Big opposition to joint water CCO
A sample of submissions for a joint local government water initiative suggests officials may have a fight on their hands.
The Clutha District Council meets in Balclutha today for hearings on its Southern Water Done Well proposals.
Thirty-three groups and individuals are scheduled to speak to their submissions regarding the proposals, under which Clutha would join forces with the Waitaki, Central Otago and Gore District Councils to manage water services infrastructure and delivery.
The council received 393 submissions during consultation, of which only the 33 from those speaking to their submissions have been made public.
Of those, 29 (88%) opposed Clutha forming a jointly council-controlled organisation (CCO), the preferred option put forward by all four councils in the group.
Only four favoured a joint or stand-alone CCO model, some with modifications.
During consultation, Clutha District Mayor Bryan Cadogan described the joint CCO as the "least bad" solution to the latest central government push for water reform.
Documents showed the four councils collectively accruing $598 million of water infrastructure debt by 2034, as they expected to spend $760m on providing improved water services in line with more stringent regulations.
At the time, Mr Cadogan said the joint CCO could lead to modest efficiencies and savings for ratepayers.
Other options included formation of a stand-alone CCO, or an in-house business unit.
Mr Cadogan warned these options could consign Clutha to insolvency during the next decade, due to mounting infrastructure debt.
Submissions against the joint council-controlled organisation cited "loss of local control" and "lack of transparency" as concerns.
Submitter Alex de Boer, of Owaka, said centralisation had been demonstrated not to work.
"The sums show very little advantage in rating by 2033-34.
"Combining with other areas will cause loss of focus on our unique issues.
"Centralisation did not work for the polytechs, hospital boards or the Auckland 'Super City'. Rates rose a lot."
Council deputy chief executive Jules Witt said yesterday the council could not comment on the overall split of submissions until the hearings had been completed.
"Council is still in the process of collating and analysing the submissions received. The submissions are part of the overall decision-making process of council," he said.
The Waitaki, Central Otago and Gore District Councils are also seeking feedback on the proposals at present.
The government will assess the council's resulting water services delivery plan and provide feedback from December.
If approved, a jointly owned CCO would begin operation in July 2027.
richard.davison@odt.co.nz
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
5 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Claim reform benefits being undermined
A "concerted" misinformation campaign around new water reforms is taking the blame for Waitaki residents not believing the benefits of creating a multi-district water company to run things, the mayor says. As part of the government's Local Water Done Well reforms local authorities need to change the way drinking water, wastewater and stormwater services are delivered. In Waitaki, three options are being considered for the future management of water services: in-house; a council-controlled organisation (CCO) wholly owned by the Waitaki District Council; and a joint CCO co-owned with three other councils. Waitaki District Mayor Gary Kircher said he was concerned about how many submissions might have been affected by the dissemination of wrong information. "It has been very unfortunate that there has been a concerted attempt to provide incorrect information and assumptions to the wider public which have not only misrepresented the actual facts, but they have also contradicted the base facts of the case," Mayor Kircher said in a council report. "It has clearly skewed the results and fed into people's natural concerns about change. "These implications raised by submitters' concerns will need to be considered and they will. "At the end of the day, we must do the best we can for our ratepayers and whether that means retaining water services or giving them up, it is my expectation that every councillor and I will do our best to deliver the best decision for long-term quality and affordability over the next 50 years or more." The council's preferred choice would have Waitaki establish a CCO with the Gore, Central Otago and Clutha District Councils in a proposal called Southern Water Done Well (SWDW). Mr Kircher said economic consultancy Infometrics was employed to "better inform" both councillors and the public about each option, the company's chief economist, Brad Olsen, concluding the SWDW proposal offered "a compelling solution" to the problem. However, mayoral candidate David Wilson said residents had given a clear "keep our waters local" message to the council. "It is insulting to imply that the submitters didn't know what they were talking about. Many of the most knowledgeable and wise people in the district responded. "The message of the people was clear." Just over 300 submissions were received, just half the amount council received during its recent submission period on the district plan. The clear winner in the popularity stakes was the in-house option, which is favoured as the first choice of 54% of submitters. The stand-alone option was favoured by 21% of submitters, the council's preferred SWDW option was favoured by 15% of submitters and 10% favoured the South Canterbury option involving a combined CCO with the Waimate, Timaru and Mackenzie councils. This was included in consultation documents even though none of those councils included Waitaki in their own consultations. Overall, "75% of submitters said they opposed collaboration between councils, with the strongest concern registered as losing local control (83%), followed by lack of transparency (64%), increased costs (60%) and 16% of submitters concerned about changes to water quality", the council 's report said. The Waitaki District Council has conducted deliberations on the proposal over the past two days, advisers from Morrison Low attending yesterday. A final decision will be made at a council meeting on July 8. The water services delivery plan must be submitted to the Department of Internal Affairs by September 3.
Otago Daily Times
17-06-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Big opposition to joint water CCO
A sample of submissions for a joint local government water initiative suggests officials may have a fight on their hands. The Clutha District Council meets in Balclutha today for hearings on its Southern Water Done Well proposals. Thirty-three groups and individuals are scheduled to speak to their submissions regarding the proposals, under which Clutha would join forces with the Waitaki, Central Otago and Gore District Councils to manage water services infrastructure and delivery. The council received 393 submissions during consultation, of which only the 33 from those speaking to their submissions have been made public. Of those, 29 (88%) opposed Clutha forming a jointly council-controlled organisation (CCO), the preferred option put forward by all four councils in the group. Only four favoured a joint or stand-alone CCO model, some with modifications. During consultation, Clutha District Mayor Bryan Cadogan described the joint CCO as the "least bad" solution to the latest central government push for water reform. Documents showed the four councils collectively accruing $598 million of water infrastructure debt by 2034, as they expected to spend $760m on providing improved water services in line with more stringent regulations. At the time, Mr Cadogan said the joint CCO could lead to modest efficiencies and savings for ratepayers. Other options included formation of a stand-alone CCO, or an in-house business unit. Mr Cadogan warned these options could consign Clutha to insolvency during the next decade, due to mounting infrastructure debt. Submissions against the joint council-controlled organisation cited "loss of local control" and "lack of transparency" as concerns. Submitter Alex de Boer, of Owaka, said centralisation had been demonstrated not to work. "The sums show very little advantage in rating by 2033-34. "Combining with other areas will cause loss of focus on our unique issues. "Centralisation did not work for the polytechs, hospital boards or the Auckland 'Super City'. Rates rose a lot." Council deputy chief executive Jules Witt said yesterday the council could not comment on the overall split of submissions until the hearings had been completed. "Council is still in the process of collating and analysing the submissions received. The submissions are part of the overall decision-making process of council," he said. The Waitaki, Central Otago and Gore District Councils are also seeking feedback on the proposals at present. The government will assess the council's resulting water services delivery plan and provide feedback from December. If approved, a jointly owned CCO would begin operation in July 2027.
Otago Daily Times
07-06-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Economist backs new water services model
One of New Zealand's best-known economists is backing the maths behind a move to shift control of Waitaki's water services and assets to a new company, jointly-formed by four Otago district councils. With water charges due to come off rates bills from the 2027 financial year because of changes to government regulations, Infometrics chief economist Brad Olsen has voiced strong support for Southern Water Done Well's preferred water services delivery model, saying it offered the "best pathway" to safe, reliable water services and long-term financial benefits for the districts involved. SWDW's four partner councils — Waitaki, Gore, Central Otago, and Clutha district councils — are consulting on options for the future delivery of water services to meet the government's Local Water Done Well legislation. Their preferred delivery model is a jointly owned council-controlled organisation (CCO) covering all four districts. The other three options being consulted on are a standalone Waitaki CCO, an in-house business unit, and in the case of WDC only, a joint CCO with Mackenzie, Timaru and Waimate districts. At a recent meeting of Southern Water Done Well (SWDW) elected politicians and senior staff, Mr Olsen outlined what he felt were the positives of the joint CCO option. Mr Olsen said one of the "most compelling" advantages was the leap in bargaining power, a media statement issued by the SWDW group said. Individually, the four councils each represent just 1% to 2% of the South Island's population. However, by forming a jointly owned council controlled organisation, they collectively represent 6.6% of the South Island's population. "That shift in scale is transformative. "In a tight infrastructure market, scale gives you options and leverage." SWDW, through Wellington-based consultants Morrison Low, has modelled all of the options, for water charges in 2027-28 and 2033-34 years in the Waitaki district. Mr Olsen noted SWDW's deliberately conservative approach to financial modelling for the jointly owned CCO. While short-term financial gains might be modest, water assets were long-term (20 years+) and by year 20, modelling for other joint water services delivery entities showed potential savings of up to 20% compared with going it alone. "Even under these conservative assumptions, the numbers still stack up." The conservative modelling projects 15% to 16% operating and capital efficiencies being achieved over "roughly a decade, which is a similar timeframe to achieve efficiencies as seen in other spaces". WDC's public consultation on the four options ends today at 5pm. Water options Water options considered (prices per year) Joint ''Southern Water Done Well'' 2027-28 2033-34 Joint council CCO (SWDW) $2168 $2894 Stand-alone CCO $2466 $3754 In-house business unit $2269 $3093 The South Canterbury council's model 2027-28 2033-34 In-house business unit $2041 $2924 Joint council $2269 $3093
