Man who threatened to shoot garda and spat blood in patrol car has jail term overturned
A man who threatened to shoot a garda, acted 'extremely aggressively' and spat blood in a patrol car has had his six-month prison sentence replaced with a suspended term on appeal.
Thomas McDonagh (23) with a last address at St Margaret's Park, Ballymun, Dublin made threats to a garda member's life and repeatedly squirted Lucozade at him.
McDonagh had pleaded not guilty in the District Court to four charges including failure to comply with a garda member under section 8 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act, 1994, obstruction of a peace officer under section 19 of the act and threatening and abusive behaviour under section 6 of the same act.
He also faced a charge for the criminal damage of a garda car under section 2(1) of the Criminal Damage Act 1991. He was convicted of all four charges and given a sentence of six months in custody, a term against which he later appealed.
Dublin District Court
Today's News in 90 Seconds - July 19th
Garda Pierce O'Dwyer told the District Court Appeals Court on Monday that he responded to a call at St Margaret's Park in Ballymun on May 12, 2023.
He said that gardaí were surrounded by ten to 12 men who were demanding that they leave and were acting aggressively.
Garda O'Dwyer said that McDonagh was 'extremely aggressive from the start' and shouted a number of threats at him, including that he knew where he lived and that he would shoot him.
He said that McDonagh sprayed him twice with a bottle of Lucozade and continued to be aggressive with him.
Garda O'Dwyer said that McDonagh was arrested, handcuffed and conveyed to a garda station, where his aggressive behaviour continued and he spat blood in a garda car, resulting in a cleaning fee of 52 euro.
Defence counsel for McDonagh, Paul Larkin Coyle BL, said his client now accepts that his behaviour was totally unacceptable and was appealing the case on the severity of his sentence only.
Mr Coyle said McDonagh was 'begging for a chance' so that he can be present for his children and that his client made an apology to the garda and the court for his behaviour.
Mr Larkin said that McDonagh's pregnant wife was in hospital at the time of the incident, and McDonagh 'got lost in the emotion of it' and 'totally lost the head'.
He said that his client is now the father of twins, understands the error of his ways and has removed himself from a situation where he was getting in trouble.
The court heard that McDonagh has 22 previous convictions, including incidents of theft, criminal damage and the possession of a knife.
Judge Christopher Callan said that McDonagh's actions were serious and it was 'difficult to see how the court can have much sympathy for him' after he threatened to shoot a garda and behaved aggressively.
Judge Callan said that the job of a garda in this day and age is very difficult and what McDonagh did 'does not make it easy'.
He said that what McDonagh did to the garda was 'completely unacceptable' but it does appear that he is turning a corner in his life since the incident.
Judge Callan decided to suspend McDonagh's six month sentence for a period of two years on the condition that he keeps the peace, engages with the probation services and provides a donation of 500 euro to the Capuchin Day Centre.
Funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
25 minutes ago
- The Journal
Convicted killer used €100,000 of criminal earnings to finance renovations of his Limerick home
A CONVICTED KILLER who is a member of a gang involved in violent feuding used €100,000 of the proceeds of crime to renovate his house, a court has been told. Detective Garda Ronan O'Reilly told the Special Criminal Court that Richard Treacy (36), was involved in a feud in the city – he served six years for the manslaughter of another man. Richard Treacy (36), of Downey St, Garryowen, Co Limerick, pleaded guilty that he, between 1 January, 2014 and 12 January, 2021, knowing or being reckless as to whether renovation work carried out at his home address was the proceeds of criminal conduct, did disguise the true source of the property. The offence is contrary to section 7 of the Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010. The Downey Street house is registered in the name of his mother but Treacy lives there with his two children and his partner. O'Reilly told the court that the gardaí had carried out a search at the house on 17 June 2020 and found money in euros and sterling in a number of locations. They found €4,000 in a drawer in a bedroom, €500 and €600 in cash in a kitchen cupboard and £3,900 in sterling. Following this Treacy came to the garda station and spoke to gardaí under caution – in this interview he claimed that the monies they seized were for renovations of his home. Treacy said his mother gave him the €4,000 for an extension but gave no explanation for the sterling. He said he saved the €600 and that the €500 was his dole money. Advertisement Garda enquiries led detectives to seek an order to freeze the financial accounts of the Richard Treacy. The gardaí also engaged a quantity surveyor and other experts to assist them in their investigation. When asked for the details of the previous convictions of the accused O'Reilly told the judges that Treacy had served a six year term for the manslaughter of a man in a feud in Limerick. That was in connection to the death of Darren Coughlan who was attacked and beaten to death on the Old Cratloe Road in the city in 2005. Three years after that the dead man's brother John shot Treacy's brother Daniel. John Coughlan is serving a life sentence for that crime. Treacy is also a nephew of the Limerick city gang leader Kieran Keane. O'Reilly listed other convictions including public order, dangerous driving and an incident violent disorder related to feuding in Limerick city. Barrister for the Defence Lorcan Connolly raised an application for the three judge panel to be recused stating that the mention of feuding was not specific and included in the charges for his client. Connolly told the judges that that the feud 'phraseology didn't feature in any part of the case'. The barrister said the garda 'went off piste' and said it to 'colour' the defendant in the minds of the judges. After rising briefly the three judges returned and Ms Justice Karen O'Connor, presiding, said they would not recuse themselves from the sentence hearing. She said that all three judges were 'very experienced at ignoring certain matters'. The Judge adjourned the case for sentence until 20 October – Treacy has been remanded on continuing bail. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man bought fake no claims bonus for car insurance on Facebook, Cork court told
A Brazilian man who was trying to secure car insurance in Ireland purchased a fake no claims bonus from a Facebook page which he submitted to the insurance company, a district court in Cork has heard. Court presenter Sergeant Eimear O'Connell told Bandon District Court that Claudio Rodrigues Pereira, aged 47 of Emmet Row, Bandon, Co Cork, submitted the false document to Axa Insurance as part of an application for motor insurance in April 2023. Axa made a complaint to gardaí about the application and Pereira was arrested and charged with using a false instrument under the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act, 2001. The court was told that Pereira had three previous convictions, two of which were for using a false instrument arising from a similar incident where he had applied to Liberty Insurance also in 2023. On that occasion he had bought a false Portuguese driving licence from a Facebook page. Defence solicitor Plunkett Taaffe said that Pereira had been living in Ireland for four years and had a full Brazilian licence when he arrived. He said that his client had been 'duped' by the Facebook page offering licenses and no claims bonuses and was 'very contrite.' Mr Taaffe said that the offending occurred over a short period of time and that his client was now taking lessons with a view to obtaining an Irish driving licence. Judge Joanne Carroll said that the offence was 'a terrible deception' that was clearly premeditated and that Pereira was 'trying to bypass Irish law while a visitor to this country.' She added: 'If you go on to a Facebook page to buy a licence or other documents you are setting out to deceive, the question is can this man stay out of prison?' Claudio Rodrigues Pereira was sentenced to four months in prison, suspended for 18 months. This article is funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
Irish Examiner
6 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man was selling cocaine for well-known Bandon family, court hears
A Cork man who pleaded guilty to the possession of cocaine for sale or supply was selling the drugs on behalf of a well-known Bandon family, according to his solicitor. Court presenter Sergeant Eimear O'Connell told Bandon District Court that a garda patrol was in the Castle Road area of Bandon, Co Cork, just after midnight on February 13, 2023. They observed an individual, identified as Adrian Dineen, aged 35 of Sunnyside, Kilbarry, Dunmanway, Co Cork, behaving in a suspicious manner. When Dineen was question he became nervous and he was searched. On his person gardaí found a white substance in his wallet later identified as cocaine and deal bags of cocaine in his jacket pockets. The total value of cocaine recovered was €500. Dineen was also in possession of a mobile phone that showed evidence of drug dealing activity. When questioned Dineen admitted possession of cocaine for sale or supply. The court heard that Dineen had 29 previous convictions, including three for the possession of illegal drugs but none for sale or supply. Defence solicitor Éamonn Fleming said that his client had 'completely cleaned up his act' since his arrest. He said that Dineen was now working full-time in a factory near Bandon and cycled the 12km to work every day 'come rain or shine'. He added that Dineen was an 'active father' to his two young children who were in the care of their maternal grandparents who he had a good relationship with and also paid maintenance. The court heard that Dinnen was drug-free for a year and a half and had attended counselling and underwent drug testing for work. Mr Fleming said that at the time of the offending Dineen was 'acting at the behest' of a family from Bandon who were well-known to the court and involved in drug-dealing. Judge Joanne Carroll said that if Mr Fleming's appraisal of Dineen's progress was correct he could expect 'a positive outcome'. She ordered a probation report and directed Dineen to take one random drug test at the direction of the Probation Service. She remanded him on continuing bail to appear again on November 7 for finalisation. This article is funded by the Courts Reporting Scheme
