From a viewing platform in Israel, observers watch Gaza's destruction through binoculars
'You'll be able to see ruined territories, but it's important to remember it's a result of their aggression towards us and our need to secure ourselves,' he said.
He was standing at a viewing point in Sderot, western Israel, last week.
Behind him were the ruins of Gaza, its blockade starting just over one kilometre away. Even with a naked eye, it is possible to see something of the scale of destruction and the constantly rising smoke, but through the binoculars the lengthy expanse of toppled buildings and decimated neighbourhoods is staggering.
READ MORE
Earlier, the same guide had warned his group – one of whom said they had individually opted to come on this day tour led by a 'licensed tour guide' – that they may hear 'a lot of booms today'.
'We can only pray that Nazis are being killed and our soldiers are safe,' the guide said. He pointed towards the destruction.
'We see some dust rising up, that's a territory called Jabalia.'
He was referencing what was once Palestine's largest refugee camp and a home for more than 110,000 people – largely descendants of those displaced in what is known as the 1948 Nakba, or 'catastrophe'.
By November last year, Haaretz
reported
that Jabalia 'no longer has a single habitable residential area'.
Gaza City was behind Jabalia, the guide said. He added that he hoped his group would have the chance to see the city from another perspective later in the day, but the view may be blocked as 'there's always an opportunity of dust because it's very active over there'.
Through the binoculars, he also told them that they would be able to spot a few high-rise buildings inside Gaza City still standing: this was proof, the guide said, that Israeli forces are not destroying 'everything' but are only going after 'terrorists' and acting to bolster 'security'.
The blockaded enclave of Gaza is just 365sq km in total, making it smaller than any Irish county. The smallest Irish county, Louth, is 2.25 times its size, with about one fifteenth of its population.
Gaza's more than two million residents have been trapped in the enclave for nearly two years now. In that period, nearly 60,000 have been killed by Israeli forces, according to Gazan health authorities. This includes more than 17,000 children – the equivalent of 28, or a 'classroom', every day, the United Nations children's agency, Unicef,
notes
. Over 33,000 more children have been injured, with Unicef saying that the Gaza Strip has the
highest
number of child amputees per capita anywhere in the world.
[
The Irish Times view on starvation in Gaza: the world cannot look away
Opens in new window
]
Mass starvation is spreading fast. Eight months after the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu and former minister of defence Yoav Gallant, who are accused of using starvation as a method of warfare, the United Nations says one in three Gazans are going multiple days without food.
More than 100 NGOs this week called for urgent action, including a permanent ceasefire, an end to weapons transfers, for the opening of borders and for the
restoration
of effective humanitarian aid systems. 'States can and must save lives before there are none left to save.'
A tour group at a viewing platform at Sderot, on the Israeli side of the border with Gaza. Photograph: Sally Hayden
Israeli government officials have openly called for the
destruction
or displacement of Gazans, as have others inside Israel. This month, hanging from a building in the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem's Old City was a sign reading 'Make Gaza Jewish Again'. Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank, who spoke to The Irish Times this month and last year, said they think Gaza should be settled by Israelis.
Yet, unlike populations in most of the rest of the world, who can only see what is happening in Gaza through online postings and the news reports of Palestinian journalists, in Israel the destruction of Gaza is taking place in full view.
Kilometres away from the bombardment and starvation are supermarkets, shopping centres and people with access to unlimited food. At the viewing point in Sderot there is a vending machine dispensing water and fizzy drinks. In a cafe a short drive away, civilians and off-duty uniformed and armed soldiers alike chat over coffees, or eat salads and sandwiches.
'Most Israeli citizens – living in abundance half an hour's drive away – are reacting to the disaster on their doorstep with indifference or gaslighting,'
tweeted
Amjad Iraqi, senior Israel and Palestine analyst for the International Crisis Group, on Wednesday. 'Few care for Gaza's parallels to the ghettos, starving and awaiting death. The dehumanisation is too deep, empathy is absent.'
[
A conversation begins: How Israelis view Gaza's unfolding hunger crisis
Opens in new window
]
Omer Bartov, a professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies at Brown University in Rhode Island, is among an ever-increasing number of experts who call what is happening in Gaza a genocide. On July 15th he
wrote
in The New York Times: 'Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the IDF as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognise one when I see one.'
People on Kobi Hill in Sderot, on the Israeli side of the border with Gaza, watch an Israeli airstrike being carried out near Beit Hanoun. Photograph: Abir Sultan/EPA
When he heard what The Irish Times saw and heard in Sderot, Prof Bartov said it reminded him 'of what the Germans called in World War II 'execution tourism', ie touring and photographing (as souvenirs) one's own atrocities'.
Multiple tours came and went in the hour or so that The Irish Times was at the main Sderot viewing point.
One, among a big group of young people, said they were Americans who travelled to Israel with an organisation 'like Birthright'. They listened to their tour guide describe how Israel first 'conquered' Gaza, and then engaged in other efforts, including 'pass[ing]a lot of luggages filled with cash to maintain the status quo' because it was 'good for Israel and our ideology'.
The guide was seemingly referring to widespread reports that Netanyahu allowed Qatar to send
billions
of dollars to Hamas, with the Israeli prime minister accused of strengthening the militant group on purpose to break ties between Gaza and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank and destroy dreams of a Palestinian state, a reasoning Netanyahu
denies
.
Everything Israel did up to the current bombardment of Gaza was a 'Band Aid' when it came to halting attacks and guaranteeing the security of Israeli citizens, the guide said, 'the wall, the fence, the Iron Dome'. He then moved the students away, out of the hot sun, into a shaded area.
Dozens of soldiers arrived next, following a guide whose T-shirt declared him to be from the 'Sderot tourism team'. A fellow Israeli and former soldier identified them as reservists, because some had long hair and they carried rifles rather than larger weapons.
The Israeli military controls access to Gaza.
Another high point with a wider panoramic view, a little outside Sderot, has been declared a closed military zone – but soldiers gave The Irish Times permission to stay for a few minutes.
There, it was possible to see smoke rising from at least four sites inside Gaza, while there were multiple bombings in those few minutes, and heavy gunfire and at least one drone were also audible.
The main viewing point in Sderot is called
Givat Kobi
, with online descriptions saying it was built as a memorial to two soldiers killed during the 2014 Gaza war. It is listed on Google Maps, where visitors leave reviews.
Any recent online complaints tend to be about access.
One recent poster complained about potholes on the path to the viewing point.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a day ago
- Irish Times
Odds and Ends - Frank McNally on the vagaries of Galway Race Week
For the second year running at the Galway Races, I found myself staying in a B&NB. That's to say, a place that does bed and no breakfast. Okay, last year's did have breakfast as an optional extra, but served in a different house nearby, so I didn't bother. This year, my gruffly cheerful – or cheerfully gruff – host responded to the query as to whether one was included or available with a laughing 'Not at all!'. It was as if I'd asked if his house had a late bar, or a chauffeured limousine service. In fairness, he was charging a mere €89 for the night, a bargain by Galway race week standards. My host in 2024 had been male too. Not only is the traditional B&B going the way of the dodo, so it seems is the traditional Bean an Tí. The last of those I saw in the wild was in north Donegal a couple of years ago while en route to Tory Island. Covid seems to have killed many of them off (not literally, I hope – just in precipitating early retirements). You'd miss their motherly presence and personal touch all the same. After taking payment up front, this year's host told me to let myself out in the morning and just leave the key. READ MORE Mind you, we chatted long enough for him to tell me that even breakfast-free accommodation is not without challenges. 'My biggest problem with the races is keeping clean sheets,' he said. I looked at him blankly, imagining various horror scenarios. 'The fake tan,' he explained. 'It's impossible to get out.' *** On the bus from Eyre Square to Ballybrit on Monday, the traffic was – as always in Galway – sclerotic. Our driver was no less frustrated than the rest of us as we oozed towards the racecourse at the speed of a leak in a molasses factory. Peering ahead over the steering wheel, he periodically shared the latest bad news: 'Nothing moving on the green light – there must be trouble somewhere.' Ominously, three fire brigades passed us at one point, lights flashing. The driver stared after them into the distance to see which direction they took. 'Did they turn or go straight on?' he asked a front-seat passenger. 'They went right, I think,' the passenger said. We had to go right too, so this was not good. 'Ah Jaysus, we're f**ked,' confirmed the driver. *** I always think the name Ballybrit sounds like it was invented for a TV sitcom, like Ballykissangel except that this series would set be in an Irish village full of posh English retirees. In fact, according to Logainm, the name is 500 years old, the earliest dated reference (to a 'Balebritt') being 1525. But speaking of coincidental anniversaries, while sitting on the bus I noticed via Twitter/X that Monday was the 266th birthday of one Hudson Lowe (1769 – 1844), who was born not only in Galway but on the Eyre Square we had just left. In other circumstances, Lowe might have left no impression on history. His fellow Anglo-Irishman the Duke of Wellington would later say of him: 'He was a man wanting in education and judgment. He was a stupid man. He knew nothing at all of the world, and like all men who know nothing of the world, he was suspicious and jealous.' So why was Wellington even talking about him? Because Lowe had been governor of Saint Helena in the years Napoleon (who was born two weeks after him) was prisoner there. And he imposed such a brutal regime that another Irishman, Napoleon's physician and friend Barry O'Meara, called him an 'executioner'. Although only acting on orders, he was later blamed for the embarrassment caused to Britain over the mistreatment of their celebrity prisoner. Wellington thought he had been 'a very bad choice' for the job. *** I could get through an entire Galway Festival, especially when working, without ever having a bet. On the other hand, like many occasional punters, I have a weakness for coincidental names. So scanning the racecard for Monday night, my eye was drawn to Theabsolutegov'nor, running in the last. If its jockey had been a Lowe or a Napoleon, I would definitely have backed it. Instead, rationality got the better of me and I didn't (wisely, it's still running). But passing through the betting ring before the Iggy Daly Easyfix Handicap Hurdle, I noticed there was a horse called 'Jerrari' entered in it. And it so happened that I have a French friend of that unusual surname. In my defence, this is as logical a reason as any to bet on a 20-horse handicap, with its countless permutations of form and weight, which you'd need to be a supercomputer to get a handle on. Jerrari was 12-1 at the time – far from favourite but not a no-hoper. So in my only bet of the meeting, I stuck a tenner each-way on him with the Tote. And sure enough, he romped to victory, earning me the price of two nights' bed without breakfast, or nearly.
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Slide in visitor numbers slows to just 2% in June, CSO says
The recent slump in official figures for the number of people visiting Ireland moderated sharply last month, according to Central Statistics Office data published on Wednesday. Some 654,500 foreign residents visited Ireland in June. That represented a year-on-year drop of 2 per cent, compared with drops of 10 per cent in May; 4 per cent in April; 15 per cent in March; and 30 per cent in February. Foreign visitors spent a total of €646.5 million in the month, excluding fares, which represented a decrease of 5.5 per cent compared with June last year. Again that is more modest that the fall in spending in previous months – 21 per cent in May, 10 per cent in April, 22 per cent in March and 31 per cent in February. READ MORE Tourism is Ireland's largest indigenous industry and biggest employer, with 257,900 people working in the sector. Ireland took in €6.2 billion from overseas tourists in 2024, although the number of bed-nights last year was down 3 per cent. CSO statistician Gregg Patrick described February's decline at the time as 'an acceleration' of the downward year-on-year trend in foreign visitor numbers that first emerged in September last year. The pattern of decline recorded by the CSO raised some eyebrows within the industry, which said it had not necessarily fit with on-the-ground experience. Broken down by expense category, the costliest subheading for tourists in June was day-to-day spending at €320.4 million (36.3 per cent). This includes expenditures such as eating out, entrance fees to venues and public transport. Next was accommodation at €292.8 million (33.2 per cent), followed by prepayments, which includes items such as car hire and pre-booked tickets, which came to €33.3 million (3.8 per cent). Overall, the typical foreign visitor spent €988 excluding fares on their trip to Ireland – €51 on prepayments, €447 on accommodation and €490 on day-to-day expenses. By way of comparison, visitors in June last year spent a total of €1,022 excluding fares – €45, €458 and €519 on those categories respectively. The data shows visitors spent 5.2 million nights in Ireland last month, up 6 per cent compared with the same month in 2024. The average length of stay was 7.9 nights, up from an average of 7.3 nights. Britain continues to be the largest country of origin for visitors, accounting for 34.2 per cent of all visitors to the Republic. However, the 224,100 people who travelled here from Britain last month was down slightly on the 227,400 who came in June last year. There were increases in the numbers coming from our next two biggest markets – the United States (166,300, up almost 6,000) and Germany (54,800, up more than 11,000). More people said they were coming here for a holiday than for any other reason at 47.5 per cent. Visiting family and friends, at 29.9 per cent, was the next most likely purpose followed by 13 per cent who were travelling for business or work. Those numbers show a slight rise in the proportion of visitors coming here for holiday or to visit family and friends but a significant 20 per cent fall in numbers coming for work-related purposes. Some 45.3 per cent of visitors stayed in a hotel, while 32.3 per cent stayed in their own property or with family and friends. About 7 per cent used rented or self-catering as their main accommodation, while 5.8 per cent used a guest house or a bed and breakfast.
Irish Times
6 days ago
- Irish Times
From a viewing platform in Israel, observers watch Gaza's destruction through binoculars
The tour guide directed his group towards the binoculars, which cost five shekels (€1.27) to look through for 2½ minutes and could be paid for with a contactless card. 'You'll be able to see ruined territories, but it's important to remember it's a result of their aggression towards us and our need to secure ourselves,' he said. He was standing at a viewing point in Sderot, western Israel, last week. Behind him were the ruins of Gaza, its blockade starting just over one kilometre away. Even with a naked eye, it is possible to see something of the scale of destruction and the constantly rising smoke, but through the binoculars the lengthy expanse of toppled buildings and decimated neighbourhoods is staggering. READ MORE Earlier, the same guide had warned his group – one of whom said they had individually opted to come on this day tour led by a 'licensed tour guide' – that they may hear 'a lot of booms today'. 'We can only pray that Nazis are being killed and our soldiers are safe,' the guide said. He pointed towards the destruction. 'We see some dust rising up, that's a territory called Jabalia.' He was referencing what was once Palestine's largest refugee camp and a home for more than 110,000 people – largely descendants of those displaced in what is known as the 1948 Nakba, or 'catastrophe'. By November last year, Haaretz reported that Jabalia 'no longer has a single habitable residential area'. Gaza City was behind Jabalia, the guide said. He added that he hoped his group would have the chance to see the city from another perspective later in the day, but the view may be blocked as 'there's always an opportunity of dust because it's very active over there'. Through the binoculars, he also told them that they would be able to spot a few high-rise buildings inside Gaza City still standing: this was proof, the guide said, that Israeli forces are not destroying 'everything' but are only going after 'terrorists' and acting to bolster 'security'. The blockaded enclave of Gaza is just 365sq km in total, making it smaller than any Irish county. The smallest Irish county, Louth, is 2.25 times its size, with about one fifteenth of its population. Gaza's more than two million residents have been trapped in the enclave for nearly two years now. In that period, nearly 60,000 have been killed by Israeli forces, according to Gazan health authorities. This includes more than 17,000 children – the equivalent of 28, or a 'classroom', every day, the United Nations children's agency, Unicef, notes . Over 33,000 more children have been injured, with Unicef saying that the Gaza Strip has the highest number of child amputees per capita anywhere in the world. [ The Irish Times view on starvation in Gaza: the world cannot look away Opens in new window ] Mass starvation is spreading fast. Eight months after the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Israeli prime minister Binyamin Netanyahu and former minister of defence Yoav Gallant, who are accused of using starvation as a method of warfare, the United Nations says one in three Gazans are going multiple days without food. More than 100 NGOs this week called for urgent action, including a permanent ceasefire, an end to weapons transfers, for the opening of borders and for the restoration of effective humanitarian aid systems. 'States can and must save lives before there are none left to save.' A tour group at a viewing platform at Sderot, on the Israeli side of the border with Gaza. Photograph: Sally Hayden Israeli government officials have openly called for the destruction or displacement of Gazans, as have others inside Israel. This month, hanging from a building in the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem's Old City was a sign reading 'Make Gaza Jewish Again'. Israeli settlers in the occupied West Bank, who spoke to The Irish Times this month and last year, said they think Gaza should be settled by Israelis. Yet, unlike populations in most of the rest of the world, who can only see what is happening in Gaza through online postings and the news reports of Palestinian journalists, in Israel the destruction of Gaza is taking place in full view. Kilometres away from the bombardment and starvation are supermarkets, shopping centres and people with access to unlimited food. At the viewing point in Sderot there is a vending machine dispensing water and fizzy drinks. In a cafe a short drive away, civilians and off-duty uniformed and armed soldiers alike chat over coffees, or eat salads and sandwiches. 'Most Israeli citizens – living in abundance half an hour's drive away – are reacting to the disaster on their doorstep with indifference or gaslighting,' tweeted Amjad Iraqi, senior Israel and Palestine analyst for the International Crisis Group, on Wednesday. 'Few care for Gaza's parallels to the ghettos, starving and awaiting death. The dehumanisation is too deep, empathy is absent.' [ A conversation begins: How Israelis view Gaza's unfolding hunger crisis Opens in new window ] Omer Bartov, a professor of Holocaust and Genocide Studies at Brown University in Rhode Island, is among an ever-increasing number of experts who call what is happening in Gaza a genocide. On July 15th he wrote in The New York Times: 'Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the IDF as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognise one when I see one.' People on Kobi Hill in Sderot, on the Israeli side of the border with Gaza, watch an Israeli airstrike being carried out near Beit Hanoun. Photograph: Abir Sultan/EPA When he heard what The Irish Times saw and heard in Sderot, Prof Bartov said it reminded him 'of what the Germans called in World War II 'execution tourism', ie touring and photographing (as souvenirs) one's own atrocities'. Multiple tours came and went in the hour or so that The Irish Times was at the main Sderot viewing point. One, among a big group of young people, said they were Americans who travelled to Israel with an organisation 'like Birthright'. They listened to their tour guide describe how Israel first 'conquered' Gaza, and then engaged in other efforts, including 'pass[ing]a lot of luggages filled with cash to maintain the status quo' because it was 'good for Israel and our ideology'. The guide was seemingly referring to widespread reports that Netanyahu allowed Qatar to send billions of dollars to Hamas, with the Israeli prime minister accused of strengthening the militant group on purpose to break ties between Gaza and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank and destroy dreams of a Palestinian state, a reasoning Netanyahu denies . Everything Israel did up to the current bombardment of Gaza was a 'Band Aid' when it came to halting attacks and guaranteeing the security of Israeli citizens, the guide said, 'the wall, the fence, the Iron Dome'. He then moved the students away, out of the hot sun, into a shaded area. Dozens of soldiers arrived next, following a guide whose T-shirt declared him to be from the 'Sderot tourism team'. A fellow Israeli and former soldier identified them as reservists, because some had long hair and they carried rifles rather than larger weapons. The Israeli military controls access to Gaza. Another high point with a wider panoramic view, a little outside Sderot, has been declared a closed military zone – but soldiers gave The Irish Times permission to stay for a few minutes. There, it was possible to see smoke rising from at least four sites inside Gaza, while there were multiple bombings in those few minutes, and heavy gunfire and at least one drone were also audible. The main viewing point in Sderot is called Givat Kobi , with online descriptions saying it was built as a memorial to two soldiers killed during the 2014 Gaza war. It is listed on Google Maps, where visitors leave reviews. Any recent online complaints tend to be about access. One recent poster complained about potholes on the path to the viewing point.
