"Prime Aaron Rodgers was better than Patrick Mahomes" says Ben Roethlisberger and NFL fans are divided
NFL legend says Aaron Rodgers was better in his prime than Patrick Mahomes is now
Just when we thought the Patrick Mahomes GOAT hype was locked in, Ben Roethlisberger pulled a plot twist nobody saw coming. On a podcast, the Steelers legend said he'd take Aaron Rodgers in his prime over Mahomes right now and yeah, the internet basically exploded.
Ben's not out here hating. In fact, he gave Mahomes major props. But his QB preference? Loud and clear. Rodgers' prime > Mahomes' now. Let's unpack what he said, why fans are spiraling, and what this means for the never-ending GOAT debate.
Ben Roethlisberger's QB take is bold and it's already causing a fan civil war
Here's the direct quote from Big Ben that started it all:
'I would take Aaron in his prime over Patrick now… (Pat) He'll go down as another arguable G.O.A.T. I think Aaron in his prime is better.'
Ben Roethlisberger Says He Would Take PRIME AARON RODGERS Over Patrick Mahomes Now!
That's a statement. Especially in 2025, when Mahomes is fresh off his third Super Bowl and still in MVP form.
Ben doubled down, calling both QBs 'arguable GOATs,' but clearly siding with Rodgers' peak form his accuracy, mobility, and raw arm talent during those dominant 2011 and 2014 seasons.
Mahomes fans? Not having it.
NFL fans are divided and everyone's defending their guy like it's a playoff game
As soon as Big Ben's Rodgers-over-Mahomes take dropped, NFL Twitter turned into the Wild West. Some fans had Rodgers' back, pointing out the nuance of winning in football, while others were quick to drop the ol'
'rings > everything'
take.
Here's how both sides fired off:
In Rodgers' corner...
@MaxonUnlimited tweeted:
'Of course, nothing against Patrick but Aaron has never had luck on his side in the playoffs.
Every team needs a bit of it to win. Aaron's defense or special teams have never been a difference maker.'
@8M11Rod went even harder, calling out the ring-only crowd:
'Only low IQ fans use the ring argument to say otherwise meanwhile actual legend QBs like Ben and Tom say Rodgers is better. It's almost like to win rings you need defense, special teams, and 10 other guys on offense to do their job.'
'Rodgers over Mahomes?' Ben Roethlisberger sparks major NFL fan debate. Image - X
They're not wrong, Rodgers' postseason exits are full of blocked punts, blown leads, and defenses that couldn't hold a fourth-quarter stop if their lives depended on it.
Meanwhile, Mahomes stans clapped back immediately...
@330ITI fired:
'That's cool so he should have SOME rings to show for it then right?'
@Uggg (aka Mark Collins) didn't sugarcoat it either:
'Yeah, not even close. Mahomes is better.'
'Rodgers over Mahomes?' Ben Roethlisberger sparks major NFL fan debate. X
They make a point, Mahomes already has three Super Bowl rings, multiple MVPs, and one of the best playoff résumés in NFL history, and he's only 28.
The stats say it's close but Mahomes is gaining fast
Let's compare the two legends side by side:
Category
Prime Aaron Rodgers
Current Patrick Mahomes
MVPs
4 MVPs (2011, 2014, 2020, 2021)
2 MVPs (2018, 2022)
Super Bowls
1 win (2010 season)
3 wins (2019, 2022, 2023 seasons)
Peak season
45 TDs, 6 INTs (2011)
50 TDs, 5,097 yds (2018 MVP year)
Play style
Elite accuracy + mobility
Clutch improviser + high football IQ
Rodgers might be the 'prettier' passer, but Mahomes has already done what Rodgers couldn't—build a dynasty.
So, is Ben stuck in the past or just giving flowers to a QB who might've been too smooth for his own good?
Also read -
Stefon Diggs trains like a beast even while vacationing in a castle with Cardi B
Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
NFL legend Aaron Rodgers at risk of midseason exit in Pittsburgh, critics claim
Steelers sign Aaron Rodgers, but midseason exit is being predicted (Image via: Getty Images) Aaron Rodgers' move to the Pittsburgh Steelers is already stirring controversy. The 40-year-old quarterback signed a one-year deal to chase one last Super Bowl, but some insiders believe his time in black and gold might not even last the full season. Critics warn this could be a short and turbulent ride for the NFL legend. NFL veteran predicts Aaron Rodgers' time in Pittsburgh could end early Aaron Rodgers is officially a Pittsburgh Steeler, aiming to close out his career with a final playoff push. But not everyone is confident it'll go as planned. Former Steelers linebacker James Harrison publicly suggested that Rodgers could be cut before the season ends if Pittsburgh struggles out of the gate. 'If they start losing and it's looking like they ain't gonna make above .500, I think it gets real ugly, real fast,' Harrison said. 'To the point where they may just be like, 'Let's let this dude go midseason.'' 'THIS IS IT' ⌛ What Aaron Rodgers' FINAL SEASON means for Steelers + Commanders updates | NFL Live Rodgers, a four-time NFL MVP and Green Bay Packers icon, brings instant leadership and elite experience to the Steelers. According to NFL analyst Phil Simms, he's in peak physical condition and has reshaped his body for one final push. But critics argue the move came too late. Short-term Rodgers deal could derail Steelers' long-term plans The biggest concern surrounding the Rodgers signing is its impact on the Steelers' long-term quarterback plans. ESPN's Ryan Clark labeled it a worst-case scenario, predicting Rodgers will keep the team just competitive enough to miss out on drafting a franchise quarterback in 2025. With top QB prospects like Shedeur Sanders and Carson Beck expected to be available, Pittsburgh could be sacrificing its future for a short-term shot at relevance. If the team hovers around the .500 mark, they might neither contend for a title nor land a top draft pick. Behind the scenes, rookie quarterback Will Howard is quietly preparing. Rodgers has taken him under his wing, and many inside the organization view him as a potential future starter. If Rodgers is injured or cut, Howard could take over and get valuable in-game experience. Also Read: Broncos could reunite Sean Payton with Taysom Hill in 2025 The Steelers are betting on a big name and a fast result. But if things go south early, the Rodgers era in Pittsburgh could end before it truly begins. Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Los Angeles Lakers Rumor: Latest Update on LeBron James' Retirement Storyline, Is the NBA King Finally Dropping the Ball?
While LeBron James looked determined and in good form, the four-time NBA champion and MVP has yet to confirm whether he will return for a 23rd NBA season. (Image via Getty Images) As the 2025 NBA offseason unfolds, LeBron James ' future remains one of the league's most scrutinized storylines. With the Los Angeles Lakers star approaching his 23rd season and free agency looming, speculation about his retirement timetable has intensified. Recent updates from team sources, analysts, and James himself provide the clearest picture yet of what fans can expect. LeBron's Current Status: Entering Season 23, No Set Retirement Date LeBron James , who turns 41 in December, is set to become a free agent but is widely expected to exercise his $52.6 million player option and return to the Lakers for the 2025-26 season. Despite ongoing speculation and annual questions about his retirement, James has not committed to any specific timeline for ending his career. According to ESPN's Dave McMenamin, James is not entering the next season with any certainty that it will be his last. He stated. "He revealed his plans for the coming season, saying he 'has not put a definite timetable, a date,' to his rumored retirement." Performance and Motivation: Still Among the NBA Elite Despite his age and a recent Grade 2 MCL sprain in his left knee, LeBron James continues to defy expectations. He averaged 24.4 points, 7.8 rebounds, and 8.2 assists during the 2024-25 regular season, and elevated his game in the playoffs despite injury. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like India:: Cost Of Gold Jewelry From Mexico Might Surprise You [See Prices] Luxury Jewelry | Search Ads Undo Analysts continue to rank him among the league's top players, with some placing him firmly in the top 20, if not higher. The Los Angeles Lakers legend has repeatedly stated that a decline in competitiveness or performance will not be the reason for his retirement. He believes he could play at a high level for another five to seven years, though he admits he is unlikely to extend his career that long. Key Factors Influencing Retirement Decision LeBron James (Image Source - Getty Images) Several factors are shaping James' decision-making process: - Family and Legacy: Playing alongside his son, Bronny James, who recently joined the Lakers, is a historic milestone and a strong motivator for LeBron to continue. - Health: James is focused on recovery and maintaining peak physical condition. He has emphasized the importance of being as close to 100% as possible for training camp. - Lakers' Roster Moves: The Lakers' willingness to upgrade their roster and keep James happy, including potentially adding a new starting center, is a major incentive for him to stay. - Financial Security: The $52.6 million player option and a full no-trade clause make remaining with the Lakers both lucrative and secure. - Championship Aspirations: LeBron James remains motivated by the pursuit of another NBA title, especially after the Lakers' early playoff exit last season. What Insiders and Analysts Are Saying - Retirement Most Likely After 2025-26: Some NBA writers, including Tyler Watts of Lake Show Life, believe that if James opts into his player option, it signals a strong possibility that the 2025-26 season could be his last. Opting in is seen as a move to secure his legacy, financial future, and possibly set up a farewell tour. - No Immediate Exit: There is consensus among insiders that James is unlikely to leave the Lakers or retire this offseason, especially with limited free agency alternatives and the Lakers' commitment to building around him. - No Coaching Plans: While there is speculation about a post-retirement coaching role, James has publicly dismissed the idea of coaching in the NBA after his playing days are over. Summary of LeBron James' Retirement Outlook Factor Current Status/Update Contract $52.6M player option for 2025–26; expected to opt in Retirement Timeline No fixed date; likely to play at least one more season Performance Still elite; averaged 24.4 PPG, 7.8 RPG, 8.2 APG in 2024–25 Team Situation Lakers expected to upgrade roster; Bronny James now a teammate Health Recovering from knee injury; focused on offseason training Analyst Consensus 2025–26 could be last season if he opts in; no immediate plans to retire Post-Retirement Plans No NBA coaching ambitions; intends to finish career with Lakers Also read: Cleveland Cavaliers Trade for Lonzo Ball in Bold Backcourt Move, Send Isaac Okoro to the Chicago Bulls LeBron James is set to return for his 23rd NBA season with the Los Angeles Lakers, having not committed to a specific retirement date. While insiders suggest the 2025-26 season could be his swan song if he opts into his player option, James remains noncommittal, focused on health, family, and chasing another championship. For now, the King's reign continues, with retirement on the horizon but not yet at hand. Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Steelers acquire DK Metcalf in major NFL trade—Here's why $132M deal makes sense
Steelers land DK Metcalf in bold trade, lock him in $132M deal (Image via: Getty Images) The Pittsburgh Steelers shocked the NFL by acquiring wide receiver DK Metcalf from the Seattle Seahawks in exchange for a 2025 second-round pick. Shortly after the trade, the Steelers handed Metcalf a massive four-year, $132 million extension. While some critics call it an overpay, the deal's structure may prove to be a win for Pittsburgh. Why DK Metcalf's contract could be a long-term steal for Pittsburgh The Steelers didn't just trade for a superstar, they bought flexibility, leverage, and long-term control. While DK Metcalf's $132 million extension with $60 million guaranteed makes him the fourth-highest-paid wide receiver in the league, there's more to the deal than meets the eye. ESPN's Dan Graziano believes the structure of Metcalf's contract makes it surprisingly team-friendly. After 2026, none of his salary is guaranteed, giving the Steelers an escape hatch. According to Over the Cap, Pittsburgh could release him after June 1, 2027, and free up $26.5 million in cap space. That means the team gets Metcalf's prime years without committing to his decline. Steelers Sights & Sounds: Aaron Rodgers, DK Metcalf Make Steelers Practice Debuts With the wide receiver market exploding, it's also a forward-thinking move. While Metcalf ranks fourth in average annual value now, there's a high likelihood he drops outside the top five by next season. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Protecting Our Oceans Rolex Read Now Undo His contract might seem expensive today but could look like a bargain in just 12 months. Beyond the dollars, the football impact is undeniable. Metcalf, still just 27, brings elite size, speed, and red-zone dominance. He gives Pittsburgh a legitimate WR1—something the team hasn't had since the peak of Antonio Brown. The addition boosts a Steelers offense looking to contend immediately. Pittsburgh pulled off the trade by parting with just a second-round pick. In today's high-demand trade market, acquiring a Pro Bowl-caliber receiver on a long-term deal for that price is rare. Also Read: Breaking: Trey Hendrickson turns down $28M from Bengals, future in Cincinnati now uncertain The Steelers' blockbuster trade for DK Metcalf may look risky at first glance, but the deal's smart structure, cap flexibility, and long-term upside make it one of the most strategic moves of 2025. If Metcalf performs as expected, Pittsburgh could come away looking like one of the NFL's sharpest front offices. Game On Season 1 continues with Mirabai Chanu's inspiring story. Watch Episode 2 here.
