Kuldeep Yadav has to play, would help India win atleast 2 Tests vs England: R Ashwin
"Kuldeep Yadav has to play. If there is not much grass, Kuldeep has to play. Drop anyone you want, but Kuldeep has to play. If he does play, the England tail also won't score many runs. Kuldeep would help you win 2-3 Tests in the series as he would create problems."When a co-panellist on his show, Prasanna Agoram, former performance analyst for South Africa, suggested three changes to the team - Kuldeep for Shardul Thakur, Arshdeep Singh for Prasidh Krishna, and Nitish Reddy in for Karun Nair or Sai Sudharsan - Ashwin shared his perspective."I sort of agree but am not a big fan of too many changes. So if Kuldeep comes in for Shardul Thakur, I would retain Prasidh Krishna, as he showed in the second innings of the first Test that when he bowls well, he could do it. I would also think about the left-arm angle of Arshdeep Singh but since he is still not a proven commodity in Test cricket, let's not forget what Akash Deep can do. I am okay with either Akash Deep or Arshdeep in case Jasprit Bumrah doesn't play," Ashwin said.advertisementDelving further into the debate on whether Nitish Kumar Reddy should replace either Karun Nair or Sai Sudharsan, Ashwin said, "I know for a fact that this management really rates Nitish Reddy."He also spoke about the pitches in England and the role of heavy rollers. "People talk about footmarks, last day etc, but England is a very unforgiving place for spinners. In Australia, you get bounce and speed and you can bowl if you have tactical plans."But in England, the pitch keeps getting slower. People forget the role of heavy rollers. First day there might be some dampness on the pitch, and there might be dents. And you might think, oh these will get worse - as that's the experience in subcontinental pitches - but in England, with heavy rollers, things start settling down. Every day and innings, you get heavy rollers, and these are those big 1-ton, 2-ton machine rollers. The pitch settles down for an hour after that, and also starts to get slower as the game progresses."He also remarked that, contrary to popular belief, spin might play a bigger role in the first three days at Edgbaston. "Edgbaston is one of the rare grounds in England, along with Headingley where the first Test was played, that there might be some bounce. Largely in the first three days, there will definitely be spin. In the back half of the game, the spin will reduce, but it will have a chance. I liked bowling with the new(ish) ball in Edgbaston."advertisementIn the 2018 Test against England at this venue, Ashwin had bowled Alastair Cook in both innings with deliveries that swerved in from round the stumps and spun sharply past the defensive prod to knock back the off stump.He also raised a point about whether India - not just the team but also its fans - place too much importance on IPL performances. "How easy is it to leave Karun Nair out? I think Sai is going to be a superstar, but he is the first batter to have less than a 40 average but has been picked for Test cricket, and still we talk about leaving Karun first rather than Sai. It raises the question of whether we in India give more importance to IPL performances. Don't misinterpret me, I think Sai is going to be a superstar."- EndsMust Watch
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
an hour ago
- NDTV
"Where Are The Daddy Hundreds?" R Ashwin Turns Table, Takes Blunt Swipe At...
Ravichandran Ashwin has slammed the broadcasters over their harsh criticism of the Indian bowlers, following the defeat to England in the 1st Test last week in Leeds. India could only manage five wickets on Day 5 as England chased down a record score of 371. While Ashwin agreed that the bowling from India was not up to the mark, he was also against the notion of putting the entire blame on the bowlers. He slammed the commentators, saying that the narration completely shifted the bowlers once England achieved the target. "Once 370 was chased down (in the first Test), I thought the commentary became a diss about the Indian bowlers. I felt that the narrative built was pointing towards how Indian bowlers failed to win the match. But with a little homework, many would have realised that in England, scores have been consistently chased down in 4th innings," Ashwin said on his YouTube channel. In fact, Ashwin went on to suggest that the batters should take more responsibility, urging them to convert 100s into more meaningful scores. For the unversed, India had four centurions in the first including, while Rishabh Pant hit one in both innings. "Batters should take up responsibility. I know batsmen are making runs. Yes, we had five centurions, but where are the daddy hundreds? We have to resign to the fact that there would be no contribution (with the bat) from the lower order. Our fast bowlers cannot bat, they cannot muster runs," he added. Ashwin, however, did question the bowlers, barring pace spearhead Jasprit Bumrah, for allowing England to score freely. He added that the others bowlers need to stick to tight lines as Bumrah will do the rest by creating pressure from the other end. "In Tests, I think maidens are quite underrated. Ideally, I would be okay with Bumrah going for a higher economy rate, but others should go low. I saw a show where someone said Siraj was unlucky to not be among wickets. I do agree he bowled well in the second innings, but the economy rate, you can't let go and hope that things fall in place. In Tests, you have to build your bowling gradually from Day 1, and the rewards will come in the final innings," Ashwin highlighted. "If you give away a lot of runs in the first innings, you tend to get conservative ato stem the flow, and you won't get wickets in this approach. If I was Morkel, I would tell the other bowlers not to do much since Bumrah is there. As the old saying goes, bowl three maidens, and you will get a wicket. Don't you think a wicket would fall after three maidens in a row against this England side? Against this side, if you are giving two runs an over, it is as good as bowling a maiden," he added.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
‘Comfort' pick 'illusionary all-rounders' under fire as India told to pick proven star before ‘reality hits on the face'
India's reluctance to include Kuldeep Yadav in their playing XI for the opening Test against England at Headingley has reignited a tactical debate. Former cricketer and commentator Sanjay Manjrekar has weighed in with a sharp critique of the team's all-rounder strategy. Despite England's susceptibility to high-quality spin, India chose to leave Kuldeep out, opting instead for a combination that prioritised batting depth through the inclusion of Ravindra Jadeja and Shardul Thakur. India's Shubman Gill with head coach Gautam Gambhir during practice (Action Images via Reuters) This decision is consistent with India's approach since the Border-Gavaskar Trophy in Australia last year, where the team often leaned on the likes of Nitish Kumar Reddy, Washington Sundar, or Jadeja, and occasionally two of them, to provide a more robust lower-order batting core. While this might have made sense in Australian conditions that demanded pace-heavy attacks, Manjrekar believes India are falling into a trap of 'illusionary all-rounders,' players whose presence reassures batting strength but who may not offer the incisiveness needed with the ball. Against a Bazball-inspired England side that thrives on momentum and attack, Manjrekar has called for India to rethink their approach and bring Kuldeep into the mix at Edgbaston. 'It's a nice comforting feel, what I call the illusionary all-rounders. It just feels nicer having them in the team before reality hits on the face. That happened in Australia, and it's unfortunate that people think like that about Kuldeep Yadav,' Manjrekar told ESPNCricinfo. "You don't actually see how a pure bowler, or a wicket-taker like Kuldeep Yadav gives the kind of advantage to the team. There's Bazball, and Kuldeep is not an easy bowler for a lot of English batters to play that kind of cricket against. 'When you have an exceptional wicket-taker... if he gets you four wickets, you get 150 runs less on the opposition's score. If you pick someone who isn't a wicket-taker and pick him for his batting skills, he might get you 1-2 wickets, plus he's never going to get you less than 150 runs.' Reliable spin option The wrist-spinner has shown the ability to extract a sharp turn even in pace-friendly conditions and has matured into a much more reliable Test option over the past year. His ability to slow down the tempo and create pressure with wicket-taking deliveries could be exactly what India need to break England's rhythm. India's bowling unit in Leeds struggled for sustained control, with only Jasprit Bumrah offering genuine penetration. With doubts over Bumrah's availability for the second Test due to workload management, the need for a frontline spinner becomes even more urgent.
India Gazette
5 hours ago
- India Gazette
"England will play Bumrah carefully, Bazball everyone else...": Ravichandran Ashwin
New Delhi [India], July 1 (ANI): Former Indian cricketer Ravichandran Ashwin believes England will focus on playing cautiously against Jasprit Bumrah while aggressively targeting other bowlers as part of their 'Bazball' approach during the Test series against India. 'It's not about how many overs Jasprit Bumrah will bowl. It's about how we keep the pressure on if Bumrah isn't bowling. So this game is very straightforward, 'We will play Bumrah carefully and then Bazball everyone else'. That is pretty much what England will do,' Ashwin said, according to India lost the Leeds Test despite five of their batters scoring centuries. Only once before has a team lost a Test after registering four hundreds. Australia against England in Melbourne (1928). The second Test begins Wednesday. England's 371-run chase against India in the first test now stands as their second-highest successful pursuit in Test history. Ashwin said that as a bowling unit, India should make strategies to play some defensive cricket. 'So, as a bowling unit, we should make strategies to play some defensive, negative cricket. The kind of wickets England are making, we should play negative, defensive cricket and ask our bowlers to contain them more,' he added. Ashwin felt 'going for the wickets', be it Test cricket or T20 cricket, is all a lie, and pressure gives you wickets. 'The whole point of 'going for the wickets', be it Test cricket or T20 cricket, is all a lie. Pressure gives you wickets. When a bowler keeps a batter at one end for 10 balls and then delivers a good ball, that's what we call rhythm. You have to put the batters under pressure without giving runs, bottling him up. Testing his technique inside out. So if India wants to win the second Test, play Bumrah, even Kuldeep Yadav and make sure the rest of the bowlers are bottling one end up,' Ashwin added. England needed 350 runs in the fourth innings to seal the match, and they did it comfortably in 82 overs. With this win, England go 1-0 up in the five-match test series. India, led by Shubman Gill, will take on Ben Stokes's England in the second of the five-match Test series (Anderson-Tendulkar Trophy) at Edgbaston in Birmingham starting from Wednesday. (ANI)
