logo
Why a quarter of immigrants in Germany are thinking of leaving

Why a quarter of immigrants in Germany are thinking of leaving

Local Germany16-06-2025
According to a study by Germany's Institute for Employment Research (IAB), approximately one in every four immigrants is currently considering leaving the country. This equates to 2.6 million people.
The study, which looked at data from a survey of around 50,000 immigrants, suggests that three percent of immigrants in Germany (300,000 people) already have concrete plans to leave.
Around 12 percent (or 1.2 million people), on the other hand, currently plan to stay in the country temporarily, and a further 30 percent (or 3 million people) are undecided.
A narrow majority of Germany's immigrant population, at around 57 percent, said they plan to stay permanently.
The Local caught up with Dr. Katia Gallegos Torres, an IAB researcher who worked on the study, to ask why some immigrants are opting-out of settling in Germany long-term and what the country's governing authorities can do about it.
Which factors push immigrants out of Germany?
According to the study, the main reasons some immigrants want to leave Germany include;
political dissatisfaction
,
discrimination
in the workplace (and during interactions with authorities), the high tax burden, and
bureaucratic obstacles
.
Family considerations and better economic prospects in other countries were also cited as reasons for contemplating emigration.
Commenting on the findings, Gallegos Torres emphasized that social integration plays a decisive role in whether or not immigrants remain in a country.
'A strong subjective feeling of being welcome, emotional ties to Germany, and low perceptions of discrimination reduce the likelihood of emigration considerations and plans,' she told The Local.
READ ALSO:
What are your responsibilities as a foreign resident in Germany?
One key finding of the survey is that 'well-integrated' migrants are more likely to consider leaving or already have concrete plans to do so. These are people who moved to Germany to work or study, and who tend to be better educated, more economically successful, and often have a better command of the German language.
'We know from migration research that people with higher levels of education are more mobile,' explained Gallegos Torres.
'However, in addition to higher mobility, there may be structural reasons driving this trend, such as the political situation in Germany.'
Advertisement
Other IAB
studies
have shown that foreign workers of all skill levels are more likely to move away from regions with more right-wing extremist attitudes.
The fact that the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) is now the largest opposition party in Germany, along with recent moves by the federal government to take a harder line on migration, may well have heightened anxieties among immigrant communities.
READ ALSO:
'A fifth of voters hate me' - How do foreigners in Germany feel about far-right surge?
What is the government doing to retain skilled workers?
Attracting migrants to Germany is one well-known challenge facing the German government, but persuading them to stay in the country is another.
'A sustainable migration policy requires more than simply promoting immigration – it is equally important to consider the possibility of people leaving the country," Gallegos Torres said.
READ ALSO:
Are significantly more skilled workers moving to Germany?
Asked what the government can do to convince working immigrants to stay in Germany for the long-term, Gallegos Torres said her research has highlighted a number of areas where improvements could be made.
'The findings of the survey provide important pointers in this regard, and underscore the urgent need to remove structural barriers, accelerate and simplify migration and administrative processes, strengthen social integration, and actively promote social openness.'
Advertisement
She cited a federal initiative to create a "digital work and stay agency" as a solid step toward addressing some of those issues.
The agency "will serve as a central IT platform to accelerate processes related to labour migration and the recognition of professional qualifications" Gallegos Torres explained.
Additional concrete measures could include offering tax incentives, promoting local integration programs, and introducing measures to make it easier for the partners and children of immigrants to gain entry to Germany.
OPINION:
If Germany is to thrive it must help foreigners feel they belong here
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Germany updates: Poland to extend border checks  – DW – 07/24/2025
Germany updates: Poland to extend border checks  – DW – 07/24/2025

DW

time10 hours ago

  • DW

Germany updates: Poland to extend border checks – DW – 07/24/2025

The border controls with Germany and Lithuania were due to expire next month. Meanwhile, Germany's second-largest airport is reportedly planning a "repatriation terminal" to process migrant deportations. DW has Left Party () has criticized the German government's decision not to sign an appeal to end the war in the Gaza Strip immediately and called for a special parliamentary debate on the subject. A total of 28 countries, plus the executive body of the European Union, the European Commission, have signed the appeal which calls on Israel to "adhere to its commitments in regards to international humanitarian law" by ending its war in Gaza. Germany, however, is not among the signatories, arguing that the appeal is not explicit enough in naming the attack on Israel by the Palestinian militant group Hamas on October 7, 2023, as the cause of the war. Left Party chairs Heidi Reichinnek and Sören Pellmann called the government's failure to sign the appeal as "a complete admission of failure" and insisted: "Germany must also join the public pressure [on Israel] and finally turn words into actions." The far-left opposition party, which has 64 seats (10.16%) in the Bundestag, has also called for a special sitting of parliament's Foreign Affairs Committee. "The government continues to close its eyes to the suffering in Palestine and is not prepared to live up to its responsibility and act," said Reichinnek and Pellmann, adding that lawmakers must be informed of "all information on the current situation" in Gaza. Representatives of the center-left Social Democrats (SPD), including Development Minister Reem Alabali Radovan, and the environmentalist Green party have also called on the German government to sign the appeal. Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul (CDU) has referred to constant, ongoing discussions between the German and Israeli governments concerning the latter's actions in Gaza. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The German Football Federation (DFB) says Euro 2025 was a "success" for Germany, despite Wednesday night's dramatic semifinal defeat to Spain, and has backed head coach Christian Wück to lead the team into the future. "We are one hundred percent convinced by Christian and his path," said DFB President Bernd Neuendorf before the departure of the German delegation from Zürich on Thursday morning. "He aimed to bring about a transformation and we have to say he has succeeded." Germany lost 1-0 to Spain on Wednesday night, taking the world champions to extra-time just days after holding on for over 130 minutes with just ten players to beat France on penalties in a dramatic quarterfinal. President Neuendorf was full of praise for the young German team, saying: "This is precisely the path we want to be on." An average of 14.26 million German viewers tuned into watch the semifinal, and head coach Wück said he was "proud" that his team had "generated such euphoria." Germany's Federal President, Frank-Walter Steinmeier, who was in the stadium to support the team in person on Wednesday, called the players "true role models" and praised them for "playing this tournament with so much passion and footballing ability." Chancellor Friedrich Merz, who is known to be a supporter of Bundesliga side Borussia Dortmund, wrote on Instagram: "You fought until the very end … thank you for these brilliant football moments – we are proud of you!" Spain will face reigning European champions England in the final on Sunday. The western German city of Duisburg on Wednesday night marked the 15th anniversary of the Love Parade tragedy, which saw 21 people killed and more than 650 injured in a deadly crush at a music festival on July 24, 2010. Although experts found numerous failings in the planning and authorization of the event, no individuals were ever brought to justice for one of the deadliest tragedies in modern German history. After a decade-long investigation, charges of involuntary homicide and physical injury resulting from negligence brought against the city of Duisburg and the event organizers were dropped in 2020 on the grounds that no relevant blame could be leveled at any individuals. Rather, the court found that a "number of circumstances" led to the tragedy. Wednesday night's memorial event, which saw 1,000 candles lit for the victims, is likely to be the last of its kind, with the association responsible for organizing it set to be wound up. "For some, the tenth anniversary was already the opportune moment to find closure," said spokesperson Jürgen Widera, saying that the emotional need for an annual event was dropping off. A permanent memorial at the site of the tragedy just south of Duisburg city center features the words (Love never ends) in seven languages to reflect the mother tongues of the victims from Germany, the Netherlands, Italy, Spain, China and Australia. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Police in the southern German state of Bavaria last week carried out raids and made arrests in connection with a suspected million-euro fraud case related to COVID-19 medication, it was confirmed on Thursday. Raids took place at 16 premises in the Bavarian cities of Munich, Regensburg, Bamberg and Bayreuth, resulting in the arrest of two people who remain in custody on suspicion of selling the government-procured drug Paxlovid "outside the prescribed distribution mechanism" — in other words, on the black market — in 2023. State prosecutors are investigating damages of up to €2.6 million ($3 million). The German government purchased large amounts of Paxlovid at the height of the pandemic and the drug was approved in January 2022. Doctors could prescribe the drug to patients who could then receive it for free at pharmacies, which in turn were compensated by the state. Germany's Police Union (GdP) has called for tighter immigration checks at German airports after a media report highlighted thousands of cases of "secondary migration," or asylum claims being made in Germany despite asylum having already been granted elsewhere in the European Union (EU). "The federal police control bridges, motorways and major roads on the borders with Poland and Austria, checking for irregular entry attempts being made by migrants and asylum seekers," said a spokesman. "But there's a loophole at airports." The comments came after a report by Germany's media group revealed that around 8,000 recognized asylum seekers had applied for asylum in Germany between January and May this year, despite having already been granted asylum in Greece, which is also in the EU. The group obtained the figures from the German Interior Ministry, which said that a total of 26,000 such secondary applications had been made in 2024. According to EU law governing "secondary migration" in the bloc's free-movement Schengen zone, recognized asylum seekers may spend up to 90 days in another EU country, but may not make another application for asylum there. "People who have been granted protection in Greece must make use of that protection there," said a ministry statement. In April, Germany's Federal Administrative Court in Leipzig ruled that single, healthy migrants who are able to work could legally be deported to Greece, where the court said they would face no extreme hardship. The Greek government, however, has said it will not take back refugees who make asylum claims in Germany, even if they've first made claims in Greece. Refugee aid organizations continue to speak of an "inhumane situation" for refugees in Greece. "No bed, no bread, no soap," one such group told the group, a "drastic formula" which "has not changed in years." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video German Chancellor Friedrich Merz and French President Emmanuel Macron put on a show of unity during the latter's visit to Berlin on Wednesday. But while the two presented a united European front in response to tariff threats from US President Donald Trump and an intention to discuss corruption issues with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, disagreements remain regarding the development of the joint Franco-German FCAS next-generation fighter jet and the condemnation of Israeli actions in Gaza. "Big topics, great unity," headlined German public broadcaster on Thursday morning, while news magazine quipped: "No fish rolls, at least" – a reference to Macron's visit to Germany in October 2023 when Merz's predecessor Olaf Scholz treated him to a , a local Hamburg delicacy with an acquired taste. Read more about what Merz and Macron discussed on DW. The Central Committee of German Catholics (ZdK) said on Thursday that it was "appalled" by the suffering being endured by Palestinians in the Gaza Strip and called on the German government to ensure the enforcement of international law. "The humanitarian situation for the civilian population in Gaza is catastrophic," ZdK President Irme Stetter-Karp told the Redaktionsnetzwerk Deutschland (RND). While acknowledging that Israel "has a legitimate right to defend itself against the terrorist organization Hamas," she said that didn't absolve the Israeli government from its responsibility to respect international law. Stetter-Karp also said Israel's military operations were impacting the civilian population to an "unjustifiable" extent and highlighted the acute threat of starvation, illness and death facing children in the besieged enclave. "We are aghast that 875 Palestinians have been killed while trying to access aid at the distribution centers in Gaza," she said. "This approach by the Israeli government must end immediately!" Stetter-Karp also highlighted the plight of Palestinian Christians in the occupied West Bank, who she said were increasingly the targets of Israeli settler violence. Germany's second-largest airport is reportedly planning to construct a special deportation terminal in which police will process the repatriation of migrants to be deported. According to a planning document seen by the Reuters news agency, the so-called "repatriation terminal" at Munich Airport is to be around 60 meters (about 200 feet) long and spread over two floors. The facility, which is designed to facilitate "up to 100 arrivals and departures processing up to 50 individual measures and group charter flights daily," is planned for 2028 and will also include a "central check-in in order to coordinate repatriations efficiently," according to the document. German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt and Bavarian Interior Minister Joachim Herrmann, both of the Christian Social Union (CSU), the Bavarian sister party of the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU), have taken a strong stance on deportations of migrants with criminal convictions or rejected asylum claims. Munich Mayor Dieter Reiter, of the center-left Social Democrats (SPD), said the deportation of those convicted of crimes to their home countries was a sensible measure. "Therefore I don't think it's fundamentally wrong to propose such a terminal," he said. But political support is not universal. Local Green party politician Gülseren Demirel told the broadsheet: "We are more than critical of a specific terminal for deportations." While you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter, Berlin Briefing. Welcome to DW's coverage of developments in Germany on Thursday, July 24. Despite Germany's dramatic defeat in the Euro 2025 semifinal last night, we all have to carry on, so here's what's on the agenda today:

Germany urged to clarify refugee policy for Palestinians  – DW – 07/24/2025
Germany urged to clarify refugee policy for Palestinians  – DW – 07/24/2025

DW

time12 hours ago

  • DW

Germany urged to clarify refugee policy for Palestinians – DW – 07/24/2025

After having just lifted a controversial 18-month freeze on asylum rulings, Germany is being pressed to grant full refugee status to Palestinians as Israel's actions in Gaza claim ever more civilian casualties. Shafiq* is a Palestinian who ended up in limbo after he managed to get out of Gaza and make his way via Egypt and Turkey to Germany, where he applied for asylum. The right to asylum is enshrined in Germany's constitution and is granted to individuals who face persecution in their home country due to their race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. But 65-year-old Shafiq arrived a few months after Germany's Federal Office of Migration and Refugees (BAMF) halted the processing of asylum applications in January 2024. "I didn't know. I wasn't sure why they weren't giving me papers. I sent a letter. Maybe six months ago, they answered that they had to wait to know what the situation was in Gaza," he said. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Human rights groups, lawyers and some opposition politicians have rejected BAMF's reasons for freezing applications for people like Shafiq. BAMF cited Article 24 of the Asylum Law, which allows decisions to be postponed in "a temporary uncertain situation." At the time of the suspension, at least 24,000 Palestinians had already been killed in the military incursion launched by Israel, according to Gaza health officials. In a statement issued to DW in conjunction with the German Interior Ministry, BAMF said that decisions about applicants from the Gaza Strip had been "deprioritized" within the administration. The reasons cited by the spokesperson are: "the conflict triggered by the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel by Hamas" (classified by Germany as a terrorist organization) and "the lack of information about the situation in the conflict zone and what persecution the civil population is facing." Legal cases were launched challenging the Federal Office of Migration and Refugees' inaction — most courts ruled in the thwarted applicants' favor. By April 2025, courts had ruled in favor of Palestinian plaintiffs some 187 times. In July 2025, the Federal Interior Ministry (BMI) disclosed in response to media inquiries that asylum claims processing had been resumed, as the situation in Gaza was no longer judged "uncertain." Refugee advocacy organization Pro Asyl told DW that the BAMF processing freeze should never have occurred in the first place. "The actual conditions in Gaza prove that people are very much in real danger of becoming a victim of Israel's military operations at any time simply by their sheer presence," said the organization's legal rights spokesperson, Peter von Auer. Berlin-based human rights lawyer Alexander Gorski described BAMF's freeze as "absurd," adding: "It is very politically difficult to say the situation is unclear — and very inhumane." The number of open asylum cases from people from across the Palestinian territories lodged with German authorities stood at around 1,100 in February 2024. The ongoing blockade of Gaza has made it practically impossible to leave and Palestinians who have fled often choose to join relatives settled in many other parts of the world. In 2024, a total of 634 asylum applications were lodged by Palestinians in Germany. This sank further to 185 in the first six months of 2025. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Advocacy group The Refugee Council of Lower Saxony is helping Palestinians from Gaza and the West Bank to fight for refugee status. Up to now, Palestinians have often been denied the full protection status afforded to other refugees under the Geneva Convention. This has been linked to their exceptional status. Palestinians are the only refugee group to have their own UN agency, UNRWA, which is regarded as responsible for their protection and assistance. Established in late 1949 to provide education, healthcare, food and other services, UNRWA — which operates in Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, the Gaza Strip and the West Bank, including East Jerusalem — was intended to be a temporary measure to help displaced Palestinians after their expulsion from what is now Israel. Germany grants "subsidiary protection" status to those who do not qualify for asylum or refugee protection but are at risk of serious harm if they return to their home country, such as the death penalty, torture, or arbitrary violence in an armed conflict. However, with the UN Palestinian refugee agency currently unable to operate in the Gaza Strip after the Israeli parliament passed a ban, German refugee rights groups and politicians are now questioning whether the granting of subsidiary protection status is legally sound. Article 1d within the Geneva Convention foresees the provision of full protection to Palestinians, too, if UNRWA's help has ceased for any reason. Lawyer and Refugee Council spokesperson Caroline Mohrs cited a European Court of Justice ruling from June 2024 in line with that clause. In Germany, refugee status has clear advantages. It is possible to receive permanent residency after three years — whereas it is five years at the earliest for people with subsidiary protection. And the chance of being allowed to benefit from programs to reunite with their families is higher as well. The new coalition of the conservative Christian Democrats (CDU), Christian Social Union (CSU) and the center-left Social Democrats (SPD) moved in June 2025 to suspend family reunification for those with subsidiary protection status for at least the next two years. Left Party parliamentarian Clara Bünger is also calling for Gazans who flee to Germany to receive refugee status upon arrival. "Many see subsidiary protection as temporary protection. But people need a long-term perspective. And one thing is clear: no one will be able to return to Gaza, to this strip of land," Bünger, who serves as her party's interior affairs spokesperson in parliament, told DW. A lawyer herself, she is now calling for the unprocessed asylum applications to be dealt with "quickly and fairly." Shafiq is still in the dark about how his asylum case will proceed. A social worker and father of four, he left his homeland in 2022 in search of a better life for himself and his family — and the hope of getting medical treatment for his sick daughter. After the Palestinian's departure from Gaza, his 26-year-old daughter died of cancer and his youngest son was killed in an Israeli rocket attack, he told DW. Two other adult children have made it to Europe — one to Germany, but authorities did not permit him to live in the same town as his son. His wife remains in Gaza, living in a tent. The family apartment was destroyed amid the military assault. The Palestinian does not know whether he will be allowed to stay in Germany, but on one thing he is clear: "There is no future, no safety, nothing in Gaza." * While you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter, Berlin Briefing.

German-Afghan relations under scrutiny over deportations – DW – 07/24/2025
German-Afghan relations under scrutiny over deportations – DW – 07/24/2025

DW

time17 hours ago

  • DW

German-Afghan relations under scrutiny over deportations – DW – 07/24/2025

The German government's policy of deporting Afghan criminials to Afghanistan relies on cooperation with the Taliban government in Kabul. The Islamists are hoping this is the first step toward diplomatic recognition. "We have succeeded in organizing another deportation flight with convicted criminals to Afghanistan," Germany's Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt said in a press release on July 18, following the departure of a plane from Leipzig to Kabul with 81 Afghan men with failed asylum applications and criminal convictions on board. As Dobrindt sees it, this flight means that the governing coalition of the center-right bloc of Christian Democratic Union (CDU) and the Christian Social Union (CSU), and the center-left Social Democratic Party (SPD) has made good on its promise. "We will start deporting people to Afghanistan and Syria, beginning with criminals and dangerous individuals," they wrote in their coalition agreement. Deportation flights had already been conducted under the previous center-left government, which lost the general election on February 23, 2025. Nevertheless, Dobrindt (CSU) spoke of a "policy shift" — with reference to the "repatriation offensive." The plan is to put more pressure on countries to take back their citizens. In the case of Afghanistan, this is particularly tricky and sensitive because Germany has not officially recognized the Taliban as a legitimate government. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The Islamist Taliban returned to power in August 2021 following 20 years of struggle, after the US-led military mission ended in failure with the withdrawal of international troops. The humanitarian situation is dire and the radical Islamic fundamentalists have once again been systematically oppressing girls and women. An estimated 377,000 individuals of Afghan origin live in Germany. Many of them came as refugees. Many of them are permitted to stay although their individual asylum request has not been granted. In Germany, just under 11,500 Afghans are registered as required to leave the country, according to the Federal Office for Migration and Refugees (BAMF) in May this year. The BAMF was unable to say whether and how many criminals or dangerous individuals are among those required to leave the country. Deportations to Afghanistan were taking place even before the Taliban regained power. They were controversial at the time due to the precarious security situation and remain so today due to ongoing human rights violations. Interior Minister Dobrindt nevertheless intends to stick to his course: "Serious criminals have no right to reside in our country," he said and government spokesman Stefan Kornelius announced on Monday that more deportations are to follow: "This isn't resolved with one flight." To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Germany is hoping to avoid the impression that it's boosting the Taliban's international standing. The German government speaks of "technical contacts." The recent deportations were facilitated by the Qatari government. As government spokesman Stefan Kornelius put it, Qatar's role is as a mediator: "We're in ongoing contact with the de facto government in Afghanistan to arrange technical aspects." He avoided using the word Taliban. An agreement had been reached for the current Afghan administration to send two representatives to Germany, who will be based in the embassy in Berlin. The new diplomats will be tasked with "supporting further planned repatriation flights." This is the first time that the regime, which is not recognized by Germany, sends its own personnel to Germany. Germany and Afghanistan are clearly entering a new phase. Nevertheless, following the latest deportation flight, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz was adamant: "Diplomatic recognition of the Taliban regime is not up for discussion. That is simply out of the question," Merz said at a press conference in Berlin. However, Conrad Schetter, an Afghanistan expert from the Bonn International Center for Conflict Studies (BICC), believes that other countries may follow Russia's lead and officially recognize the Taliban government. Schetter pointed to Afghanistan's close ties with other countries, including Pakistan and Qatar: if these countries follow Russia's example, it could put considerable political pressure on Western countries, he told DW. "And this is likely to spark the kind of diplomatic momentum that the Taliban are hoping will be triggered by Russia's latest move," said Schetter. To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Peace and conflict researcher Nicole Deitelhoff from the University of Frankfurt am Main has strongly criticized Germany's policy on Afghanistan. In the newspaper, she wrote that deportations are inadmissible if those affected are at risk of torture or inhumane treatment in their country of origin. What's more, she predicts that the policy shift will negatively impact on Germany's reputation. Deitelhoff points to the German government's decision to end its admission program for former Afghan workers who aided the Bundeswehr during its military engagement. "Who can still trust a country that promises its civilian aid workers that it will ensure their safety in the future and then abandons them just like that?" Deitelhoff you're here: Every Tuesday, DW editors round up what is happening in German politics and society. You can sign up here for the weekly email newsletter, Berlin Briefing.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store