Trans woman killed her husband by 'stabbing and slicing him' more than 50 times with samurai sword she bought in the 1980s, jury finds
Joanna Rowland-Stuart, 71, had been deemed 'unfit to plead' to the murder of her husband Andrew Rowland-Stuart, 69, in their 15th-floor flat in Lavender Street in Brighton, on May 27 last year.
She told police attending the scene that 'she had no choice' but to kill him after he attacked her with the sword, which she bought in the 1980s.
When police and paramedics arrived at the scene, they tried to conduct life-saving treatment, but Mr Rowland-Stuart's injuries were 'simply not survivable'.
On Thursday afternoon, jurors at Lewes Crown Court found that Rowland-Stuart had killed her husband in a trial of the act which decides if someone physically committed a crime, rather than their intent.
Rowland-Stuart was given an indefinite Hospital Order Under Section 41 of the Mental Health Act 1983.
While prosecuting, Charlotte Newell KC said there was 'no doubt' Rowland-Stuart had inflicted the injuries, 'which she did by stabbing and slicing him over 50 times with a samurai sword'.
Ms Newell added: 'Although Joanna Rowland-Stuart made some suggestion to attending police officers at the time that she did act in self-defence - the crown suggest that can safely be rejected.
'On the basis that, whatever the cause for attacking Andrew, the sheer number and the nature of the wounds that she inflicted, could not possibly be a reasonable use of force.'
Jurors heard that Rowland-Stuart, who is transgender, married Mr Rowland Stuart, known as Andy, in a civil partnership in 2006.
Their neighbours gave witness statements that described them as a 'normal couple' who they had never heard arguing.
Describing the scene, Ms Newell said: 'Andy was lying in the small living room in a pool of blood - he was covered in blood from significant knife wounds to his hands, his arms and to his torso - he was wearing underwear and a long sleeve t-shirt and that was soaked through.
'The samurai sword, which had been used to inflict all bar one of the injuries, had been placed back on a sheath and back on its stand from where it was later recovered.'
During the trial, Rowland-Stuart was found 'unfit' to plead and participate in her trial.
Judge Christine Laing KC ruled: 'She would be an unreliable witness in her own defence and would not be fit to be cross-examined, and for those reasons alone I find her unfit to plead.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
11 hours ago
- BBC News
Cheltenham man cleared of sexual offences by jury
A man who was on trial for a number of sexual offences has been cleared of all Atkinson, 27, was found not guilty of 11 counts of rape, six counts of assault by penetration, one of sexual assault and one of attempted Atkinson, of Imperial Court in Cheltenham, was acquitted by a jury on Friday at Gloucester Crown Court.
Daily Mirror
13 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
Carer, 44, 'urged boy at kids' home to go missing so they could have night away'
Lindy Leah, 44, allegedly 'fell in love with' a teenage boy at the kids' home where she worked, and was said to have encouraged him to go 'missing from care' so they could spend time together A care worker encouraged a boy at the children's home she worked at to go "missing" so they could later meet up for a night away, a court heard. Lindy Leah, 44, from Warrington, allegedly "fell in love" with the teen, who she had been assigned to as his key worker. Lindy worked as a deputy manager at the home. The 44-year-old was said to have worn inappropriate and revealing outfits in his presence and allowed him to sleep in her bed, as well as apparently asking him "for a love bite", the court heard. She however "denies any improper behaviour" and is currently on trial at Liverpool Crown Court. Jurors were read a series of WhatsApp messages which were exchanged between Leah and the boy yesterday afternoon, Liverpool Echo reports. One one occasion, she told him "proper paranoid" that she had "lost him to a slag" before stating: "If you never met me then your life would be better. I miss you so much. All I want is for me and you to have a night away from everyone, just us. So if I wake up from these tablets and wine, then we will." Leah then went on to add: "Do you wanna go MSC [missing from care]? I love you so much. Can I book somewhere for me and you on Friday? Red and silky with some balloons and flake. Make sure you get your arse home tonight so you can go missing from care with me without there being meetings." Graham Pickavance, prosecuting, told the court that "balloons" was a "colloquial term" for the class C drug nitrous oxide. In a further message, Leah told the teen: "Just listened to a song and it made me cry. Stupid love songs. It made me think of you, then it made me cry. I won't be listening to that again. Add me back on Instagram now. "Why you took me off it? I get paranoid. I find it hard to trust you. I'm just scared you're still talking to her and going to see her. I just can't bear catching you out again. What's the point, because you know I'll find out? I hate her." In another message, Leah said: "I wanted to give you the chance to apologise to me before I left. I can't do this any more. I'm done. You really are not sorry for what you did today. Vile, what you did to me today. "Texting 'I'm sorry' after you called me all of the names and hit me isn't enough. Bye. Enjoy your ket session. One day you will realise what you did to me today. Enjoy the last 25 quid you ever took from me. Last chance to see me before I go." Leah was meanwhile said to have promised to buy the boy a tracksuit if he "stop sniffing ket" for two weeks. But, in a further message, she told him: "What you've done to me is vile. The worst thing is you, you don't even give a f***. You got what you wanted. "You actually don't give a f***. This will be the hardest decision of my life. I deserve to be treated better. The fact you stole and lied and you can't be arsed begging me to take you back shows you don't even give a f*** about me. Bye then. You hurt me then won't even speak to me. Instead of making an effort to say sorry, you blocked me. "You really want me to go away forever. You lied and stole from me and you blocked me. If I lied and stole from you would you speak to me? You're horrible to me. You don't care if you ever speak to me again or see me again. You're with your mates and they're clearly more important than how I feel. "Instead of being vile to me, how about fixing what you broke? You had no right to block me on Instagram and Snapchat. Add me back now. It's not even funny, 'cos I'm the one crying again. I've done f*** all wrong and I'm the one that gets hurt again. You genuinely don't give a f*** about me at all. A jury of six men and six women previously heard that Leah, of Capesthorne Road in Orford, Warrington, was employed as deputy manager of the care home in St Helens where the boy had been placed and was assigned as his key worker. But Mr Pickavance said during the prosecution's opening: "The defendant, by her own admission, admitted that she fell in love with him. But the crown say that it was not simply parental love, but something that went far beyond that and was physical love." While the teenager "does not support the prosecution", colleagues described "inappropriate" behaviour from Leah, who wore a black dress in the dock with her blonde hair tied back in a bun, as well as "unprofessional interventions which prevented [the boy] from being challenged about his behaviour". He was also said to have been seen lying in her bed at the home "as if it was completely normal", with the defendant having apparently remarked of this: "He's comfortable. He always does that. No one else has a problem." A subsequent investigation by Merseyside Police similarly recovered video footage of the teenager asleep in her bed. Leah was meanwhile reported to have "worn skin tight and highly revealing clothing" in his presence, including a bodysuit with no underwear and a "highly visible thong". The youth's mum also "grew more concerned" about the relationship between her son and Leah, who allegedly told the mother that the boy "had her wrapped around his little finger" and called him "gorgeous and handsome". Mr Pickavance added that messages exchanged between the two "painted a picture of a relationship far removed from a carer and child". When interviewed by detectives, she "denied any improper behaviour" but, having been released on bail under conditions not to contact the boy, the two were then spotted together weeks later beside a white Audi car at Walton Hall and Gardens in Warrington by a fellow care worker. Leah, who is represented by Rebecca Filletti, denies one count of being a person in a position of trust causing or inciting a child to engage in sexual activity. The trial, before Judge Brian Cummings KC, continues.
South Wales Argus
16 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Newport drugs boss made more than £500,000 selling cocaine
Jamie Webber, 35, from Newport was jailed for 10 years and four months earlier this year for being part of an organised crime group. He and his fellow co-defendants trafficked nearly 3kg of the class A drug in Newport, Cwmbran and Pontypool. Nuhu Gobir, prosecuting, told a proceeds of crime hearing that Webber, of Buttermere Way, St Julians, profited by £570,338.76. The defendant has just £28,782 in available assets, Cardiff Crown Court heard. Judge Eugene Egan ordered Webber to hand it over within three months or face an extra two years in prison. Gwent Police's Operation Biggin brought his gang's activities to a shuddering halt in February last year. The six defendants, all from Newport, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to supply cocaine. In January this year, they were sentenced. The other five were: Said Kaid, 35, of Alice Street, sent to prison for eight years Michael Cornwall, 44, of no fixed abode, jailed for five years Nabeela Kaid, 36, of James Street, locked up for three years and four months. Alexa Cronin, 42, of Parry Drive, imprisoned for 28 months. Sinead Carey, 25, of Don Close, Bettws, jailed for 24 months but the sentence was suspended for 24 months Following the conclusion of the case, Detective Chief Inspector Matthew Edwards paid tribute to the roles the community and his team played in shattering their operation. 'With the sentencing of Kaid Said, Operation Biggin has resulted in lengthy sentences for this organised crime group with six people facing justice for their actions,' he said. 'These outcomes were made possible by the important role our communities play in these enquiries as the information given to us helps build our intelligence picture and gives us the chance to bring criminals before the courts. "Using this intelligence, the serious and organised crime team worked tirelessly to enforce and investigative this organised crime gang. "The superb work of all officers and staff involved has resulted in the sentences seen over the past few weeks." The gang used a drugs line and had 23 runners working for them delivering cocaine throughout Newport and Torfaen. A Gwent Police spokesperson added: "If you have any concerns or information about illegal drug supply or dealing in your community, please report it to us via the website, by calling 101 or sending us a direct message on social media, so that we can act. "Alternatively, you can contact Crimestoppers, anonymously, on 0800 555 111, with information or visit their website."
