Judge suggests NSW police had ‘absolutely no evidence' to justify main strip-search in class action
Justice Dina Yehia made the comment in the NSW supreme court during closing arguments in a class action against the police.
The state of NSW has disputed that the vast majority of strip-searches conducted by police between 2018 and 2022 at music festivals were unlawful.
NSW police did, however, admit in court documents before the hearings began last week to unlawfully strip-searching the lead plaintiff, Raya Meredith, at a music festival in 2018.
Meredith is the lead plaintiff of a group of 3,000 people, including children, searched by police. She was strip-searched at the 2018 Splendour in the Grass festival after a drug dog sniffed in her direction but then walked on.
The class action is being led by Slater and Gordon lawyers and the Redfern Legal Centre.
Julian Sexton SC, acting on behalf of NSW police, on Thursday disputed the plaintiff's call for aggravated damages to be paid because of the force's conduct during proceedings.
He argued aggravated damages could not be awarded because Meredith had not been recalled to give evidence about how she felt about NSW police's conduct during the class action.
Yehia said in response she was 'much more concerned' about the police having three iterations of its defence before backflipping shortly before proceedings began and admitting it did unlawfully strip-search Meredith.
'That is a matter, I'll be quite honest with you, of grave concern to me,' Yehia said on Thursday.
The judge said she was concerned the police defence suggested officers had formed a reasonable suspicion to strip-search Meredith based on 'things like her demeanour, what was said outside the tent, and [the officers] recalling it was said outside the tent and not inside'.
'There is absolutely no evidence, unless you can take me to it and I've missed something,' Yehia said to Sexton.
Sign up to Morning Mail
Our Australian morning briefing breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'All I have is the officers' statements that say either they don't remember the search, or both that they don't remember the search nor remember the lead plaintiff. In those circumstances, I'm just not sure how this could ever have proceeded in the way that it did with the initial pleadings.'
In the days before the hearing began, the state of NSW withdrew 22 witnesses, mostly police officers who had been due to contest Meredith's version of events. That change saw the case reduced from a scheduled 2o days to three days.
Sexton argued the defence was based on police 'practice' in such instances, adding it was 'not [based] on distinct recollections of somebody'.
Yehia said the police suggesting there were 'reasonable grounds' for the search due to Meredith's physical appearance and body language were 'specific matters relating to this plaintiff in circumstances where [the female police officer who searched her] not only doesn't remember, but as far as I understand it, didn't even make a notebook entry in relation to that interaction'.
Closing arguments before Yehia were expected to end on Thursday.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
28 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Police shoot man dead after gunfire during siege in Victorian town of Daisy Hill
An armed man has been shot dead by police after a seven-hour siege prompted by earlier gunfire. Police were called to Menzies Drive in Daisy Hill, near the Victorian town of Maryborough, about 3pm on Thursday after reports of a gun being fired in an incident where no one was injured. They tried to speak with the man before an hours-long siege, with the Critical Incident Response Team, Special Operations Group and Dog Squad called in to assist, Victoria police said in a statement on Friday. It is alleged the man fired shots towards police, who returned fire just before 10pm. The man, who has not been formally identified, was hit and died at the scene. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Homicide Squad detectives will investigate the fatal shooting with oversight from the Professional Standards Command, as is the standard procedure, police said. The state coroner has visited the scene. There have been several shootings by police in Victoria in recent months. Madeline Margaret Henry, 33, was shot dead on 24 May in South Melbourne after allegedly driving towards a male senior constable during the arrest of a machete-wielding man. The senior constable shot at the vehicle four times, hitting and killing the female driver. Abdifatah Ahmed was also shot dead at Footscray in the city's inner west on 17 April after allegedly rushing at police with a knife. Commander Tim Tully said two officers told the man to drop the weapon and shot him when he charged at police.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Urgent warning issued to Qantas customers after hack: How you could be targeted
Qantas customers need to remain vigilant in the coming days after a hacker targeted a third-party platform containing the personal information of millions of people. Names, phone numbers, dates of birth and email addresses are among the data believed to have been leaked. In an update on Friday, Qantas said the group believed responsible for the incident remained unclear and that it had not received a ransom request. The biggest risk for people now is that their data is used to attempt fraud or even steal their identity. Airlines are being warned to tighten security after a hack affecting millions of Qantas customers has left the aviation giant exposed to possible legal action. Legal experts have suggested the incident could lead to a class action in a repeat of compensation claims lodged following major breaches at Optus and Medibank in 2022. The hack of sensitive customer details at the health insurer could end up costing it $700million or more, analysts have said. The primary wrongdoing was clearly with the hackers, but Qantas could still face secondary liability if it was found to have breached its duties, Monash University associate law professor Michael Duffy said. 'Based on previous class actions that have been taken for data breaches, there is certainly a possibility of action being taken against Qantas,' he told AAP. 'This issue of data and privacy breaches is not going to go away.' The exposure of customers' dates of birth was particularly sensitive, Assoc Prof Duffy said. 'While exposure of names and email addresses is a concern, any exposure of dates of birth is more serious because of the potential for wrongdoers to try and use them for nefarious purposes,' he said. Qantas has reassured customers that their financial information, passport numbers, credit card details and frequent flyer PINs were not accessed. It is not the first time an airline has faced a cyber attack, with America's Hawaiian Airlines and WestJet compromised in recent weeks. Security experts warn the hack could mean the aviation industry is being targeted. 'Airlines hold all kinds of sensitive information, and cybercriminals are looking to take it,' NordVPN chief technology officer Marijus Briedis said. In an update on Friday, Qantas said the group believed responsible for the incident remained unclear and that it had not received a ransom request (pictured, a Qantas terminal in Sydney) 'The industry needs to implement proactive, multi-layered security approaches that assume breaches will happen and focus on minimising their impact.' There is speculation the hackers responsible for the airline attacks is Scattered Spider, a group of young cyber criminals living in the US and UK. Security experts are concerned about the risk of follow-on scams targeting affected customers. Macquarie University's Dali Kaafar said the release of private details could lead to malicious actors building a more complete profile about individuals, making them more susceptible to other forms of cyber crime. He warned Qantas customers to change their passwords and access codes to prevent potential hacks. That was because many people used their date of birth as a PIN, but the information had now been compromised, Professor Kaafar said. Qantas is investigating the cyber attack and its impacts, urging customers to be on high alert for future scam attempts. Chief executive Vanessa Hudson confirmed the company was working closely with the National Cyber Security Coordinator, the Australian Cyber Security Centre and independent specialised cyber security experts. A customer support line was established to provide customers with the latest information. Qantas shares were slightly up on Thursday after initially shedding 3.6 per cent following news of the hack.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Ex-Wallabies star James O'Connor breaks his silence about one of the biggest scandals of his colourful career - 'looks like we didn't care'
Former Wallabies star James O'Connor has opened up about one of the biggest scandals of his career - and insists it was blown out of proportion. The drama unfolded following a late-night burger run at Hungry Jack's in Melbourne's CBD back in 2013. Hours earlier, O'Connor and fellow young gun Kurtley Beale had attended the Melbourne Rebels' clash against the British and Irish Lions. In hindsight, the pair should have immediately returned to the Wallabies team hotel, but youthful exuberance won out. Instead, O'Connor and Beale caught up with then-Rebels Super Rugby teammates, and in a flash it was past 3am. O'Connor - who insists he and Beale didn't touch a drop of alcohol on the night - ducked in for a burger and agreed to a photo with a fan, which was quickly posted on Facebook. Chaos followed, with the sheepish duo forced to address their teammates. 'We were asked to apologise, but I didn't understand what I was apologising for,' O'Connor told Code Sports. '(I get it) of course people are going to be pissed off. This is a Lions series, everyone else was bloody asleep. 'It looks like we didn't care....'Our teammates probably thought we'd had some drinks as well. 'I wasn't actually sorry for what I did. So they would have felt that maybe I wasn't actually sorry because I just felt like I was apologising as a token.' Given the second Test against the Lions in Melbourne was just three days later, it wasn't a good look. Australia managed to win a thriller 16-15 to force a series decider, but the Lions proved to be too strong in Sydney to collect the silverware. Coach Robbie Deans was also on borrowed time as a result, with a perception he didn't have control of the playing group. Now 34, O'Connor - who was no stranger to off-field scandals across his career - can see why he got teammates and fans offside at the time in Melbourne. A generational talent, O'Connor was playing international rugby aged just 18, and Wallabies fans were licking their lips at the time as fellow rising stars Beale and Quade Cooper left their mark on the team. But ultimately, Bledisloe Cups and World Cup trophies didn't follow - and O'Connor laments what could have been. 'Looking back, I let the team down quite a few times,' he said. 'I (was young), I didn't even have the emotional awareness to know that what I was doing was hurting the group because it was all just about me. 'When you can take your blinkers off, you can understand the world a little bit more.' The first Test of the 2025 Lions series is on July 19 at Suncorp Stadium in Brisbane.
