‘Comfort' pick 'illusionary all-rounders' under fire as India told to pick proven star before ‘reality hits on the face'
This decision is consistent with India's approach since the Border-Gavaskar Trophy in Australia last year, where the team often leaned on the likes of Nitish Kumar Reddy, Washington Sundar, or Jadeja, and occasionally two of them, to provide a more robust lower-order batting core. While this might have made sense in Australian conditions that demanded pace-heavy attacks, Manjrekar believes India are falling into a trap of 'illusionary all-rounders,' players whose presence reassures batting strength but who may not offer the incisiveness needed with the ball.
Against a Bazball-inspired England side that thrives on momentum and attack, Manjrekar has called for India to rethink their approach and bring Kuldeep into the mix at Edgbaston.
'It's a nice comforting feel, what I call the illusionary all-rounders. It just feels nicer having them in the team before reality hits on the face. That happened in Australia, and it's unfortunate that people think like that about Kuldeep Yadav,' Manjrekar told ESPNCricinfo.
"You don't actually see how a pure bowler, or a wicket-taker like Kuldeep Yadav gives the kind of advantage to the team. There's Bazball, and Kuldeep is not an easy bowler for a lot of English batters to play that kind of cricket against.
'When you have an exceptional wicket-taker... if he gets you four wickets, you get 150 runs less on the opposition's score. If you pick someone who isn't a wicket-taker and pick him for his batting skills, he might get you 1-2 wickets, plus he's never going to get you less than 150 runs.' Reliable spin option
The wrist-spinner has shown the ability to extract a sharp turn even in pace-friendly conditions and has matured into a much more reliable Test option over the past year. His ability to slow down the tempo and create pressure with wicket-taking deliveries could be exactly what India need to break England's rhythm.
India's bowling unit in Leeds struggled for sustained control, with only Jasprit Bumrah offering genuine penetration. With doubts over Bumrah's availability for the second Test due to workload management, the need for a frontline spinner becomes even more urgent.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
42 minutes ago
- First Post
India solid on Day 1 but Bumrah's absence and team balance raise deeper questions
Shubman Gill's century anchored India to 310/5 on Day 1 of the 2nd Test against England, but questionable team selection, especially the exclusion of Jasprit Bumrah, raises concerns about team's strategy in their series comeback attempt. read more Shubman Gill may have scored the crucial hundred that tied India's innings together on day one, his 114 at number four the backbone of a more than respectable 310/5; however, after a thrilling day's play, he may well not be the captain who will go home the happiest. Inserting India in almost perfect batting conditions, on a surface with very few demons, England would have been well aware that a repeat of Headingley, where the tourists piled on the runs for the loss of very few wickets, was highly likely again. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Instead, they looked much-improved with the ball, giving the impression that they are only growing into this series. Chris Woakes was very disappointing at Headingley, his performance one of his worst on English soil. Today, he was back to the sort of consistency that has come to be expected of him, in particular unlucky not to take more wickets in the morning session. Brydon Carse bowled with pace and menace, despite the placid surface, and Ben Stokes captained intelligently and provided the wicket of Yashasvi Jaiswal at a crucial moment. In short, even on a day that ultimately ended pretty much honours even, England looked like a team with real forward momentum, while India appeared a little uncertain in themselves. India's team selection raises eyebrows In truth, India put themselves on the back foot before a ball had even been bowled, their team selection for this Test raising more than a few eyebrows. The headline grabber was, of course, the omission of Jasprit Bumrah – predetermined to only be playing three Tests in this series, he was always going to be left out at some point, but it felt an odd decision at this stage on multiple fronts. The first is schedule-related. With the management of Bumrah's workload – after his injury layoff – the driving force behind his planned absences, this seems a strange time to give him a rest. There has been a week's gap between the first Test at Headingley and this one – ample time for a fast bowler to fully recover from the toils of a five day game. This then seemed like the perfect opportunity for Bumrah to play back-to-back Tests without causing undue strain on his body. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Only multiplying this is the fact that if there ever was a point in a series that India needed the world's best fast bowler on their side then it is this one. After the defeat at Headingley, the tourists' margin for error in this series has been considerably reduced. Another defeat might well be terminal for their prospects – the list of teams who have come back from 2-0 in a series is monumentally small. On top of that this Test is being played on a surface that might generously be described as benign, and with Bumrah's excellence the one area where there is a vast gulf in class between these two sides, having a bowler who can create something out of nothing – no matter the conditions – could have been a hugely advantageous point of difference. However, the handling of Bumrah's selection has not been the only place off the field that Indian thinking has looked muddled; the makeup of the side as a whole appeared curious from the outside. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Arguably, one of India's biggest mistakes at Headingley was neither committing fully to the strengths of their batting nor bowling attacks. The selection of Shardul Thakur, in an attempt to bolster both, ultimately did neither – the allrounder ultimately contributing only a pair of cheap final day wickets and five runs across two innings. Their response to this potentially match-losing bit of first Test hedging? Double down at Edgbaston, with Nitish Kumar Reddy and Washington Sundar brought into the side. Instead of leaning into either batting or bowling strength, India have once again opted to try and find that elusive sweet spot in the middle straddling the two. To an outsider, it appears they have simply reinforced the batting strength of the tail while making their top order weaker and without strengthening their bowling attack – it's a bold strategy, let's see if it pays off. There is, of course, a long way to go and India have not started badly in this Test, however, they may well rue the shaky foundations on which they are trying to build their comeback in the series. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Soccer-Rhine is fine for cooling fans ahead of Switzerland's Women's Euro kickoff
Jul 03, 2025 12:28 AM IST BASEL, Switzerland, July 2 (Reuters) - With the temperature set to reach fever pitch in Switzerland when the hosts take on Norway in their opening game at the Women's Euros on Wednesday, fans spent the afternoon cooling off in the Rhine river as the mercury soared again in Basel. HT Image The Fan Zone featured sprays of water and free sunscreen for fans and many followed the lead of clued-in locals, who were seen packing belongings into buoyant "Wicklefisch" waterproof swim bags before taking a cooling dip in the water. "Reinschwimmen" (Rhine swimming) is one way to cope. We also have a fountain near our house and sometimes we take a dip in that to cool off, but that's about all we can do," Basel resident David Borrowman told Reuters as he and his daughter sat by the river with their bags. With temperatures of 35 degrees expected on Wednesday, visiting fans were shocked by the intensity of the heat and welcomed the decision by UEFA to allow them to bring half-litre plastic or aluminium bottles into the St Jakob-Park stadium for the game. 'I think that's very nice, because it's very important to drink a lot of water, so half a litre of water per person is very nice to get in," Norway fan Lars Haloersen told Reuters before taking a much-needed cooling dip with his family. The game between Switzerland and Norway gets under way at 2100 Central European Time (1900GMT). (Reporting by Cecile Mantovani and Elena Rodriguez; writing by Philip O'Connor; Editing by Ken Ferris)
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Soccer-Denmark's Bruun seeks revenge at Women's Euros after Swedish drubbing
By Philip O'Connor HT Image NEUCHATEL, Switzerland, July 2 (Reuters) - Denmark's Signe Bruun won't be holding back with her tackles when they kick off their Women's Euro 2025 campaign against Sweden on Friday, with the attacker still smarting from a 6-1 Nations League defeat by the Swedes in Stockholm last month. Bruun got the assist for Denmark's goal that evening, but it was about the only thing that went right for the Danes as they conceded three goals in the opening 11 minutes to their Scandinavian rivals en route to a heavy defeat. "It was a tough, tough game. We were so disappointed, it hurts. We kind of took a step back, looked at some basic stuff, and now we're building from that one step back to two steps forward," a confident Bruun, her nails painted in Denmark's colours, told Reuters in an interview at the Danish team hotel on Wednesday. "A lot of the tools, the physical (things), quality on the ball, all this basic football stuff, sometimes you need to reset and go from there." Playing her club football for Real Madrid, the forward said she is used to dealing with the kind of heatwave that currently has temperatures soaring in Switzerland, and she expects plenty of open play form the 16 teams at the tournament. "I think more teams will play out (from the back), play possession football. I also feel like the tactical aspects of women's football has improved over the years, and I think we'll see that in this tournament as well, so I expect good football," she said. "I mean, we want to play, we want to be good on the ball, but we also want to play to our strengths. We want to be strong, we want to be a team that's difficult to play against, score a lot of goals, but also try to keep the clean sheet and do everything we can in that way." Warming to the subject, Bruun said she would not be backing out of any challenges against the Swedes when the game kicks off in Geneva on Friday. "I'm always a hard-working player, and if I need to put in a tackle, I'm going to put in a tackle. So if that's what it takes for me to help the team, I'm going to do that, but I'm around the box, I want to score goals and I think that's where my strength is," she said. Denmark are in Group C along with the Swedes, Germany and tournament debutants Poland. (Reporting by Philip O'Connor; Editing by Ken Ferris)
