'I wouldn't I agree with it. You've to earn your right': Lee opposes Munster SFC seeding
The proposed change is that the two highest-ranked counties from the league receive byes to the Munster semi-final and, additionally, be kept apart in that semi-final draw.
If the league-based seeding is voted in later this month, Cork and Kerry would be the seeded pair for 2026 on account of Cork's fifth-place finish in Division 2 earlier this year bettering Clare's third-place finish in Division 3.
The current structure, which has been in place since 2015, seeds the previous year's Munster finalists.
Clare and Kerry, as a result of reaching the 2024 Munster decider, were given semi-final byes for the 2025 draw, albeit they could still have been paired against one another in that last-four stage.
'I wouldn't agree with it,' said Jimmy Lee when asked for his views on the recommended change that will go before the full Munster Council later this month.
'Why wouldn't I agree with it? You've to earn your right. If it was the same across all four provinces, I'd probably be fine with it. But if you were to look at it coldly, who would be seeded next year? It would be Cork and Kerry. Our neighbours Clare, Munster finalists this year and for the two years before that, they have done nothing wrong. So for me, it is a no.
'I'd be happy out with that [current system]. Clare, and I am just using them as an example, they have worked so hard to get there and maintain it, they have been consistent for years.
'They've earned the right to be there and that's the only issue I'd have with it. You've got to earn these rights. You can't hand them out.'
Although Munster GAA have yet to clarify the motivation behind the proposal, it is understood to be linked to a sharp fall in Munster final attendances across the three most recent Kerry-Clare deciders, as well as the one-sided nature of two of those games.
Clare chairman Kieran Keating recently told the Irish Examiner that putting Cork and Kerry up on a 'pedestal' will do nothing to improve the standard of football in Munster.
'Improving the standard in Cork is not going to fix Munster football, it is by helping other counties, giving a leg up to other counties, rather than putting Cork and Kerry on the pedestal up above them and saying to the others, you fight for the scraps.'
With Clare and Limerick set to vote against the proposal, they would require similar opposition from Tipperary and Waterford to ensure the status quo is retained in 2026.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
an hour ago
- Irish Examiner
Dundalk stay four points clear at top of the First Division as they see off Kerry
SSE Airtricity First Division: Kerry 0 Dundalk 4 (Groome 20', Kenny 60', Ward 90+3', Paraschiv 90+4') Dundalk remain four points clear at the top of the First Division after defeating Kerry FC at Mounthawk Park and fully deserved their win. However, the scoreline probably flattered the league leaders. Dundalk deserved their 2-0 lead heading into added time but for the second week in a row, Kerry conceded two late goals to compound a poor seven says for Colin Healy and his struggling Kerry side. Dundalk created the first opening in the fourth minute when Daryl Horgans' snap shot just missed the target. Kerry countered as Sean McGrath ran on to a rebound from a Sean O'Connell effort that was blocked but Enda Minogue was down quickly to smother the shot. Dundalk took the lead in the 20th minute when a misplaced pass out of defence by Alex Dunne was intercepted by Harry Groome who picked his spot and unleashed a terrific shot that dipped under the crossbar despite efforts of keeper Tim –Oliver Hiemer. Dundalk almost doubled their lead in the 28th minute when Eoin Kenny skinned his marker down the right but Horgan failed to make contact in the six yard box. Niall Brookwell then saved the home side when he cleared an Arubi shot off the line after another dangerous Kenny cross. Kerry finished the half strongly and could have equalised in the 40th minute when a cross from Alex Dunne was met in the box by Kennedy Amechi with his back to goal but his cheeky bicycle kick was parried by Dundalk keeper Minogue and collected. But Kerry had shown that they were able to trouble the league leaders defence who retired 1-0 in front at the interval. Kerry began the second half brightly and McGrath was causing Dundalk problems through the middle in the absence of Ronan Teahan. McGrath was fouled in a central position and when Oran Crowe floated in the resultant free kick, Chris McQueen headed down but Amechi's effort was straight at the keeper. Dundalk doubled their lead on the hour when another defensive error saw Kevin Williams head the ball into the path of Dean Ebbe who found Eoin Kenny raiding on the right side and he beat Hiemer from just inside the box, at his near post. McQueen headed over from a Crowe corner in the 67th minute as Kerry tried valiantly to get a goal back. Dundalk wrapped the points with two late goals from a Keith Ward free kick that should have been saved and a tiring home side was caught out at the back again, in the final move of the game, when Andy Paraschiv fired home from inside the box to secure the points. Kerry FC: Hiemer; Dunne, Williams, Brookwell, McQueen, O'Connell; McGrath, Mujaguzi, Crowe, Palmer, Amechi. Subs: Healy for Mujaguzi (h/t), Barrett for Dunne (76) Dundalk FC: Minogue; Wilson, Animasahun, Leonard, Keogh; Dervin, Groome, Kenny, Ebbe, Horgan, Arubi Subs: D McDaid for Horgan ( 61), McHale for Keogh ( 69), Ward for Arubi ( 69), Paraschiv for Groome ( 69), Mulligan for Wilson ( 81). Referee: L Keating (Cork)
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Christy O'Connor: Kilkenny finally end search for a settled midfield pairing
When Cian Kenny appeared on the Kilkenny People Sport podcast last September, much of the discussion centred around his disappointment at Kilkenny's defeat to Clare in the All-Ireland semi-final. 'That game still haunts us,' said Kenny. 'It's a game that I'd say will live with us for the rest of our lives.' Kenny was still one of the few Kilkenny players who performed well that afternoon. He was Kilkenny's most consistent player in the 2024 championship. When the All-Star team was announced in October, Kenny was one the tiny handful of players deemed unlucky not to win an award. This is exclusive subscriber content. Already a subscriber? Sign in Take us with you this summer. Annual €130€65 Best value Monthly €12€6 / month
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
Malachy Clerkin: Cork's beautiful miracle has reached an excruciating point
It's entirely possible that the Cork hurlers will not win the All-Ireland . Just saying, like. This is not meant as an insult, nor even just to tweak the proud Cork noses as they head for Croke Park this weekend. It just seems like a good time to point out that there is a world in which 2025 ends in the same way as every one of the past 20 seasons have. That is to say, with somebody other than a Cork captain singing and bucklepping on the steps of the Hogan Stand. We are at the point of peak Cork giddiness. Everyone – or at any rate, everyone outside the Dublin dressingroom – assumes that this weekend is a straightforward tick of a box. Cork didn't come this far to lose to Dublin, for the love of Ring. Check the Irish Rail website – the Cork-Heuston trains on All-Ireland final day are already sold out. So now, right now, this is when all is for the best in this best of all possible Cork worlds. They're odds-on favourites for the All-Ireland heading into the last four. This has to be a unique occurrence for a team looking to end a famine, or very close to it. READ MORE It can't have happened too many times before that a county who hasn't lifted Liam MacCarthy in such a long time are odds-on shots before they've even played the All-Ireland semi-final. Who would even be the candidates for a list like that? Limerick in 1994? Clare in '95? No way. Maybe, at a push, Limerick in '96. They had Antrim in the semi-final and would have felt they had little to fear from Galway and Wexford on the other side of the draw. They were probably favourites before the semi-finals but they wouldn't have been 4-5 shots, surely. A bookie would do slim business at that price. So we're in new territory here. And yet, it somehow feels like old territory too. Cork, Tipperary and Kilkenny filling three of the four spots in the All-Ireland semi-finals, the blue bloods reasserting their command over the old game. Stick your revolution, lads. The empire is striking back. Now, not to jinx it or anything, but Cork have never won Liam MacCarthy when all three have still been involved at this point. This is the sixth time it's happened, since you ask. Kilkenny have won four of the other five, Tipp did it in 2010. In fact, Cork have only once made it to the final in these circumstances. Joe Canning: Most people think it's Cork's All-Ireland to lose and that suits Kilkenny just fine — Irish Times Sport (@IrishTimesSport) That's why this is such a golden moment for all the Rebels pouring into the capital this weekend, their spirits high and their voices higher. Rightly or wrongly, there are no nerves to deal with here. If Dublin turn them over, it will be an immediate apocalypse, a sudden and brutal cardiac shock. But it's the kind of thing they can't feel worried about until they're stuck in the middle of it. If they win through to the final, that's when the nerves will start to infest and to spread. Cork hurling supporters are bullish but they are not bulletproof. They will feel they're better than Tipp and better than Kilkenny too but they won't be able to truly trust it. A fortnight is a long time to think about all the ways you can crash and burn, especially when you've crashed and burned in the past four finals you've been to. But that's a worry for Monday and beyond. In the here and now, we get to observe the Cork hurling albatross with its wings at full span. Watch it swoop upon Dublin city, haughty and noble and unstoppable, picking off the bits it fancies as it goes. Eating the best food the capital has to offer, drinking its porter, still full sure that the English Market and the Hi-B are superior. And quite right too. The gathering speed of the Cork hurling bandwagon has been one of the beautiful miracles of Irish sport over the past decade or so. Nobody had ever sold out an All-Ireland hurling semi-final until last year and now they're about to do it again. And not against Limerick or Clare or Wexford or any of the other mad-bastard support bases. Against Dublin, who didn't even fill Parnell Park for their Leinster matches. This will be Cork's eighth championship sell-out in a row. For any GAA team to do that is a wild achievement at a time when ticket prices have never been as high and when the cost of living is through the roof. For Cork to do it while not even winning an All-Ireland (yet?) is bananas. Yes, fine, Cork people love their hurling. But they didn't just start loving it in the past couple of years. It's easy to forget that they didn't even make it out of Munster in 2023. This is the perfect storm of a likable team, a manager of obvious decency and humanity, a starving fan base, a much-dumped-upon stadium and a county board that is finally looking outward after decades of insularity. It has grown organically, gradually, Corkily. And now it's gathering speed. They're hurtling through that twilight zone where people think of them as the best team in the country without them actually having done the thing yet. Most presume they will. But they might not. It's a precarious, delicious, excruciating position to be in. You'd feel for the hoors, if you didn't know better.
