Apple must pay Optis $502 million lump sum in UK patent dispute, court rules
Apple
must pay a U.S. patent holder $502 million for the use of
4G patents
in devices including iPhones and iPads, London's Court of Appeal ruled on Thursday, in the latest stage of a long-running legal battle.
Texas-based Optis Cellular Technology LLC sued Apple in London in 2019 over its use of patents which Optis says are essential to certain technological standards, such as 4G.
London's High Court ruled in 2023 that Apple should pay Optis a total of $56.43 million plus interest to cover past and future sales over a set period.
But Optis argued that was far too low and challenged the decision at an appeal heard in February and March.
The Court of Appeal said in a partially-redacted written ruling that Apple should pay a lump sum of $502 million, not including interest, for the period from 2013 to 2027.
The lump sum relates to a global licence to use Optis' patents.
An Apple spokesperson said they were "disappointed by this decision and plan to appeal".
"Optis makes no products and their sole business is to sue companies using patents they buy," the spokesperson added. "We will continue to defend against their attempts to extract unreasonable payments."
Optis did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside U.S. office hours.
Thursday's ruling is the latest decision in the legal battle between Apple and Optis over the FRAND (fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory) terms to use Optis' patents.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
11 minutes ago
- Time of India
Apple hits pause on foldable iPad plans, here's why
Apple is said to be working on a foldable iPad which the company was rumoured to launch this year. However, a new online report suggests that Apple has halted the development of its foldable iPad due to high production cost, limited consumer demand and some unsolved technical and design issues. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now According to a report by DigiTimes, the Cupertino-based tech giant has presently shifted its focus from foldable iPad to foldable iPhone. The foldable iPhone is going through early prototyping stages and is tipped to launch next year. The foldable iPad, once envisioned as a premium hybrid between a tablet and a MacBook, is now delayed indefinitely, with no clear timeline for revival. 'Sources familiar with the matter say Apple had also been exploring a foldable iPad alongside the iPhone. However, the company has decided to pause progress on the larger foldable device for the time being. Industry experts attribute this decision to manufacturing difficulties, increased production expenses—particularly related to flexible display technology—and a relatively modest consumer demand for larger foldable devices,' said the report. The report also suggests that sources close to the matter reveal the foldable iPad's price tag could exceed even its most expensive iPads, making it a tough sell in a market where tablets already occupy a niche segment. Additionally, Apple's insistence on a crease-free display—a problem that still plagues many foldables—has proven difficult to solve without driving up cost. While the project isn't canceled outright, analysts now expect a potential launch closer to 2028, if at all.
India Today
15 minutes ago
- India Today
It is true: Soham Parekh admits working multiple full-time jobs at once, says it was necessary
India-based software engineerSoham Parekh has publicly admitted to simultaneously working full-time for multiple startups, in a disclosure that has reignited debates around remote work norms and ethics in the tech industry. The issue first emerged when Suhail Doshi, former CEO of Mixpanel, posted on X alleging that Parekh was employed by '34 startups at the same time' and had deceived Y Combinator-backed firms. Doshi claimed he terminated Parekh within a week after discovering the overlap. Additional founders corroborated Doshi's warning, leading at least one to cancel Parekh's trial week, while another revealed they had just interviewed him before learning of his dual eventually responded to the allegations during an interview on the tech show TBPN, openly acknowledging the truth behind the accusations. 'It is true,' he said, adding, 'I'm not proud of what I've you know, financial circumstances, essentially. No one really likes to work 140 hours a week, right? But I had to do this out of necessity. I was in extremely dire financial circumstances.' He clarified that he personally handled all assigned work without the help of other engineers or AI to Parekh, he began juggling multiple full-time jobs around 2022 after postponing graduate school and enrolling in an online program from Georgia Tech. However, a spokesperson from Georgia Tech reportedly confirmed that there is no record of Parekh as an enrolled student—raising questions about the timeline or documentation. Further exposure came via an exchange on X with Andriy Mulyar, CEO of Nomic AI, who confirmed Parekh worked there. Parekh stated he once held up to four concurrent roles, earning between $30,000 and $40,000 monthly. Mulyar later verified Parekh's identity and affected employer, Marcus Lowe of Create, described hiring Parekh after a strong interview performance but soon faced attendance issues. Lowe reviewed Parekh's GitHub activity and found code contributions to another startup, during claimed personal downtime. He said the situation 'was a huge waste of time such direct immoral behavior felt worth speaking out about.'In addition to Lowe's account, several employees confirmed Parekh's involvement, supported by internal materials and online content showing his presence within their operations. The company declined further controversy has drawn attention to the growing trend of 'overemployment,' where workers take multiple remote jobs without disclosing full engagement. A Wall Street Journal report estimates about 5.5percent of Americans now hold two or more jobs—a trend accelerated by pandemic-era remote work freedoms. However, conflicts with employment agreements and fairness concerns have triggered scrutiny within startup communities, particularly among small teams reliant on full-time the public exposure, Parekh said he has accepted a single role with Darwin, a young startup. Darwin's founder and CEO, Sanjit Juneja, issued a statement expressing confidence in Parekh's skills: 'Soham is an incredibly talented engineer and we believe in his abilities to help bring our products to market.'advertisementParekh also responded via his confirmed X account, stating, 'I've been isolated, written off and shut out by nearly everyone I've known and every company I've worked at. But building is the only thing I've ever truly known, and it's what I'll keep doing.'He reassured that he has ended all other employment engagements and entered into an exclusive agreement with Darwin.- Ends
Mint
19 minutes ago
- Mint
‘Sent me a ChatGPT email': Laid-off TikTok worker slams company amid layoffs, exposes toxic work culture
Amid the controversial layoffs at TikTok's parent company ByteDance, employees are speaking out against the China-based firm's allegedly toxic work culture. In one such social media post, a laid off employee claimed that he was sent an AI-generated email to inform that he was let go by TikTok. Posting on professional social media platform Blind, the worker, who withheld his name, said he stayed up late to deliver his work all the time, but TikTok just sent a 'ChatGPT email' to let him know about his layoff. 'I'm impacted in the latest Bytedance/TikTok layoff. I worked my ass off, staying up late for late night meetings, delivering on always random critical shit projects that don't make sense. Then they sent me a ChatGPT email,' he said. The employee claimed that there was no clarity on what comes for the laid off employees next. 'What I want to know is, what's the next process? Will they literally reach out to everyone that's laid off to talk about the next step via personal email? Can we negotiate on severance?' The laid off staffer accused TikTok of honing 'toxic' work culture, and threatened to complain to the US Congress. 'I know so much toxic culture problems that the Congress and other public would love to hear about discriminations, disgusting bathroom usage, and how incompetently they still deal with personally identifiable information of American citizens,' the employee said. Beleagured video sharing platform TikTok has opted for a third round of layoffs since April in the US, this time hitting workers from its US e-commerce division TikTok Shop, Bloomberg reported on Thursday. 'As the TikTok Shop business evolves, we regularly review our operations to ensure long-term success,' a spokesperson for the video-sharing app was quoted as saying in a statement Wednesday. 'We've made the difficult decision to adjust parts of our team to better align with strategic priorities,' the spokesperson said. TikTok Shop's US operations have undergone a series of changes in the past few months following a year in which the division fell short of internal sales targets. TikTok Shop eliminated some jobs in April and enacted a second round of cuts in May, Bloomberg previously reported. TikTok has not issued an official comment on how many people will be affected due to its latest round of layoffs.
