subramaniam: I like that you called it 'activity' and not 'investing,' which is a mistake many people make.
I chose my words carefully. SIP is investing; trading is activity.
Sunil Subramaniam: Exactly. What we're seeing is the gambling instinct in people. It's clear. In the absence of widespread lotteries or casinos across India, trading has become a vehicle for people to indulge that instinct. And when you look at it from that lens, in gambling, the house always wins—the casino wins, the lottery provider wins. So, it's not surprising.
Now, regarding these losses—it's not that every single trade results in a loss. Traders win sometimes, but overall, they lose more. Ask any gambler: the more they lose, the more they bet. That's the core of gambling—chasing one big trade to wipe out all past losses. That's human nature, and you can't go against it.Given that context, two points come up. First, SEBI has been consistent in highlighting the risks and simplifying things to reduce potential losses. Around 20 lakh people have already stopped trading—from 60 lakh down to about 41 lakh. That's a positive move—a 27–30% drop. It shows that people are learning or becoming more cautious. Hopefully, next year, we'll see further decline.Second, we cannot ignore the Jane Street episode. Under normal circumstances, odds are already stacked against retail traders, but over the past couple of years, we've seen what could be described as price rigging—especially in the index. That's worsened the situation. Investigations have not stopped at just one player. Other HFTs are being examined too, which is encouraging.
ADVERTISEMENT So, next year's data may show not just fewer traders due to fear or awareness, but also a possible decline in the total losses. And one final point: we tend to treat these people as the black sheep, saying they're reckless. But they provide essential liquidity to the market. As a developing market, India still lacks deep liquidity across segments. These retail participants help build that liquidity.Of course, we must make it safer for them. They need to understand the risks, avoid chasing losses, and practice risk management. Brokers also have a role here. Instead of banning such trading, we should focus on educating participants. Financial literacy is key. Regulators should also crack down on bad actors, especially institutions.
ADVERTISEMENT Yes, 91% are losing money, but the number of such participants has come down. Those who remain are typically the more aggressive gamblers, which explains why per-person and total losses have reached ₹1 lakh crore. SEBI will likely take further action. Many recent changes are still playing out. But overall, we have a proactive regulator, willing to take on big players and educate the public. There's only so much more SEBI can do, but they're doing an excellent job.
Over time, I believe more retail investors will shift away from gambling-based trading and towards informed investing. That's where AMCs and mutual fund distributors must step in. We have more than twice the number of Demat accounts compared to unique mutual fund folios. These people must be targeted for education—teach them that while risk exists, it can be managed with diversification and professional advice.
ADVERTISEMENT This is all part of a long journey. As a developing market, we will face these teething problems. But they're necessary steps toward building a healthy, well-regulated, deep capital market.
One observation—the total loss figure has actually come down in Q4. Perhaps that's due to SEBI's curbs on weekly expiries. What more can the regulator do to curb the temptation of this so-called 'activity'?
Sunil Subramaniam: I'm currently based in Singapore, and here we have Marina Bay Sands—the casino. What do they do? They track people who've incurred heavy losses and ban them because their behavior becomes addictive.
ADVERTISEMENT Similarly, in India, all these people trade through brokers who are regulated by SEBI. SEBI must act through brokers—track investors' behavior. If someone is consistently throwing in large sums to recover losses, they should be restricted. Many of their families may not even know how much is being risked. So, brokers need to play a role—either voluntarily or through regulation.Also, finfluencers are a big factor influencing retail traders. Regulating finfluencers and ensuring that brokers communicate risks—not just rewards—is critical. They must not oversell the idea of potential profits while ignoring the downside.
But what more can the regulator do to reduce this kind of participation from traders? Equity penetration in India is still in single digits, compared to developed countries. Yet the number of traders is growing exponentially.
Sunil Subramaniam: I wouldn't say we need to discourage this. When capital market penetration expands, more people will come in. The issue is whether they enter as investors or as traders. That's where the challenge lies. SEBI, just like the mutual fund industry allocates 2 basis points for investor awareness, should enforce a similar model for brokers. A portion of brokerage revenue should be used for financial literacy campaigns. Ultimately, people must be taught to enter the capital markets the right way.Today, many enter via Demat accounts and directly into equities, only later transitioning to mutual funds. That's not ideal. Education must come first.But curbing entry outright isn't the answer. These traders do provide liquidity. They also get to channel their gambling instinct in a regulated environment. So yes, we must regulate and guide—but not ban.For me, financial literacy is the top priority. Secondly, SEBI has advanced AI tools—that's how they uncovered Jane Street's role. Those tools can be used to study investor behavior: how losses impact decision-making, whether risk-taking increases, etc. Understanding emotional and behavioral patterns is essential.As a regulator, SEBI is already doing well—cracking down on institutional manipulation, reducing trading days, aligning expiry dates—all good steps. But the ultimate balance is this: bring more people into markets, but guide them to do it right—not through speculation but long-term investing.
There are no easy fixes. But we need to keep moving forward. Equity participation must increase—but so must education, awareness, and regulation.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Sebi's bond central to deepen corporate bond market, improve price discovery: Vineet Agrawal
India's corporate bond market is set for a major revamp with the launch of Bond Central , a Sebi- and OBPP-backed platform aimed at creating a centralized, transparent database for bond issuances. The initiative is designed to simplify access to pricing, risk metrics, and disclosures for both retail and institutional investors. By reducing information gaps and lowering the minimum investment threshold to Rs 10,000, Bond Central is expected to drive greater retail participation, improve price discovery, and align India's bond infrastructure with global standards such as FINRA TRACE. With the launch of Bond Central, a Sebi-OBPP initiative to aid investors in the fixed-income market, Vineet Agrawal , Co-Founder of Jiraaf, shared his insights with ETMarkets: Bonds Corner Powered By Sebi's bond central to deepen corporate bond market, improve price discovery: Vineet Agrawal SEBI and OBPP have launched Bond Central, a centralized bond database aimed at boosting transparency and retail participation in India's corporate bond market. The platform offers easy access to pricing, risk metrics, and disclosures, while lowering the minimum investment to Rs 10,000. Experts say it could align India's market infrastructure with global standards and deepen fixed-income penetration. ETMarkets Smart Talk: Fixed income still has a place in FY26 - 15–20% allocation ideal for most, 70% for seniors, says Aamar Deo Singh India's Rs 50 lakh crore bond market grows, but retail investors still sit on the sidelines: Experts Adani Enterprises' Rs 500-crore NCD issue oversubscribed 3x Adani Enterprises' public debt issue oversubscribed on launch day, bankers say Browse all Bonds News with What are the primary objectives behind Sebi's initiative with OBPP to launch Bond Central? How does it benefit the fixed-income market in India? Sebi's stakeholders launched Bond Central to offer a single, centralized database of corporate bond issuances—including listing terms, pricing, risk metrics, and documents—accessible to both retail and institutional investors. By reducing information asymmetry, the initiative aims to foster greater transparency, build market confidence, and drive increased retail participation, which has historically been low. Could you explain how Bond Central will streamline bond market activities and help investors access bonds more efficiently? Bond Central aggregates listings from exchanges and issuers, enabling users to discover, compare, and evaluate bonds in one convenient location. It includes price comparisons with government securities (G-Secs) and fixed-income indices, supported by disclosures and risk insights. This simplifies decision-making and reduces reliance on multiple platforms. Live Events How will this initiative enhance liquidity and transparency in the Indian bond market? By publishing standardized data—including real-time pricing, yield, and credit risk—Bond Central helps reduce opacity in the secondary market. Better visibility supports improved price discovery and attracts more participants, thereby enhancing market liquidity over time. What impact do you foresee this Bond Central initiative having on retail investors and their participation in fixed-income products? Lowering the minimum investment threshold from Rs 1,00,000 to Rs 10,000 via OBPP platforms, combined with access to uniform bond information, democratizes market entry for retail investors. This will likely boost retail volumes, deepen market access, and narrow the participation gap between institutional and individual investors. Can you discuss the potential risks and challenges involved in this initiative and how Sebi and OBPP plan to address them? Key challenges include ensuring data accuracy, timely updates, and investor awareness of bond risk profiles. Sebi and OBPP aim to mitigate these through standardized disclosures, a strong governance framework under a non-profit model, and targeted investor education campaigns via the platform. In what ways can this move contribute to the development of a more vibrant corporate bond market in India? Improved transparency, easier access, and broader investor participation will encourage corporate issuers. As demand from retail investors rises, issuers may increasingly tap into this pool, creating a positive feedback loop. Streamlined issuance and distribution mechanisms will further support market vibrancy. How does this Bond Central initiative compare to similar initiatives in global markets, and what lessons can India learn from them? Bond Central aligns with global systems like the U.S. FINRA TRACE, which consolidates post-trade bond data to promote transparency. India can adopt best practices around real-time trade reporting, regulatory oversight, and compliance standards from such mature platforms. Do you think the introduction of a centralized bond platform will attract more foreign institutional investors (FIIs) to India's bond market? Why or why not? Yes. FIIs value rich, standardized, and reliable data. A centralized platform reduces market opacity and settlement friction, enhancing India's appeal. That said, FIIs will also consider other factors such as currency risk, regulatory clarity, and ease of capital movement. What role do digitalization and technological advancements play in making Bond Central a success, and what kind of infrastructure is required to support it? The success of Bond Central depends on robust digital infrastructure, real-time data feeds from exchanges and depositories, and APIs for seamless OBPP integration. Looking ahead, advanced analytics, AI-driven tools, and investor education features will be key to maximizing its utility. What advice would you give to investors looking to capitalize on this new development in India's bond market, especially in the context of changing interest rates and inflation? Utilize transparency: Compare corporate bonds with G-Secs to assess value and risk. Diversify: Spread investments across issuers and tenors to manage credit and interest rate risks. Stay informed: Monitor repo rate changes (currently 5.5%) and inflation trends. Match duration: Align bond maturity with your investment horizon and liquidity needs. Use tools: Leverage Bond Central's analytics and disclosures for informed decision-making.


Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Sebi's bond central to deepen corporate bond market, improve price discovery: Vineet Agrawal
What are the primary objectives behind Sebi's initiative with OBPP to launch Bond Central? How does it benefit the fixed-income market in India? Could you explain how Bond Central will streamline bond market activities and help investors access bonds more efficiently? Live Events How will this initiative enhance liquidity and transparency in the Indian bond market? What impact do you foresee this Bond Central initiative having on retail investors and their participation in fixed-income products? Can you discuss the potential risks and challenges involved in this initiative and how Sebi and OBPP plan to address them? In what ways can this move contribute to the development of a more vibrant corporate bond market in India? How does this Bond Central initiative compare to similar initiatives in global markets, and what lessons can India learn from them? Do you think the introduction of a centralized bond platform will attract more foreign institutional investors (FIIs) to India's bond market? Why or why not? What role do digitalization and technological advancements play in making Bond Central a success, and what kind of infrastructure is required to support it? What advice would you give to investors looking to capitalize on this new development in India's bond market, especially in the context of changing interest rates and inflation? Utilize transparency: Compare corporate bonds with G-Secs to assess value and risk. Compare corporate bonds with G-Secs to assess value and risk. Diversify: Spread investments across issuers and tenors to manage credit and interest rate risks. Spread investments across issuers and tenors to manage credit and interest rate risks. Stay informed: Monitor repo rate changes (currently 5.5%) and inflation trends. Monitor repo rate changes (currently 5.5%) and inflation trends. Match duration: Align bond maturity with your investment horizon and liquidity needs. Align bond maturity with your investment horizon and liquidity needs. Use tools: Leverage Bond Central's analytics and disclosures for informed decision-making. (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel India's corporate bond market is set for a major revamp with the launch of Bond Central , a Sebi- and OBPP-backed platform aimed at creating a centralized, transparent database for bond issuances. The initiative is designed to simplify access to pricing, risk metrics, and disclosures for both retail and institutional reducing information gaps and lowering the minimum investment threshold to Rs 10,000, Bond Central is expected to drive greater retail participation, improve price discovery, and align India's bond infrastructure with global standards such as FINRA the launch of Bond Central, a Sebi-OBPP initiative to aid investors in the fixed-income market, Vineet Agrawal , Co-Founder of Jiraaf, shared his insights with ETMarkets:Sebi's stakeholders launched Bond Central to offer a single, centralized database of corporate bond issuances—including listing terms, pricing, risk metrics, and documents—accessible to both retail and institutional investors. By reducing information asymmetry, the initiative aims to foster greater transparency, build market confidence, and drive increased retail participation, which has historically been Central aggregates listings from exchanges and issuers, enabling users to discover, compare, and evaluate bonds in one convenient location. It includes price comparisons with government securities (G-Secs) and fixed-income indices, supported by disclosures and risk insights. This simplifies decision-making and reduces reliance on multiple publishing standardized data—including real-time pricing, yield, and credit risk—Bond Central helps reduce opacity in the secondary market. Better visibility supports improved price discovery and attracts more participants, thereby enhancing market liquidity over the minimum investment threshold from Rs 1,00,000 to Rs 10,000 via OBPP platforms, combined with access to uniform bond information, democratizes market entry for retail investors. This will likely boost retail volumes, deepen market access, and narrow the participation gap between institutional and individual challenges include ensuring data accuracy, timely updates, and investor awareness of bond risk profiles. Sebi and OBPP aim to mitigate these through standardized disclosures, a strong governance framework under a non-profit model, and targeted investor education campaigns via the transparency, easier access, and broader investor participation will encourage corporate issuers. As demand from retail investors rises, issuers may increasingly tap into this pool, creating a positive feedback loop. Streamlined issuance and distribution mechanisms will further support market Central aligns with global systems like the U.S. FINRA TRACE, which consolidates post-trade bond data to promote transparency. India can adopt best practices around real-time trade reporting, regulatory oversight, and compliance standards from such mature FIIs value rich, standardized, and reliable data. A centralized platform reduces market opacity and settlement friction, enhancing India's appeal. That said, FIIs will also consider other factors such as currency risk, regulatory clarity, and ease of capital success of Bond Central depends on robust digital infrastructure, real-time data feeds from exchanges and depositories, and APIs for seamless OBPP integration. Looking ahead, advanced analytics, AI-driven tools, and investor education features will be key to maximizing its utility.


Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Shankar Sharma slams high options trading costs in India, calls it 'frightfully expensive'
Live Events (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our ETMarkets WhatsApp channel Veteran investor Shankar Sharma has raised concerns over the high cost of options trading in India, calling it "frightfully expensive" compared to global markets. In a tweet, the GQuant and First Global founder said that trading charges in India significantly erode investor returns."One thing I can categorically say: trading options in India is frightfully expensive compared to other markets (I do both). Trading charges in India eat away returns massively," Sharma tweeted on to a structural issue, Sharma highlighted that the exchanges' strong profitability is fueled by these high fees. "That goes to SE bottomlines, out of investors' pockets," he wrote, referring to near-monopoly exchanges like NSE and BSE in the Indian capital markets."Total misuse of monopolistic gift by GOI. I'm clear: Monopolies must have regulated profits. Not unfettered profiteering," Sharma this, a Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) study finds that India continues to see a relatively very high level of trading in the Equity Derivatives Segment (EDS), compared to other markets, particularly in index comment follows the recent report by Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) study that said that nearly 91% of individual traders incurred net loss in the equity derivatives segment (EDS) in FY25 at the aggregate level, similar to the trends observed in FY24. The net losses of individual traders widened by 41% to Rs 1.05 lakh crore in FY25 from Rs 74,812 crore in Thursday, even Kotak Mahindra Bank 's Founder and Director Uday Kotak on Wednesday had highlighted the global market share of Indian in options trading. Kotak said that India's share in the number of contracts in index and stock options is a staggering 80% of the Read: India has staggering 80% market share in global index, stock options: Uday Kotak The Sebi study also said that nearly 91% of individual traders incurred net loss in the equity derivatives segment (EDS) in FY25 at the aggregate level, similar to the trends observed in FY24. The net losses of individual traders widened by 41% to Rs 1.05 lakh crore in FY25 from Rs 74,812 crore in FY24.