Sweeping move-on police powers blasted by protesters
Josh Lees, on behalf of the Palestinian Action Group, has taken the NSW government to the NSW Supreme Court over the anti-protest laws implemented in February.
The activist is challenging the constitutional validity of police powers to move people on during protests deemed to be near places of worship.
His lawyers argue the laws allow police to direct protesters to desist, even in instances where there is no evidence a worshipper has been obstructed, harassed or is in fear.
That meant the laws have stretched police powers beyond their legitimate constitutional bounds, the court was told.
The lawyers claim neither police nor protesters can determine the reach of those powers or the definition of nearness to a place of worship to take into consideration.
"Because of those vagaries, the upshot is that a person might just stay home," Craig Lenehan SC told the court.
He took aim at the "legislative blunderbuss" which he said was "blasting away at an ill-defined mischief" and could have a chilling effect on protesting in NSW.
The laws were discriminatory because they expressly targeted certain types of political speech in a way that inevitably favoured some viewpoints over others, Mr Lenehan contended.
When deciding to move on protesters, police needed to make a subjective determination of whether someone feels obstructed or fearful near a place of worship.
That could be extended beyond worshippers to the protection of passers-by and people unconnected to the holy place, Mr Lenehan said.
"(It) is a very broad police power conferred by very ill-defined application," he said.
"It has nothing to do with the exercise of religious freedom."
NSW Solicitor General Michael Sexton SC will address the court about the validity of the new legislation on behalf of the state government on Thursday afternoon.
The laws were introduced by the state Labor government after a spate of anti-Semitic attacks across the nation and amid concerns about rallies going past the Great Synagogue in the Sydney CBD.
Before their passage, Attorney-General Michael Daley said stronger penalties and boosted police powers would ensure people could practise their faith in safety.
"We believe these proposed reforms strike the right balance between protecting people of faith and the community's right to protest," he said.
Premier Chris Minns underscored his determination to protect the Jewish community in his first speech to parliament in 2025.
"We will not be a state where someone feels like they have to remove their yarmulke (skullcap) just to walk down the street, where people are made to hide their heritage because of the ignorance, the bigotry, the racism of other people," he said.
Mr Lees said the challenge against the expanded police powers was urgent because they presented a threat to the right to protest in NSW.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News24
4 hours ago
- News24
Australia spy boss warns Russia, China, Iran as espionage threats ‘trying to steal our secrets'
Australia's spy chief has singled out Russia as an 'aggressive espionage threat', saying several Moscow-linked intelligence officers have been caught and expelled in recent years. Intelligence boss Mike Burgess used a speech on Thursday night to warn of the mounting threat posed by foreign actors such as Russia and China. Burgess said 24 major espionage operations had been dismantled since 2022 - more than the previous eight years combined. 'A new iteration of great power competition is driving a relentless hunger for strategic advantage and an insatiable appetite for inside information,' he said. 'Russia remains a persistent and aggressive espionage threat,' added Burgess, director-general of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation (ASIO). Without providing details, Burgess said a number of Russian spies had been expelled from Australia in recent years. He also mentioned China and Iran as nations actively trying to pilfer classified information. He said: You would be genuinely shocked by the number and names of countries trying to steal our secrets. Repeating a warning sounded earlier this year, Burgess said foreign actors were targeting Australia's fledgling nuclear-powered submarine programme. Australia plans to deploy stealthy nuclear-powered submarines in a pact with the United States and Britain known as AUKUS. 'In particular, we are seeing foreign intelligence services taking a very unhealthy interest in AUKUS and its associated capabilities,' said Burgess. Australian police in 2024 charged a married Russian-born couple with spying for Moscow. The couple - accused of trying to steal military secrets - had lived in Australia for more than 10 years. Vitalii Nosach/Global Images Ukraine via Getty Images On Wednesday, Reuters reported that Ukraine's domestic security agency detained an air force officer on charges of having spied for Russia by leaking the location of prized F-16 and Mirage 2000 fighter jets, officials said. The unidentified officer, a flight instructor holding the rank of major, stands accused of helping Russia carry out air strikes by providing coordinates and suggesting strike tactics, the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) said in a statement. 'In particular, the enemy's priority targets were airfields where F-16s, Mirage 2000s and Su-24s were based,' it said. F-16s are US-made and Mirages are French while the Su-24 is an older, Soviet-manufactured jet bomber. 'The agent collected the coordinates of the location of these aircraft, schedules and ... the order of their departure.' The SBU also detained two Chinese nationals on suspicion of spying on Ukraine's Neptune anti-ship missile programme, a key part of Kyiv's growing domestic arms industry.
Newsweek
8 hours ago
- Newsweek
China State Media Reveals New Nuclear-Armed Submarine
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. A Chinese sailor deployed aboard a nuclear-armed submarine vowed that his unit would fire missiles "without hesitation" upon receiving an order, according to a report by state media. The report by China Central Television also claimed this was the "first disclosure" of a new Chinese submarine conducting a long-distance mission in an undisclosed maritime location. Newsweek reached out to the Chinese Defense Ministry for comment via email. Why It Matters China possesses more than 370 naval vessels, making it the world's largest combat fleet by hull count, including six Type 094 nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines, each armed with 12 nuclear ballistic missiles, according to the Federation of American Scientists. All Type 094 submarines are homeported at Longpo Naval Base on Hainan Island in southern China, which borders the South China Sea, and represent China's "first credible sea-based nuclear deterrent," the Pentagon assessed in its report on Chinese military power. Ballistic missile submarines are the most survivable leg of China's nuclear triad, alongside land-based ballistic missiles and nuclear-capable bombers, because they are extremely difficult to detect while conducting patrols that maintain a constant at-sea deterrent presence. What To Know A Chinese submarine, unidentified in the report, was seen departing a naval base at an undisclosed location, according to footage aired by China Central Television on Thursday. Australia-based naval analyst Alex Luck told Newsweek the submarine is one of six Type 094 boats in service, suggesting the footage was likely taken at Longpo Naval Base. It remains unclear whether the submarine carried out its mission in the South China Sea. A Chinese Type 094 nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine docks at an undisclosed location on July 31, 2025. A Chinese Type 094 nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine docks at an undisclosed location on July 31, 2025. China Central Television While the footage offered a rare glimpse inside the submarine and how sailors operate it, certain interior sections were blurred, likely for operational security reasons. It was not immediately clear whether the interior scenes were filmed while the submarine was at sea. "Today is a peaceful era, but tomorrow may mark the start of war. On the day real war begins, we will wait only for the order—and then launch this missile without hesitation," said Ma Xiaohui, a sailor assigned to an unidentified submarine unit. The Type 094 submarine can be armed with either JL-2 or JL-3 ballistic missiles, which have ranges of 4,488 miles and 6,214 miles, respectively. The JL-3 missile is capable of targeting portions of the U.S. mainland when launched from China's littoral waters. As part of Chinese President Xi Jinping's accelerated development of nuclear forces, China's next-generation nuclear-armed ballistic missile submarine, the Type 096, is expected to enter service in the late 2020s or early 2030s, according to the Pentagon's assessment report. A Chinese Type 094 nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine transits an undisclosed maritime location on July 31, 2025. A Chinese Type 094 nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarine transits an undisclosed maritime location on July 31, 2025. China Central Television In comparison, the United States currently operates a fleet of 14 Ohio-class ballistic missile submarines, each armed with up to 20 Trident II D5LE nuclear missiles. According to the Federation of American Scientists, this missile has an estimated range of 7,456 miles. What People Are Saying The Pentagon, in its report on Chinese military power: "The [People's Republic of China]'s next-generation Type 096 [nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines] will reportedly be armed with follow-on longer range [submarine-launched ballistic missiles]." The Federation of American Scientists, in its report on Chinese nuclear weapons: "Whenever they are in the South China Sea, China's [nuclear-powered ballistic missile submarines] typically appear to be accompanied by a protection detail, including surface warships and aircraft (and possibly attack submarines) capable of tracking adversarial submarines." What Happens Next It remains to be seen whether the Chinese military will disclose details of other nuclear forces in the coming days as it celebrates the 98th anniversary of its founding on Friday.
Yahoo
14 hours ago
- Yahoo
New Sask. legislation intended to discourage street weapons comes into force
The Safe Public Spaces Act, also known as the Street Weapons Act, is coming into effect in Saskatchewan on Aug. 1. The act gives police the power to seize street weapons, which include large knives, hatchets, and bear spray. Municipalities and First Nations must first opt-in to the act, meaning that each jurisdiction has a say. Sask. Justice Minister and Attorney General Tim Mcleod announced the coming-into-force on Thursday at Moose Jaw Police Service Headquarters. "All of the Charter protections still exist and the Criminal Code isn't being changed by this legislation," said McLeod. "However, we have seen an increasing number of incidents where there were people openly carrying a machete, or unfortunately, bear spray has become a real concern in a variety of situations." McLeod says that the legislation builds upon regulations surrounding bear spray, and expands it to other potentially dangerous items. The "street weapons" listed include blades over 30 centimetres, hatchets, sledgehammers, body armour and bear spray. "It's giving police an additional tool where somebody may be carrying an item that otherwise didn't violate the Criminal Code, but is simply dangerous for a public purpose," said McLeod. "We've heard many stories coming out of Saskatoon with bear spray in shopping malls. Bear spray does not belong in shopping malls." Moose Jaw Police Service's Superintendent Trish Seman said that the act will be an important tool for officers. "Typically right now we would be more reactive than proactive," said Seman. "We get on the scene a lot of times and things have already happened. If we were at a situation or event, we see the machete as the extreme case … Sometimes we run into situations where we might not be able to seize it because there might not be a reason for us to, but this allows us now to seize it." Possessing the street weapons in a public setting could potentially cause convictions with fines up to $5,000, or a full year in police don't need to lay a charge however, as they can simply seize the dangerous item. Joanne Klassen, co-owner of The Boutique Next Door, says in the 32 years she's been in business in downtown Moose Jaw, crime and violence have declined greatly. "It wouldn't be a city unless there were areas that felt unsafe," said Klassen. "As for walking around downtown, that is not a frightening thing for me at all. I think sometimes things can be over-exaggerated … It feels safe and fun."
