Data quizzed after cook's phone pinged near mushrooms
Patterson, 50, is facing the fourth week of trial in regional Victoria, where she stands accused of three murders by allegedly deliberately poisoning a beef Wellington she served to her former in-laws.
Don and Gail Patterson, 70, and Heather Wilkinson, 66, all died in hospital days after eating the meal cooked by Patterson in July 2023.
The fourth lunch guest, Heather's husband Ian Wilkinson, survived the meal and Patterson has been charged with his attempted murder.
She has pleaded not guilty to all offences and claims the poisonings were a terrible accident.
Digital forensic expert Matthew Sorrell gave evidence for a second day at the court in Morwell, Victoria's southeast, today.
Yesterday, he told the jury his analysis of Patterson's phone records showed she was in the vicinity of the Gippsland towns of Outtrim and Loch on May 22, 2023.
A post had been published on the iNaturalist science website on May 21, revealing that death cap mushrooms had been located on Neilson St, Outtrim, the jury was told earlier yesterday.
Another post on April 18 stated the poisonous mushrooms had been spotted earlier that day at the Loch recreation reserve.
Under cross-examination by Patterson's barrister Colin Mandy SC today, Sorrell admitted there were limitations to his analysis.
He explained that he used two types of records to analyse Patterson's phone – call charge records and event-based monitoring data.
"That data allows for the possibility of a visit?" Mandy asked.
"It allows for the possibility of being in the area," Sorrell replied.
"But it does not necessarily indicate there was a visit to those locations?" Mandy continued.
"There's nothing to indicate there was a specific visit to an address," the expert said.
Mandy probed whether it was easier to exclude that a phone was in a particular area than to confirm it was there, and Sorrell agreed.
The defence barrister told the jury Patterson lived about 20 minutes' drive from Outtrim and half an hour from Loch.
Mandy asked Sorrell whether a phone could switch cell towers at different locations from inside Patterson's Leongatha home, for example if she picked up her phone and walked to her door.
"I accept that proposition," Sorrell said.
"Even if you've only moved 20 or 30 metres?" Mandy continued.
"Yes," Dr Sorrell said.
Mandy listed other limitations of the analysis including that a visit to Outtrim might not be recorded if no SMS, phone calls or data had been accessed on the phone, to which Sorrell agreed.
Evidence so far in the trial of Erin Patterson, the Australian woman accused of murdering three people with beef Wellingtons. (Source: 1News)
One of the homicide detectives tasked with investigating the allegedly murderous lunch was called as a witness this afternoon.
Detective Senior Constable Khuong Tran told the jury he obtained CCTV for the case, including from a BP petrol station in Caldermeade.
In video shown to the jury, about 3.19pm on July 30 – the day after the mushroom meal – Patterson is seen getting out of a red vehicle and walking into the service station towards the bathroom.
Patterson, wearing a grey top and white pants with a black crossbody shoulder bag and sandals, spends about nine seconds in the toilets and then takes an item from the fridge before paying and leaving.
She said she had experienced stomach pain and diarrhoea the day after the beef Wellington and took herself to hospital on July 31, the jury was told previously.
The trial before Justice Christopher Beale will continue tomorrow.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
7 hours ago
- 1News
Big, awkward, neglected: Auckland scores poorly on international report
The recent report comparing Auckland to nine international peer cities delivered an uncomfortable truth: our largest city is falling behind, hampered by car dependency, low-density housing and 'weak economic performance'. Timothy Welch reports. The Deloitte State of the City analysis was no surprise to anyone who has watched successive governments treat the city as a problem to manage, rather than an engine to fuel. The report's findings were stark: Auckland rates 82nd out of 84 cities globally for pedestrian friendliness, and its car-dependent transport system is more carbon-intensive and slower to decarbonise than peer cities. (Source: This is the direct result of decades of planning failures, including what urban researchers call the 1970s 'great down-zoning' which halved central Auckland's housing capacity. ADVERTISEMENT This isn't just Auckland's problem. When we mismanage what geographers call a 'primate city,' it reveals our fundamental misunderstanding of how modern economies work. The concept of the primate city was formalised by geographer Mark Jefferson in 1939. Such cities are defined as being 'at least twice as large as the next largest city and more than twice as significant'. Auckland fits this definition perfectly. With more than 1.7 million people, it is over four times larger than Christchurch or the greater Wellington region. The city accounts for 34% of New Zealand's population and is projected to hit 40% of the working-age population by 2048. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including Hulk Hogan dies, sentencing for a New Zealander who assaulted two airline stewards, and a big accolade for Te Papa. (Source: 1News) Auckland contributes 38% of New Zealand's gross domestic product and its per-capita GDP is 15% higher than the rest of the country's. Its most productive area, the central business district, enjoys a 40% productivity premium over the national average. To economists, these numbers represent the 'agglomeration benefits' research shows primate cities generate. It is the economic effect of combining businesses, talent and infrastructure. Yet New Zealand systematically underinvests in the very place generating this outsized economic contribution. ADVERTISEMENT A pattern of infrastructure failure Auckland's infrastructure deficit follows a predictable pattern. The City Rail Link, while progressing, has grown from an initial budget of NZ$2-3 billion to $5.5 billion, with opening delayed until 2026. The first train to be tested in Auckland's City Rail Link travels through Maungawhau in February. (Source: City Rail Link) Light rail was cancelled entirely after years of planning. A second harbour crossing has been studied for decades without a shovel hitting dirt. Each represents billions in opportunity costs while congestion worsens. This goes well beyond project mismanagement. It is a deep structural problem. The Infrastructure Commission-Te Waihanga identifies a $210 billion national infrastructure shortfall, with Auckland bearing a disproportionate burden despite generating a disproportionately high level of revenue. International research by the OECD shows successful countries treat metropolitan regions as engines of national growth, not a burden. ADVERTISEMENT The 'Wellington problem' Public policy expert Ian Shirley called it the 'Wellington Problem': the way Auckland's governance became an obsession for politicians and bureaucrats based in Wellington. The tension dates to 1865 when the capital was moved from Auckland to Wellington, establishing a pattern where political power was deliberately separated from economic power. Parliament (file image). (Source: 1News) Auckland loses an estimated $415.35 million annually in GST collected on rates. This goes to Wellington and into government revenue rather than being reinvested locally. Central government properties in Auckland, worth $36.3 million in rates, are exempt from payment while still using Auckland's infrastructure. When Auckland speaks with 'one voice' through its unified council, Wellington responds with legislative overrides. The recent National Land Transport Programme, for example, cut Auckland's transport funding by $564 million. Mayor Wayne Brown said the government's transport policy 'makes zero sense for Auckland'. ADVERTISEMENT Learning from others The contrast with international approaches reveals just how counterproductive New Zealand's approach has been. London has an integrated Transport for London authority with congestion charging powers, generating £136 million annually for reinvestment. Paris is investing more than €35 billion in the Grand Paris Express transit project. Paris: city of trains (Source: Japan's 'Quality Infrastructure Investment' principles include ¥13.2 trillion in regional infrastructure investment. Australia's A$120 billion infrastructure programme explicitly recognises its largest cities contribute over 50% of GDP and require proportional investment. Research has shown excessive urban concentration in one country can create problems. But denying the primate city resources only leads to a 'deterioration in the quality of life' that drags down the entire national economy. The solution lies in making strategic investments that maximise the benefits of agglomeration while managing any negative costs to the national economy. ADVERTISEMENT Growing pains Auckland isn't a problem to be managed, it is an asset to be leveraged. Every successful developed economy has learned this lesson. Paris generates 31% of France's GDP and gets treated accordingly. Seoul produces 23% of South Korea's output and receives massive infrastructure investment. Tokyo drives Japan's economy. The international evidence is unambiguous: countries that strategically invest in their primate cities achieve higher productivity growth and maintain competitive advantages. Auckland doesn't need sympathy or special treatment. It needs what every primate city in every successful economy gets: infrastructure investment proportional to its economic contribution, governance structures that reflect its scale, and political leadership that understands agglomeration economics. The question isn't whether Auckland is too big. The question is whether New Zealand is big enough to nurture its primate city. Timothy Welch Senior Lecturer in Urban Planning, University of Auckland, Waipapa Taumata Rau This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons licence.
1News
2 days ago
- 1News
Man who lost family in Waiuku crash speaks of 'unimaginable loss'
A man who lost his wife, daughter, and niece in a triple-fatal crash on the way home from school last week says his world has been shattered. Frances Latu-Vailea, her five-year-old daughter, Oneahi Vailea, and seven-year-old niece, Marly Tulua, died when their car left Masters Road in Auckland's Waiuku and crashed into a culvert in a wetland. In a social media post on Tuesday, Amanaki Vailea, spoke of his grief. The site where three people lost their lives in a crash in Waiuku (Source: 1News) "A week ago, my world was shattered by the loss of my beloved wife and our precious daughter. ADVERTISEMENT "The pain of their sudden passing is hard to put into words. "My wife was my better half, my confidant, and the steady heart of our home. Her love was unwavering and her presence brought warmth and light to everyone who knew her. She was not only my companion in life, but also my greatest blessing. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including Ozzy Osbourne dies, a worrying find on Rakiura Stewart Island, and new Coke coming. (Source: 1News) "Our daughter was a beautiful soul, full of innocence, laughter, and a light that touched every corner of our hearts. She brought us joy beyond measure, and her absence leaves a silence that nothing can fill." He thanked everyone who had supported him as he faced an "unimaginable loss".
NZ Herald
2 days ago
- NZ Herald
Govt's 500 police target delayed again as Australia poaching campaign considered
Associate Police Minister Casey Costello and Police Commissioner Richard Chambers appear at select committee. Photo / Mark Mitchell When the policy was first announced, it had a two-year deadline from late November 2023 to increase NZ Police's constabulary force from 10,211 to 10,711 by November 2025. Government ministers had gradually accepted the initial deadline was unlikely to be met after Police Commissioner Richard Chambers indicated June 2026 was more realistic, given his commitment to training standards. As of July 21, NZ Police had added just 23 extra officers. About 90 recruits were due to graduate at the end of the month. Associate Police Minister Casey Costello, who was responsible for the policy, said in February she was 'even more confident' the target would be reached in November this year amid a boost in applications. In a statement this week, Costello said projections shifted from month to month based on the timing of graduations and the number of officers leaving or retiring. 'We always knew it was an ambitious timeline.' Labour police spokeswoman Ginny Andersen is criticising the Government's ability to deliver. Photo / Mark Mitchell Labour police spokeswoman Ginny Andersen condemned the delay as an example of Luxon's 'inability to deliver'. 'Meanwhile, meth use is surging and our communities are suffering,' she said. 'The Government shouldn't promise what it can't deliver on.' Police keep latest projections under wraps In an interview with the Herald yesterday, Penny wouldn't provide NZ Police's latest estimate when the target would be reached, saying it was 'pretty hard to be accurate' given the variable nature of training numbers and attrition. Asked whether she could guarantee it would be achieved before the 2026 election, Penny wouldn't speculate. About 370 recruits were currently progressing through NZ Police's 20-week training course, while another 340 would begin training by the end of the year. That was offset by an attrition rate of 5.4% and an aging workforce, according to Penny. She acknowledged police had been a 'bit sluggish in the beginning', but a dedicated team had since been set up to improve recruitment efforts. 'There are some things we can do to maybe deliver it a little bit sooner and that's why last week I was with all the district commanders and asking ourselves the question around what are we doing now that's working and what are we not doing so we can move things faster. 'We are going to deliver it, but we will get there when we get there.' Police Assistant Commissioner Tusha Penny said training standards wouldn't be compromised to hit the target. Photo / Jason Oxenham One of those measures to boost recruitment could be an effort to poach Kiwi cops now in Australia and possibly Australian officers as well. Penny said Chambers had asked senior leaders to assess whether an Australian recruitment drive would be useful. A decision hadn't yet been made. It followed several attempts from Australian police officials to attract New Zealand officers across the ditch, most recently by members of Northern Territory Police. While any recruitment drive would likely focus on New Zealand officers, Penny said it was being discussed whether to broaden the campaign. 'We have had a number of conversations that we should maybe say, 'Hey, bring one of your Aussie work besties back with you', but that's in negotiation.' Adam Pearse is the Deputy Political Editor and part of the NZ Herald's Press Gallery team based at Parliament in Wellington. He has worked for NZME since 2018, reporting for the Northern Advocate in Whangārei and the Herald in Auckland.
