Texas sues New York official for refusing to take action against abortion provider
Ken Paxton, Texas's attorney general, has petitioned the New York state supreme court to order a county clerk to enforce a fine against Dr Margaret Carpenter, a New York doctor accused of mailing abortion pills across state lines.
Paxton accused Carpenter last year of mailing abortion pills to a Texas woman in defiance of Texas's ban on virtually all abortions. After Carpenter failed to show up in a Texas court, a judge ordered her to pay more than $100,000 in penalties.
But the acting Ulster county clerk, Taylor Bruck, in New York has twice rejected Paxton's efforts to levy that fine. Under New York's 'shield law', state law enforcement officials are blocked from complying with out-of-state prosecutions against abortion providers who ship pills to patients, even if those patients are located outside New York state.
'No matter where they reside, pro-abortion extremists who send drugs designed to kill the unborn into Texas will face the full force of our state's pro-life laws,' Paxton, a Republican, said in a statement announcing Monday's filing.
Bruck, 34, said that he was just following New York state law.
'I'm just proud to live in a state that has something like the shield law here to protect our healthcare providers from out-of-state proceedings like this,' Bruck said. 'This has the potential of getting appealed up and up and up.'
Paxton's petition marks the latest escalation in the burgeoning clash between states that protect abortion rights and those that do not. In the three years since the supreme court overturned Roe v Wade, abortion opponents in red states have repeatedly tried to push for legislation and litigation that would curtail people's ability to cross state lines for abortions or to receive abortion pills in the mail. Meanwhile, blue states, including New York, have enacted an array of shield laws to preserve people's abortion access.
The US supreme court will probably be forced to step in to settle these debates between states, legal experts say.
'Ultimately, it's a states' rights argument,' Bruck said, adding that he remains 'still stunned by the whole thing'.
'It's not something I was really expecting, coming into this role,' Bruck said. 'It's really unprecedented for a clerk to be in this position.'
The best public interest journalism relies on first-hand accounts from people in the know.
If you have something to share on this subject you can contact us confidentially using the following methods.
Secure Messaging in the Guardian app
The Guardian app has a tool to send tips about stories. Messages are end to end encrypted and concealed within the routine activity that every Guardian mobile app performs. This prevents an observer from knowing that you are communicating with us at all, let alone what is being said.
If you don't already have the Guardian app, download it (iOS/Android) and go to the menu. Select 'Secure Messaging'.
SecureDrop, instant messengers, email, telephone and post
See our guide at theguardian.com/tips for alternative methods and the pros and cons of each.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
31 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Talking politics has bartenders on edge in Trump's Washington DC
Deke Dunne relocated to Washington DC from Wyoming in 2008 to pursue a career in politics. Though a progressive himself, he worked as a legislative aide for Republican senator Mike Enzi and spent many nights at local watering holes, guzzling $10 pitchers and eating wings with fellow broke staffers from both sides of the aisle. Long before he began moonlighting as a bartender, he learned that talking politics in DC bars was always a recipe for disaster. 'When I used to work in politics, I would spend a lot of time in bars near Capitol Hill,' said Dunne, 'so I was exposed to more political professionals. In those spaces, you often find yourself witnessing knockdown, drag-out arguments about politics.' Today, Dunne is one of DC's most influential mixologists, having abandoned politics almost a decade ago for a hospitality career. Serving drinks in a city that is more ideologically divided than ever, Dunne says he exercises more diplomacy behind the bar now than he ever did working in politics. There has always been an unspoken rule among Washington DC bartenders, according to Dunne, that political conversations across the bar should be avoided at all costs. It is generally understood that maintaining neutrality is critical to ensuring that guests of all political persuasions feel welcome. But the partisan rancor in Washington during the early stages of Donald Trump's presidential encore has created palpable tension in hospitality spaces, placing undue strain on staff to manage the vibes. 'It's always been an accepted truth in DC that every four to eight years, you get a whole new swath of people in from a different political ideology and if you want to have a strong, viable business, you don't talk politics,' said Dunne. 'Trump broke that rule.' According to local bar professionals in the nation's capital, the 'tending' part of bartending has never been more challenging. 'Politics in DC is not only something that a lot of people care about, but it's also a lot of people's livelihoods,' said Zac Hoffman, a bar industry veteran who until recently managed the restaurant inside the National Democratic Club near the Capitol. 'When you're talking about work, you're talking about politics. That's just the reality of where we live. It's a company town.' At Allegory, where Dunne oversees the beverage program, the bar has always taken a progressive approach, which occasionally provokes more conservative-minded guests who stay in the Eaton, the boutique hotel and cultural hub in downtown where the bar opened seven years ago. Its aesthetic and cocktail menu reimagines Lewis Carroll's Alice in Wonderland, but featuring a young Ruby Bridges, the iconic civil rights activist who faced a jeering mob when she desegregated a Little Rock elementary school. 'Our very presence as a mission-based bar has sparked many conversations surrounding our concept, but also gender-neutral bathrooms, provocative art and advocacy,' he said. 'We've had people that are clearly uncomfortable with our concept leave and then post a negative review but frame it about something else.' The resurgent, and often strident, brand of conservatism that dominates the political sphere in Washington today has many of the city's more progressive bar owners on edge. At The Green Zone, a Middle Eastern cocktail bar in Adams Morgan on the city's north side, politics have always been integral to the bar's identity since it opened in 2018. Bar owner Chris Hassaan Francke, whose mother is Iraqi, has earned a reputation for being outspoken about political conflicts, especially those in the Middle East. But since Trump's return to office, he admits to having toned down some of the rhetoric. 'We changed the name of one of our most infamous cocktails [which contained an incendiary reference to the current president],' said Francke. 'It kills me that I can't always say everything I want to say, but ultimately the safety and wellbeing of my staff [are] more important than that.' While the city may be under Republican rule at the moment, DC itself is still overwhelmingly liberal (Kamala Harris won over 90% of the vote in the 2024 election), which means that a majority of its hospitality workers are liberal, too. 'I know some bartenders who will say the opposite of what they believe around customers they don't agree with politically,' said Hoffman. 'There are plenty of socialists who make great tips talking shit about liberals with Republicans.' It isn't only the more progressive venues around town that have become targets. After recent articles in the New York Times and Washington Post championed upscale Capitol Hill bistro Butterworth's as a haven for Maga sympathizers, backlash ensued. According to chef and co-owner Bart Hutchins – who, like Dunne, also left a career in politics to work in hospitality – being perceived as pro-Trump has attracted crowds to his fledgling restaurant, which opened last fall. But it's also created some unwanted operational challenges. For one, a serial provocateur with an air-horn routinely disrupts his weekly dinner service by sounding it through the front entrance, often multiple times a week. Despite Butterworth's reputation for being a sanctuary for high-profile Trump supporters such as Steve Bannon, not every political conversation at the bar is peaceful. 'I've broken up at least three political arguments since we opened,' said Hutchins. 'It always starts with somebody who's really, really insistent that everyone agrees with them, someone who's watching way too much cable news who's really determined to have their Sean Hannity or Rachel Maddow moment.' Another unfortunate byproduct of being known as a right-leaning restaurant in a left-leaning town, Hutchins says, has been difficulty hiring and retaining staff. 'There have been times where it's been really hard to hire people,' he said. 'Early on, we had some servers self-select out and say: 'I don't want to serve these people.' But a lot of those people have moved on.' Over time, the staff has found ways to put their political convictions aside for the good of the restaurant. 'Our No 1 rule that's written on a door in the back is: 'Everybody's a VIP,' said Hutchins. 'We're not interested in using politics as a measuring device for whether or not someone deserves great service.' For DC bars, proximity to Capitol Hill has historically increased the likelihood that the conversations inside them will revolve around politics. And while some bars on the Hill may welcome these spirited conversations, many older, legacy bars prefer that patrons leave their partisanship at the door. Tune Inn, a well-loved dive bar that originally opened a few blocks from the Capitol in 1947, outwardly discourages political conversations of any kind. 'You can always tell the newbies because they want to come in and immediately start talking about politics,' said Stephanie Hulbert, who has worked as a bartender, server and now general manager at the bar for more than 17 years. 'They get shut down very quickly.' To keep the peace and maintain nonpartisan decorum inside the bar, she and her staff regularly intervene and admonish guests to keep their politics to themselves. These interventions occur at least two or three times every week, according to Hulbert, which is why the TVs inside the bar are deliberately set to sports channels rather than news outlets. 'I'll argue about sports all day long with you,' she said. 'But I won't argue about politics.' Despite the heightened anxiety in Washington, Dunne is optimistic that healthy dialogues in more progressive bars including Allegory can effect positive change. In January, Trump's inauguration drew conservative revelers to the Eaton, where inclusivity and multiculturalism is essential to its brand and mission. That led to some uncomfortable conversations with Republican patrons about the bar's progressive ethos. 'I don't know how effective the conversations were, but they were constructive,' he said. 'We found middle ground about the fact that what Ruby [Bridges] went through was tragic. It's common ground you don't find very often around here anymore.'
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Letter: Malcolm Dean obituary
As a young researcher trying to understand the British media's obsession with social security 'scroungers' in the 1970s I came to appreciate the invaluable answers that the Guardian journalist Malcolm Dean gave to my endless questions. He was a crucial resource in my studies, later published in book form as Images of Welfare (1982). Over subsequent years we had frequent conversations, many of which surfaced, I'm sure, as 'academics are saying …' inserts into his social policy leaders. His own book, Democracy Under Attack (2011), was an informed insider discussion of the ways social policy matters reached public awareness through the media. His experience, knowledge and insight are much missed, and his generous contribution to my own understanding will always be deeply valued.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Texas governor threatens Democrats who left state to prevent congressional map vote
Update: Date: 2025-08-04T16:13:25.000Z Title: Republican Texas governor Greg Abbott has said he will begin trying to remove Democratic lawmakers from office on Monday if they don't return after dozens of them left the state in a last-resort attempt to block redrawn US House maps that president Donald Trump wants before the 2026 midterm elections Content: Greg Abbott says he will try to remove Democrats unless they return to allow vote to take place on redrawing the US House map to favour Republicans Lucy Campbell (now); Shrai Popat and Tom Ambrose (earlier) Mon 4 Aug 2025 17.13 BST First published on Mon 4 Aug 2025 10.58 BST From 10.58am BST 10:58 Hello and welcome to the US politics live blog. I am Tom Ambrose and I will be bringing you all the latest news lines over the next few hours. We start with the news that . The revolt by the state House Democrats, many of whom went to Illinois or New York on Sunday, and Abbott giving them less than 24 hours to come home ratcheted up a widening fight over congressional maps, Associated Press reported. The planned vote on Monday could see five new Republican-leaning seats created in the House of Representatives. The move by the Democrats threatens to thwart Republican efforts by denying them a quorum, or the minimum number of members to validate the vote's proceedings. In a statement, Texas Democrats accused their counterparts, the Texas Republicans, of a 'cowardly' surrender to Trump's call for a redrawing of the congressional map to 'continue pushing his disastrous policies'. 'Texas Democratic lawmakers are halting Trump's plan by denying his bootlickers a quorum,' the statement read. The scheme to flee the state is reported to have been put together by the Illinois governor, JB Pritzker, who met with the Texas Democratic caucus late last month and has directed staff to provide logistical support for their stay. The Texas group has accused governor Abbott of withholding aid to victims of Guadalupe River flooding last month in a bid to force the redistricting vote through. 'We're leaving Texas to fight for Texans,' Gene Wu, the Texas House Democratic caucus chair, said in a statement. 'We will not allow disaster relief to be held hostage to a Trump gerrymander.' 'We're not walking out on our responsibilities; we're walking out on a rigged system that refuses to listen to the people we represent,' Wu added. 'As of today, this corrupt special session is over.' Read our full story here: In other developments: US trade representative Jamieson Greer has defended the firing of labor statistics chief Erika McEntarfer. 'The president is the president. He can choose who works in the executive branch,' he said on Face the Nation. Greer was among a host of Trump administration officials who were deployed to defend Trump after a week of bruising economic numbers. The US Senate left Washington DC on Saturday night for its month-long August recess without a deal to advance dozens of Donald Trump's nominees, calling it quits after days of contentious bipartisan negotiations and the president taking to social media to tell Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer to 'GO TO HELL!' In a new court filing, attorneys for the Trump administration denied the existence of a daily quota for immigration arrests, despite reports and prior statements from White House officials about pursuing a goal of at least 3,000 deportations or deportation arrests per day. Lawyers representing the US justice department said that the Department of Homeland Security had confirmed that 'neither Ice leadership nor its field offices have been directed to meet any numerical quota or target for arrests, detentions, removals, field encounters, or any other operational activities that Ice or its components undertake in the course of enforcing federal immigration law.' The US Senate has confirmed Jeanine Pirro – a former Fox News host and staunch Donald Trump ally who boosted lies that he lost the 2020 presidential race because of electoral fraudsters – as the top federal prosecutor for the nation's capital. Pirro – a former New York state district attorney and county judge who joined Fox News in 2011 – was confirmed on Saturday in a 50-45 vote along party lines. The Smithsonian says it will restore Trump impeachment exhibits in 'coming weeks'. Updated at 11.29am BST 5.03pm BST 17:03 Richard Luscombe A Doge-style audit launched by Florida's Republican governor Ron DeSantis into Democratic-run cities and counties he accuses of wasteful spending could soon be known by an offensive new name: FAFO, universally known as a meme for the phrase 'fuck around and find out'. In a post to X on Monday, DeSantis said the acronym - which he claims actually stands for a Florida Agency for Fiscal Oversight he has yet to formally commission, had 'a nice ring to it' and that he 'might need to work up an executive order and make it official'. Under the guise of ensuring 'transparency and accountability' in local government, DeSantis sent audit teams last week into the city of Gainesville, and Broward county, two pockets of Democratic strength in a largely Republican state. It is part of a wider initiative the governor trumpeted earlier this year to replicate Elon Musk's Doge (the so-called 'department of government efficiency') efforts at state level in support of his ambitious longer-term goal of eliminating property taxes. Taking credit for the FAFO handle is Florida's new chief financial officer Blaise Ingoglia, a staunch DeSantis ally whose X profile includes the words 'If you're looking for snark, you've found it.' He posted on Monday an assertion that he got 'a rave reception' when he rolled out the new nickname at a party event over the weekend. Updated at 5.13pm BST 4.39pm BST 16:39 The president has said that India will be subject to a tariff hike for not only 'buying massive amounts of Russian oil' but 'selling it on the open market for big profits'. He announced his decision on Truth Social, saying that India does not care 'how many people in Ukraine are being killed by the Russian War Machine'. It's unclear what the levy increase will be. Trump already hit India with a 25% tariff last week, citing the country's substantial purchasing of Russian oil as part of the penalty. Updated at 4.45pm BST 4.19pm BST 16:19 South Carolina congresswoman Nancy Mace has officially entered governor's race for the Palmetto state. In a video announcement posted on social media, Mace, 47, positions herself as a conservative 'firebrand' and a 'fighter'. She also cites her credentials as the first woman to graduate from South Carolina's 'The Citadel'– one of the country's oldest military colleges. In her first two terms in office, Mace was a vocal Trump adversary. In 2021, she was one of seven House Republicans who signed a letter that said Congress did not have the authority to overturn the 2020 election results. She also heavily criticised the president's role in the Capitol attacks on 6 January 2021. Notably, Mace did not vote to impeach him for inciting an insurrection. Throughout her third term in Congress, Mace has now become a key Trump ally. She's waged some of the president's key battles in the culture war – including a resolution prohibiting trans women using bathrooms that align with their gender identity at the US Capitol. Mace confirmed this was to target incoming freshman Representative Sarah McBride of Delaware. Mace is entering an already crowded primary for gubernatorial race in South Carolina. While the incumbent, Henry McMaster, is unable to seek a third term, Mace will be facing off against Alan Wilson, the state's attorney general. In a lengthy floor speech earlier this year, Mace called out Wilson for failing to prosecute four men, including her ex-fiancé, who she accuses of rape and sex-trafficking. Updated at 4.45pm BST 3.44pm BST 15:44 Governor Hochul confirms that she hasn't and won't spend any money housing the Texas lawmakers in New York City. She added that the Democrats who did flee will probably face exorbitant legal fees, as well as highlighting the daily fine of $500 for not appearing during the legislative session without permission. The delegation of Texas lawmakers present today did not confirm where they would be travelling to next, but did say they 'won't be going back to Texas'. Updated at 3.53pm BST 3.32pm BST 15:32 Representative Mihaela Plesa, vice-chair of the House Democratic caucus, says that the redistricting battle in Texas goes beyonds the state's borders: If Trump and Abbott succeed, it will give them five seats. But then where else do they go? Ohio, Missouri, any other Republican legislature with Democratic Congress people. They're on the chopping block too. Updated at 3.33pm BST 3.23pm BST 15:23 Governor Hochul calls the Texas Democrats who left the state to trigger a quorum break 'profiles in courage'. She adds that they're 'on the right side of history' and this redistricting fight is a 'war'. Updated at 3.24pm BST 3.16pm BST 15:16 Texas Democrats who fled the state are now holding a press conference with New York Governor Kathy Hochul. Hochul kicks off her remarks: Americans don't want a system that's stacked against them. They believe in fairness, it's fundamental. I'll tell you this. They're done with the chaos, they're done with the cruelty. And I would say they're ready to vote Republicans out of power in Washington, certainly in the upcoming 2026 elections. 2.56pm BST 14:56 House Speaker Mike Johnson has made an unannounced visit to Israel, per the minister of defense's post on X. Johnson was joined by a delegation of House Republicans. Axios reports that this was a trip organised by a pro-Israel advocacy group, and that Johnson made a stop at a settlement on the occupied West Bank. This comes after Steve Witkoff, the Trump administration's Middle East envoy, travelled to Gaza on Friday to assess the food and aid situation after several reports of worsening starvation in the region. On Sunday, the president addressed reporters' questions about Witkoff's visit. 'We're putting up money to get people fed,' he said. 'We don't want people to starve.' Updated at 3.11pm BST 2.27pm BST 14:27 Just a short while ago, the president took to Truth Social to repeat his claim that last week's jobs report was 'rigged' and the overall conduct of the Bureau of Labor Statistics is 'in favor of the Radical Left Democrats'. He added that 'the FAKE political numbers that were CONCOCTED in order to make a great Republican Success look less stellar!!!' The administration has provided no evidence that McEntarfer's conduct was in any way political, or that the recent jobs numbers were manipulated. Updated at 2.33pm BST 2.04pm BST 14:04 In an interview with CNN's Audie Cornish, the Texas Democratic party chair Kendall Scudder urged Democrats to 'stop trying to be the only adults in the room'. He added that the GOP's new congressional map should be a 'signal flare' for blue states to 'start carving up their own seats'. Scudder said that this weekend's action by Texas Democrats is part of an effort to hold state Republicans 'accountable for their actions': The reality is, no Democrat is sitting around itching and waiting for a quorum break. But this is what has to be done to make sure we're preserving democracy. Updated at 2.13pm BST 1.50pm BST 13:50 In response to Governor Greg Abbott threatening to arrest and expel any Texas legislators who refuse to return to the state capitol by 3pm local time on Monday, the Texas House Democratic Caucus issued a short and simple statement: 'Come and take it.' Governor Abbott however, has also said that Texas Democrats 'may have committed felonies' by asking for donations to help pay for fines that they incur by fleeing the state. House rules in Texas state that lawmakers rack up a $500-a-day fine for each day they are absent without permission during a legislative session. Updated at 3.31pm BST
