Octopus Energy and Scottish Power in row over zonal pricing
Octopus Energy has said repeatedly that such a system could mean Scots benefit from some of the lowest energy prices in Europe.
But the UK Government has said it will not split the country's energy market into regions if it raises people's bills in some areas.
A decision on the issue is expected to be made in the coming weeks.
READ MORE: Scottish households will pay more for energy than London, data says
Anderson is set to tell delegates at the All-Energy trade show in Glasgow and "it is important the government is careful not to snatch defeat from the jaws of victory", urging ministers not to "derail the stable policy framework that attracts that capital".
Anderson will say: "Don't tamper with a system that works. Policy uncertainty on big market reforms such as zonal pricing does not help in this regard."
Jackson (below) has said the argument from Scottish Power is "astonishing".
(Image: Tony Blair Institute for Global Change) He posted on Twitter/X: "It's astonishing to see an energy boss saying this is a 'system that works'. It may work for incumbent energy generators but it doesn't work for households or businesses struggling with Europe's highest energy costs.
"The case for reform is clear."
Despite claims zonal pricing would turn the UK energy market into a postcode lottery, analysis showed last month households in Scotland will already be paying more for electricity in the next year than those living in London.
READ MORE: John Swinney won't pick side as energy giants debate zonal pricing
Consumers in north Wales and Merseyside will pay £120 more than households in London for their electricity over the coming year, Cornwall Insight forecasts, while those in the north of Scotland will pay £96 more than those in the capital.
The large differentials stem from variation in the charges levied on bills to fund the upkeep of Britain's 14 regional electricity distribution networks, which are regulated by Ofgem.
The headline figure for the energy price cap on standard tariffs, which stands at £1849 a year at present, is a national average that masks such regional differentials.
Octopus Energy's director for regulation Rachel Fletcher told the Sunday National earlier this year the arguments being made against zonal are 'overblown', adding the single wholesale price setup in the UK is 'bonkers and broken'.
At the moment, Britain has one national energy price even though at any point in the day the cost of producing electricity differs radically around the country.
READ MORE: Scots could get free electricity from zonal pricing, Octopus Energy boss says
If an offshore wind farm in Scotland produces more electricity than the network can handle it is paid to turn off, or "constrained", and a gas-fired power plant in the south of England is paid to turn on.
The constraint costs – which are collected from consumers – are huge and in 2022/23 they amounted to £1.5 billion and are projected to rise to £3.7bn by 2030, something Octopus considers a 'staggering waste of electricity'.
Fletcher said the system is only going to become more wasteful as time goes on, and while she believes a zonal pricing system needs to be designed 'carefully', she said it makes logical sense to make the transition.
Fletcher insisted there is plenty of evidence internationally of zonal pricing markets being extremely successful in attracting renewable investment, so there is no reason to believe that can't be replicated in the UK.
She said: 'The international evidence does not support the idea that zonal would be a disaster for renewable investment.
"It is untenable to say that zonal is incompatible with investment in renewables.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
23 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
John Swinney ‘could be in danger of losing his Holyrood constituency seat' if people vote tactically
The First Minister is facing a renewed challenge from veteran Tory Murdo Fraser next year SWINNERS & LOSERS John Swinney 'could be in danger of losing his Holyrood constituency seat' if people vote tactically Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) JOHN Swinney could be in danger of losing his Holyrood constituency seat if people vote tactically, a top pollster has claimed. The First Minister is facing a renewed challenge from veteran Tory Murdo Fraser in Perthshire North next year. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 The First Minister could be in danger of losing his Holyrood constituency seat if people vote tactically, a top pollster claims Credit: Michael Schofield 2 Analysis professional Mark Diffley thinks if voters snub Reform UK and Labour and cast ballots for Mr Fraser then Mr Swinney's 4,053 majority could be in jeopardy Credit: jo hanley 2020 And analysis professional Mark Diffley reckons if voters snub Reform UK and Labour and cast ballots for Mr Fraser then Mr Swinney's 4,053 majority could be in peril. Mr Diffley, of the Diffley Partnership, said: 'Tactical voting is a possibility but the Labour and Lib Dem vote shares in this seat in 2021 were negligible. 'Reform might expect to do well here and are likely to eat into Tory votes which makes the job easier for the SNP. 'The SNP took almost 50 per cent of the vote in 2021 and polls indicate that their vote share has fallen by around 15 points since, which might bring this seat into play.' Mr Fraser will be taking on Mr Swinney for a seventh time. He polled 15,807 votes compared to the First Minister's 19,860 in 2021, while Labour got 2,324. The Tory challenger said: 'Nigel Farage has already said he isn't worried about giving the SNP another five years in power. That should terrify every supporter of the Union living in John Swinney's backyard. 'If pro-UK voters in Perthshire want to deliver a verdict on the SNP leader being at the heart of 18 years of nationalist failure, then they must vote for me. 'I will be taking that message to local voters who are sick and tired of the SNP's continual focus on fringe issues, rather than delivering on the real priorities of the people.' Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay has said Mr Fraser has a 'realistic' chance of winning the seat. In his conference speech last month, he said: 'The SNP will do everything to protect John Swinney but those seats can be in play for us. Wouldn't that be some prize? Swinney paying the price for his abysmal record.' 'Sad to see him go' - GAA fans emotional seeing Michael D Higgins attend last men's All-Ireland final as President But even if Mr Swinney loses the constituency he is still likely to be elected as a regional list MSP. Mr Diffley said Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar will be hoping his party's 'unexpected' win by new MSP Davy Russell in last month's Hamilton, Larkhall and Stonehouse by-election has boosted their chances of forming a government. He added: 'The SNP is far less popular than it was at the last Holyrood election and polls show low support for the government's performance across key policy issues. 'But Labour has not capitalised on that and the national polls point, at this stage, to the likelihood of the SNP being re-elected next year. 'Many voters are disillusioned with both the UK and Scottish governments which partly explains the rise of Reform and the likelihood that they will do well next year.' Reform and Labour confirmed they will be standing in every seat but their candidates for Perthshire North have yet to be announced. A Scottish Labour spokeswoman said: 'Scotland has been badly failed by both the SNP and the Tories, and Scottish Labour will be fighting to win in every part of the country. 'Only Scottish Labour can get rid of this incompetent SNP government and deliver a new direction.' The SNP did not respond to our request for comment.
Scottish Sun
23 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Scots museum chiefs blasted after claiming all loo users will have to be gender checked
Staff will have a duty to ensure the sex of people at all taxpayer sites across Scotland LOO JOKING? Scots museum chiefs blasted after claiming all loo users will have to be gender checked Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) MUSEUMS chiefs have been blasted after claiming all loo users will have to be gender checked. Taxpayer-funded Museums and Galleries Scotland say staff will have to make sure of the sex of people at 455 sites across the country. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Gender checks will be carried out on those using toilet facilities at all tax-payer museums across Scotland 2 Scottish Tory MSP Tess White says the move would put women and girls in danger And it has criticised initial advice from the Equality and Human Rights Commission following the Supreme Court's landmark biological sex ruling. It states trans women must use male facilities and trans men female restrooms. Museums Scotland said: 'To avoid discrimination, it would require every person using toilets to be checked, adding substantial workload and staff costs. 'The guidance implies that to allow trans people to use toilets that fit their identity would put organisations at risk of legal consequences. Scottish Tory equalities spokeswoman Tess White said: 'By criticising the EHRC's guidance, Museums Scotland are flouting the law, putting women and girls in danger and laying themselves open to legal challenge. There is no excuse for evasion on this issue. 'All public bodies must immediately comply with the law.'
Telegraph
23 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Trump: wind farms are a ‘con job'
President Donald Trump branded wind power a 'con job' after playing golf in Scotland, describing how turbines ruined the view from the 18th hole of his Turnberry course. The president said wind farms spoiled the landscape and sucked in expensive subsidies in comments likely to complicate a meeting with Sir Keir Starmer on Monday. 'The whole thing is a con job. It's very expensive,' he added as he announced a trade deal with the EU. The deal includes the EU buying billions of dollars of American energy, including natural gas. Mr Trump spent Sunday morning playing golf with his son Eric and club members before sitting down for crucial European trade talks. 'Today I'm playing the best course, I think, in the world, Turnberry,' he said, in front of a giant picture window looking out on its fairways, dunes and the sea beyond. 'It's probably the best course in the world. And I look over the horizon and I see nine windmills at the end of the 18th. I said, 'Isn't that a shame?'' Mr Trump's Scotland visit is centred around his two golf clubs. On Friday, engulfed in the Epstein scandal at home, he issued an eleventh-hour invitation to Ursula von der Leyen, the European Commission president, to come to his Ayrshire golf club to try to agree a trade deal before crippling tariffs come into force on August 1. He announced a trade deal shortly after the meeting at Turnberry, and dismissed the idea the deal was a useful distraction from the Epstein accusations. 'We have reached a deal. It's a good deal for everybody,' he told reporters, confirming 15 per cent tariffs on all goods. Ms von der Leyen also hailed it as a 'good deal'. Mr Trump's comments on wind energy, however, are likely to complicate Mr Trump's meeting on Monday with Sir Keir, who has staked Britain's future energy supply on wind. In its manifesto last year, Labour promised to work with the private sector to double Britain's onshore wind power capacity by 2030. That meant ending the de facto ban on new onshore wind farms in England and, by declaring them nationally significant infrastructure projects, stripping councils of their power to block giant onshore wind farm developments. The policy, drawn up by Ed Miliband, the Energy Secretary, and condemned by critics as a 'power grab', cleared the way for a raft of new wind farms with turbines predicted to exceed 800ft in height. In Scotland on Sunday, Mr Trump pushed back on any suggestion that his 'beautiful' morning of golf had put him in a good mood. 'I'm actually not in a great mood,' he said at the press conference with Ms von der Leyen, to laughter from his team. Mr Trump may be on British soil, but he is meeting foreign leaders on home territory. The vast ballroom at Turnberry was set out like the Oval Office, scene of so many televised showdowns. The president took the seat on the right, just as he would at the White House, with his five advisers in seats beside him, arranged as if on the familiar couches, facing their counterparts no more than four feet away. A small group of guests, including his sons Donald Jr and Eric, were seated to one side, with a close-up view of the spectacle. But for all the important issues at stake, Mr Trump could not resist returning to golf and the presence of wind turbines. He was visiting Turnberry for the first time since Kirk Hill wind farm began producing energy from eight turbines that rise more than 300 ft into the air. 'The whole thing is a con job,' he said. 'It's very expensive, and in all fairness, Germany tried it and wind doesn't work.' He said it made no sense to subsidise energy projects such as wind farms. 'With energy, you make money, you don't lose money. But more important than that is it ruins the landscape,' he said. 'It kills the birds.' He also said that 'windmills' were driving whales 'loco'. Long-running battle over turbines Mr Trump's hatred of turbines stems from a long-planning battle he had with Scottish authorities. He opposed plans for a major North Sea wind power development that he complained could be seen from his Aberdeenshire course but lost the case. On Monday, Sir Keir is expected to push Mr Trump for his help in securing a ceasefire in Gaza. The president promised more aid for Gaza but indicated that he had run out of patience with Hamas, accusing the terror group of toughening its line on returning the last remaining Israeli hostages. 'They don't want to give them back, and so Israel's going to have to make a decision,' he said. His US negotiators left Qatar, which is mediating talks, on Thursday as talks collapsed. In the press conference, Mr Trump also called Iran 'stupid' for continuing to enrich uranium in the wake of US air strikes on its nuclear facilities. He said Iran had been 'beaten up very badly, for good reason'. 'I think Iran has been very nasty, with their words, with their mouth. I think they've been very nasty. They got the hell knocked out of them and I don't think they know it,' he added. 'You've just come out of something that's so bad and they talk about: we want to continue enrichment … How stupid can you be to say that?'
