NHS in Scotland 'stuck in analogue age' as health boards shell out millions on pagers
Scotland's NHS is " stuck in an analogue age" after it was revealed that health boards have shelled out millions of pounds on pagers in recent years.
The devices were widely used in the 1980s and 1990s for instant communication before being replaced long ago by smartphones.
Scottish Labour said the continued reliance on the devices proved the SNP Government was failing to equip the NHS for the 21st century.
Data obtained by the party found health boards had spent at least £4,596,608 on pagers since 2018/19, with NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde spending almost £1.8 million and NHS Lothian spending close to £1 million.
But the total figure is expected to be higher as some health boards failed to respond to a freedom of information request.
Spending on pagers increased in at least seven health boards, while rising by 8 percent overall between 2018/19 and 2024/25.Scottish Labour is now calling for improvements to hospital WiFi to reduce reliance on outdated technology like pagers and improve service delivery.
At least 13 fax machines — used for sending messages instantly before emails — are still in use in Scottish hospitals.
Jackie Baillie, Scottish Labour health spokeswoman, said: "The UK Labour government is setting out a blueprint for NHS England's digital future, but the SNP, Scotland's NHS is still stuck in an analogue age.
"The SNP has been in power for as long as the iPhone has existed, yet all analogue John has invented is excuses. Getting reliable WiFi in Scottish hospitals is the bare minimum the Scottish Government should do to bring our NHS into the 21 st century.
"While English patients will soon be able to book appointments by app, the SNP can only promise a pilot for dermatology appointments in Lanarkshire.
"Only Scottish Labour can take our NHS out of the SNP's analogue age — that's the new direction Scotland needs."
It comes after Wes Streeting last week branded John Swinney an "analogue politician". The UK Health Secretary took a swipe at the First Minister as plans were announced to expand the NHS app available for patients in England. The Scottish version has yet to launch.
Streeting said: "The UK Labour government is embracing technology to deliver a better NHS for patients and their families, giving them more control and transparency over their treatment.
"In John Swinney the SNP have an analogue politician in a digital age and patients in Scotland are missing out. The SNP have record funding and complete control of the NHS in Scotland.
"There are no excuses for [not having an app in place] and it just shows why Scotland can't afford a third decade of the SNP."
A Scottish Government spokesperson said: 'This spend of £4.6 million since 2018/19 must be seen in the context of an NHS budget that was more than £100 billion over the same period.
'While innovation and use of digital technology is essential to ensure the health and social care system's long-term sustainability, health boards should deploy the technology that enables NHS staff to best serve the needs of patients.
"We expect health boards to embrace the latest tools, but also understand that pagers may be more practical and preferred in some cases.
'We have already taken significant steps through our Operational Improvement Plan and Health and Social Care Service Renewal Framework to set out clear actions to harness digital innovation, improve access to treatment, shift the balance of care into the community and strengthen prevention.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Rhyl Journal
4 minutes ago
- Rhyl Journal
Unite could move to disaffiliate from Labour in future, union boss warns
Unite general secretary Sharon Graham criticised the Deputy Prime Minister after her union voted to suspend Ms Rayner's membership on Friday. Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme on Saturday, Ms Graham said: 'Angela Rayner refuses to get involved, and she is directly aiding and abetting the fire and rehire of these bin workers, it is totally and utterly abhorrent.' At their conference in Brighton, Unite members also voted to 're-examine' their relationship with Labour. Unite is one of a number of unions which are affiliated with the Labour Party, and pay hundreds of thousands of pounds towards it each year, as well as making donations to individual Labour MPs. Ms Graham told the BBC that re-examining the union's relationship with Labour could mean disaffiliation, potentially leaving the party without a major donor it has previously relied upon. Unite members have to see that the fee to affiliate with Labour is 'worth something', she said. Ms Graham added: 'At this present moment in time, it is hard to justify it, if I'm being honest. 'Would that money be better spent on frontline services for my members? 'But the decision will be a serious decision. 'It's not a rash decision.' Such a decision would go to a rules conference of the union, she said, adding that she was 'having pressure to have an emergency rules conference, which would mean we would disaffiliate'. Ms Graham said: 'If it was me and I had a major backer like Unite, that has everyday people in it, remember, this was a vote of members at the parliament of our union, that were saying that we don't believe that Labour defends workers in the way that we thought they would, we believe that they're making the wrong decisions, I would be concerned about that.' After Unite announced it had suspended the Deputy Prime Minister's membership, a source close to Ms Rayner said she had already resigned her membership of the union in April. The union boss suggested Ms Rayner may have attempted to do a 'Houdini act' in recent months by leaving Unite. Membership is counted in quarters of the year, Ms Graham said, and the Deputy PM was a member as of the March records. She added: 'Now, if she has over the last couple of weeks, because she's seen the mood music, because this isn't the first time that we've discussed that we're not happy with what's going on, then she may well have done that.' Unite also voted on Friday to suspend the union membership of John Cotton, the Labour leader of Birmingham City Council, and other union members on the authority. The strikes have resulted in unsanitary conditions throughout the city, with large piles of rubbish in the streets. Downing Street insisted on Friday that the Government's priority throughout the dispute had 'always' been Birmingham's residents.
South Wales Guardian
5 minutes ago
- South Wales Guardian
Unite could move to disaffiliate from Labour in future, union boss warns
Unite general secretary Sharon Graham criticised the Deputy Prime Minister after her union voted to suspend Ms Rayner's membership on Friday. Speaking on BBC Radio 4's Today programme on Saturday, Ms Graham said: 'Angela Rayner refuses to get involved, and she is directly aiding and abetting the fire and rehire of these bin workers, it is totally and utterly abhorrent.' At their conference in Brighton, Unite members also voted to 're-examine' their relationship with Labour. Unite is one of a number of unions which are affiliated with the Labour Party, and pay hundreds of thousands of pounds towards it each year, as well as making donations to individual Labour MPs. Ms Graham told the BBC that re-examining the union's relationship with Labour could mean disaffiliation, potentially leaving the party without a major donor it has previously relied upon. Unite members have to see that the fee to affiliate with Labour is 'worth something', she said. Ms Graham added: 'At this present moment in time, it is hard to justify it, if I'm being honest. 'Would that money be better spent on frontline services for my members? 'But the decision will be a serious decision. 'It's not a rash decision.' Such a decision would go to a rules conference of the union, she said, adding that she was 'having pressure to have an emergency rules conference, which would mean we would disaffiliate'. Ms Graham said: 'If it was me and I had a major backer like Unite, that has everyday people in it, remember, this was a vote of members at the parliament of our union, that were saying that we don't believe that Labour defends workers in the way that we thought they would, we believe that they're making the wrong decisions, I would be concerned about that.' After Unite announced it had suspended the Deputy Prime Minister's membership, a source close to Ms Rayner said she had already resigned her membership of the union in April. The union boss suggested Ms Rayner may have attempted to do a 'Houdini act' in recent months by leaving Unite. Membership is counted in quarters of the year, Ms Graham said, and the Deputy PM was a member as of the March records. She added: 'Now, if she has over the last couple of weeks, because she's seen the mood music, because this isn't the first time that we've discussed that we're not happy with what's going on, then she may well have done that.' Unite also voted on Friday to suspend the union membership of John Cotton, the Labour leader of Birmingham City Council, and other union members on the authority. The strikes have resulted in unsanitary conditions throughout the city, with large piles of rubbish in the streets. Downing Street insisted on Friday that the Government's priority throughout the dispute had 'always' been Birmingham's residents.
The Independent
7 minutes ago
- The Independent
Kemi Badenoch opposes major energy project in her constituency – despite hitting out at nimbyism
Kemi Badenoch has been accused of 'staggering hypocrisy' after privately opposing an energy infrastructure project in her constituency, despite taking aim at the government for not doing enough to tackle nimby blockers. In a letter to constituents last month, seen by The Independent, the Tory leader said she has 'joined six other Conservative MPs from across East Anglia in writing to Ed Miliband to demand a fair and thorough assessment of alternatives to the Norwich to Tilbury pylons project'. She said the project – which passes through her Saffron Waldon constituency – "risks permanent environmental and visual damage, would hurt house prices, disrupt farms, businesses and community spaces". The project will see a new 400 kilovolt electricity transmission line built between Norwich and Tilbury, spanning over 180 kilometres. Mrs Badenoch said she told the energy secretary to consider laying the pylons underground, even though such a move is estimated to cost taxpayers far more. When the Tory leader's office was asked about her opposition to the plans, they claimed 'there is evidence it is just as cost-effective' to put the cables underground. But when asked to provide the evidence, they failed to do so. National Grid sources said that burying the cables would not only be up to seven times more expensive, it would also not meet the requirements of the project. Meanwhile, a report from the Institution of Engineering and Technology said underground cables are, on average, around 4.5 times more expensive than overhead lines. Writing in The Times less than a month ago, Mrs Badenoch said: "Politically, government is increasingly powerless in the face of legal challenges. 'Last week I spoke about the tangle of domestic and international rules that block us building new homes and infrastructure '. And last year, as shadow housing secretary in the weeks after the election, she suggested that new Labour backbenchers would turn into nimbys when they face complaints from voters. 'Many of them have been thinking they'd get into government and concrete over lots of Tory constituencies,' she told the Commons. 'Three weeks ago just 15 per cent of the green belt was in Labour constituencies, now it's 50 per cent. They aren't Tory constituencies now, they are Labour. 'They are now your voters and you're going to have to tell them that you're going to do something that many of you promised locally that you would never do.' Labour MP for Milton Keynes North, Chris Curtis, warned that Mrs Badenoch's decision to oppose the pylon line demonstrates 'the same 'one rule for us' mindset that brought us wild parties in Downing Street while the country suffered in silence'. " Kemi Badenoch is fast becoming the poster child for everything the British public rightly despises about politics', he said. 'She rails against legal blockages in the media while using them at home when it suits her. Voters have had over a decade of being lectured by politicians in Westminster, only to watch them flip flop whenever they could benefit personally or politically. 'It is the same 'one rule for us' mindset that brought us wild parties in Downing Street while the country suffered in silence.' He added: 'But that kind of hypocrisy is not just insulting, it is holding Britain back'. Meanwhile, David Taylor – Labour MP for Hemel Hempstead – said it was 'staggering hypocrisy', warning that Britain 'can't afford more Tory nimbyism when our country's future is on the line.' He said: 'After her government did their best to bankrupt the country, she's joined fellow Tory MPs to block the Tilbury pylons project in her own patch, while the country urgently needs new energy infrastructure to keep the lights on and power new homes. 'This is classic one rule for them, another for everyone else. The Conservatives were in power for 14 years and left us with the worst housebuilding record since the 1920s, a time when pylons hadn't even been invented. 'Now Labour's in government, we're serious about building the infrastructure and homes Britain desperately needs.' A spokesperson for National Grid said: 'We're committed to consulting extensively and listening to the views of communities and stakeholders as we develop and shape our plans. "Our role is to find a way to take the home-grown, more affordable and cleaner energy from where it's generated to where it's needed in our homes, business and public services, and we share our plans with Ofgem to ensure value for money for bill payers. 'We consider all technology options - offshore, underground, and overhead lines - and then balance a range of factors, including what's possible from an engineering and environmental point of view and feedback from local communities. 'The secretary of state for energy security & net zero will then make the final decision, following a recommendation from the Planning Inspectorate, on whether we have got that balance right when considering granting planning permission.' A spokesperson for Mrs Badenoch said: 'She's pushing for the cables to be buried. She's on the record calling for this and that there is evidence it is just as cost effective.'
