Family creates AI video to depict Arizona man addressing his killer in court
Liliana Salgado
and
Andrew Goudsward
, Reuters
Law professor at the University of Colorado Harry Surden says the use of generative AI material in court raises ethical concerns.
Photo:
ikiryo/123RF
A simulation of a dead man created by
artificial intelligence
addressed his killer in an Arizona court this month, in what appears to be one of the first such instances in a US courtroom.
Made by his family, an AI-generated avatar of Christopher Pelkey spoke in Maricopa County Superior Court on 1 May, as a judge prepared to sentence Gabriel Paul Horcasitas for shooting and killing Pelkey in a 2021 road-rage incident.
"It is a shame we encountered each other that day in those circumstances," the Pelkey avatar said in the video. "In another life, we probably could have been friends."
The Pelkey avatar appears in the video sporting a long beard and green sweatshirt against a white backdrop.
He cautions at the start that he was an AI-version of Pelkey, which was apparent through the gaps in audio and slightly mismatched movement of his mouth.
Pelkey, a US Army veteran, was 37 at the time of the shooting.
The video marked a novel use of AI in the legal system, which has viewed the rapidly growing technology with a mix of fascination and trepidation.
Courts generally have strict rules on the types of information that can be presented in legal proceedings, and several lawyers have been sanctioned after AI systems created fake cases that they cited in legal briefs.
Pelkey's relatives were given more leeway to present the AI-generated video to the judge at sentencing, given that it was not evidence in the case.
Horcasitas, who was sentenced to 10.5 years in state prison, had already been convicted on manslaughter and endangerment charges.
Pelkey's sister Stacey Wales said she scripted the AI-generated message after struggling to convey years of grief and pain in her own statement.
She said she was not ready to forgive Horcasitas, but felt her brother would have a more understanding outlook.
"The goal was to humanise Chris, to reach the judge, and let him know his impact on this world and that he existed," she told Reuters.
Generative AI, Wales said, was "just another avenue that you can use to reach somebody".
Wales said she worked with her husband and a family friend, who all work in the tech industry, to create it.
Law professor at the University of Colorado Harry Surden said the use of generative AI material in court raises
ethical concerns
, as others may seek to use those tools to play on the emotions of judges and juries.
The content was a simulation of reality, not the verified evidence that courts typically assessed, Surden said.
"What we're seeing is the simulations have gotten so good that it completely bypasses our natural scepticism and goes straight to our emotion," he said.
- Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
a day ago
- NZ Herald
Christchurch man Shane Bell sentenced for years of sexual abuse and exploitation
'I am angry with him, with what he did to me.' He said Bell's actions had made him feel insecure. 'I could not trust other men, I thought they would do the same. I think he should go to jail for a long time - other teenagers should not have to go through this.' Bell, 49, sat expressionless in the Christchurch District Court as the teen and his father, flanked by supporters, struggled to contain their emotions at times during the sentencing hearing. The boy's father said he had a lot of trust in Bell being around his son. 'I don't have any trust in him now after what he has done to my son. I don't even like talking about him, as it makes me angry, what [he did] to my son. 'It has made me mindful of who I allow around my other kids, as I don't want this to happen to any of them. It has become a very traumatic experience.' He added that the experience 'has made me closer to my son, which I am grateful for'. The boy's father said the abuse had taken a toll on his family as they had to deal with residual trauma. The court heard the victim was extremely vulnerable, with a head injury, and Bell had taken advantage of him. A pre-sentence report indicated Bell was at high risk of reoffending, with distorted thinking and no display of remorse. Alongside charges of sexual connection with a young person and indecent acts with a young person, Bell faced charges of possessing hundreds of objectionable publications and making an objectionable publication that involved the victim. He would look after the victim, who would often spend time at Bell's house and stay overnight. Over 18 months, he performed sex acts on the boy and told him not to tell anyone. The victim was too scared to reveal what was happening. The boy told Bell it was illegal and tried to get away from him once, but Bell held him down. The victim believed Bell had committed the sex acts on him about 50 times. Bell also supplied the boy with cannabis and alcohol. Bell came to the attention of Polish authorities via a cellphone that had received child exploitation material, and in early 2023 the information was passed on to New Zealand police, who executed a search warrant on his home, seizing several devices. More than 1000 files were found on his laptop and cellphone, images involving young boys in a variety of sexual acts and a large array of animals being sexually violated. Bell's web history showed more than 100 searches for child exploitation material and bestiality. Also on his phone were photographs and videos of Bell and the victim. Bell was jailed for six years and three months at the Christchurch District Court. Photo / George Heard Judge Gerard Lynch described the offending as deplorable, vile and degrading. The judge said Bell had told authorities that if the victim had been unhappy with the offending, he would not have visited his home. Bell's main concern while in custody was with the wellbeing of his cats, Judge Lynch said. Bell was at high risk without treatment, and it had been noted that an intensive sexual treatment programme would be vital. Judge Lynch did not accept Bell's apology and sentenced him to six years and three months' jail. Bell was also placed on the Child Sex Offenders Register as part of his sentencing. Al Williams is an Open Justice reporter for the New Zealand Herald, based in Christchurch. He has worked in daily and community titles in New Zealand and overseas for the past 16 years. Most recently, he was editor of the Hauraki-Coromandel Post, based in Whangamatā. He was previously deputy editor of the Cook Islands News.
RNZ News
a day ago
- RNZ News
11 people injured and suspect in custody after 'random' stabbing in Michigan Walmart, officials say
By Zoe Sottile , CNN The sheriff said three of the victims are undergoing surgery and he was awaiting more information about the status of all the victims. Photo: 123RF Eleven people were injured in a "random" stabbing by a man with a folding knife-style weapon at a Walmart in Traverse City, Michigan, Saturday, according to the Grand Traverse County sheriff. A 42-year-old suspect, a Michigan resident, was taken into custody, Grand Traverse County Sheriff Michael Shea said at a news conference. Shea didn't name the suspect but said authorities believe he acted alone. "There is no information indicating there were additional suspects," Shea said. "It appears that these were all random acts." The sheriff said three of the victims are undergoing surgery and he was awaiting more information about the status of all the victims. Six of the victims are male and five female, he said. Munson Healthcare, a hospital system in northern Michigan, is treating 11 victims from the incident, according to their Facebook post, which did not provide details on the exact nature of the injuries or the conditions of the victims. There was "citizen involvement" in taking the suspect into custody, Shea said. The suspect was not injured, he added. The incident started near the checkout area and involved what "appears to be a standard folding knife-style weapon," according to the sheriff. He said that the Michigan State Police Crime Lab is en route to assist with processing the scene. Once the scene is cleared, the Walmart will be able to reopen. FBI personnel are also responding to the incident to provide assistance, FBI deputy director Dan Bongino said in a post on X. Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer said she was in touch with law enforcement about the "horrible news" in a post on X. I'm in touch with law enforcement about the horrible news out of Traverse City. Our thoughts are with the victims and the community reeling from this brutal act of violence. I am grateful to the first responders for their swift response to apprehend the suspect. "Our thoughts are with the victims and the community reeling from this brutal act of violence," Whitmer said. "I am grateful to the first responders for their swift response to apprehend the suspect." Walmart corporate spokesperson Joe Pennington told CNN that "violence like this is unacceptable. Our thoughts are with those who were injured and we're thankful for the swift action of first responders." "We'll continue working closely with law enforcement during their investigation." Traverse City is located in northern Michigan, around 225km north of Grand Rapids. CNN has reached out to Michigan State Police and Munson Healthcare for additional information. Shea urged people to "be vigilant." Violence "is very uncommon for our area," the sheriff said. "But unfortunately ... no one is immune to this." - CNN
RNZ News
2 days ago
- RNZ News
Defence to explore potential plea deal in murder trial over brothers killed in Mexico
By Carrington Clarke , ABC Callum, left, and Jake Robinson with their family dog. Photo: Instagram/Supplied Lawyers for the four people charged in connection with the alleged murder of Australian brothers Callum and Jake Robinson have asked for another court delay, to give them more time to discuss a potential plea deal with prosecutors. Judge Oscar Padilla agreed to grant them until a new hearing date on 13 November, but he said this would be the last delay in the case and warned all the lawyers that they would be fined if they were not prepared for the next hearing. Three men - Jesús Gerardo, also known as "El Kekas"; Irineo Francisco and Ángel Jesús - all face charges of aggravated homicide, aggravated robbery, violent robbery and grand theft auto over the killing of the Australian brothers and their American travelling companion, Carter Rhoad, in April last year. Jesús Gerardo is also charged with forced disappearance. The prosecution said a fourth suspect, Ari Gisell, was facing charges of inciting a violent robbery, but was not charged with murder. The defendants' surnames have been withheld for legal reasons. It was Ari Gisell's lawyer who asked the judge for a delay to allow time for discussions to take place with the prosecution regarding a potential plea deal. His motion was then supported by the other defence lawyers. The lawyer said the prosecutor's office was seeking a 32-year sentence for his client, but he believed eight years would be more appropriate given the crime she was accused of. Ari Gisell was romantically involved with one of the other defendants at the time. Photo: Supplied / ABC None of the suspects has entered a plea to any of the charges at this point. Prosecutor Raúl Gerardo Cobo Montejano told the ABC that if the accused pleaded guilty, it was possible they would receive a reduced sentence. The legal manoeuvrer was a surprise to the families of the victims, who were watching proceedings via video link. The judge asked an advocate who was attending proceedings on behalf of "indirect victims" to talk to them privately about what had occurred in court. Last week's hearing was postponed to allow time for both sides to consider arguments about whether to combine El Kekas's forced disappearance charge with the other charges. But there seems to be a dispute within the prosecution's office about exactly what transpired in April. A rescue worker descends into a waterhole where human remains were found near La Bocana Beach in Ensenada, Mexico, on 3 May, 2024. Photo: AFP/ Guillermo Arias The lead prosecutor in the homicide case told the judge he did not agree with the theory that the victims were first kidnapped or detained before being killed, as his colleague had contended. The judge expressed exasperation that there was not a consistent theory from the prosecution office at this point in the case. Irineo Francisco has links to the Sinaloa cartel, according to court documents. Photo: Supplied / ABC The judge has allowed the forced disappearance charge to be rolled in with the other charges, but it is unclear which will be the working theory when the case resumes. Jake and Callum Robinson, and their American friend Carter Rhoad, were found dead after disappearing during a camping trip in Mexico's remote north-west in April last year. They had travelled south to surf while Jake, a 31-year-old doctor from Perth, was visiting Callum, 32, who was living in California after moving to the US to play lacrosse. Both Callum (left) and Jake Robinson are keen surfers. Photo: Supplied / Instagram The defendants' surnames have been withheld for legal reasons. Last week, the ABC revealed that two of the accused, Jesús Gerardo and Irineo Francisco, had suspected links to the Sinaloa cartel. Local authorities had previously said there was no evidence linking the killings to cartels, despite their frequent violent activity in the region. Jesús Gerardo. Photo: Supplied / ABC / Mexican police A court document said the men were transferred from the local Ensenada jail to the maximum-security El Hongo complex last August, after prison authorities raised concerns about their alleged cartel links. The Sinaloa cartel, which was once led by the high-profile crime boss El Chapo, is considered one of Mexico's most brutal. - ABC
