Woman claims BMW Financial Services' non-cooperation led to R787,000 debt
Image: Supplied
A woman who bought a car through BMW Financial Services is accusing the motor company of failing to cooperate when she indicated that she was unable to continue making payments to her car.
The woman, who has chosen to remain anonymous, purchased a BMW 218i Gran Coupe M Sport in October 2021, with the vehicle being financed through BMW Financial Services. According to the terms of the agreement, she was granted a credit facility exceeding R787,000 to cover the cost of the vehicle. This financing arrangement came with an estimated monthly repayment obligation of more than R11,000, placing a significant financial commitment on her.
She was able to maintain her monthly instalments for just over six months before coming to a realisation that the monthly instalments were financially not viable as it was consuming nearly half her salary leaving her with insufficient funds to cover her basic financial needs and other financial obligations. This growing strain on her finances forced her to reassess her ability to continue honouring the credit agreement, prompting her to reach out to BMW Financial Services to seek relief or explore alternative solutions.
She explained that after recognising the financial strain, she approached BMW Financial Services to request assistance in selling the vehicle, hoping to find a solution that would alleviate her debt burden. However, she was informed by the motor company that the total amount required to settle the outstanding debt on the vehicle was R814,000. At the same time, BMW offered to purchase the vehicle for only R600,000, which would leave her with a significant shortfall of R214,000. Despite her efforts to engage and find a mutually beneficial resolution, she alleges that no further assistance, guidance, or alternative options were provided by the company. This left her feeling abandoned and solely responsible for the substantial debt, with no meaningful support from the institution that had financed the purchase.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
"After mounting arrears and further attempts to engage BMW, our client voluntarily surrendered the vehicle on June 7, 2022 – the valuation provided by BMW reflected a large shortfall, and she took back the vehicle in an effort to secure a better private offer," said her attorney, Liesel Kriel.
After relocating from Gauteng to Durban in an effort to improve her financial circumstances, she said she actively sought out better trade-in or resale offers for the vehicle. She managed to secure more favourable valuations from multiple third-party dealers, which exceeded the initial offer made by BMW. In a bid to resolve the matter, she submitted the alternative quotes to BMW Financial Services, along with supporting financial documentation detailing her income and financial hardship. However, despite her proactive approach and willingness to cooperate, she claims that BMW failed to respond and completely ignored her submissions.
To her shock, she later discovered in November 2022 that the vehicle had been transferred out of her name as far back as June 2022 without her knowledge, permission, or any formal notification. This discovery raised serious concerns for her, not only about the handling of the vehicle but also about the lack of transparency and communication from BMW Financial Services throughout the process.
After the shocking discovery she lodged a complaint against BMW with the Motor Industry Ombudsman of South Africa (MIOSA), which directed her to the National Credit Regulator (NCR) due to the matter relating to reckless lending.
According to her, it was around this time that , she was also informed that legal proceedings had been instituted against her by BMW Financial Services. She expressed shock and frustration, particularly because she had previously notified BMW in writing, via email, of her change of address following her relocation from Gauteng to Durban. Despite this clear communication, she claims that BMW continued to serve legal documents at her former address, effectively depriving her of the opportunity to respond to or engage with the legal process in a timely and meaningful manner. As a result, she believes that BMW acted negligently and unfairly, further compounding her distress and legal vulnerability.
She said the NCR process was plagued with delays – it was only in June 2024 that the NCR advised her the matter had not been considered and then issued a non-referral notice, prompting her to refer the matter to the National Consumer Tribunal (NCT).
During the tribunal proceedings, it was noted that woman had opted not to defend herself when the case was in the High Court, and as a result, her claims of reckless lending against BMW were not considered.
In February 2025, the NCT held that the high court is a competent forum that had already reached a decisive conclusion on her failure to honour her financial commitments.
"Any subsequent ruling by the tribunal regarding reckless lending will impact the high court's judgment, which goes against the principle of res judicata," said the tribunal.
She said following the judgment, in March 2025, BMW attempted to enforce the judgment and execute the warrant at her erstwhile address – the address was later amended.
"Due to BMW's lack of cooperation, our client had no choice but to obtain legal assistance and as such our offices proceeded to launch a rescission application based on the pending regulatory processes and improper service," said Kriel.
Kriel said BMW has opposed the rescission application, raising technical defences, including the time delay in bringing the application.
"BMW maintains that our client was aware of the proceedings, had a chance to respond, and that the regulatory complaints were merely delay tactics," Kriel added.
When approached for comment, BMW declined to speak on the matter, stating that it remained sub judice.
"I have, however, determined the matter is still being considered by a court. We cannot, therefore, provide comments to you at this time," said BMW spokesperson, Hailey Philander.
In closing, the woman's case reflects the complex and often frustrating journey consumers face when navigating disputes with large financial institutions. Despite her efforts to seek assistance from BMW Financial Services, the National Credit Regulator, and eventually the National Consumer Tribunal, procedural technicalities and jurisdictional limitations ultimately stood in the way of her reckless lending claim being meaningfully assessed. The High Court's prior ruling based on her failure to defend the matter effectively closed the door to further adjudication by the Tribunal, citing the legal principle of res judicata, which prevents re-litigation of issues already decided by a competent court.
The attempted enforcement of the judgment at her former address and the subsequent legal wrangling over the rescission application have only added to the woman's sense of being sidelined by a system she believes failed to accommodate her financial vulnerability. Her legal representative, Kriel, argues that the mishandling of notices and the disregard of pending regulatory processes justify reopening the case. BMW, however, continues to oppose the rescission, framing the delays and regulatory complaints as tactical manoeuvres rather than legitimate grievances.
With BMW declining to comment further due to the matter being sub judice, the case remains in legal limbo highlighting the wider challenges consumers face when trying to assert their rights in the face of institutional power and procedural complexity.
IOL
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
37 minutes ago
- IOL News
SA Reserve Bank rate cut offers relief to consumers
South African Reserve Bank governor Lesetja Kganyago. Image: Thobile Mathonsi / Independent Newspapers South African consumers were given some reprieve this past week as the South African Reserve Bank lowered interest rates in the country. Sarb Governor Governor Lesetja Kganyago announced that the central bank's Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) voted to cut the repurchase rate (repo rate) by 25 basis points (BPS). This means the repo rate will decrease from 7.25% to 7%, effectively taking the prime lending rate to the country to 10.50% from 10.75%. Kganyago said that the decision was unanimous by the MPC members. "For policy, as we showed last time, lower inflation allows for lower interest rates. In our Quarterly Projection Model, for a 4.5% objective, rates bottom out around 7%. By contrast, the forecast for a 3% objective has roughly five more cuts, over the medium term, taking interest rates slightly below 6%. The logic of the model is that interest rates need to fall as inflation eases, to prevent the inflation-adjusted rate, or real interest rate, from rising too much. Real rates are nonetheless temporarily higher for a 3% objective, and there is a modest growth sacrifice, which helps anchor expectations at lower levels," the Sarb Governor said on Thursday. Frank Blackmore, Lead economist at KPMG said that that the repo rate was reduced because the stronger rand helped moderate inflationary pressures. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ "Although there is some increase in food price inflation, headline inflation is seen by the bank to come in at around 3.3% for 2025. One of the most interesting statements made by the governor of the Reserve Bank at this MPC announcement was that the Reserve Bank will start to aim at the bottom of the inflation target range which is at 3% as their inflation target going forward," Blackmore told Business Report. "There are several benefits to lowering that inflation target from the current 4.5% to the 3% level. Firstly, the core inflation remains close to 3% instead of reverting back up towards 4.5%. However, expectations will take a while to come down to this 3% level as well. Secondly, there will be further rate cuts on the 3% target scenario. The governor mentioned up to five more possible cuts, this would lead us to level of around 5.75% on repo or 9.25% prime," Blackmore added. "This would lower the borrowing costs and support the strength of the Rand. Reducing inflation to this level is an exciting prospect going forward," Blackmore said. Meanwhile, Neil Roets CEO of Debt Rescue said that the latest repo rate cut offers little real relief for millions of South Africans battling financial strain. Roets said, "Consumers are facing a looming crisis, as both global and local economic pressures combine to hit household budgets even harder. 'What's coming could make the challenges of recent months look mild by comparison. A major concern is the 30% tariff hike on South African exports, which took effect on Friday, 1 August." 'This is not just a trade issue, it's a direct threat to consumer financial stability,' Roets added. 'Sectors like agriculture, wine, metals, vehicles, and manufacturing are all at risk. The knock-on effect will be felt in rising costs for food, fuel, and other essentials, along with job losses and business closures,' he said. 'Consumers are expected to survive under impossible conditions. Their budgets are stretched to the last rand. Hope has been their only lifeline — and even that is beginning to fade,' Roets said. He warned that the current wave of economic setbacks could be the final blow for millions. 'We're not just talking about financial strain anymore — we are staring down the possibility of widespread social unrest. The warning signs are clear, and urgent action is needed.' 'My advice to those who have fallen into a debt trap is to seek help from a registered debt counsellor who can assist them to manage their financial predicament. This has been a very successful solution for thousands of consumers who are plagued by over-indebtedness,' Roets said. BUSINESS REPORT
The Citizen
37 minutes ago
- The Citizen
2025 Nissan Magnite scores upgraded safety rating
Introduced to the South African market in June 2021, the pre-facelifted current-generation Nissan Magnite only managed to score two stars at the Global New Car Assessment Programme (GNCAP). However, the updated model, which made local landfall in October 2024, has now improved on the original safety rating; upgrading to a GNCAP safety rating of five stars overall. The India-built crossover was awarded five stars for Adult Occupant Protection and three stars for Child Occupant Protection; accumulating in the overall five-star score. 'This significant milestone further cements the Magnite as a safety and engineering leader within the sub-R400k compact-SUV space. Our engineers achieved an incredible feat, raising the Magnite from a two-star to five-star safety rating in a remarkably short timeframe,' said Maciej Klenkiewicz, the managing director of Nissan South Africa and independent markets. Richard Woods, the CEO of GNCAP, added: 'It's very welcome to see Nissan's focus on improving the Magnite's safety performance. The five-star rating is relevant to consumers in South Africa and India, and it demonstrates what can be achieved in a relatively short period of time when a manufacturer is fully committed to engage in the NCAP process.' The most affordable compact SUV in South Africa, the Magnite is equipped with such safety items as six airbags, ABS, electronic brake-force distribution, electronic stability control, traction control and hill start assist, among others. As a reminder, locally, the Magnite is available with the choice of two 1l, three-cylinder engines – one naturally aspirated and the other, turbocharged. The former and latter units produce 53kW/96Nm and 74kW/152Nm, respectively, and have respective claimed average fuel consumption figures of 5.9l/100km and 6.0l/100km. Browse thousands of new and used vehicles here with CARmag! The post 2025 Nissan Magnite Scores Upgraded Safety Rating appeared first on CAR Magazine. Breaking news at your fingertips… Follow Caxton Network News on Facebook and join our WhatsApp channel. Nuus wat saakmaak. Volg Caxton Netwerk-nuus op Facebook en sluit aan by ons WhatsApp-kanaal.
IOL News
an hour ago
- IOL News
Stellenbosch FC chief Rob Benadie: How SA can become a continental powerhouse again
Stellenbosch FC chief executive Rob Benadie says South African football can be a continental powerhouse if they sort out the off-field issues. Image: Backpagepix In the ever-turbulent world of South African football, few voices speak with as much calm, clarity, and measured insight as Rob Benadie, CEO of Stellenbosch FC. As his club prepares for another competitive Betway Premiership season, Benadie's reflections offer not only a window into the ambitions of a growing club but also a pointed commentary on the state of football in the country. Speaking during an interview with the South African Football Journalists Association (Safja), Benadie was characteristically open, outlining both the footballing and operational blueprint of a club that has steadily emerged from the Cape Winelands to become a respected force in the PSL. 'We go into the season usually as one of the better-prepared clubs,' Benadie noted. 'We try to do everything we can to ensure we're ready — from pre-season training camps to scouting smartly.' Indeed, the club's approach to recruitment is methodical. While Stellenbosch FC lost key players such as Ismael Toure, Fawaaz Basadien and Sihle Nduli, Benadie is confident in their replacements — a Belgian centre-back, a left-back from Azerbaijan, and depth in midfield, including the arrival of midfield dynamo Khiba. 'We're confident in our scouting process,' Benadie explained. 'Our recruitment uses data, video analysis, and coach consultations. We don't just sign names — we sign players who fit our style.' This measured approach extends off the field as well, particularly in an era when financial mismanagement plagues many clubs. Unlike some of their bigger rivals, Stellenbosch FC is not a club throwing money at problems. 'We don't pay exorbitant salaries,' Benadie said candidly. 'But we do offer a conducive environment for players to grow, compete, and be seen by bigger clubs. Our players know they're in the shop window.' In fact, Stellenbosch's model — modest salaries, focused development, and consistent exposure — has made it a destination of choice for ambitious talent. The club's use of platforms like TransferRoom, which connects clubs globally for transfer dealings, is just one example of their forward-thinking approach. 'We're not here to hoard talent,' Benadie stated. 'If a player can go overseas or to a bigger local club, that's a win for us too. We focus on long-term sustainability.' Yet, even with their success, there remain frustrations — particularly with the lack of proper stadium access and infrastructure support in the Western Cape. For now, they'll play their MTN8 fixtures at Cape Town Stadium due to poor pitch conditions at Danie Craven Stadium. It's far from ideal, but Benadie sees a longer-term solution in the works. With the backing of major shareholder Remgro, the club is in advanced negotiations with the Stellenbosch Municipality to take over the historic Van der Stel Sports Grounds — with the intention of building a purpose-fit stadium and high-performance training centre. 'We envision a facility with an 8,000 to 10,000-seater stadium — that's more than enough for PSL matches,' said Benadie. 'We want to create a home-ground advantage, like Wits did when they won the league. That kind of intimacy can be a weapon.' The project, expected to cost tens of millions of rands, will also house development infrastructure, possibly making Stellenbosch a genuine academy powerhouse. While timelines stretch into 2026, the long-term thinking is clear — this is a club laying down roots for the future. And what of that future? For Benadie, the dream is both local and continental. He openly admires Morocco's recent rise in African football and points to their investment in elite youth academies as a key reason. 'When we visited RS Berkane, we saw the future of African football. Their academy had 400 kids living and breathing football,' he recalled. 'We want to do the same — build the best academy in Africa, right here in Stellenbosch.' But he's also clear-eyed about the broader challenges in South African football — administrative bungling, governance failures, and missed opportunities.
